iPhone 17 Pro Max vs. Galaxy S25 Ultra Drop Test

Mobile Arena
1 follower
The iPhone 17 Pro Max drop test is finally here,
where it's going head-to-head against the Galaxy S25 Ultra.
This year, Apple looks to have made
some really big improvements,
with the 17 Pros not only getting an aluminum unibody,
which means that there's literally less glass on the back
to crack to begin with,
but the portion that still is glass now uses ceramic shield,
which Apple says is four times stronger.
On top of that, the glass on the front
is even tougher than before with ceramic shield too,
which Apple says delivers
three times better scratch resistance.
Of course, the Galaxy has some advantages of its own.
It has Corning's Gorilla Armor on the front,
and unlike Apple, it's still using titanium
instead of aluminum while also being 15 grams lighter.
Will that be enough for it to beat the iPhone,
or will Apple's durability claims prove true?
Let's find out.
This episode is sponsored by ESR,
who sent out their new CyberTuff case
along with their Armorite Pro screen protector,
which is actually made with accessory glass
by Corning, or the same company
that makes the glass for the iPhone itself.
Now, this case is built like a tank.
ESR rates it for up to 23 feet of drop protection,
and it's thanks to its two-layered design,
where you get a hard shell for structure
and a soft inner shell to help absorb impact.
And combined with the raised lips
over the front and the camera,
plus the full button coverage
and even a dust flap for the USB-C port
gives you all-around protection for the iPhone 17 Pro Max.
And what's cool is this zinc alloy guard
also doubles as a kickstand.
It works in both landscape and in portrait,
with the MagSafe magnets on here
also being two times stronger than most cases,
so your attachments will stay nice and secure.
Now, to go with the case,
ESR says not only is their new screen protector
10 times stronger than generic ones,
while also offering two times better scratch resistance,
but it's also super easy to install
with their two-step tray system,
and maybe more importantly,
it reduces reflections by up to 50%.
And yes, in our drop tests on the back,
the corner, and the face drop,
the combo helped the iPhone survive without a problem.
I mean, the screen protector needed replacing,
but the phone underneath is perfect.
ESR also has this classic clear case
if you want something a little bit thinner,
while still getting 11 feet of drop protection,
so I'll be putting all the links and info you need
down below.
All right, so before we start dropping these phones,
we need to address two major problems
that we've had with our drop tests in the past.
The first has to do with our mounting system.
So even though we used bubble levels,
they weren't perfectly accurate.
So we spent weeks designing and testing
a custom mounting system that lets us rig devices
with just a much higher degree of precision.
And then the second issue we had
has to do with this concrete paver,
where technically, every time we dropped a phone on it,
it's smoothing the paver out a bit,
which made the surface weaker over time.
Now, you would think that just swapping the paver out
would solve this,
but because every paver is made slightly differently,
it would make any cross comparisons we did inconsistent.
So to truly solve the problem,
we're switching over to sandpaper.
This is the same type of surface
that Corning themselves uses in their lab testing,
where we can easily swap in a fresh sheet
after every single drop,
while maintaining consistency when we do so.
Now, to make sure that we weren't just guessing
on which sandpaper to use,
we bought a professional roughness meter.
We took dozens and dozens of samples
from real sidewalks and asphalt,
and found that 80 grit sandpaper is the perfect blend,
giving us the best match to a real world surface.
So with that out of the way,
let's get to round number one in the one meter backdrop.
Okay, so you were able to see it in that slow-mo footage.
The rear glass on the iPhone cracks,
but at least compared to the Galaxy, it's not that bad.
Now, part of this has to do with the fact
that there's just less glass to crack to begin with,
but part of it also could be due
to the extra structural strength
that that aluminum unibody is providing.
Whereas on the Galaxy,
not only is the glass just shattered,
but it almost looks like the glass
near the telephoto camera is caving in a bit.
And if you look closely at the camera system,
unfortunately, that laser autofocus also has a crack in it,
as well as both of the telephoto cameras.
