Steve Scully, senior fellow at the former Members of Congress Association, Mally Smith, Democratic strategist, and Amanda Makki, attorney and Republican strategist, joined a panel discussion with NTD's Iris Tao, the backlash to President Donald Trump's ballroom project surrounding the demolition, naming it after Trump, and the timing of the construction project during the government shutdown. The panel also discussed the affordability of the Affordable Care Act, the benefit it has become for insurance companies, and the Democrats' strategy to make Americans feel the pain to force Republicans to the negotiating table. The panel also discussed the Trump administration's strikes on boats carrying drugs from Latin America and heading to the United States, and the buildup of military forces in the waters near South America to combat narco-trafficking.
Welcome back. I'm Irish Tao. President
Trump is reportedly planning to name his
new White House ballroom after himself.
Is it a fair move? Joining us now live
to discuss is Steve Scully, senior
fellow at the former members of Congress
Association, Mali Smith, Democratic
strategist, as well as Amanda Mackey,
lawyer and Republican strategist. Great
to have you all on today to discuss
these topics. So, first, the East Wing
has now been mostly torn down already to
make way for the new $300 million
privately funded ballroom. So, Steve,
first to you. For how much President
Trump has put into the project himself,
do you consider a fair move to
potentially name it after himself as
well?
>> Well, first of all, it's completely
gone. I mean, it's not partially torn
down. the colonade, the Jackie Kennedy
Rose Garden, the entire east wing, which
was built back in 1902, expanded in 1942
by President Roosevelt. So, it is
completely gone. Is it appropriate? I
mean, I guess it's not not a surprise.
Uh, he is the one putting up the money.
Certainly, under this administration, it
will be known as the Trump Ballroom. The
question is, in a future administration,
if a Democrat is elected, do they keep
that name? Uh, if you think about it,
there's only the Lincoln bedroom and the
Truman Library. Otherwise, it's the
state dining room, the east room. And
the other issue in all of this is the
size of this ballroom, 90,000 square
feet. It's going to dwarf the size of
the executive mansion. Something that
even George Washington never wanted
something so ostentatious. So, a lot of
debate, a lot of churn, certainly a lot
of concerns about what has been lost
with the demolition of the East Wing,
but not a surprise that he wouldn't want
to name the ballroom after him, at least
for the next three years.
So, Mali, President Trump's team has
also laid out a timeline showing how
past presidents have also made
significant changes to the White House.
Do you think there's a difference here?
>> I don't really care that he is
renovating the White House. There's been
renovations to the White House all the
time. What I'm more concerned about is
having a president who is focusing his
priorities on building a ballroom and
not making uh life better for the
American people. Under President Trump's
leadership, we have seen inflation rise
to 3%. We have seen job growth so bad
that he fired the BLS uh commissioner
and farmers are going bankrupt because
of his trade war with China. But if he
is choosing to focus his time on a
ballroom so he can have bigger parties,
I guess that's where his priorities lie.
At least the ballroom is cemented to the
ground so he can't take it home with him
like his Qatari jet.
Well, to your point here, we have seen
actually in the past few days a quote by
White House press secretary Karen Levit
uh being taken out of context actually
her responding to a reporter's question
at a press conference saying that while
among potential other projects the
ballroom is his priority but apparently
not among all things that the president
is dealing with. Amanda, what's your
response to some Democratic criticism on
this project that's ongoing? And also we
have heard for example um former the
daughter of former President Bill
Clinton uh Chelsea Clinton saying that
oh this is the people's house is not his
house not President Trump's house. So
what what do you respond to that?
>> I respond that her father was the one
who was running rooms in the White
House. And so if that isn't a disgrace I
don't know what is. Um, President Trump
is putting up his own money and um, he
said he would do whatever is necessary
to make sure that this is completed. Um,
he is also using money from YouTube for
example in a settlement uh, that they
reached of $22 million and other
companies that have been mentioned, tech
companies, but also families um, people
who are interested in seeing the
beautifification of the White House. So,
um, you know, over the course of the
last hundred years, we've seen various
renovations to the White House. Um, and
none has really seemed to be as
controversial as what President Trump's
doing. Yet, he's the one that he is
putting up his own money to make sure
that it's done and done properly. And at
the end of the day, uh, to Mali's point,
he's not taking it with him. this is
something that he contributes back to
the people of the United States and to
the next president. So, it is a
wonderful thing to be able to have more
people enjoy the White House, uh, which
in essence is what a larger, uh, room
would do.
>> So, if I could just jump in, I I I think
the bigger issue in all of this is the
fact that the East Wing was taken down
without any public notice. And yes, the
ballroom, I'm sure, is going to be
beautiful. And yes, past presidents have
wanted more space. So taking that into
account, I think that the mistake this
week was not being totally transparent
by saying this is what we're going to do
and this is why we're going to do it to
the extreme trying to block photographs
of this as if it wasn't going to happen.
