China’s Rare Earth Strategy Backfires! Trump Kicks Xi Out, Discovers 12.5 Million Tons of Rare Earth

Global Finance News
11 followers
A river near a rare earth mining site in Jiangxi province is facing severe pollution.
Video footage reveals untreated wastewater contaminated with rare earth waste being
released directly into the waterway. The Doing vlogger raised concerns about the lasting
environmental damage caused by rare earth mining, warning that the harm extends beyond the present,
threatening the future of local communities and leaving future generations to bear the consequences.
Another video exposed a rare earth processing plant in Ganzhou, Jiangxi. The wastewater from
the factory flows directly into a nearby reservoir and the air is filled with a pungent unpleasant
smell. This unchecked pollution has posed a significant threat to the physical and mental
health of local residents. The vlogger who posted the video urged attention to these hidden dangers.
Next, let's look at the rare earth ore processing site. In a simple shed, several workers without
any protective equipment are engaged in rough processing and loading of rare earth ore powder.
The vlogger pointed out that while the mining process itself is straightforward,
its environmental cost is high. Mining areas are often barren and the land remains permanently
desolate. Reports have indicated that producing one ton of rare earth ore in China requires
permanently destroying about 200 square meters of vegetation, piling up 2,000 tons of waste
tailing and posing serious health risks to surrounding residents. For example, near a rare
earth lake in Inner Mongolia, some villages have cancer rates that are several times higher than
the national average, which is deeply alarming. This is the heavy price of the rare earth hegemony
that the Chinese Communist Party takes pride in.
What did we trade for this systemic hegemony? When we secured leverage over others,
did we ever think about how our own water and land might be held hostage? Some might say that
for the rise of a great nation, for international leverage, sacrifices must be made. A price must
be paid. But anyone who says that a price must be paid is never the one paying it. Because those
who speak from a comfortable position don't feel the pain themselves. The vlogger described this
move as the CCP using its control over rare earth to pressure Western countries, particularly the
United States. On October 9, the CCP announced new export controls on rare earth materials and
technologies, aiming to limit their availability to foreign markets. In response, the US took
multiple countermeasures, including increasing tariffs, further escalating tensions between the
Shortly after, on October 30, US President Trump and Xi Jinping met in South Korea, and Trump
stated in a joint media interview abroad Air Force One that the two sides had reached a one-year
agreement on critical rare earth supplies, with the possibility of extending it. This meant that
the CCP temporarily withdrew the rare earth card. At the same time, the US announced the cancellation
of the 100% tariff on Chinese goods that was set to begin in November. Xi Jinping used the withdrawal
of the rare earth export restrictions as leverage to secure the removal of tariffs by the US.
The CCP has lost on both fronts in this battle, and here's the reason why. On one hand,
the entire extraction process of rare earth comes at the expense of the environment and lives,
making it highly costly. The CCP's official estimates show that the environmental restoration
debt in a region of Ganzhou Jiangxi reached 38 billion yuan a decade ago, and over the years,
the figure has only grown. CCTV reported in 2012 that in some old mining areas of Jiangxi,
entire mountains had been dissolved, and water wells were filled with dark,
soya-sauce-coloured water, posing serious threats to local residents' safety.
However, China's state-owned rare earth companies are generally operating at a loss.
Companies like China Rare Earth and Guangshan Nonferrous, key players in the heavy rare earth
sector, or Northern Rare Earth, a leader in light rare earths, have reported poor financial results.
Profits are slim, and some quarters even show negative growth. Cash flow per share is often
tight. Articles have analysed that this is primarily due to internal management issues,
particularly lax cost control. Some state-owned rare earth giants, perhaps complacent with their
monopoly, lack the drive for careful budgeting. Excessive internal consumption erodes already
weak profits, reducing their market advantage. Additionally, the rare earth industry is riddled
with complex, interrelated transactions creating a web that is difficult to navigate,
from underground mining to smelting and separation, and then to downstream processing
and applications. The rare earth supply chain is long and intricate. These internal flows provide
opportunities for profit to be shuffled between different entities. The practice of keeping profit
within the group while benefiting the overall group can lead to distorted financial reports
for listed companies, making it difficult for external investors to accurately gauge
their true profitability. This in turn reflects a broader issue of state-owned enterprises' monopolies,
which gives rise to several misalignments with market economics. This includes weakening market
signals, a lack of innovation, inefficiencies in internal management, and heightened risk of
countermeasures against exports. Over time, these factors could become significant obstacles to the
development of China's rare earth industry. This means that the enormous cost is not yielding good
profits. At this point, the CCP wants to play the rare earth card by withholding rare earth from the
essentially shrinking the profit margin to rare earths even further. The CCP's rare earth strategy
angered President Trump, who then raised tariffs on China. The CCP's decision to lift the export
restrictions was the condition for the US to remove those tariffs. For the CCP, it essentially
gained nothing but saw the profits of its rare earth enterprises shrink. Veteran media professional
Guo Jun remarked on the Elite Forum program that before the fourth plenary session, Xi Jinping
attempted to forcefully play the rare earth card. He sought to initiate the so-called global rare
earth long-arm jurisdiction by restricting rare earth exports. But this strategy failed. The US
responded by launching a comprehensive constitution plan, causing rare earth futures on the London
metal exchange to fall by 12% that day. Chinese rare earth stocks also plummeted. This blow made
many within the CCP realize that this path was not viable. According to internal sources, the new
central power core has now halted the rare earth battle, or else the China-US trade talks would
never have progressed. This was a strategic loss for the CCP, and the loss of troops was the
backlash from the Western world, particularly the US, which Trump united with other countries
to develop alternatives to rare earths, effectively pushing Xi Jinping out. This could prove to be a
fatal blow, rendering the CCP's rare earth strategy ineffective. Taiwan's Institute of National Defense
and Security Research Director Xu Ziyun told foreign media that the Trump-Xi meeting marked
a temporary ceasefire, with both sides putting a hold on the rare earth issue for a year.
