Deep Parody: Anime Review of Martian Successor Nadesico (TV)

Movie Review
40 followers
A review of the anime TV series "Martian Successor Nadesico," which manages to both parody mecha anime series and be a creditable mecha series itself.
#anime #moviereview
And welcome back to OtakuNoVideo, as always, thank you very much for joining me.
For today, I am reviewing Martian Successor Nadesco, a hugely popular anime series from
the mid-90s.
And the most important thing to know about it is this.
Nadesco is a parody of Mecha anime series, and it is a top-notch Mecha anime series.
This is actually extremely hard to pull off.
Legend has it, the staff were working on the project one day, and they were putting in
all the requisite Mecha anime elements.
And the director turned to them and said, this is such a pastiche of existing anime
cliches, what if we just made it a parody?
Fortunately, Nadesco is a loving parody.
It laughs at all of the tired cliches of Mecha anime and anime in general, and it celebrates
the things that keep bringing us back.
It has characters we care about dealing with tough choices, big sacrifices, high-octane
action, and sweeping stories.
Fortunately, the staff chose some elements that are very well suited to their needs.
The show is about a hastily assembled starship crew on a ridiculously powerful battlecruiser
sent to fight mysterious aliens.
Yes, we've all heard that before, that's the point.
The crew includes a nervous, supernaturally skilled male pilot character who just wants
to be a cook, a brainless female captain, a quiet girl who laughs uproariously at weird
puns, a voice actress, no I'm not kidding, a blue-haired emotionless little girl with
a psychic link to the ship, and a skirt-chasing chief mechanic, among others.
So with this crew, the staff can just as easily tell ridiculous sitcom stories as tough war
stories, and fortunately, they do.
Nadesco works because of its writing and its direction.
I have rarely seen a show that is this confident in its presentation.
The direction is amazingly crisp and appropriate to the action.
When it's fast, it's fast.
When it needs to be slow, it is slow.
There is no wasted movement, there is no wasted action.
You get exactly what you need.
It is amazing.
And the writers tell the story at an extremely measured pace.
Now I don't mean that in a monotonic sense.
I mean that the story moves at a very confident pace.
The writers seem to know exactly what beats that they want to hit.
And this show can turn on a dime.
You'll get a few episodes of light screwball comedy, followed by a punch-in-the-gut moment.
These characters are fighting a war.
People die.
Okay, on to the art.
Now Nadesco was made in the last days of hand-painted cell animation, and it certainly shows.
It has that same slightly sketchy feel of 80s and 90s animation.
Interestingly, the crew also goes with a relatively muted and relatively dark color palette,
which actually reminds me a bit more of the darker anime series of, say, the 80s,
as opposed to the slightly brighter color palette of the 90s.
Now the animation doesn't even try to be naturalistic or realistic.
It is classic 80s and 90s stylized animation and movements.
Characters strike poses, so forth and so on.
That is very much intentional, though.
The animation remains high quality, though, and by that I mean the characters are almost
never off-model, very consistently drawn.
The only time when they're not the exact same drawing style is when they're clearly being
handed over to a specific animator to get that specific animator's style on them.
This is something that has become common among anime fans over in Japan, is to give them
a little something by taking a famous animator and throwing them into a show so folks can
say, oh, that's clearly a sequence by this particular animator.
Now one thing I want to point out is an important element that ADV Films actually adapted perfectly
in.
It's a good example of the complexities of adaptation.
One of the important elements of the show is this show within a show.
So within Nadesico, the characters on the ship become increasingly obsessed with this
cheesy 70s giant robot anime series called Gekiganger, which is invented for the purposes
of Nadesico.
It's kind of complicated.
Anyway, so the characters are all sitting around watching this cheesy anime series.
Now in the Japanese dub of Nadesico, when these clips of Gekiganger come on, they're
all dubbed using this very flat, monotonic, oh no, here comes Gekiganger, we must crush
it.
Because in Japan, that's what those dubs sounded like back in the 70s.
Over here, of course, we got a different style of dub.
So for ADV Films' dub of Nadesico, the Gekiganger sequences are all dubbed like, curse you, Gekiganger
3!
It's terrible dubs, which is perfect.
It's exactly what it should be.
And so I want to say how impressed I am with ADV Films for understanding the intent of
the original joke and adapting it properly for American audiences.
All in all, you'll enjoy Nadesico if you can appreciate its unique, and I do mean unique,
flavor.
There's this relentless screwball comedy punctuated by serious drama, along with joyous
celebration of mecha and anime cliches.
It's an acquired taste, but boy, did I enjoy that flavor.
