'St. John Baptizing' (c. 1506–1511) by Giovanni Francesco Rustici

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
7 Video Views·Oct 29, 2025
Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator Xavier F. Salomon focuses on Francesco da Sangallo’s “St. John Baptizing,” which can be found at the very center of the third floor of Frick Madison. Commissioned in the 16th century for a church in the Tuscan town of Prato, the bronze statuette has been installed atop a facsimile of the marble holy water font on which it was originally displayed, allowing visitors to see it as it was meant to be viewed.
Good evening, welcome to this episode of Cocktails of the Curator.
I am Xavier Salomon, the Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator at The Frick Collection.
Just a few weeks ago, we opened Frick Madison, a temporary new home in the Breuer Building,
which was designed in 1966 for the Whitney Museum of American Art.
And at the very centre of this installation of Frick Madison, in the middle of the third floor,
you have the object that you see here.
And this is part a great work of art of The Frick, belonging to The Frick,
and part a reconstruction which was made especially for Frick Madison.
Just across from this object, you see it here on the left,
is a little chapel with the Bellini Saint Francis.
But the central object was actually made in Tuscany by a Tuscan artist,
and it is here seen in juxtaposition with the portrait by Bronzino of Ludovico Caponi,
another work made in Tuscany and Florence by a Florentine artist representing a Florentine patron.
Because of this, I am drinking a twist on the most famous Florentine cocktail.
In the late nineteenth century, Count Negroni invented the Negroni,
the famous cocktail supposedly first made on a bar in Via Tornabuoni in Florence.
We've been drinking, over some of the past episodes,
both a Negroni and a Negroni Sbagliato, which is another version of the Negroni.
This is yet again another modern twist on the Negroni,
and it's a white Negroni, a Negroni Bianco,
which is equal parts of gin, of L'Ile Blanc, and of Suze.
And Suze is a liquor which was invented in France in 1889,
and it is made from the root of a plant, of the gentian,
which is an aromatic herb which grows in the Alps.
So this is a very herbal, flowery drink.
And as I say, it is a version of the more traditional Negroni.
Salute!
When the Whitney commissioned Marcel Breuer to design this building,
Breuer produced a modern museum
and produced a museum that was designed and conceived
for modern and contemporary works of art.
With Frick Madison, it is the first time that the entire building
is actually inhabited by objects which are much older.
Nothing really at the Frick post-dates the late 19th, early 20th century.
And none of the objects that are displayed in this museum
were ever conceived to be in a museum.
All of the artists—here you see, of course, Bellini and Bronzino
in terms of the paintings and the central sculpture
that we will be talking about—
were all made for either domestic interiors
or ecclesiastical interiors, churches,
without an idea that these would eventually end up in a museum.
I mean, the concept of a museum in sixteenth-century Italy, for example,
was not something that was conceivable in people's imagination.
So one of the big dilemmas of us as curators
is how do we bring some of this original context
back into a building, into a museum,
where works of art that were never designed to be shown together
are forced, in a way, together by the circumstances of acquisition
and the fortunes of history.
Now, the central object that I'm talking about this evening
is usually, yet again, in a very different context.
Here you see the West Gallery of the Frick Collection
at 1 East 70th Street,
and you see the doorway that leads from the West Gallery
into the Oval Room and through that to the East Gallery.
And on the table, the large wood table that you see in the foreground,
you see three bronzes.
All three of them are actually on display at Frick Madison.
But the central one is this small statue of St. John the Baptist
in bronze by the Tuscan Renaissance artist Francesco da Sangallo.
And here you see it on a base placed on the table.
This in itself is a beautiful small sculpture.
It is cast in solid bronze.
It represents St. John the Baptist in the act of baptizing.
So he holds a shallow bowl in his right hand,
and with it he is in the act of pouring water,
presumably over a person who's being baptized.
And, of course, John, as the precursor of Christ,
is often shown dressed in rough clothes,
as he inhabited the desert,
and drawing water from the River Jordan,
where he will eventually also baptize Christ.
As an object in itself,
the statuette looks pretty complete on a pedestal on a table at the Frick.
And, in fact, it is one of the great sculptural works of art in the museum.
When John Pope-Hennessy wrote the catalog of sculpture of the Frick Collection,
the Italian volume had on the cover an image of the Sangallo bronze.
This is the only signed work in bronze by Francesco da Sangallo,
who came from a family of artists.
His father was the great architect, Giuliano da Sangallo.
His uncle and cousins were also architects, artists.
And here you see him in a self-portrait medal,
showing him as a great character of those times,
wearing this rather peculiar turban,
sort of headgear and elegantly dressed.
