A Democratic super majority city council has great influence over the Mayor’s agenda. With 51 seats open this election, how could their elections impact the future mayor? Political strategist and attorney Gerard Filitti, senior counsel at The Lawfare Project, weighs in. -- 🧶More NTD Programs: https://www.ntd.com/programs?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=SocialM
While there's a huge focus on the New
York City mayor's race, residents are
also voting for their city council
representatives. Now, all 51 seats are
up for grabs. Winners will have the
power to introduce and vote on bills,
monitor city agencies, and override the
mayor's vetos. So, how important are
these races and what impact could the
outcomes have on how the new mayor runs
the city?
Joining us now is political strategist
and attorney Gerard Fiti. He's senior
counsel at the LawFare Project. Gerard,
thank you so much for joining us.
>> My pleasure. Thank you for having me.
>> Now, currently the New York City Council
has 45 Democrats and six Republicans.
So, first off, how important are these
city council races for any political
party?
>> These city council races are really
crucial in New York City. While all of
the attention has gone to the candidates
running for mayor, at the end of the
day, New York City's budget and
priorities are really set by the city
council. Like Congress, they have the
power of the purse. They appropriate
funding. They raise or lower taxes. They
prioritize which departments and
programs get budgets uh and how they're
effectively uh the prioritizing what is
going on in New York City. They also
hold vetos. Uh they can override a
mayoral veto, especially when you have
46 Democrats. The real distinction isn't
between Republican and Democrat, but
whether you have more moderate members
of the city council versus more
progressive ones.
>> So, so far the with the current city
council, what kinds of policies have
they pushed during Mayor Adams tenure?
>> Well, the policies have really been
center left. It's it's not been policy
so much as it has been initiatives
initiatives with the police department.
They've not increased funding
significantly. They've put money in
schools, but those have gone more
towards uh diversity programs rather
than core educational programs. Uh
you've seen an increase in spending on
public arts activities. Uh beautifying
the city, so to speak, programs that
benefit or work with NOS's with
non-government organizations. Uh so this
has really been the alignment of the
city. Right now, the city council has
six Republicans, but of the Democrats,
about 20 of those lean progressive, and
their policies are more left of center
than the moderate Democrats, which are
somewhat more aligned with the
Republicans.
>> Now, the council also has tremendous
influence over how New Yorkers may vote
in this mayor's race. So over 20 council
members as you just mentioned have
endorsed Zoron Mdani which is more
progressive and just one has endorsed
Andrew Cuomo and the six Republicans
have endorsed Curtis Leewa. Now Cuomo is
technically still a Democrat. So how
likely is it that those other 20 or so
moderate council members would actually
rally votes for him?
>> It's possible that they will and we've
seen a lot of city council members out
at rallies encouraging people to vote.
uh they many of them have made their
voting preferences clear in a private
setting, not so much public. I think
there is a bit of trepidation on the
relationships that the city council may
have with the mayor if it is mom Donnie
that ultimately wins on Tuesday. So
you're not seeing a rush of of council
members going to endorse Cuomo. The
Republicans have endorsed Siwa, but many
Republicans in New York City are
actually not voting for the Republican
candidate. uh they they think that Cuomo
has a better chance of defeating M
Donnie and they're quite scared and of
the outcome of New York City swinging
more into the Democrat socialist
category.
>> Now, you mentioned a little earlier
about, you know, the the control and
power council has over things like um
influencing and improving the
legislation. They can propose and vote
on bills and and even the mayor uh they
can vetos the bill. They can get a
twothirds majority and override that
veto. So, we saw this happening under
Mayor Adams, but in a deep blue city
like New York, could we still expect to
see more Republicans winning seats for a
more balanced council?
>> It's always possible. There are of this
election, there are four seats out of
these 51 that are a little bit more
competitive where we can see Republicans
potentially gain one of two open seats
uh and if not more. So there is the
possibility that when we when we we do
the counting after this election, we
will have slightly more, maybe seven or
eight Republican seats. But we have to
remember New York City is heavily
Democratic. The proportion of seats
actually corresponds pretty closely to
voter registration within the city
overall. Uh and absent redistricting,
it's difficult for Republicans to get
beyond that 10 seat threshold. Uh so we
really do have a distinction in New York
City that's not so much along party
lines but along extremes of the spectrum
whether it's progressive or conservative
uh with most with most council members
even the Republican ones falling
somewhat to the middle.
>> Now Manny doesn't have majority support
from city council and he's consistently
polling at about 45%
in this general election. So, if he wins
without even a simple majority, how
difficult could it be for him to advance
his his policies?
>> It may be difficult, but it would
require a lot of unity, not just among
Republicans, but among the more
conservative or moderate Democrats
within the city council. Right now there
are probably a good enough number of
Democrats to who are more on the
progressive side and have even endorsed
Mani that Mandani may be over to able to
veto what city council does and the city
council may not be able to override it.
So this really comes down to priorities.
Mani will have his job cut out for him
to convince more moderateleaning
Democrats to approve of his priorities
uh and to not second guessess his
choices. So this is really a challenge.
It depends on whether he keeps two to
what he has said he's doing during this
campaign, which is more radical than
most city council members prefer or
whether he builds bridges with the more
conservative and moderate Democrats.
>> Now, let's talk about Curtis Leewa. He's
at the top of the ticket for
Republicans. Could a growing push not to
vote for him leader
people voting for Republican candidates
in this city council race?
>> It's possible, but not likely. I think
that Republicans are well motivated to
vote at the city council level. Uh
looking at New York City historically,
there's always been a good push by city
council candidates to do the canvasing,
to do the door knockocking, to get
people out to the ballots, whether it's
early voting that started last week or
whether it's on election day. So that
sometimes is at odds with the mayoral
race where people may be undecided or
not even cast a vote for mayor. I think
that Republican candidates and Democrat
ones for that matter have been very
effective at getting out the vote in
their districts for themselves as
candidates. So I don't see a carryover
effect. However, I do think that there
will be a split vote by a lot of
Republicans who will be voting for their
Republican council member but will be
voting for Cuomo for mayor.
>> And lastly, um do you think Americans
today are putting enough emphasis on
these local races which appear to be
very important?
Well, I think these local races do play
a very important part in setting
priorities for the city. Uh, and both
parties have been prioritizing them
increasingly. But what's interesting in
New York City is that it's the more
radical wing of the Democratic party
that's really played a close attention
to these local council races and really
invested time, money, and efforts into
getting those seats away from more
moderate Democrats. So, I think it's
time that both the Republican and
Democrat parties start to realize the
importance of these local races.
Otherwise, they're risking having a
balance shift more to the socialist
side, to the progressive side, uh, which
is uncomfortable for both most Democrats
and the Republican party.
>> Now, regardless of which one of these
candidates wins the mayoral race, I
think they're going to face a tough city
council in getting all of their policies
passed. Gerard Fiti, attorney and
political strategist, thank you so much
for joining us.
>> My pleasure. Thank you.