What If We're NOT the First Civilization? Graham Hancock & Michael Button

Ancient Civilizations
15 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 7, 2025
Graham Hancock interviews Michael Button.
This interview was already published on the Graham Hancock Official Channel, but Graham was kind enough to let me post it here too!
The canvas gets much wider and much broader and we go back into deep time and have to consider
the possibility that the ability that we pride ourselves for, the ability to create civilizations,
was present in our ancestors tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, perhaps even more than
half a million years ago. I'm looking for productive ways to proceed. I would rather
cooperate with archaeologists than not. Last week I had the incredible opportunity to speak
to the legendary Graham Hancock. Now this interview was already uploaded onto Graham's
channel but he was kind enough to let me upload it onto mine as well. Now what's crazy is that
this is Graham interviewing me which is nuts and something I never thought would happen but it did
so for now here is my interview with Graham Hancock. Michael thanks for joining me today.
First of all congratulations on your YouTube channel which I think goes by by your name
and while we're dealing with such issues on your upcoming appearance in Scottsdale,
Arizona on the 5th to the 7th of November and that's the Quest for Ancient Civilizations
conference and we'll be putting a link to that conference in the description
of this video. I wish I could be there at that conference. It's organized by
two friends of mine Robert Dakota and Mike Collins and they do an excellent job so I
think you're going to have a fantastic event there and I encourage anybody who's tuning
into this to if you're in the US to attend the conference. It's going to be absolutely brilliant
and subscribe to Michael's channel. You're a fresh new voice in this field. So I think that's
where I want to begin. You are a fresh new and importantly young voice in this field and I have
to say as a bit of an old fart being 75 years old and having cut my teeth in the 1950s and 1960s
and particularly the revolutionary period of the 1960s, I find a lot of today's youth supine,
docile, unchallenging and unwilling to ask questions and that wasn't the case when I was
a young man. We challenged everything and I'm disappointed to see this trend in the youth today
where the voice of authority is just automatically accepted and never challenged and I think,
correct me if I'm wrong, I think that one of the important things you're doing
is challenging that voice of authority and asking the questions that need to be asked.
Well thank you Graham and yeah I mean it's a huge honour to be speaking with you today. You're
someone who's greatly inspired me over the years and have inspired millions of people around the
world so I'm very grateful to be speaking with you and to be speaking in front of your audience.
Yeah so my name is Michael Button. I'm an ancient history graduate who decided to not continue
pursuing a career in academia and instead start doing my own thing, go independent and
as you say start a YouTube channel just to talk about these ideas that I love really regarding
the dawn of civilization, the story of our species, the deep history of human intelligence and
things like that and the reason I chose to do that was because it was during the course of my
university study that I began to feel myself growing more and more opposed to the high level
perspective of human history, the timeline of our species that we were being taught. So about a year
ago I decided to start my YouTube channel and it's been an incredible journey ever since then.
Was there any particular event, any particular moment where you thought
right I'm going to start a channel now? So I finished my degree about four years ago now
so it wasn't that I was in my degree and I was immediately like I need to start my YouTube
channel. There was moments during my degree when I started getting a spark that I wasn't happy with
the the kind of conventional narrative regarding history. In terms of actually starting the channel
it was more accumulation over years and years of having this seed in my brain that I wasn't happy
with the kind of you know the story of history that I'd been taught and it never left me and
over the years after my YouTube channel I started doing a few other things after my degree I mean
but it never left me. It was always in my head and so yeah roughly around a year ago I decided
I want to start speaking about this, I want to put my opinions across. I felt like I was in a
relatively unique position to do so due to my academic background so I wouldn't say there was
necessarily a spark to start the YouTube channel. It was more a culmination of years of thinking
about these ideas and not being completely happy with the perspective that I had been taught and
that everyone pretty much is taught in the university system regarding our history.
Is your YouTube channel your only means of outreach at the moment or do you have other
social media outreach also? I mean I have all the social medias, I have Twitter X, I have Instagram
but the YouTube channel is the main thing that's where I speak about these ideas in detail so that's
We'll link all your social media links in the description as well
but in a few words I mean what do you hope to achieve with your channel? What's the plan?
What's the ultimate objective with this outreach that you're doing? I mean there's lots of ways
that we can reach out with information in the modern world. Books are kind of falling away,
people are not reading so much and it seems that visual media is the strong way to communicate.