Sangallo was also himself an architect and a sculptor,
and he worked mostly in marble.
And just to give you one example here,
this is the life-size sculpture of Paolo Giovio,
the great intellectual in the Church of San Lorenzo in Florence.
And this was made for Giovio's monument.
You see the full statue, signed at the bottom,
where he prominently signs himself as Giuliano da Sangallo's son.
And you see a detail of the face,
where you see how in the marbles Sangallo is playing with different textures,
the texture of the beard, the flesh, the old flesh of Giovio,
the vestments of his ecclesiastical role.
The John the Baptist, of course, is a smaller sculpture,
a much more modest work.
But at the same time, Sangallo again is playing
with the different textures of the sculpture,
so the haggard flesh of the Baptist in the desert
and the rough outfit of fur and skin
that the Baptist is wearing.
Now, this object was originally made, as I mentioned at the beginning,
for a very different context.
And during an episode of Travels with a Curator last year,
we traveled to the city of Prato.
And we go back there to the same church of Santa Maria delle Carceri,
which is the place for which the Sangallo sculpture was made.
This stands on a site in the center of Prato,
which is northwest of Florence,
very close to the castle, the medieval castle of Prato,
which you see here on the right,
which was built by Emperor Frederick II.
And Santa Maria delle Carceri is named after the prisons,
the Carceri of Prato, which stood on this site.
Because in 1484, a young boy of Prato had a vision,
saw a fresco of the Virgin and Child on the walls of the prisons of Prato,
on the exterior wall of the so-called Stinche.
And the Virgin and Child appeared to him, came out of the wall.
And since that miracle in 1484, a church was commissioned,
a church which was patronized and paid for in great part
by Lorenzo de' Medici, Lorenzo il Magnifico,
and was designed by Giuliano da Sangallo, Francesco's father.
As you can see from this image,
the church was actually never quite finished.
The façade was left unfinished by Giuliano in the 1490s,
and then subsequently parts of it were finished.
Parts of it are still left with the rough brick that you see there.
But this is a central church, centrally planned church,
with a central dome, with four equal parts,
is what is called technically a Greek cross, with equal arms.
And you can enter it from, as you see in this image,
from different doors.
And the altar, the main altar,
is on the wall on which the miraculous fresco was placed to begin with.
So the church is really built around this wall of the prisons,
which is englobed in this new church for this miraculous image.
Francesco works in the church that his father designed and built,
and the commission for this object is a commission
that, to begin with, does not directly involve Francesco.
So on the 22nd of March, 1534,
so we are almost fifty years after the church was built
and after the miracle,
the two groups of people in Prato,
the Ortolani, which were the vegetable sellers of the city,
and the Poponai, which were the sellers of melons, of fruit,
together gathered an amount of money, 30 scudi,
to pay a stone carver, a man called Giovanni Francesco Pagni,
to make an acqua santiera, or a pila.
And an acqua santiera, a pila, is a holy water stoop or a holy water font
and is the object that usually stands at the entrance of a church
and that contains blessed water
with which people then cross themselves
as they walk in and out of a church.
So as you walk into Santa Maria delle Carceri, on the right,
here is the acqua santiera designed and carved by Pagni.
But the Ortolani and Poponai didn't seem to have been
altogether happy with the result,
and the original commission of 1534
is just the lower part of this object.
So if you see the basin column and the basin,
that was what was made by Pagni.
Four years later, in August 1538,
the Ortolani and Poponai go to Francesco da Sangallo
and ask him to enhance the acqua santiera with a statue.
And so Francesco da Sangallo adds the little column
decorated with leaves and the bronze sculpture on top
of Saint John the Baptist baptizing.
So as you see here,
the basin would have originally contained holy water,
and from the basin, this column,
this new added pedestal,
is put on with the Sangallo sculpture on top.
Now, the church kept this work
all the way till the late nineteenth, early twentieth century.
When the sculpture,
the bronze John the Baptist by Sangallo, was sold,
it went through a dealer, Bardini,
who was a famous Florentine dealer,
and then through a German collection,
through the Morgan collection,
until Frick acquired it,
together with a large selection of the Morgan bronzes.
And by the end of the nineteenth century,
all the way till quite recently,
the original bronze Sangallo sculpture
has been displayed on a pedestal
as a freestanding sculpture,
as you've seen on a table in the West Gallery.
Even though it was always known
that it came from Santa Maria delle Carceri,
this context is somewhat lost.
What happened in the church instead,
which is rather interesting,
is that in 1902 an exact copy in bronze
of the John the Baptist was commissioned
and placed over the Acqua Santiera.
