Penny Samar Stuns Judges with "Pink Pony Club" & Starts the Pink Penny Club! | American Idol

You wanted me to stay, but I can't ignore the crazy visions of me in LA. And I heard that there's a special place where boys and girls can all be queens every single day. I'm having wicked dreams of leaving Tennessee. Oh, Santa Monica, I swear it's calling me. Won't make my mama proud. It's gonna cause a scene. She sees her baby girl. I know she's gonna scream, You're a pink pony girl and you dance at the club, oh mama. I'm just having fun on the stage in my heels. It's where I belong down at the pink pony club. I'm gonna keep on dancing at the pink pony club. Pink pony club. You have a beautiful voice. I felt like there was a little too much sauce in the performance. Yeah, I mean, I like your voice. I like where you go with it. I mean, your face locking in and all No, I love that. I mean, it's character. It's certainly not vanilla. Thanks. I'm someone that over the years I've really had to like work on emoting. You do not have that problem. You emote a lot and sometimes I think it might be best to dial back a little bit because it was a little distracting from how great your voice is. Yeah, I think that Carrie said it. I think the facial expressions were distracting and I'm not sure. So I guess the moment of truth is here. Who wants to go first? I'm ready. Yes. Yes. Wow. I'm going to give you, I'm gonna give you a no. Your voice is amazing.