What are you hoping to achieve with this project of yours? Well what I really want to get across
is the fact that so much of human history and especially the ancient stuff and the prehistoric
stuff is based on very fragmented bits of information that we construct narratives around
and these narratives are presented as facts and it's fine to construct narratives around these
small fragments of information that we have regarding our prehistoric past but they should
be presented as exactly that, as narratives rather than as facts, as truth and I felt myself
growing a little bit tired of the fact that we were taught that we knew everything about our
ancient past and our prehistoric past when I think that is not the case. I think there's such a
chasm, such a kind of shadow, such a murky cloud of unknown when it comes to these topics that
I didn't agree with the way that it has been presented by mainstream academia because I feel
like at the end of the day none of us really know what happened deep in prehistory and before the
start of civilization, before the invention of writing and even after then, so I felt that I
wanted to get across my opinions regarding our past and I felt the best way to do that was to do it
via a YouTube channel because I felt that is, as you say, quite a modern medium and it's a good
way to get to people that necessarily perhaps haven't read books or other kind of sources of
information so I felt like that was a good way to do it and that's kind of what I'm trying to
achieve. I'm trying to encourage people to ask questions about our stories as a species and
yeah that's what I'm trying to get across. Is your material available on other platforms
apart from YouTube like Spotify for example? It's not, I do post my videos on Rumble as well just
as a kind of safe backup but it's mainly YouTube for my stuff yeah. How important
are visuals in your videos? So it's quite important mainly because I almost source
what I'm saying with the visuals so I show the papers, I highlight the evidence that I've got
from the papers and obviously you can show ancient sites and stuff like that and I've been to a few
ancient sites so I film them when I'm there but I mean obviously what's more important is actually
what I'm saying but I try to complement that with good visuals as well. I suppose I'm
just wondering whether there's a parallel track that's audio only. People listen
to output in their cars. I'm finding these days my audio books
are doing much better than my print books and that's because people are making long car journeys
and it's an interesting diversion on a car journey. Have you thought about
an audio only version which doesn't depend on visuals? Yeah definitely and I mean things like
podcasts are absolutely booming at the moment and I definitely hope to one day either kind of convert
my video scripts into some sort of podcast audio form of media or just to start something new
along the line because as you say that is definitely a way that we can get these ideas across.
Well you know you're just really beginning in this field and yet your
channel already after what a year has become a meteoric success. What do you
attribute the success of your channel to? I'm not sure to be honest. I think partly I think I
do it quite well. I think you do too. I try my best to condense the information
into a digestible format and present it in a good way but also mainly because I think there's
so many people out there that aren't quite satisfied with the story of history that is presented
by academia and so many people are aware of these big inconsistencies and these massive questions
and want different sources of information, want people that take a slightly different perspective,
want people that come from a position of we don't know here's a possible answer rather than we know
here is the answer this is the truth you must believe it and I feel like someone like myself
and of course someone like you comes way more from the position of many things could be possible.
We sit in a place where we can't quite see the past, we don't know what happened in the past
and so here are some potential theories regarding what happened and I think people
gravitate towards that, people like that, people don't like being told exactly what to think and
how to feel about history so I think that is a big reason behind the success of what I do.
Yeah and the big reason behind the failure of mainstream archaeology to communicate in an
empathetic way with the public, the voices I hear coming out of mainstream archaeology have
no empathy at all for alternative ideas they just sneer at them and spit upon them and I think
they're out of touch with the public mood right now where people want to ask questions and
on that point questioning, asking questions is a big part of what you do on your channel. Give me
some examples of some of the questions that intrigue you and that you're asking that you
have asked and that you will ask in the future. Yeah so I began or I didn't begin but the first
videos I did that started to gain traction were when I started asking this question regarding how
long we have been a species and how that seems very opposed to this model we have of history that
nothing happened until effectively the Neolithic revolution and the Holocene climate epoch
which is the the idea is that that is what caused agriculture and thus civilization to develop
but it was during my university course that they announced that they discovered these homo sapien
remains in Morocco at the Jebel Ibroud site which had been dated to 315 000 years old or something
like that and very important discovery yeah very important discovery and I remember seeing that and
thinking which reminds us and it's worth making the point now that that that you and I and others
in the alternative sphere we do also depend on archaeology it's not that we're sneering at
archaeology it's a particular attitude that archaeology takes towards alternative
points of view which certainly bothers me but I would be the first to say
that I couldn't do any of my work without the work that archaeologists have done and I believe
that's the case with you as well I mean the Jebel Irhoud discovery is the result of the work of
archaeologists so let's give them credit where credit is due and at the same time let's
point out the faults in the way that they're dealing because I think there could be a synergy
between the alternative and quote unquote mainstream points of view you know it doesn't