Now, the good news is it doesn't seem
to affect the Galaxy's functionality
after our 15-point inspection,
but it is a clear win for the iPhone in round number one.
Round number two, one meter corner drop.
Two, one.
So the good news is both phones
still remain fully functional,
but the bad news, at least for the iPhone,
is that aluminum does not look good at all.
Not only is it scuffed up really bad,
but it is also dented.
Like, I don't think I've ever seen damage like this before.
It might just be due to the thinner bezels
that Apple is using now
compared to the last time they used aluminum,
but compared to the Galaxy
and its more premium titanium, it's no contest.
I mean, the Galaxy looks almost
like it wasn't even dropped on its corner,
giving it the easy win in round number two.
Round number three, one meter face drop.
Three, two, one.
All right, moment of truth.
Did one of these phones survive?
And no.
Whether you call it Gorilla Armor or Ceramic Shield 2,
both phones unfortunately have their glass cracked.
Now, I will say, at least compared to previous generations
from a few years ago,
these cracks aren't as bad as the full-on shattering
that we've seen, but at least for the iPhone,
it was unlucky enough to have some of its spider webbing
go over that new selfie camera,
which is causing flare issues.
Now, the good news is Face ID still works perfectly fine,
as does the fingerprint scanner on the Galaxy,
but because the Galaxy still retains
its perfect functionality,
it gets the edge in round number three.
Round number four, 1.5 meter backdrop.
Three, two, one.
So with both phones already having their rear glass cracked,
at this point, we're more interested
in their impact and shock resistance,
plus any secondary damage,
which for the iPhone, there isn't a whole lot.
It looks pretty much the same as before,
apart from some of the scuffing around the camera housing,
where on the Galaxy, it's a different story,
with all five of its camera system elements
now having cracks in it.
I mean, the ultrawide is completely shattered,
and that main One X camera is also in pretty bad shape,
and as you would expect, it's showing up
in the image quality,
with there being significant flaring issues
on the ultrawide, as well as a bit of flare
on the main camera, whereas on the iPhone,
the camera system is holding up just fine,
giving it the win in round number four.
Round number five, 1.5 meter corner drop.
Two, one.
After that 1.5 meter corner drop,
the iPhone's aluminum looks even worse than before,
with a lot of that orange paint's now stripping away,
but the bigger issue is what's happened
to its main One X camera,
which has now lost its ability to focus,
meaning anything that isn't at just the right distance away
will appear blurry, whereas on the Galaxy,
the cameras do still technically work,
obviously outside of the flaring,
with the titanium corner looking almost perfect.
I mean, there are barely any scuffs and zero dents,
so it's a big win for the Galaxy in round number five.
Round number six, 1.5 meter face drop.
Three, two, one.
So with that final drop straight onto its face,
there isn't too big of a difference between the two.
I mean, obviously the glass on both phones
are now more shattered than before,
but that's to be expected,
given that they were already cracked,
but the big thing we're looking for
is additional loss of functionality,
which at this point doesn't really seem to be the case,
with both phones working just as they were
in the last round.
So I'm gonna have to call it a tie in round number six.
All right, so with all six rounds in the books,
it's time to take a look at the scorecard,
where in round number one,
the iPhone's aluminum unibody translated into less damage,
not just to the glass panel, but also to the camera system.
In round number two, the Galaxy's titanium
looked pretty much undamaged
compared to the scuffed and dented frame on the iPhone.
In round three, the phones did pretty much the same
outside of a hairline crack through the iPhone selfie cam.
In round four, every single element
on the Galaxy's camera system either cracked or shattered,
with the iPhone only suffering some scuffs.
In round five, all that brute force on the corner
caused the iPhone to lose actual functionality
on its main One X camera,
which presumably would be more expensive to repair.
And then finally, in round six,
well, both phones held up roughly the same,
which means in the end, this one is a tie.
But how do you score it?
Let me know down below in the comments.
Anyways, that is it for me in this video.
Thank you for watching.
And as always, I'll see you in the very next episode.