Both sides are following different strategies. Beijing still wants to keep rare earth as a
bargaining chip for future use, but the West will quickly move to reduce dependence on China's rare
earths. Veteran media professional Akio Yaitai also remarked that the one-year delay in China's
rare earth export control to the US has given the US valuable time. With a year to prepare,
the US could become self-sufficient by purchasing rare earths from other countries and developing
its own, easing its dependence. The United States is working to rebuild its rare earth
supply chain domestically. Key actions include supporting the revival and expansion of Mountain
Pass, the only large-scale rare earth mine still active in the US. This mine produces some of the
world's highest-grade rare earth elements, including neodymium, praseodymium, cerium,
and lanthanum. Since its reopening in 2018, it has produced about 45,000 tons of rare earth
annually and continues to expand. The US government, along with the Department of
Defense, is heavily backing the development of a domestic rare earth supply chain to strengthen
the country's strategic resource security. The US government has also made direct investments
or provided low-interest loans to domestic rare earth companies like MP Materials,
encouraging their integration of downstream operations. The Department of Defense invested
$400 million in convertible preferred stock, becoming MP Materials' largest shareholder.
In October, the Department of Defense added a $150 million loan and committed to purchasing
all rare earth magnets produced by MP Materials, setting a price floor for neodymium and praseodymium
for the next 10 years to prevent Chinese price manipulation. MP Materials is currently building
a rare earth magnet plant in Fort Worth, Texas. In Austin, Texas, Noveon Magnetics has emerged as
a symbol of the US rare earth industry revival. After 10 years of development,
Noveon officially began the commercial sale of rare earth magnets in 2023.
Back in 2017, during his first term, President Trump signed Executive Order 13817 formally
recognizing rare earth under the Defense Production Act. This gave the US government
the authority to support the rare earth industry by utilizing wartime resources. In 2021, the US
released the Critical Minerals and Semiconductor Supply Chain 100-Day Review Report, identifying
rare earth as a strategic resource. The report also included direct investments in private rare
earth companies to restart the domestic supply chain and strengthen control over its strategic
management. While the CCP has weaponized rare earth, creating short-term supply shortages,
this has ironically accelerated global cooperation and the relocation of production capacities.
On the international stage, President Trump is actively strengthening partnerships with
traditional allies and emerging nations. On October 28, President Trump met with Japan's
new Prime Minister, Sanae Takaichi, to sign the Rare Earth and Critical Minerals Supply Chain
Framework Agreement. This agreement covers resource extraction, processing, and stockpiling
coordination to ensure the availability of materials needed for industries such as electric
vehicles and semiconductors while reducing reliance on China's supply chain. On October 26,
President Trump also signed an agreement with Malaysia to ensure the uninterrupted supply of
rare earth to the US. In October, the US and Australia agreed to jointly invest in mining
and processing projects and implement measures to prevent unhealthy competition, such as setting
minimum pricing. Recently, US-based Novio Magnetics and Australian Linus Rare Earth
signed an agreement to supply both light and heavy rare earths to support US defense and
civilian industries. Other US companies including USA Rare Earth, Volcan Elements, Germany's Vacuum
Schmeltz, GMBH, and South Korea's JS Link are also building new magnet factories. US Treasury
Secretary Scott Besant said in Washington that the US is closely consulting with European allies,
Australia, Canada, India, and other Asian democracies to form a comprehensive response.
Japan's Finance Minister Kato Katsunobu called for unity among the G7 nations to address China's
actions, while Germany's Finance Minister supported collective action. Australian Prime
Minister Scott Morrison is also seeking to strengthen cooperation on critical mineral
supply chains to reduce dependence on China. The US has led the creation of the Mineral Security
Partnership, MSP, and the Sustainable Critical Minerals Alliance, SCMA, working with Japan,
the EU, the UK, France, Germany, South Korea, and other democracies to promote
sustainable and responsible supply chain management and standards development. The US
is also expanding its partnership with countries like Vietnam, Greenland, Ukraine, Brazil, Russia,
and India, covering the full supply chain from mining and refining to permanent magnet manufacturing.