have to be this sort of mutual hate campaign it could be if that side did not constantly
smear us and sneer at us I think our reaction to them would be completely different but
the fact is you know we have a right of self-defense and speaking personally I've been
attacked by archaeology consistently continuously for more than 30 years and it's very
clear that that technique on the part of archaeology isn't actually working. Yeah very much so and
you've always handed yourself a great grace Graham even though you've been attacked by many people
most of the time extremely unfairly but I completely agree we use archaeologists and
historians work all the time because we have to because they do great work they discover these
things that we need to use to you know talk about these theories and pose these questions but it
is sad that I think it's possibly more of a vocal a very vocal minority rather than perhaps a
broad brushstroke of all archaeologists that very much make themselves heard when they smear people
like yourself and that is sad but I like to think that hopefully more and more archaeologists
and mainstream historians will start to look at these questions and become to you know start to
come on board with these ideas and start to delve into them in a or if not to come on board at least
at least not to smear them and sneer at them this is this it's this snobbish we know best we know
everything attitude of what you rightly say is a is a small faction of archaeologists it's like
fundamentalist archaeology it's wrong even to call it mainstream archaeology it's a small faction
um the the the problem is that other archaeologists despite being aware that these
people are often deceptive and dishonest are circling the wagons around them and are not
speaking out against them and ultimately that means that the rest of archaeology is complicit
uh in in what these uh individuals are doing yeah and I I fundamentally disagree with that
viewpoint because I think at the end of the day as I said earlier none of us quite know what was
going on in the deep past the older you go as well the harder it is for us to to understand what could
possibly have happened so I think that the the possibilities are much wider than what is
conventionally accepted so I do not understand when people viciously attack others for simply
posing alternative points of view it doesn't mean that the alternative points of view are necessarily
correct but I think they're worth you know raising so with open-minded consideration and yet and yet
these individuals react as though it's some kind of existential threat to them something something
that must be fought tooth and nail must be must be attacked and and and and and actually
misrepresented so often these these attacks are are straw man attacks they say you know Hancock
said this or Button said this but uh actually neither I nor you did say that they create a
straw man and then attack that and for for members of the public who don't dive deeper and who don't
look into it deeper the words of these archaeologists may may ring home and they may think
oh that's true and they just accept it I I I do actually regard it as an abuse of archaeological
authority archaeologists are given a certain authority and status in our society and they
should not use that authority and status to undermine and attack ideas that they simply
don't agree with it can be done in a more decent a more civil way without the insults that that
constantly fly around I I I note that um Clint Dibble who's one of the one of the uh individuals
who um has consistently attacked my work over the years and of course he's got every right to attack
my work and I don't I don't take that away from him what I object to is is the smears and the
sneers and and I noticed let me see what did he just say about you oh he just said about you in
a recent post about you Michael Button this dude keeps making ---- up like a grifter I mean I can't
tell you how many times though that same language has been applied to me by Flint Dibble and by
others who are associated with with him uh this is sort of cheap easy dismissal this dude keeps
making ---- up like a grifter and this constant use of the word grifter well in this case you
know what it was about it's about this this this recent evidence of potentially much greater
antiquity for the human species were you making ---- up were you were you being a grifter how do
you respond to to to this kind of smear being put out on social media uh against you by a man like
Clint Dibble I find I found that absolutely bizarre because for all the things he could have come at me
for that post that he did come at me for I directly quoted the BBC article regarding this find uh word
for word so he I'm not quite sure why he's calling me a grifter on that uh note because I am literally
just reporting the news that is being reported by outlets such as the BBC and that has been
announced by the Natural History Museum so I'm not quite sure how that makes me a grifter in any way
but I think that's just the way they operate and um it's part of their playbook it's to use
it's to use language like this to keep on applying it to people who they disagree with to keep that
keep on calling them grifters to never accept that that that the people they disagree with
might actually be sincere and honest in our our point of view uh to to always try to attach this
notion of grifter hoax fraud to to what we're doing and and this to me is a playbook this is
this is a deliberate strategy it never really involves in-depth uh investigation or criticism
of what we're saying it's just this constant constant smearing and that definitely started
with archaeologists and their friends in social media and and I'm I'm very clear that you and I
and others on the alternative side are simply fighting back against these these smear attacks
and they they then represent our fight back as an attack upon them it's a very bizarre situation
that we're in at the moment and it's doubly bizarre because it concerns the human past
our collective past as a human species could there be anything more important than that
in understanding our collective future as a species yeah it's it's an odd odd way of operating
and uh I always say challenge me with ideas instead of insults because I'm perfectly happy
for people to you know disagree with my conclusions that I've drawn from evidence and say that actually
