The Hagia Sophia. Part 4 - The Mosaics

Prehistoric Civilization
160 followers
Hello everyone, I'm Robin Pearson and I'm here to show you
what remains of the Church of the Agia Sophia in Istanbul.
In today's video we're going to look at the beautiful Byzantine mosaics which decorate the
building. This is part four of our series on the Agia Sophia. In part one we introduced the
and in parts two and three we looked at what remains from the Byzantine era on the ground
floor and then upstairs in the galleries. The Byzantine mosaics are one of the major
attractions of the museum. Before we begin to explore each in turn I should just check that
you know how mosaics are made. To simplify, an initial painting is made and then covered in
tiny pieces of coloured glass or stone which is then affixed to a wall. If you'd like to see how
the process works then check out this video from the Art Institute of Chicago. As we discussed in
part one, the Agia Sophia was built in a hurry and the decision was taken not to include any
figurative mosaics amongst the decorations. Creating mosaics featuring emperors or biblical
figures is a time-consuming process and for any to be placed high up in the building would have
required complex scaffolding. So instead most of the ceiling was simply covered in gold tesserae
with only decorative patterns of red, blue and green along with endlessly repeated images of the
cross. Some of this original mosaic decoration still survives, particularly here in the arches
of the narthex. Gold tesserae usually feature a small amount of real gold, known as gold leaf,
surrounded by glass. These golden walls made a big impact on contemporaries who were awed at
how the light shimmered off them. Although small patches of these tesserae survive,
most of what you see today is paint on top of plaster. The gold paint was applied in the
19th century by the Swiss Fossati brothers who were called in to perform a major restoration job
on the building. Naturally over time many tesserae had fallen off, leaving large gaps in the
decoration. So the Fossatis decided to keep the essence of Justinian's decoration but with a
modern touch. So gold paint replaces mosaics but keeps the colour scheme. These colourful shapes
and patterns were added perhaps to simulate some of those from the Byzantine era but they also
reflect the style of 19th century Ottoman decoration. Up in the galleries it is mostly just
the Fossati's paint which can be seen, though there's a little spot here near Dandolo's sarcophagus
lid where you can see both. The plaster has peeled away, revealing the original mosaic underneath.
Down on the ground floor, if you make your way to the northwest corner, you can see some of the
original crosses breaking through the paint. The 19th century geometric patterns seem to have been
added directly on top of the earlier crosses and now the two are battling for prominence.
This extraordinary process awaits further study. Let's move on to the figurative mosaics.
As you may know, the Byzantine world went through a prolonged battle over the place
of religious art in public life during the 8th and 9th centuries. At the end of this period,
usually known as Iconoclasm, the lovers of icons emerged victorious and began to decorate all
religious institutions with mosaics and frescoes. Christ, Mary, the saints and biblical scenes now
covered every surface. Naturally, the Hagia Sophia was no exception and so it was that at
Easter 867, the first figurative mosaic in the city's cathedral was unveiled.
The Byzantine celestial hierarchy was played out in the decoration of its churches and so here at
one of its highest points is the Virgin Mary holding the baby Jesus. She sits on a throne
while he holds one hand up to give a blessing and clutches a scroll in the other. We are being
transported to that cave in Bethlehem when the saviour of the world arrived. An inscription,
now largely gone, announces these icons the deceivers once cast down, the pious emperors
have again restored. On the arch around the apse we see the archangel Gabriel on the right.
He wears a robe of white silk and holds a staff and a crystal globe and his wings have brightly
coloured feathers. He was once mirrored by the angel Michael on the left-hand side but only a
few feathers can now be seen. Most scholars believe that this was the first figurative
mosaic to be unveiled, though there is a huge amount we still don't understand about the
iconoclastic period. Assuming it was though then the rest of the nave was decorated next.
This would have meant an entire heavenly host appearing on the upper parts of the church.
Only a few of these mosaics survive but because of the constant seismic activity the walls have
experienced. The most prominent survivals are the seraphim on the pendentives. We believe these
winged angels were in place early in the mosaic program but those you can see on the east side
close to the apse date from a restoration in the 14th century. They do have faces which may
one day be uncovered again. These stars were installed to hide their features in the 17th
century when Islamic strictures against figural representation were enforced across the building.
