Guan Yu’s Defeat at Maicheng, Lü Meng’s Death After Victory:The Astonishing Secret of the 3 Kingdoms

Shang Dynasty Culture
18 followers
45 Video Views·Oct 29, 2025
The smartest man of the Three Kingdoms wasn’t Zhuge Liang — it was Guan Lu, the genius diviner
Hello everyone, welcome to History and Culture.
Here, we take you back to the Three Kingdoms period.
To tell a story about the decline of the Shu Han regime.
And about a key figure, Lu Meng, the famous general of Eastern Wu.
Whose legendary life and mysterious death left a lasting mark on history.
The story begins with Guan Yu, the great general of Shu Han.
Guan Yu, courtesy name Yun Chang.
Was the sworn brother of Lu Bei.
The second of the three heroes in the Oath of the Peach Garden.
His bravery and loyalty were known across the land.
Yet, the decline of Shu Han.
Quietly began from the moment he was defeated at Meicheng.
If Guan Yu had not lost that battle.
The history of Shu Han might have turned out very differently.
Lu Bei would not have launched a campaign in grief and anger over his brother's death.
Zhang Fei might not have met his tragic fate.
And Lu Bei himself might not have fallen ill after being defeated.
By the young Eastern Wu general Lu Sun at the Battle of Yiling.
Eventually dying after entrusting his son to Zhuge Liang.
From then on, the three sworn brothers of the Peach Garden passed away one after another.
Shu Han lost many of its finest generals.
And its national strength greatly declined.
The turning point of all these events.
Was closely tied to one man from Eastern Wu.
Lu Meng, the legendary general later known as the Unlearned Man from Wu.
Lu Meng not only changed the fate of Shu Han.
But also left a bold and brilliant mark in Chinese history.
However, to everyone's surprise.
Just when he was about to be rewarded for his great achievements.
He suddenly died at the age of 42.
The cause of his death remains a mystery to this day.
Was it simply fate's jealousy of talent?
Or was there more behind it?
Now, let us start from the very beginning.
Lu Meng was born in the year 178.
In Lijiagang, Wanghua Town, Funan County, Anhui Province.
It was a time of chaos.
The early years of the Three Kingdoms era.
When war and turmoil made life hard for the common people.
His family was poor.
Often struggling to find their next meal.
Despite this, Lu Meng showed extraordinary determination and courage from a young age.
He refused to accept a life of poverty.
And vowed to change his fate through his own efforts.
In his youth, he trained diligently with local martial instructors.
Honing his combat skills with the dream of one day earning glory on the battlefield.
At 15, believing he had mastered the basics.
Lu Meng secretly crossed the Yangtze River without telling his mother.
To join his brother-in-law Dang Dang, who was serving as a general in Eastern Wu.
Dang Dang thought the boy was too young and might die in battle.
So he refused to let him enlist.
But Lu Meng was a stubborn young man.
He ignored the warnings and secretly followed the army into combat.
During one battle, Dang Dang spotted the reckless youth on the field.
Furious, he brought him back and told Lu Meng's mother to discipline him.
Lu Meng, however, said to his mother.
Our life is too hard, we can't go on like this.
If I can earn military merit in battle.
Maybe we can escape this poverty and live better.
After all, without taking risks, how can there be any reward?
Seeing his determination, his mother no longer stopped him.
And allowed him to continue following Dang Dang.
From that moment, Lu Meng officially began his military career.
He fought bravely.
Always leading the charge at the front lines.
With his courage and skill.
He quickly distinguished himself in the army.
And earned the respect of his comrades.
His performance soon caught the attention of the Eastern Wu leadership.
And his rank steadily rose.
In the year 200, Su Wen Che was assassinated.
And the young Su Wen Chuan succeeded him as ruler of Eastern Wu.
From then on, Lu Meng gained Su Wen Chuan's full trust.
He followed famous generals like Lu Su and Zhou Yu on numerous campaigns.
Achieving remarkable victories.
He took part in major battles such as the conquest of Huangzhou.
The capture of Nan Commandery.
And the pacification of the southern Jingzhou territories.
At the Battle of Xiaoyao Ford.
He helped cover Su Wen Chuan's retreat.
And later defended Ruxiku.
Repelling a major invasion by Wei forces.
Thanks to his military achievements,
he was promoted to Left Protector of the Army and General of Tiger Valor.
Earning great fame across the realm.
In 217, after the death of Grand Commander Lu Su.
Su Wen Chuan appointed Lu Meng as his successor.
Stationing him at Lukou.
Right next to Guan Yu, the commander of Shu Han's forces in Jingzhou.