I think this is that that's perfectly fine but to just randomly insult me as a person I I'm not
quite sure where he's going with that especially in regard to this discovery I think it's mainly
just because this is a discovery that's extremely disruptive to the the worldview that people like
flint dibble have because obviously if homo sapiens are potentially 1 million years old which is what
this study strongly suggests or at least strongly suggests that our lineage diverged that far back
in time that is an incredibly disruptive discovery for their worldview of history that they promote
and that they defend so viciously so I think it's more than isn't it I I mean what we're saying is
that the the um the defining characteristic of of the human being is the ability to create
civilization that's that's what we do that other animal species don't do um and and the notion of
a lost civilization didn't quite fit when we thought that our species was just 50 000 years
old or 40 000 years old as we did back in the 1990s there isn't there isn't enough room in that
40 or 50 000 years to lose a whole civilization but then when you have Jebel Irhoud pushing
the human species back to more than 300 000 years and then when we consider Neanderthals
and Denis Servans and Homo Naledi and Homo Floresiensis all the other different human
species who have a right to claim humanity and who appear to have indulged in cultural activities
the canvas gets much wider and much broader and we go back into deep time and have to consider
the possibility that the ability that we pride ourselves for the ability to create civilizations
was present in our ancestors tens of thousands hundreds of thousands perhaps even more than half
a million years ago and this just rips the rug out from under the feet of the rips the foundations
to use a better metaphor from from beneath the house of history that archaeologists have built
yeah i mean and this is the thing it's because we have these models of history that we
developed or not we but the you know archaeology or history developed collectively as a as a society
and as and in that society it is archaeologists who are specifically tasked with investigating
and understanding the past and that's why i talk about the abuse of archaeological power
because it's like a doctor telling you you you must take this vaccine because it's better for
you without giving us any choice in the matter and that's the same with archaeology they say
we know best this is how it is and everything else is wrong and and this can't be a productive
way to proceed in the future i'm looking for i'm looking for productive ways to proceed i would
rather cooperate with archaeologists than not and and the only thing that's barring that cooperation
is the tendency of archaeologists to smear uh to mount smear campaigns and and to to to to
pour insults upon us inevitably we have to react to that and somehow somehow this has to come i'm
not a i'm not a pacifist if people attack me i am definitely going to to hit back maybe i should
become more i don't know more zen uh in in in my outlook you're just beginning you're going to face
a lot of this you're going to hear yourself called a grifter many many times in the future i
see in a follow-up comment he also called you a pseudoscientist that's another one of their
favorite labels to try to just get rid of anybody without they don't even have to do any hard work
they just apply the labels and hope that enough people will just see those labels and not think
of anything else yeah they do that and because then exactly then people immediately think you
know graham or michael is a pseudoscientist you can't listen to anything they say but
another thing they love is saying these ideas have already been debunked uh they constantly
constantly repeat that these ideas have already been debunked why because because somebody said
that they had debunked the ideas i'm sorry that's not good enough to debunk ideas you have to go in
depth into those ideas not simply not simply knee jerk reject them yeah and i think the core problem
is that many of these archaeologists still base their idea around history around these this world
view that was created you know 50 to 100 years ago when you know the discipline really started
which is you know homo sapiens only 30 to 50 000 years old climate then got warmer about 30 000
years later civilization developed blah blah makes perfect sense but over the last you know half
century the evidence has come on so so much since then but we are still stuck clinging to this out
of date world view but now that we know modern humans are 300 000 years old from fossil evidence
now that we have serious evidence that suggests our species diverged up to a million years ago
it starts to make absolutely no sense in my view that nothing happened that we didn't really
develop as a species technologically at all for you know 99.99 of our history we lived in one
exclusive form of life as a nomadic hunter-gatherer for you know if if we've been around let's take
fossil remains in morocco if we've been around for we have been around for 300 000 years to then
say that nothing happened in terms of technological or any kind of development right up until the
neolithic revolution 12 000 years ago doesn't make sense to me especially as the argument is that it's
the climate that led to that change but we've lived through multiple warm periods in that time
and then if you take the divergence from a million years ago then we've lived through something like
11 warm periods and so it just cannot complete perhaps the most intriguing is the is the emian
around 120 000 years ago when the world was certainly for many thousands of years a much
more hospitable place than it even is today yep perfectly stable climate it lasted for longer
than the holocene has so far and you think of how much we've achieved in the holocene and the emian
you know there's a few thousand years to go until we reach the length of the emian um and it was
yeah warm and stable as you say and we'd already been around even if you take the oldest fossil
remains for you know the best part of 200 000 years as an anatomically modern species so what's
to say we couldn't have achieved anything what's to say sophisticated human culture couldn't have
flourished in the emian and we just don't see it because it's so long ago because it's 120 000
years ago that what are the chances we would see much to survive from that long we have hardly any
