Pros and Cons of Cosmos

My Green Garden
1 follower
Oct 27, 2025
Hi guys, it's Casey here at Colonial Gardens, an independent garden center in Phoenixville,
Pennsylvania. It is late October and I am by one of the last of our test gardens that we didn't
get to cover this year. This is Lindsay's cosmically inspired garden. So she decided
to pick plants that either had names that were very similar to planetary bodies or reminded her
in their shape. So in this bed we had star flower this year for example, night sky petunias, and
to represent the cosmos, cosmos. Cosmos are a very popular annual flower, especially if you're
going for the wildflower vibe and you can really see why. It's late October and these things are
massive. They're actually part of the aster family and native to Mexico and they have these really
delicate papery flowers that get up to like three inches wide on this particular variety,
but there's some varieties that are even wider, even bigger, and sometimes have many,
many layers of petals. So there's a lot of different colors that cosmos can come in
and they're really valued for this sort of whimsical vibe that they give off. You can see
the foliage is extremely finely textured. I often think of them as the background on like a Windows
8 laptop computer. You might see like a field full of wildflowers, you might see the cosmos
as one of those representatives. Now they're interesting to grow because I think sometimes
my idealized version of a cosmos is not exactly what you get in reality. So I planted them in my
yard last year and I had a very similar experience to what we're seeing now. Actually my experience
was much worse than what we're seeing now because right now you are seeing dozens, if not over a
hundred, flowers on these plants. But if we kind of take a greater view of this garden, the cosmos
really took over this space. So they're amongst a bunch of other pretty well-performing plants,
but they really went crazy. Even though they started the same size as everything else,
they really maximized their height. You can see that they're over five feet tall when you crop
them up and some of them have really started a very thick root base. So the reason I pulled up
my cosmos last year is because they ended up being mostly this root and mine never actually produced
these giant stalks of flowers. They just became this massive foliage monster of a plant and I
figured out what my issue was and that was that I was taking way too good care of my cosmos. These
are flowers that thrive in dry lean soils and if you fertilize them they will punish you. So that's
actually a little bit what we see here. We didn't do a lot of fertilization because I warned the
team, hey this is what happened to mine, let's really leave the cosmos alone. But I even think
that the amended soil that we gave them with topsoil and compost was too nice for them and we
ended up with these really really massive plants. Now that's not totally a bad thing. These are
really stunning, especially from a distance. So when we're running our events, people can see them
from across the pathway and are really drawn to these big beautiful flowers. But when you're trying
to put them in a more formal garden setting, they're not really behaving the way that you might
want a plant to behave alongside the other plants. It ended up shading them out, it ended up really
overwhelming the space, really a different scale of plant than all of the other garden plants that
were in this bed. And so this was definitely a learning experience for us on how these plants
best behave. And what I would say is if you love cosmos, they're probably best grown in more of a
naturalized garden. So one that's a little less formal, a little less needing to play well with
others, and probably more as a background plant on the edge of your garden versus one that's more
formal in the front of your yard. So again this is cosmos. It is an annual in our zone.
If we let these go to seed entirely, we may see them reseed in other parts of the garden, but for
the most part they're going to die back over winter and we'll be able to restart the garden entirely
next spring. So thanks for watching. You can get cosmos here at Colonial Gardens in the spring.
