James Webb observe des point rouges que personne ne comprends !

Mysteries of the Universe
550 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
In 2022, while James Webb's observations had just begun,
researchers from the JAD program made a disconcerting announcement.
In the first deep fields of the telescope,
they had discovered much larger and more massive primordial galaxies.
A few hundred million years after the Big Bang,
they already seemed very mature.
They very quickly received a very evocative nickname,
the impossible galaxies of James Webb.
We talked a lot about it at the time,
and three years later, the mystery persists.
The attempts to explain it have been repeated,
but none are consensual at the moment.
These first observations had been made
thanks to the NIRCAM instrument of the telescope.
More recently, James Webb revisited some of his targets,
this time using his NIRSPEC instrument.
This was an opportunity to get a different part of their spectrum,
and to bring out an absolutely incredible new explanation.
For four of these objects,
the spectrum corresponds to what we would expect from black stars.
Huge, yet hypothetical objects,
which would have existed at the very beginning of the universe,
and which would rely on reactions of annihilation of black matter.
The concept of black stars was proposed in 2007
as a mechanism for the formation of the very first stars in the universe,
the famous stars of Population 3.
Classical stars are formed from a cloud of gas and dust.
The cloud concentrates under the effect of gravity
and becomes denser and denser.
It ends up reaching the temperature and pressure necessary
to trigger nuclear fusion reactions.
These exert a pressure that repels the external layers.
So on one side, we have gravity, which wants to bring everything back to the centre,
and on the other, nuclear reactions, which want to disperse everything.
The object thus reaches a balance, and it becomes a star,
which will be able to shine for millions or billions of years.
The model of black stars offers a very different mechanism,
on a much larger scale.
Here, everything starts much earlier,
when the cloud is not yet very dense
and has not started a nuclear fusion reaction.
It still makes several astronomical units in diameter
and up to a million times the mass of the Sun.
In the primordial universe,
during the first hundred million years after the Big Bang,
such a cloud would have been almost exclusively made up of hydrogen and helium.
These very first gas clouds
also had to form in regions where there was a super-density of black matter.
In the most accepted models of cosmology,
black-matter halos appeared before galaxies.
In fact, galaxies formed where they formed because of these halos.
They represented the first densities
We could therefore expect that our primordial clouds,
not yet collapsed,
contain themselves an important proportion of black matter,
around 1%.
And that's where things get interesting.
In some models of black matter, such as WIMPs,
the particles that form it can interact with each other to annihilate each other.
A meeting between two WIMPs thus causes the disappearance of this
and the very energetic production of other particles,
notably in the form of gamma rays and neutrinos.
We can thus imagine an environment where black matter is dense enough
for frequent annihilation reactions.
These reactions could even prevent a classic matter cloud from collapsing.
This is the mechanism at the heart of a black star.
In this one, we have gravity, which always tries to gather everything in one place.
But to counter it, we no longer count on nuclear reactions.
This was only possible during the first hundred million years of the universe,
and it is precisely the period that interests us
with the impossible galaxies of James Webb.
As we have just described,
black stars are huge objects.
Just after their formation,
they were able to make a few astronomical units in diameter
for a hundred solar masses.
Their surface temperature
But because of their size,
they would have constituted very bright and quite red objects.
You can see that we are starting to get closer
to the observations of the impossible galaxies of James Webb.
But there are still a few orders of magnitude to cross.
The object we have just described is not bright enough
to explain the little red dots of James Webb.
This is where another mechanism,
described in 2010 by the same team, intervenes.
Supermassive black stars.
As these objects have a fairly low surface temperature,
they emit a relatively low radiative pressure.
The surrounding gases can therefore continue to agglomerate
on the newly formed object.
Its mass and size thus increase over time,
which allows it to trap additional black matter
to maintain annihilation reactions.
With this mechanism,
we can get to absolutely gigantic objects.
It becomes possible to model black stars
of several thousand astronomical units in diameter.
It would thus make the size of the solar system,
the belt of Kuiper and internal Hortus clouds included.
This would correspond to a mass
consisting of millions of solar masses
and a luminosity equivalent to that of a galaxy,
while remaining very red.
Objects that correspond surprisingly well
to the impossible galaxies of James Webb.
In fact, the paper from 2010 is not mistaken
and announces that this class of objects
should be detectable by James Webb.