homo sapien sites that are older than a hundred thousand years so what are the what are the
chances we would see if a sophisticated human culture had flourished back then it's uh it's
hard to say that we would actually see anything at all well it's a problem of visibility or
specifically of archaeologically archaeological visibility at the point at which something
becomes visible to archaeologists and i think there's two aspects of that one is um the fact
that only a tiny proportion of the earth's surface has ever been investigated at all
by archaeologists now the fact that archaeologists haven't investigated the vast mass of the earth's
surface doesn't prove that there was a lost civilization of course that doesn't prove
anything but when we look at the areas that haven't been investigated enough uh for example
the sahara desert for example the amazon rainforest for example the submerged continental shelves
which were flooded at the end of the last ice age uh when when we we look at all of these we're
looking at areas that were actually habitable and perhaps the best real estate on earth during the
last ice age and they're precisely the areas that archaeology should be deeply investigating not
shallowly investigating they'll say oh we've we've scanned dozens of sites in the sahara i'm sorry
that's just not enough the sahara is way too big what's needed is a very detailed investigation
likewise with the amazon rainforest we're already puzzling new information is emerging and likewise
in the continental shelves i'm i'm pleased to see that the national institute of ocean technology
in india is following up dives that i and santa did back in the late 1990s and early 2000s uh
of southeast india looking at at submerged structures there much more work needs to be
done fortunately some archaeologists are doing it but we have huge areas of the world that were
very attractive for human beings during the last ice age that simply have not been investigated at
all that's visibility problem number one visibility problem number two you've already touched on is
the is the massive destruction that time brings anything that's in the intertidal zone for example
during sea level rise in the first five meters is going to be pounded pounded pounded by
massive waves and just ground to dust and rubble very very very quickly so there's the destructive
effect of the ages and then finally and this is the point i'd like to address i'd like you to
address michael is the the fact is that a hypothetical a hypothetical civilization of
prehistory of the last ice age might not look anything like what we think a civilization
should look like i think this is part of when archaea we go for archaeological visibility
archaeologists have a pair of binoculars in front of their eyes and what they appear to be looking
for if they're going to accept any notion of a high civilization what they appear to be looking
for is something like us address that point should we be looking for something like us if we're
looking for a lost civilization well that i mean this is the thing humans are so adaptable as a
species and we can live in so many different environments and progress in so many different
ways that this idea that we're looking for exactly our civilization in the past you know
skyscrapers and and train tracks or whatever you know it's it's it's unlikely that humans would
progress in the specific same way every single time and human culture has the potential to
flourish in so many different ways and so to challenge to to deal with different challenges
in different ways and i always think when i'm looking back in to say again the emian period is
for example like what's to say a human culture didn't flourish back then in a completely in a
you know using materials that they just found in their environment like the wood the hide the
reeds or anything they could find in their in their local environment and just build a very
sophisticated culture they could easily have lived in a permanent settlement there could be multiple
permanent settlements that will connect trade together they could have had writing which they
wrote on some form of paper or anything and all of that it would be completely gone by say 10 000
years later let alone 100 000 years later and so these possibilities are they don't seem to people
don't seem to agree that that is a possibility and i really don't understand that i think that when
we look at our past we should surely accept that multiple possibilities are viable and uh yeah i
don't understand why anything like this is is dismissed yeah and and has become the subject of
such heated uh conversations particularly online i mean i i realize that there is a toxic element
to the whole online online world but but it has become particularly toxic uh around this field of
of of prehistory i mean i i don't regard myself as a conspiracy theorist and by the way conspiracy
theorist is another one of those put downs that that archaeologists use oh it's just a conspiracy
theory um i i i i don't regard myself as a conspiracy theorist but i but i do i do sometimes
wonder what what what's going on it seems that whenever one touches on the issue of a cataclysm
that brought a former civilization to an end which i've inevitably had to do in my in in my book since
Fingerprints of the Gods that was published in 1995 and that's when these attacks really began
uh the moment that you consider the possibility that some kind of cataclysm
was it a an impact of multiple fragments of a disintegrating comet that's my favorite scenario
at the moment but it's not the only one professor robert shock at boston university attributes the
onset of the younger dryas cataclysmic climate episode to changes in solar activity uh the the
the reason why it happened uh is is not clear i we may have our favorite points of view and
i think the younger dryas impact hypothesis is the strongest but i'm open to many other
hypotheses as well that consider this bizarre climate episode called the younger dryas that
set in about 12 800 years ago and ended about 11 600 years ago and whatever caused it it was
horrendously cataclysmic uh and i think that's the point where we become a species with amnesia
where we where we lose track we lose our memory uh of of of what went before but it
it bothers me that it's the the moment one starts talking about a cataclysm bringing an end to a
former civilization that this is what brings the the swarm of bees down down upon you uh