Jingzhou was a vital strategic region during the Three Kingdoms period.
Whoever controlled Jingzhou held the key passage
connecting the central plains and the land of Shu.
Lu Meng understood this well.
He began to plan how to seize Jingzhou and expand Eastern Wu's territory.
Thus, his target was none other than Shu Han's mighty general, Guan Yu.
In 219 AD, Guan Yu led his forces north to besiege Xiangyang and Fancheng,
strongholds of the Wei Kingdom.
He first achieved a decisive victory over the Wei army at the Han River.
Then famously flooded seven enemy armies, capturing General Eugene.
And defeating Pangde.
His reputation shook the entire realm.
Even Chao Chao was forced to consider relocating the capital to avoid his growing power.
At that moment, Guan Yu's prestige was at its peak.
But it also gave Eastern Wu a rare opportunity.
Lu Meng keenly observed that with Guan Yu campaigning in the north.
Jingzhou was left poorly defended.
It was the perfect time to strike.
Su Wen Chuan accepted Lu Meng's proposal and decided to launch an attack.
Meanwhile, Chao Chao also sent envoys to contact Su Wen Chuan.
Offering territorial rewards in Jiangnan.
In exchange for Wu's assistance in attacking Guan Yu from the rear.
Su Wen Chuan gladly agreed, appointing Lu Meng as commander-in-chief.
And ordering him to secretly cross the Yangtze River.
To surprise Jingzhou.
Lu Meng devised a brilliant strategy known as the White Cloth Crossing.
He disguised his soldiers as ordinary merchants.
Hiding them aboard ships that silently approached Jingzhou.
When the Eastern Wu army suddenly appeared beneath Jingzhou's walls.
The city's defenders, Mi Fang and Fu Shuren.
Both of whom harbored grudges against Guan Yu.
Chose to surrender without resistance.
Thus, Jingzhou fell swiftly into Eastern Wu's hands.
Even worse for Guan Yu.
Many of his soldiers' families were inside Jingzhou.
When news of its fall spread.
The troops' morale collapsed.
And they no longer had the will to fight.
Left with no other choice, Guan Yu led his remaining men.
To retreat toward Maicheng.
In December 219, Guan Yu, accompanied by a few dozen loyal followers.
Attempted to break through enemy lines and flee back to Shu.
However, near Lingzhu, not far from Maicheng.
He was ambushed by Wu General Ma Zhong.
Guan Yu and his eldest son, Guan Ping.
Fought bravely to the end.
But were ultimately captured.
Lu Meng, fully aware of Guan Yu's legendary status.
And fearing that Sun Quan might show mercy.
Under political pressure from Shu Han.
Decisively ordered the execution of Guan Yu and his son.
This victory secured Eastern Wu's complete control over Jingzhou.
And Lu Meng's triumph became one of the most remarkable feats in Wu's history.
Sun Quan rewarded him by appointing him as governor of Nan Commandery.
And Marquis of Chongling.
Along with generous riches and honors.
Tragically, however, just as Lu Meng was at the height of his fame and success.
He suddenly fell ill and died at the age of 42.
The cause of his death has remained uncertain for centuries.
According to the records of the Three Kingdoms, Sangwozi.
Lu Meng fell gravely ill in the city of Gongan, where Sun Quan was residing.
Before his official rewards had even been formally bestowed.
And he soon passed away.
Sun Quan was deeply grieved.
He even summoned Taoist priests to pray for him.
But all efforts were in vain.
Some historical sources describe Lu Meng's death as due to illness.
Though none specify the exact nature of it.
Looking back at Lu Meng's life, he was truly a man who rose from humble origins.
Born into poverty.
He relied on his courage, perseverance, and intelligence.
To become one of Eastern Wu's greatest pillars of strength.
Having fought countless battles.
It is likely that his body bore many old wounds.
Perhaps his untimely death was the price he paid.
For a lifetime of valor on the battlefield.
The capture of Jingzhou marked the pinnacle of Lu Meng's military career.
After such a tremendous victory, it was natural for him to relax.
Celebrating joyfully with his friends and comrades.
Perhaps days of feasting and drinking took a toll on his body.
Causing exhaustion and the relapse of old wounds.
Which ultimately led to his physical collapse.
Another possible explanation is disease.
The Jingzhou region had suffered years of war and poor sanitation.
Making it prone to outbreaks of plague.
Several Eastern Wu generals who participated in the Jingzhou campaign.
Also died within the same year.
Leading some to suspect that they had all contracted the same illness.
Of course, popular legends tell a far more dramatic story.
In Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
Luo Guanzhong depicts Lu Meng's death.
As the vengeful spirit of Guan Yu coming to claim his life.
Frightening him so much that his soul left his body.
Though clearly fictional, this literary portrayal.
Was meant to glorify Guan Yu's image of loyalty and righteousness.
Offering him an ending that resonated with folk sentiment.
After all, for a hero of Guan Yu's stature.
A simple death at the hands of an enemy seemed far too anticlimactic.
Yet, history records another theory.
That Lu Meng's death might somehow have been connected to Sun Quan himself.
Let us take a closer look at this possibility.
Sun Quan's decision to attack Jingzhou.
Was driven partly by Cao Cao's invitation.
And partly by his own deep desire to seize the territory.
Jingzhou was a strategically critical region.
By taking it, Eastern Wu could use it as a buffer.
Against both Chao Wei to the north and Shu Han to the west.
Thus securing its borders.
Lu Meng's campaign perfectly achieved this objective.
Perhaps a little too perfectly.
Not only did he recapture Jingzhou.
But he also captured Guan Yu and his son alive.
However, before Sun Quan's envoys could arrive.
With orders to treat Guan Yu with courtesy.
Lu Meng took it upon himself to execute them.
When Sun Quan learned that Guan Yu had been killed.
He was furious.
In his view, keeping Guan Yu alive.
Could have provided valuable leverage in negotiations with Lu Bei.
Now, with Guan Yu dead.
There was no doubt that Lu Bei.
Bound to him by the brotherhood of the Peach Garden.
Would seek vengeance.
Indeed, Lu Bei soon led his armies eastward.
To launch the famous battle of Yiling against Eastern Wu.
Sun Quan realized that Lu Meng's decision.
Had plunged Wu into a major diplomatic crisis.
He began to suspect that Lu Meng, emboldened by his success.
Might have grown too powerful.
A hero whose achievements could one day threaten his own authority.
To defuse the crisis.
Sun Quan took a series of careful measures.
He sent Guan Yu's severed head to Chao Chao.
Hoping to redirect Lu Bei's anger.
And strengthen ties with Wei.
He also dispatched envoys to Shu Han.
In an attempt to make peace.
But Lu Bei refused any reconciliation.
Trapped between enemies and uneasy allies.
Sun Quan found himself in a precarious position.
He needed to placate Shu Han on one hand.
And prevent Lu Meng, whose fame and merit now overshadowed others.
From becoming a potential rival on the other.
Thus, some later speculated.
That Sun Quan might have secretly decided.
To eliminate Lu Meng.
According to rumor.
During a celebratory banquet.
Sun Quan may have taken covert action against him.
And soon after, Lu Meng fell ill and died.
It is said that Sun Quan ordered a substance to be secretly added to Lu Meng's wine.
Intending to make him die quietly and without suspicion.
However, Lu Meng seemed to sense that something was wrong.
Feigning illness, he found excuses to avoid drinking.
And even deliberately overturned his wine cup in an attempt to escape the trap.
But Sun Quan did not let him go so easily.
Under the pretext of providing medical treatment.
He summoned Lu Meng to the palace and kept him under strict watch.
In the end, with no means of escape.
Lu Meng was forced to drink the fatal potion.
Thus ending his own life.
After Lu Meng's death, Sun Quan held a grand funeral in his honor.
Granted his son Lu Ba his father's noble title.
And bestowed land upon the family.
On the surface, it all appeared to be a sincere display of mourning.
Yet privately, Sun Quan revoked the enormous rewards.
He had originally promised to Lu Meng.
As if deliberately minimizing his achievements.
This series of actions raised suspicion.
Had Sun Quan used Lu Meng's death.
To accomplish several goals at once?
By doing so, he could ease tensions with Xu Han.
Remove a potential internal threat.
And save a vast amount of wealth in rewards.
Though there is no definitive historical evidence to prove this theory.
Considering the political realities of the Three Kingdoms period.
It is not entirely implausible.
As for Lu Meng.
This decorated general fell at the height of his glory.
A fate both tragic and thought-provoking.
His death was not only the downfall of a brilliant individual.
But also a reflection of the ruthless power struggles.
That defined the era of the Three Kingdoms.
As later historians have remarked.
When we look back on Lu Meng's life.
We see the journey of a man who rose from humble beginnings.
To become one of Eastern Wu's greatest commanders.
A legend forged through courage, intelligence.
And an unyielding will to change his destiny.
This is the History and Culture channel.
Liking and subscribing are the greatest help and support to us.
Thank you everyone and see you in the next time.
