Why Did Pontiac Turn Their Best V8 Into A 4 Cylinder?

Engine in Focus
4 followers
The Pontiac 389 is an iconic engine, so why did they cut it in half and package it as a 4 cylinder?
#machine #engine
Throughout their automotive reign spanning from 1926 to 2010, Pontiac was always a bit of a wild
child. They loved to push the boundaries, and even when they were swallowed up by General Motors,
they were still the lifeblood of excitement. Pushing the envelope was in Pontiac's DNA.
After all, they are largely credited with being the creators of the muscle car as we know it.
But just a couple years before the GTO burst onto the market, a storm was brewing inside Pontiac,
and from it, they hatched one of their craziest ideas ever. To build a 45 degree slant inline
4 by lopping off half of their already existing V8 engine architecture. It was wholly unorthodox
as you will soon see, and it ended up being one of the quirkiest engines ever made for its
incredibly short lifespan. This is the true story of the Pontiac Trophy 4.
The Pontiac Trophy 4's lineage can all be traced back to an internal Pontiac Skunk Works project
that was spearheaded by Malcolm Keller, one of Pontiac's most gifted powertrain engineers.
Malcolm and his team, as a research experiment before the creation of the Pontiac Tempest,
were experimenting with solutions for better fuel economy with existing engines. Part of that
experiment led them down the path of disabling one bank of cylinders on their V8 fitted inside
a Catalina. And it turns out, even with the engines severely neutered, the Catalina,
which was a big car, was still usable and able to maintain highway speeds with ease.
Now, Pontiac surely was not planning on launching a new range-topping four-cylinder cat,
but the idea was in the back of their mind for their newest vehicular offering, the Tempest.
See, by the end of the 1950s, the American automotive landscape was changing fast. The
post-war boom was still in full swing, but cracks were beginning to show in the one-size-fits-all
big car model. Families were still growing, but as were traffic jams. Fuel prices were creeping
upward, and America was becoming increasingly more condensed and suburbanized. Demand was shifting,
and Detroit needed a new kind of car. At General Motors, the answer came in the form of the Y-Body
platform, a fresh approach to downsized motoring that would be easy to mass-produce at scale
amongst all of GM's owned companies. Rather than building just a set of cheap,
stripped-down economy cars, GM envisioned a new class of Senior Compacts, which were smaller than
their full-size brethren, but still were refined enough to wear a premium badge. The Y-Body would
primarily be used by the likes of Buick's new Skylark, Oldsmobile's new F85, and what would
become the future home of the Pontiac four-cylinder, the Tempest. Each division would
take the Y-Body and tailor it to its own DNA and styling cues. Add in their own power plants,
and voila, you had a new car. But in typical Pontiac fashion, they just had to be different
from the rest. A simple, rebodied Y-Platform car just wasn't going to do it for them,
especially when John DeLorean was the man in the driver's seat at Pontiac.
They wanted to do something wild. For as new as the Y-Platform chassis was at GM,
it was still a fairly traditional setup, with a front engine, rear-wheel drive,
and a live axle out the back. It was quintessentially American, though. Pontiac's
use of the Y-Platform, however, would deviate from that plan significantly, and not just from
an engine standpoint, which we'll get to in a minute. But the rest of the new-for-1961 Tempest
was anything but ordinary. Gone was the live axle, and in its place was an independent rear
suspension setup based on that of the Corvair's. They would also utilize a rear-mounted trans-axle
on the Tempest rather than a standard transmission to achieve not only a 50-50 weight distribution,
but a nearly flat floor pan due to the absence of a full trans-tunnel, which meant that the
Tempest could comfortably seat 6 rather than 5. Mind you, this trans-axle system,
with its thin rope-like driveshaft that connected the engine up front to the rear wheels, was only
used in the Tempest, as was that glorious, yet not so little, Slant 4. Unlike the Catalina by
American car standards, the new Tempest was light at just 2,600 pounds, which would make it a great
candidate for a more fuel-efficient and compact powerplant. Pontiac would take their learnings
from that test-mule V8 that I mentioned earlier and reverse-engineer that idea as a standalone
engine. Normally, when manufacturers create engines from another, they either combine
two of their inline-4 or inline-6 engines to create a V8 or V12, or they'll chop some cylinders off of
a V8, for example, to make it into a V6. Taking an initially designed V8 and turning it into an
inline-4, though, that was weird. Pontiac used their versatile yet high-performance 389 cubic
inch V8 as the base, and they lopped off one bank of cylinders. The bore remained the same at 4.060
inches and the stroke at 3.6 inches, which meant that the same pistons and rods from the 389
could be used in this 4-banger too, thus helping the economies of scale at production. And if we
know anything about big car companies, it's that they love to save a nickel wherever they can.
Pontiac would obviously need to recast the block, as to not have a gaping hole in the side,
and create a new crankshaft. But on the outside of that, this new Trophy 4 was remarkably similar
to the Pontiac 389. Even the block still kept the existing cylinder bank on that 45-degree angle,
like the original V8 did. And since they kept one bank of cylinders unchanged,
they could use an entire V8 cylinder head here too. The exhaust manifold for that side would
work too, and over a hundred parts between the V8 and the inline-4 were compatible.