why why is there this this fear of talking about cataclysms i don't want to be a conspiracy
theorist but is does somebody know that that that this is that that what goes around comes around
that the certainly in terms of the younger dryas impact hypothesis we do pass through the torrid
meteor stream twice a year and the torrid meteor stream contains dozens of enormous objects which
are the remnants of a fragmented comet is it is it possible that somebody knows something that we
don't know that that that that or is it just that that it's kind of considered bad taste to talk
about cataclysms why why do they provoke such a reaction from the mainstream i think it's because
we think in very short time scales we think in the time scale of a human life 100 years or at
most the time scale of our civilization you know 5 000 years but it's obvious that earth has been
profoundly shaped by cataclysms by natural disaster by natural events and has done throughout
the speech the history of our species like as we say we've been around for so long and the earth
has been subject to incredibly devastating things during that time that has both the potential to
wipe out human culture and to erase the geological and archaeological record clean that those cultures
ever existed and i think that people are so opposed to it because we have lived in this
stable period for the last 12 000 years and so in our human brains it's like oh the climate is
it's fine we don't have these massive natural disasters that impact the entire planet or vast
regions of the planet but you just have to look at the kind of geological record of the earth to
see that we do and that we have been living in an abnormal time because it's warm and stable but the
norm is cataclysm and massive changes in temperature and huge events that can completely disrupt the
climate and human populations on the earth and then when you look at the younger dryas which is
probably the most recent one that you could define as a kind of cataclysmic climate event
the climate was getting warm the climate was getting stable civilization could have you know
begun flourished or already existed and then we have this dramatic event we have this horrific
event for whoever was living there and as you say no matter what it is that caused it that can be
debated and we haven't fully established that yet but the fact is it was a completely horrific
climate shift that would have been devastating for human culture in whatever form it was that
lived on the planet at that time and stayed devastating for you know the best part of a
thousand years i think so i don't understand why because we debate what caused the younger dryas
that kind of shoves away the fact that the younger dryas was a very dramatic event and
definitely had the potential to cause severe devastation so i don't know i'm not sure exactly
where i land on the debate i think there's very good merits to the the comet research group and
i've looked into their work a bit i did a small video on that i didn't do too much of a deep dive
but i did a little bit of an inquiry into the potential of a comet striking 12 000 years ago
and there's obviously some interesting kind of mythological evidence if you want to call it that
for such a thing occurring but yeah i don't fall into any camp particularly but i think
while you're looking at the different camps do do take a look at robert shock's excellent work
on the the involvement the possible involvement of the sun in the in the younger dryas events
you know robert shock is another person of a professor of geology at boston university who
stuck his neck out and taken the slings and arrows of hatred that have been projected at him by
again this this small group of of archaeologists who seem to want to own the past robert has stuck
his neck out and taken those risks and put his reputation on the line and carried on doing
excellent excellent excellent geological work and and and again i i feel this is this is worth
recognizing so i hope you'll take a look into into robert's take on the younger dryas as well
yeah i will and as you say that's another thing that can cause massive disruption on this planet
and there are so many different factors that we just do not appreciate what we've been through as
a species what we know we have been through because we know that our species is at least
300 000 years old we know our species is now potentially you know up to a million years old
when we diverged so we have been through some incredible things and it's both testament to
how good we are as survivors but it's also testament to how much could have happened how
many stories how many human lives how many cultures potentially flourished rose and fell
in our deep past and the the history of the earth is so brutal the fact that we made it through
what would we do we really expect that nothing happened and that we just kept going up and we
didn't have any setbacks that nothing pushed us back it doesn't make sense to me and yeah i mean
dr robert shock is a very very interesting guy i've obviously looked into his work on the sphinx
with john anthony west and very interesting that ties into the green sahara that you were talking
about earlier which is a bizarre thing that's never made sense to me that you know yeah i'm
i'm just just planning uh i think we were talking off air about that but i i'm i'm actually about to
to take a big trip uh right across the sahara uh because the fact of the matter is that the sahara
was green and fertile uh for several thousand years before ancient egypt appears as an
archaeologically recognizable civilization along the banks of the nile uh and and uh you know i i
have to wonder whether whether some of the mystery of the origins of ancient egyptian
civilization may lie in the in the sahara desert which we know for sure had lakes had had had rivers
had grasslands had savannah was a nurturing and positive environment for thousands of years
certainly from 10 11 000 years ago down to about seven or six thousand years ago and then suddenly
ancient egypt appears as a as a fully developed pre-dynastic egypt as a fully fully developed
civilization on on on the banks of the nile and you know it's the it's the background to these
things the same with mesopotamia when we go when we go there ancient sumer ancient sumer actually
doesn't just come out of nothing there is a background to that as well um and uh yeah i'm i'm
interested in in looking at all of that just to just to round up on the on the cataclysm issue