The US and its allies have finally realized after China's first restricted rare earth exports to
That industrial independence from China depends on refining capabilities. The US and its allies
are rapidly improving their domestic rare earth refining capacity, a process that will take
several years, but it is seen as a worthwhile investment to maintain the vitality of defense
production. An article in North America Intellectual Property News highlighted that
these international collaborations not only promote technological exchanges and strengthen
supply chain resilience, but also effectively reduce reliance on Chinese rare earths.
This ensures the supply of key materials from national defense and green energy industries,
greatly improving the economic and strategic security of the US and its allies. The European
Union is also seeking rare earth procurement agreements with countries such as Australia,
Canada, Greenland, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Chile. China has the largest
rare earth reserves in the world, followed by Brazil, India, and the US, which ranks seventh.
Recently, Turkey discovered 12.5 million tons of rare earths, which could make it the third
largest global reserve. On October 15, the Turkish president announced that the city of
Eskeşehir in northwestern Turkey may hold 12.5 million tons of rare earth reserves.
Erdoğan stated that Turkey aims to become one of the world's top five rare earth producers.
According to a report from Nikkei Asia, Turkish officials mentioned that samples collected
from 310 different locations in the Belikova mining area in Eskeşehir
indicated a total mineral resource of 690 million tons. Turkey has not yet disclosed the exact
rare earth composition of these resources, but it has mentioned detecting cerium oxide,
lithium oxide, neodymium oxide, praseodymium oxide, as well as fluorite, barite, and thorium.
CEO and chairman of Turkey's state-owned mining company, ET Maiden, Yalçın Aydın,
stated that the ore grade at the Belikova mine is about 1.75%. This refers to the proportion of
valuable minerals in the ore. ET Maiden plans to begin the design phase for the factory next year,
production expected to start between 2027 and 2028. The goal is to process 570,000 tons of ore
annually to produce 10,000 tons of rare earth oxides. Turkey's Minister of Energy and Natural
Resources, Elpan Slen Barakta, announced that Turkey is currently in discussions with China,
the United States, Europe, Canada, and Australia to find suitable technology providers in an effort
to increase the added value of local rare earth production. Willis Thomas, a senior advisor at
CRU Group, a London-based commodity research firm, highlighted that Turkey's estimated 12.5 million
tons of rare earth reserves is a significant amount. This will increase global non-China
rare earth reserves by 17%. Due to Turkey's proximity to Europe, these reserves could
play a key role in supporting Europe's electric vehicle development and its overall rare earth
value chain. Europe is actively working to reduce its dependence on China for critical minerals and
rare earths. Goldman Sachs has estimated that developing new rare earth mines typically takes
around 10 years. The building refining facilities takes about 5 years. As a result, some commentators
suggest that rare earth could become a choke point for the CCP in its dealings with the US and the
However, some experts disagree with this view. Bloomberg columnist David Fickling argued that
rare earth extraction and processing are not highly advanced technologies. There aren't rocket
science, nor are there like 3NM chip designs that require extreme ultraviolet lithography, which
would need decades of research and billions of dollars in development. While the CCP does hold
an advantage in rare earth production, Fickling believes this advantage is minor and could easily
be overtaken. In reality, China's control over the rare earth industry is less about overcoming
technical barriers, as it claims, and more about policy support and subsidies. The western rare
earth industry driven by market forces lacks these kinds of government-backed supports, and while
environmental concerns are an issue, the CCP has shown little regard for them. Over the past two
decades, the CCP has leveraged its global dominance in rare earth refining and processing,
along with subsidies and industrial support, to drastically lower prices, forcing foreign
competitors to go bankrupt. China may be a major player in rare earth, but it is not a true
superpower in the field. The primary reason is that the patents for rare earth applications are
mostly controlled by the US and Japan, with many of these technologies subject to export controls.
As a result, China has had to rely on imitation and theft. For instance, the high-purity rare
earth metal preparation technology managed by the US Department of Energy's Iowa State University
can produce 99.9999% pure rare earth metal, which is 1 million times higher in purity levels
than China's 99.99% pure metals. When looking at the entire development of China's rare earth
industry, there are still several significant choke points, technical challenges in the
production of mid- and high-end products. Overall, whether from internal struggles within the CCP,
issues with its rare earth production systems, or the international community collaborating to
break free from China's rare earth limitations, the CCP's rare earth trump card is likely to lose
its effectiveness over time. Using rare earth to challenge the US is in fact a self-defeating
strategy for the CCP. As noted by public intellectual and commentator Gong Zhishen,
the CCP currently controls 85% of global rare earth refining, 95% of graphite, and 70% of
cobalt processing, making it a short-term strategic leverage. However, the US and its
allies are rapidly restructuring supply chains. By 2028, they aim for a 30-40% self-sufficiency rate,
60-70% by 2032, and over 80% by 2037. After 2030, even if China imposes an export ban,
it will only cause minor disruptions for the US, not a fatal blow.