They were such sister motors that the engines could even be built on the same assembly line,
sans the few parts that were specific to each, like the block and their intake manifolds.
When all said and done, this half of a 389 displaced exactly half the cubes, at 194.5
cubic inches, which actually made it really large for a 4-cylinder. It was also pretty heavy for
one too. Utilizing a jerry-rigged iron V8 block that was recast for this, with existing iron
cylinder heads, meant that this 4-banger tipped the scales at about 550 pounds. Per reference,
a fully-dressed 1.8-liter, or 110-cubic-inch inline-4 that would've came in the MGB would've
displaced around 450 pounds. So the extra displacement of the Pontiac did carry with it
a weight penalty. There was a smattering of trim levels available for the Trophy 4,
all offering different levels of performance. At the low end of the totem pole, the base Trophy
4 offered 115 horsepower on tap, courtesy of a 2-barrel carburetor and a lower 8.6-to-1
compression ratio. The mid-tier option got a significantly higher power bump to 140 horsepower,
thanks to a new carb and a 10.25-to-1 compression ratio. And finally, there was the top-dog Trophy
4 that made 166 horsepower with its 4-barrel and that same high compression. Now at a glance,
this doesn't seem all that bad. This engine was half the size of a 389 and made half the power.
But upon closer examination, the Trophy 4's facade starts to unravel a bit. For all the shared parts
and clever cost-cutting, the Trophy 4 was, at its core, a compromise. And like all compromises,
it came with consequences. The most glaring of which was balance. A purpose-built inline-4 is
designed with counterweights, balance shafts, or specific engine geometries that neutralize
vibration. The Trophy 4 didn't really have any of that. Because it was literally half of a V8,
it inherited the V8's crankpin spacing and firing order, but had no opposing bank of cylinders to
counteract the force. The result was a car that, at idle, shook like a washing machine
loaded with cinder blocks. Okay, I may be exaggerating, but it was for sure harsher
than basically any other engine choice on the market outside of a race motor. Pontiac tried
to mitigate the shakes to the best of their ability using heavy rubber engine mounts and
the unorthodox driveshaft as a pseudo-damper, but inside the cabin, the vibrations translated
to buzzing dashboards and some annoyed passengers. Even worse, though, was the weight penalty.
Again, at 550 pounds, this was a pretty heavy motor to stick inside a compact car that it was
supposed to empower. A lot of people don't know this, but the Pontiac Tempest for those early
Trophy 4 years was also offered with the optional 215 cubic inch Buick V8, which made more power,
and since it was aluminum, it weighed less than the Trophy 4 by nearly 200 pounds. The 215 was
a gem of a motor, but something like over 95% of buyers opted for the Trophy 4 over the 215,
mainly due to cost. For most, on paper, it just didn't seem worth it, until they got a chance to
live with it, and then the 215 would have proved to have been worth every penny. Not really that
it mattered, though, because the Pontiac Trophy 4 only lasted as long as the first-generation
Tempest. By 1964, Pontiac moved the Tempest from the Y-body to GM's A-body platform. Along with
the platform change came a return to a conventional front-engine, rear-wheel-drive architecture for
all the brands at this time. The exotic rear-mounted transaxle and rope drive were tossed
aside, and the Trophy 4 was discontinued as well after just three model years, where it was
replaced by more conventional six-cylinders and eventually low cubic inch V8s across the board.
So, was the Trophy 4 a dead end? Well, not entirely. Despite its flaws and the fact that
it lived solely in the 61-63 Tempest for the average consumer, the engine was undeniably cool,
and it had some advantages. It made good torque for a four-banger. Plus, its displacement and
beefy internals meant that it could take punishment considering most of the components
were designed to hold way more power. The few hot-rodders out there who dared to modify the
Trophy 4 could squeeze upwards of 180 to 200 horsepower out of them without too much trouble.
People have supercharged these motors as well and gotten over 300 horsepower out of them doing so.
And because they're still on that 45-degree angle, the root-style superchargers, the way
they mount them on these Trophy 4s, looks super sick. But those supercharged builds
were really rare, because for most, the Trophy 4 just wasn't worth the trouble.
Most people bought the Tempest wanting a fairly affordable, up-badged form of transportation.
It was like an American-model BMW 3-series in essence, and that's what they got. But as
technology moved on and GM came to their senses, this motor got phased out to eventually make way
for engines like the Pontiac Overhead Cam 6 that followed, which was actually a fantastic motor.
The Trophy 4 itself wasn't bad, it wasn't great, but we can all agree
that it was undeniably unique. And that's why we made the video on it.
Hope you all enjoyed. This was just such a fascinating motor that I really had to dive
into this in detail. I did a video on this car and engine a little bit a long time ago,
but I didn't touch on the engine as much, so I wanted to make this video to do so.
If you liked it, please like, share, and comment. That really helps me out.
But otherwise, I will see you all in the next one, enthusiasts.