i've noticed that when i talk uh about the younger dryas which was undoubtedly a massive
climate change event that took place between 12 800 and 11 600 years ago whatever caused it
when i talk about that quite often on youtube youtube will add a warning uh telling viewers
that you know this can day contains counterfactual information about climate so it seems that maybe
the reason that that certain archaeologists are are just so dismissive of the role of cataclysms
in in the human story is because the role of those cataclysms uh to some extent undermines
the climate change ideology being entirely caused by human beings uh which is now uh very much in
in the air in fact it's one of those things that you can hardly question without having a a swarm
of attacks uh descending upon you now i'm i'm not saying that there is no climate change there is
climate change today for sure it's minor by comparison with what happened during the younger
dryas but there is climate change today and i think that the broader factors that cause climate change
need to be taken into account as well as human activity that doesn't mean that i think we're
doing things right as human beings i think we should love and nurture and care for our planet
i think we should do everything right by our planet because our planet has been doing right by us
we have this is our home this is our garden in the universe this is where we live where our future is
where our children are and our grandchildren will grow up we have to take care of it nurture it love
it look after it not pollute it not destroy it but the climate change narrative is using fear
to make people afraid and that is counterproductive if if we want human beings to
behave in a better way towards the planet it's not it's not creating a false narrative uh about
how we're the cause of everything it's understanding that we could behave in a much better way towards
the planet and we don't need fear to drive us that we just need intelligence and and love and respect
for this planet that has given us life yeah i mean both things can be true right like yes we should
definitely treat the planet with more respect and we should try and clean up our act for sure but
also this buys into the whole kind of arrogance almost of the modern view we think we know
everything that happened in the past we think we are the biggest you know influencer on the climate
but we're clearly not you just have to look at the temperature record of the last three hundred
thousand years or last million years and i got similar warnings on some of my videos where i
talk about these topics and i'm literally just discussing the temperature graphs and saying look
it's up it's down it's up it's down and we're currently up we don't want to go down and yet
i still get flags for you know disrupting the climate change narrative because we do not want
it to get cold global warming is bad but global cooling dramatic global cooling would be devastating
for our civilization and has potentially been devastating for civilizations that occurred in the
past yeah no it's very it's it's it's slightly sinister that there are more and more subjects
in the world today which um one becomes almost afraid to talk about uh because of the the the
massive hostile negative reaction that that will be produced it's we seem to be entering blindfold
into a kind of orwellian world you know george l george orwell really got it right back in 1984
and that is what's happening it's wearing different clothes it doesn't look exactly
like the 1984 world he imagined but when you get down to the roots of it thought control mind
control thought crime all of these things are actually happening in our society today and
it's so weird that one of those thought crimes is to even consider the possibility that archaeology
might have missed a whole civilization in the in the human record michael i'm sorry i'm getting
into a bit of a rant here so i just want to move on what what are your plans for the future um and
do you have any travel bucket lists that you're intending to fulfill in the years ahead yeah so i
mean my plans for the the near future is to keep doing what i'm doing keep pumping out videos keep
asking these questions i really hope that this channel provides me with the opportunity to start
to travel to these ancient sites as you mentioned because now that i am you know getting some
traction i feel like i can justify the going you know abroad and going to all these sites and you
know making content about them giving my views about them so i really hope that that is the kind
of place i can take it in terms of my bucket list for where i want to go i am planning to go to
egypt early next year so that's number one of the the bucket list definitely to giza your audience
is going to have a treat to look forward to i hope so i hope so i hope i can uh you know because i
mean obviously egypt's been covered a lot by lots of people including yourself so i don't want to
you know just like rehash old stuff but the point of view is as i said at the beginning you're
you're bringing a fresh new perspective to these ideas and that's just absolutely what's needed
right now yeah yeah so i'm just gonna you know go there see it for myself mainly but also convey uh
my opinions on because i haven't really touched egypt in my videos i did one video about the sahara
but i've yeah because i you know it's it's almost the best place and i i want to kind of save it
until i'm ready so uh so yeah that's number one in the bucket list and i might make it a two-week
trip and go to the south of the country as well but i haven't quite decided yet so that's number
one on the bucket list number two is right with me before you go i can give you some suggestions
i'd love that i'd love that thank you gray um number two is a is a big battle between uh turkey
uh ancient anatolia and south america i always switch between which one i want to go to i'll
probably end up going to turkey first just for convenience because obviously us in the uk we can
get to turkey and it's also it's it's the heart of a huge mystery at the moment i mean what is
being revealed in turkey around the tash tepler civilization which is the name that turkish
archaeologists are giving to what is now clearly a civilization of which gobekli tepe was a part
uh a civilization that extends down into the jordan valley that extends into syria
that extends as far as cyprus uh the heart of this matter is is in turkey is in is in anatolia