You might notice a difference between the angels on the eastern side and those on the western
pendentives. The original western seraphs seem to have been lost and the ones you can see now
were painted on by the Fossati brothers during that restoration. The seraphim's position on the
pendentives was intended to show them flanking the image in the dome itself. What was there has
now been covered up but we assume that it was an image of Christ Pantocrator, Jesus as judge of the
world. This is the image we'd expect to see in any other Byzantine church. During the 17th century
Islamic redecoration this image was replaced with this Arabic text. It's the 35th verse of the 24th
surah of the Quran about the light of God. You can see rays of gold mosaic emanating from the central
disk illustrating this. So at the highest level would be Christ as judge, essentially God in human
form, and closest to him are Mary and the angels. On the next level down in our descending heavenly
host would be human figures, saints and martyrs who helped communicate the Christian message
to the world. Only a few of these figures survive a sequence of bishops on the north wall. As you can
see from my visit the scaffolding currently obscures most of them and there were once 14
of these senior prelates but only three now stand. Saint Ignatius the Younger, Saint John Chrysostom
and Saint Ignatius Theophorus. From the ground or the opposite gallery these figures seem small
but they are actually life-size. Each played a prominent role in the history of the orthodox
church and would have been remembered by services in the church on their feast day. As you scan the
interior of the nave you might be able to spot other fragments of the mosaic decoration but
we've discussed the only figurative images which are easy to see. Fortunately for us many more
survive lower down. Chronologically speaking our next mosaic would be this one situated above the
nave door in the inner narthex. It's been dated to the late 9th or early 10th century. Christ sits
on a throne giving a blessing while holding a book in the other hand on which peace be with you
I am the light of the world is written. In the medallions either side of him are Mary and an
angel. Prostrating himself on the ground is a Roman emperor. The symbolism here is clear. Christ
is the real emperor. Just as men come to court to bow down before the basileps so he must humble
The position of this mosaic is no coincidence. It sits above the imperial door where the emperor
would enter the church. Whether they always got down on their knees we don't know but certainly
they were meant to remove some of the insignia of their office and enter the nave in humility.
We assume that the emperor pictured is meant to represent a real person and given the dating
it's either Basil I, Leo VI or Constantine VII. Scholarly speculation tends to lean towards Leo.
This mosaic could have been sponsored by an emperor in order to demonstrate his
humility and generosity. Though an alternative interpretation would be to see this image as
requested by the patriarch to remind future emperors of their rightful place in the hierarchy.
If there is any truth in the latter then Leo becomes a prime suspect because he fought
bitterly with the church to get his third and fourth marriages legitimised. If it is Leo in
that image then his brother Alexander may have been inspired to produce one of his own. If you've
seen part three of our series then you'll know that up here in the north gallery a lonely imperial
figure hides in the shadows. Alexander ruled for just over a year and was not popular so it seems
likely that he commissioned this image himself. He is in full imperial regalia and holds an orb
in his left hand. In his right is the Akakiya which was a roll containing dust. This was held
by emperors during ceremonies and seems to have represented the mortal nature of man and his power.
A very appropriate item for the short-lived Alexander to have carried around.
Next we move back to the narthex and retrace our steps to the vestibule of the warriors.
As we talked about in part two, in later centuries this is the entrance where the emperor would shed
some of his regalia and leave his bodyguards behind. Above the door is this striking image
of two emperors presenting gifts to the virgin and child.
This mosaic was installed during the reign of Basil II. Handily each emperor is identified
by an inscription next to them. On the left we have Justinian, emperor of illustrious memory
and on the right we have Constantine the Great, emperor among the saints. Each is holding a
familiar object. Justinian has the Achaea Sophia which he built, Constantine the city itself that
he founded. The Byzantines believed that Mary offered their city special protection and so
in this mosaic we see a beautiful summation of the city's history and ideology. But remember
the nearby narthex mosaic that seemed to be reminding emperors of their place and proper
conduct. Here again in the vestibule, art historians sense another message. New Roman
leaders were expected to bring gifts to the church, both as a sign of their piety and as a
political gesture towards the clergy. These gifts would be presented at the altar during a service
and what was prominent above the altar? This mosaic of Mary and the Christ child.