So when you go into Santa Maria delle Carceri today,
you see the original marble Acqua Santiera,
holy water font,
with above it a modern 1902 copy
of the Sangallo sculpture.
And the Sangallo sculpture is so important for the church
that another version of it
is actually displayed over the baptismal font
of the Church of Santa Maria delle Carceri,
which is behind in a space towards the sacristy.
So here you see the niche with the font below it.
This is where young children and infants are baptized.
And another version of the John the Baptist,
again modern, has been placed over it.
So the sculpture is obviously linked
very directly with the church,
and it's still very much part
of the iconography of the church.
So as we were working on Frick Madison,
the idea came about of bringing some of this context
into a new temporary museum.
And so we've been working with Facto Marte,
a group of wonderful people based in Madrid,
who have been working on fabricating works of art
and facsimile of important works of art all over the world.
We worked very closely
with the Church of Santa Maria delle Carceri,
and what we decided to do
was to create an exact replica of the holy water font
to place as a base for our original John the Baptist.
So effectively doing the opposite
of what happens in the church.
In the church, you have the original base
with a copy of the sculpture.
We have the original sculpture with a copy of the base.
Imagining that the marble base
could come to New York even temporarily
is out of the question
because of all sorts of logistical reasons.
So the exact copy is what we could aim for.
And so what we decided to do
was to work with Facto Marte.
This whole project was sponsored by Fabrizio Moretti,
who is from Prato.
And basically helped us bring a piece of his town to New York.
So here you see part of the process
where a 3D rendering of the holy water font
was made after very specific photography
and recordings of the original object in the church.
And then this is the object being worked on in Madrid.
This is, of course, not made of marble
as the original,
but it's made out of other lighter materials.
But it imitates the look and feel of marble.
In many ways, this project has also been a restoration project.
And here you see on the left
the final result at Frick Madison
and on the right, the original.
And what you can see
is that there are certain differences in color.
And the differences in color
are due to the fact that holding water,
this marble basin over time,
has, of course, been somewhat changed in appearance.
The base in which the sculpture is placed
has a metal rod going through it,
which over the centuries has rusted.
And so some of the rust has now
sort of covered part of the surface of the marble.
The other detail which is different
is that at the bottom of the original, on the right,
you can see that there are bronze letterings.
And these were probably added in the early twentieth century.
And so there is an inscription now
around the base of the original pila
in Santa Maria delle Carceri.
And we decided in the replica to actually ignore that,
to not replicate that,
in a way to restore the Pagni pedestal
as it would have been to begin with in 1534.
The sculpture is now at the top of this facsimile.
And what you can do now at Frick Madison
for the first time in more than a hundred years
is you can actually see it at the right height
in the right sort of position in space.
And you realize that this is not a sculpture
that you're meant to see from above on a table,
but it's something that you're meant to see from below.
And suddenly the proportions of the sculpture
and the gesture of,
the very elegant gesture of John the Baptist
pouring water as he baptizes people
becomes a lot more logical.
And so here again, you see the overall effect of this.
Of course, even though we're trying to recreate
the effect of Santa Maria delle Carceri,
of the original, there are some differences.
And of course, with time,
there are certain things that cannot be replicated.
Of course, the space, the surroundings,
are very different from the surroundings
of Santa Maria delle Carceri,
even though the coloring of this gallery
with the gray walls and the concrete grid
is not far off from the type of coloring
with pietra serena and light gray walls
that is used in many Tuscan buildings
of the fifteenth and sixteenth century.
But the two main differences would have been
to do with, again, some of the aspects of this object.
First of all, the water in the basin,
for condition reasons, for conservation reasons,
we cannot replicate that.
But you have to imagine that the basin
would have had the very reflective surface of water in it.
And the other difference is that the sculpture,
we now know from documents, was originally gilded.
So instead of having this brownish-dark appearance,
it would have been a bright gold sculpture.
And of course, there is no way of reverting back
to the original.
And so imagine the interior of the church,
candlelit.
It's actually quite a dark church,
Santa Maria delle Carceri,
with this gold sculpture reflected in the water
in the basin below, in the marble basin.
So that is an effect that we can only imagine.
But I'm very much hoping that this temporary reconstruction
of this work of art will make people think
about the original context of many of the objects
in the museum and will bring back to you
the feeling of seeing this wonderful sculpture
by Francesco da Sangallo in a situation,
in a surrounding which is much closer
to what Sangallo himself imagined for it to begin with.
And of course, as I said earlier,
one of the great points of a museum
is to explore and present the original context
of many of the works of art in the museum
when we can do that
and when we can explain what that was
through research and through temporary solutions
like this one.
Thank you for joining us this evening,
and I look forward to seeing you all soon
with another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