where the tigris and euphrates rivers rise that run down into mesopotamia the home of
supposedly the world's first high civilization uh ancient sumer so yeah i'd highly recommend
turkey as uh as a very important point on your on your yeah definitely i really want to go there
and i think that just quickly on that point i think that tash tepella and gobekli tepe and
all these sites will be classified as civilization one day i think it's just going to take you know
a few years or just people's thinking to update because there is so much evidence that you know
they're all connected this monumental architecture said some shared symbolic thinking therefore
probably shared you know spiritual thinking and yeah i mean it has a lot it's it's just in many
senses michael the lost civilization that we're looking for has actually been found there's already
been found there in turkey uh and gobekli tepe isn't the whole story it's part of the story
and i think um me as well as many other people that was the the big smoking gun that really
shifted my viewpoint and then led me to start looking into all this other stuff because i
remember seeing that and i remember thinking why is this not considered civilization look at some
of the civilizations we do consider civilizations in you know post 3000 bc many of them don't tick
every single part of the checklist but because they're at the right date they're considered
civilization so it seems to me the only reason tash tepella isn't considered civilization is
purely because of this extremely uncomfortable date but i think that with time thinking will
update on that and uh yeah i look forward to it and yeah definitely really want to go there
um and then as i mentioned i want to go to south america i really want to see sasha
joman where i know you've just been i really want to see oyatai tambo not only that uh
having just been to peru the actually the main focus of the visit that santa and i just made to
peru uh wasn't sasha although exciting and extraordinary things are happening there which
which i'm going to be documenting um but but really intriguing on peru are the coastal pyramid
cities banduria caral uh penico aspero uh these are if we go for the orthodox dates of the giza
pyramids these gigantic pyramids in peru are older than those they're they're they're hitting close
more and again all tribute to the work of archaeologist ruth shady solace who has
single-handedly but now with a good team around her being responsible for the revelation and
excavation of these sites which are completely changing human history i remember a time when
it used to be said oh there could be no connection of any kind between the pyramids of egypt and the
pyramids of the americas because the pyramids of the americas are much younger well no sorry here
again another turn of the archaeologist spade has revealed that that old saw was not correct
and that there are older pyramids in in the americas so that's another area i'd i'd recommend
you bring your fresh new perspective to it take a look at definitely and there's just so much
mystery in south america so much mystery it's it's almost unbelievable how little we know
i think in comparison to some other parts of the world it's uh it's incredible so so yeah i
definitely want to visit all those sites um but that would be a big big big trip but hopefully
it's it's it's it's a it's a big trip but you've started you've started on the road
you've got an excellent channel out there you're asking thought-provoking questions
and you're getting people who might not be interested in these subjects at all to take
an interest in them uh and you're also getting the flack from the archaeological lobby so
welcome to the club i'll i'll remind our our viewers again that you are speaking in the united
states um fifth to the seventh of november and that's at the quest for the lost civilizations
conference it's going to be held in scottsdale arizona in the u.s we will put the link in the
description of this of this video and i hope those who are in the u.s or able to get to the u.s will
attend that conference because as well as you there's a lot of other excellent speakers and
it's going to be a really fantastic event i'm very glad for you that you've been invited to
speak there and i i look forward to seeing the hopefully the broadcast of what you have to say
afterwards i wish i could join you but i'm i'm too busy writing a new book right now yeah well
i'm very excited um both for your new book and also for the for the conference um i am yeah
really looking forward to meeting so many cool people uh both the speakers and also everyone
that's going to come along it's going to be a really exciting event and um yeah super super
looking forward to it it's around christmas time i think so christmas in arizona should be
should be great well not quite christmas fifth not quite that's christmas time hang on scottsdale
arizona is it it's it's it's not november it's december let me get this right let me get this
right it's fifth yeah sorry i may have i may have announced it incorrectly at the beginning of i
think you said december maybe not and i i may have said november you know we get confused at my great
age um but anyway it's the quest for ancient civilizations scottsdale arizona 5th to the 7th
of december 2025 and the link will be in the description uh under under this video michael
thank you very much for joining me today it's been a pleasure to talk with you and i wish you
joy on your path in the future thank you graham as i said it's it's a great honor to speak with
you you've inspired me a lot so thank you so much and uh i hope everyone enjoyed it i'm i'm i'm sure
that many people will find this discussion of of interest and and i i intend to have more
discussions like this with with with more people in the future uh this might even be the beginning
of a graham hancock podcast who knows you should love to see it if so it'll have to wait until i
finish the new book but somewhere down the line yeah i mean you're a great interviewer graham and
you're you're a great man so the people would love to see something like that i'm i'm absolutely
certain thank you for those kind words michael i really appreciate it very good to talk to you be
wow what an honor i just want to again extend my thanks to graham for this incredible opportunity
thanks so much for watching guys and if you enjoyed this video please consider giving it
a like or subscribing to my channel see you next time