So here as the emperor divests himself of his earthly apparel is a reminder of his duty to
keep donating to the cathedral and to those whose favour really matters. Reinforcing this image of
imperial patronage are our next two mosaics. We are back up in the galleries at the end of the
south aisle. This area was reserved for members of the imperial family and so appropriately
images of imperial couples who donated to the church were installed here. First we have the
empress Zoe and her third husband Constantine Monomachos. Zoe and her first husband Romanos
had made a special donation to the church early in their marriage. It was a supplementary income
for the clergy to be paid annually from the treasury. You can see here that the emperor
holds a bag of money while the empress carries the document which authorises this. This was a
win-win for both sides. The church gains in resources and the imperial couple are forever
honoured. But you may notice that I said Monomachos was Zoe's third husband. If you look closely
you'll see that all three faces and the words on the document have been changed. There are some
fun theories about Zoe's tempestuous marriages which could explain this but it may simply be
that Monomachos asked for the mosaic to be altered to reflect his own generosity. Presumably Zoe and
Jesus' faces were changed to give the mosaic a consistent aesthetic.
A few feet away is another imperial couple from a century later. This is John Komnenos son of
Alexius and his wife Irene of Hungary. Again a donation from the palace is celebrated.
On this occasion room was found on the wall next to the couple to portray their son
Alexius. This may have been added a few years later when he came of age and sadly he died
shortly afterwards. Backtracking a little to the centre of the south gallery we come to our final
mosaic and one of the finest pieces of Byzantine art. The diocese or diesis. Here we see Christ
the all-powerful judge of humanity raising his hand just about to give the blessing that will see
our sins forgiven. Either side of him are Mary and John the Baptist, their heads bowed,
their faces serious, their hands reaching out in prayer. They are beseeching him to intercede
on behalf of humanity. This scene, the diocese, is a common one in Orthodox churches but is somewhat
less familiar in the Catholic and Protestant worlds. There images of Christ on the cross
dying for our sins are regularly seen. Here the story has moved on to the end of time,
it's judgment day and Mary and John ask Jesus, the judge, if he will forgive humanity for its
collective failures. But Christ is serene as he raises his hand. He paid that price for us long
ago. That same image of Christ Pantocrator would have been in the dome of the Hagia Sophia as well
as in several of the mosaics we've seen. But here we get a high quality, fully realised,
emotive portrayal of the most significant moment in the Christian narrative of our world.
The mosaic was commissioned in the 1260s to mark the return of Byzantine rule to Constantinople
after the Latin occupation that followed the Fourth Crusade. As you can see when comparing
this mosaic to others in the building, artistic skills and tastes have developed considerably in
the intervening period. Here we see a softer naturalism in the portrayal of the faces.
The artist has used shade to convey a sense of three-dimensionality and by using smaller and
smaller tesserae set as close together as possible, the result is much closer to a painting
than any of the other mosaics. This period in Byzantine art is sometimes called
the Paleolocan Renaissance, named for the dynasty who recovered the capital from the Latins.
Byzantine artists were reaching for the same level of skill and expression as their Italian
counterparts. In the Kahn Academy video about this mosaic, they make the comparison between the image
of Mary here and on the Maesta of Duccio in Siena, painted just a few decades earlier.
But the goal of the artist was not just aesthetic. Representations of holy figures
were meant to bring the believer closer to the subject. To quote art historian Robin Cormack,
the great achievement of the artist is to have composed a work which is massive and monumental
in scale but with figures whose attitudes and expressions make them sympathetic and approachable
through prayer. In our next video we bring our tour of the Achaea Sophia to a close
by taking a look around the outside of the building. If you'd like more detailed information
about the Achaea Sophia then visit thebyzantinelegacy.com. It's a fantastic website providing
breakdowns of the Byzantine buildings that can still be seen today and there you'll find most of
the still images and sketches used in these videos. If you'd like to know more about John
Chrysostom or Leo VI then check out these episodes of the History of Byzantium podcast.