Supermassive black stars also allow
to solve another problem of cosmology.
At their death, when the annihilation reactions
would no longer be maintained,
the giant gas clouds it would cause would collapse
to create a very large black hole,
potentially of several million solar masses.
We would thus have a mechanism
to explain the birth of supermassive black holes,
which also appear too big, too fast,
in the history of the universe.
The theory of black stars is a stone's throw away,
which makes it particularly seductive.
And the latest observations of NIRSPEC by James Webb
come to the fore.
A team that includes some of the same researchers
who had made the original paper in 2007,
find in the instrument data
four objects that correspond well
to what they had modeled for supermassive black stars.
One of the objects in particular,
has in its spectrum
a ray of absorption qualified as an unmissable signature.
We could thus draw closer to an explanation
for the impossible galaxies,
of a mechanism for the birth of supermassive black holes,
and we would have as a bonus,
an indirect proof of the existence of black matter.
What more could you ask for?
We can still oppose some arguments
to supermassive black stars or not.
The first is that all their mechanisms
To obtain this energy that prevents
the primordial clouds from collapsing,
a black matter must be able to self-annihilate.
A property that is mainly present
in the WIMPS model.
However, as we have discussed lately on the channel,
WIMPS are no longer necessarily
the most popular particle to explain black matter.
In recent years,
we have seen a return in force of actions,
or even gravitons as a candidate particle.
These particles do not have a sufficient self-annihilation mechanism
to maintain the mechanism found at the heart of black stars.
If WIMPS do not exist,
then black stars cannot exist either.
This is not a disqualification,
but it is a sufficiently important condition
to weigh a big question mark on the theory.
The corollary of this is that we can just hope
to use black stars to prove the existence of WIMPS.
If in one way or another we can reach the certainty
that the impossible galaxies of James Webb
are indeed supermassive black stars,
then we will have strong proof
that there is a form of black matter capable of self-annihilation.
Basically, we would prove the existence of WIMPS.
The two objects, one tiny and the other gigantic,
are thus in some way linked in their destiny.
In addition to WIMPS,
black stars require a very fine balance to function.
If the reactions of the annihilation of black matter are not large enough,
the clouds can contract and the nuclear fusion can start.
If these reactions are, on the contrary, too strong,
the formed object is very unstable.
It would therefore have been necessary at the very beginning of the history of the universe
to find halos of black matter with the right density
and a rate of interaction neither too strong nor too weak.
This is not impossible,
but it reduces the chances of a spontaneous creation of black stars.
It will be very difficult to obtain observational certainties.
What distinguishes the model of black stars
is that it produces very bright objects,
but which appear relatively cold.
This corresponds rather well to the little red dot of James Webb.
However, this is not the only possible explanation.
A young galaxy rich in dust
can also give this illusion of a very bright object, but quite cold.
Even the red absorption of JADGSZ14-0
could find alternative explanations.
We are talking about an object that has an extreme shift towards red
and that flirts with the limits of James Webb.
It is very difficult to say if a bright object at JADGSZ14-0
is a compact galaxy or an active black hole or a black star.
However, one day we will have to find an explanation for these impossible galaxies.
Do all other hypotheses also suffer from limits?
If the little red dots are, for example, young galaxies rich in dust,
how to explain the presence of so much dust at JADGSZ14-0,
when the universe should have been almost exclusively made up of hydrogen and helium?
If they are active black holes, why don't we find their X-ray signature?
There is, for the moment,
no perfect mechanism for the impossible galaxies of James Webb.
Three years after their discovery, the mystery remains thick.
I personally like the model of black stars,
because it would solve many problems of modern physics at once.
The little red dots, the supermassive black holes and the nature of black matter.
It would be funny practical.
Unfortunately, I don't think that funny practical is an argument
that weighs very heavily with astrophysicists.
We could talk about the problem for decades.
If the impossible galaxies of James Webb remain unanswered,
I would not be surprised if they weigh on the design of the next large space telescope of NASA.
The space agency could choose its capabilities in order to be able to provide observations
that would suddenly divide the different theories.
In the meantime, we will see if new alternative explanations emerge.
So, this is what's blocking this space file.
I invite you to share your questions and remarks in the comments,
we will answer them in a future video.
You can also consult the description to find our sources.
As for us, we'll meet again next week for a new DNDE,
and until then, citizens, be well.
