The M5 iPad Pro is NOT a MacBook! But yeah…it can replace one.

Technical Sea
259 followers
This M5 iPad Pro is not a MacBook.
Is it super powerful and fast?
Yes.
Can you do all kinds of productivity on it
like creating PowerPoints or managing spreadsheets
or typing up research papers?
Yep.
Can you do things on it that you can't do on a MacBook
like take handwritten notes or use cellular
or get access to really good mobile games?
Yes.
Yes, you can.
But all that being said, it's still not a MacBook
and it never will be.
Hey everyone, Tech Dad here.
And we have almost demanded that Apple turn the iPad
into a MacBook-like device.
And I am guilty of that for sure.
I've wanted to do everything on my iPad
since the thing came out in like 2010.
And honestly, Apple is trying to deliver.
They have given us iPadOS 26 this year.
So now we have a lot of Mac-like features
in the operating system.
We've got windowing like a Mac.
We can manage files very similar to a Mac.
They're giving us accessories to turn our iPads
into the Mac.
They have the Magic Keyboard.
You can connect to a secondary display.
But the cold hard truth is the M5 iPad Pro
is not a MacBook.
But can it replace a MacBook?
That is the question at hand.
And the answer is, oh yeah.
For so many people, the M5 iPad Pro
is probably way more computing power
than you're ever gonna need or use.
So in this video, we have to break down
what the M5 iPad Pro is and what it isn't.
We have to talk about its purpose
and how it's different from the MacBook.
We need to talk about the trade-offs.
What are you getting with an iPad
that you don't get with a MacBook and vice versa?
And finally, we will answer the question for you.
Can you replace your MacBook,
just get the M5 iPad Pro and be good to go?
So without further ado, let's jump into it.
All right, so let's start by defining the M5 iPad Pro
and what it is.
So the iPad is its own category of device.
Steve Jobs made this very clear.
It is not a laptop.
It is not a big iPhone.
Can't stand hearing that anymore.
It's a tablet.
It's its own thing.
It's designed to be held in hand.
It's designed to use touch controls first.
Can you slap a keyboard and trackpad on this thing?
Yes.
Does it work as well as a MacBook?
No.
So I use my keyboard and trackpad a lot,
but that doesn't mean it's not buggy
and that certainly doesn't mean it's on par with a MacBook.
Keyboards and trackpads were designed for computers first,
way back in the 90s.
Well, the iPad wasn't designed
for using keyboards and trackpads.
It was designed to use through touch.
And even though we have modified it
and Apple has changed it quite a bit over the years,
it really is still a touch-first device
and that's how it works the best.
And I think where people get frustrated
is they hook this thing to a keyboard and trackpad,
they try to use it like a MacBook.
It doesn't work exactly like a MacBook
and then they wanna take the thing
and throw it in the garbage.
And so if you wanna save yourself some frustration,
stop trying to believe that your iPad Pro is a MacBook.
Start trying to use it as a tablet, put it in your hands,
make a PowerPoint presentation with the touch controls
and even use Apple Pencil
because that is an incredible addition to the iPad Pro.
So Apple Pencil Pro gives you all kinds of haptic feedback.
It gives you some precision when grabbing text.
It has hover like a mouse
so you can hover over before you select something.
So there's a lot of power in the Apple Pencil
that really makes the tablet functionality come alive
and it's something that you're not getting with a MacBook.
Okay, Tech Dad, we recognize that the iPad Pro is a tablet
but what does that mean?
What are you getting at?
Well, to answer that, we need to talk about the trade-offs
and I always like to use car analogies.
So let's say you look at a Ford F-150 pickup truck
versus a Ford Mustang.
You could say that they are both vehicles.
They both fall into the same category of vehicles.
They can both drive you to the grocery store, no problem.
They can both go over 90 miles per hour, no problem.
But just because they have those similarities
doesn't mean you can categorize them as the same thing.
Trucks can tow thousands of pounds of equipment.
They can haul humongous loads in their truck bed.
They're really great for off-road conditions
and snowy road conditions.
The Mustang is not good at any of that.
It offers a completely different experience
and it has some things that it's better at.
It has a much higher top speed.
It's sleeker and is probably considered better looking
because it's a sports car.
It sounds different.
The cab is different
and that's the way it is between a Mac and an iPad.
They're really different categories of devices
and you get pluses and minuses with each device.
So with the iPad Pro, you get functionality
that you're not gonna get with a MacBook.
You get that awesome, ridiculously thin form factor.
You get ultra portability.
You get the option of cellular that MacBooks don't have.
You get to take handwritten notes
that the MacBook just can't do.
But on the other side, with Mac,
you get all kinds of things the iPad can't do.
You get a better mouse and keyboard experience.
You get a more powerful operating system
that was designed under the hood to handle more work,
more complicated software, more tasks at a time.
You get a more advanced web browsing experience
because the desktop browser is just more advanced.
You can connect to more accessories like multiple monitors.
The iPad only supports one monitor.
So I like to think of the MacBook as a workhorse
or as an F-150 pickup.
And I like to think of the iPad Pro as that sports car.
You can definitely get around with this thing,
but it's also just really gorgeous to look at and use.
And it just gives those other factors that I've listed
that just give it advantages over a MacBook.
So the question is,
can this M5 iPad Pro replace your MacBook?
Well, that's kind of like asking,
can a car replace a truck?
And the answer is yes, for some people.
Some people buy a truck and never do anything with it.
They don't haul anything or tow anything.
They just drive it around.
Well, if that's the case,
they could probably drive a Mustang around
just as well as they could their truck.
But sometimes you need to tow a 10,000 pound camper
and the Mustang's not gonna do that.
So sometimes you can't get the car
or if your life permits it, just get both.
Have your sports car for driving around for fun
and then have your truck for the work.
And that's the way it is with Mac and iPad.
You can do all kinds of great work on an iPad Pro,
including productivity, video editing, graphic design,
but if you have some specific softwares
or a heavy workload, just get the Mac.
Me, myself, I use an iPad Pro 95% of the time,
but I have a Mac Mini just for those rare occasions
where I need a desktop application
that has the extra features,
or I need a desktop browser,
or I wanna play some retro video games
like World of Warcraft Classic.
iPad's not gonna do that.
So if you're considering purchasing
or if you're looking into the iPad,
just keep those considerations in mind.
Let me know what you think of this whole
can an iPad replace a MacBook debate.
You can leave a comment below.
That's all I got for you.
If you like this sort of content,
please like and subscribe and we'll see you next time.