So that was the one mistake I think that
this White House made this week on it.
>> Well, to be fair on that point,
photographers were able to get the
pictures because they did open up the
park
>> after just today. So pictures were
surely able to be taken by people around
the White House here. Did you have a
point to say as well?
>> Well, the planning commission said that
they didn't actually need to be part of
the demolition, just part of the
building of it. So, um that was not
something that was required because your
question was posed uh to Miss Levit. So,
I think all in all, people just want to
find something to say about President
Trump and certainly the press pool is um
highly encouraged to go after President
Trump and to say, "Oh, look, we're in a
government shutdown and look what he's
doing." But the reality is is that life
has to go on. Just because the Democrats
want to stop uh the government from
reopening doesn't mean the president
can't go on and do other things during
that time.
>> And speaking of the shutdown here, that
leads to our next topic. Health
insurance premiums on healthcare.gov are
expected to rise about 30% next year
according to final rates approved by
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services. So Steve, some say that
Obamacare has become a subsidy for
insurance companies. Of course, we know
there's a lot of debate on Obamacare
recently. Is there a truth to that
statement?
There is in large part. And look, the
insurance companies are to blame for all
of this. And I think the Democrats are
to blame for not really trying to figure
out a long-term solution to the
Affordable Care Act. They're the ones
that put this deadline in place. The
political reality though is that those
premiums now will will go into effect
November 1st. So notices are going out
and I think that that is their strategy
is to try to make sure that they can
make people feel the pain to force the
Republicans to the ne negotiating table.
Keep in mind that the House has been in
recess since September the 19th. So
they're not here. Uh the Senate will be
back next week. Uh my hope is that the
president would sit down all sides and
try to figure out a compromise because
now that we're dealing with air traffic
controllers not showing up for the job,
the health care subsidies, the SNAP
program, all of this collectively is
creating a lot of pain for millions of
Americans, plus the fact that workers,
federal workers, they're not getting
paid.
So Mali, at the core of this debate
around uh healthc care subsidies here,
do you think Americans have become
reliant on these subsidies potentially
due to some say the afor the unfortunate
changes from insurance companies?
>> I think with costs rising, yes, these
subsidies are critical for many
Americans to afford health insurance.
But let's talk about the excesses uh the
success of Obamacare. When Obamacare was
passed, uh the uninsurance the
uninsurance rate in our country was 15%.
That has been cut in half to 7%. When
Obamacare was passed, national health
spending was growing at a rate of 7% a
year and that has been cut to 4%. So
Obamacare has been an unquestionable
success in both expanding access to
coverage and lowering overall health
care spending for our country. But the
question ahead of us is what do we do to
continue to bring down health care
costs? And what we need to do is extend
the ACA tax credits or premiums will
double for 22 million Americans uh if
they um if they uh fail, if they
subside. So we need to create a deal
that reopens the government and extends
these credits permanently. So Amanda,
how do you see Congress potentially
helping to bring premiums back down to
their original levels? Any solutions you
see on the table? Of course, and we have
heard the administration as well as
Republicans saying that, well, we're
fine with discussing these details later
on, but you got to open the government
first. What do you say about that
argument?
>> Yes, the government needs to be opened
first, and the Republicans have made
that very clear. But two, you're really
speaking to the unaffordability of the
Obamacare act, something that
Republicans
discussed in 2009 and 2010. And that's
why you basically saw a partisan bill uh
pass in a reconciliation package, which
for those of you who are not versed in
uh DC talk, that just means they need a
majority um 51. And so that's how they
passed that bill. Uh so the reality is
is that Obamacare is unaffordable. Now,
I will agree with Mi that it is
something that um many welcomed uh
especially when we were in the era back
then of patients bill of rights. Um
Senator Edwards of North Carolina was
someone who really touted that because
insurance companies were denying
patients access to care. Uh breast
cancer patients weren't getting care.
But here's the reality is that the
Democrats did this during COVID. Um they
lifted the income restrictions. And so
you've made this wholly unaffordable.
And if the Democrats thought it was such
a great idea, why didn't they do
anything about this when they controlled
the White House, the House, and the
Senate? They didn't because it's an
unaffordable proposition. And there in
lies the problem. So Republicans
understandably know when you give uh
government treats, you can't take them
back. It's a very difficult thing to do.
We all acknowledge that regardless of
party affiliation. Um, but the reality
is is that these premium notices are
going to go out November 1st. It's going
to light up the Capitol phone lines. So,
Capitol Hill has not seen anything yet
until these phone lines light up when
they get those premium increases. But
also, 40 million Americans on the SNAP
program are not going to have access to
literally putting food on the table. So,
this is a whole mess. And of course,
both sides are blaming each other. But
if you're neutral, you would just say
you're passing a clean CR. What's the
problem? And Democrats don't want to
give President Trump a victory because
they saw what happened to Senator
Schumer when he did that in March. So,
they're going to play politics with
Americans lives.
Real quick note on affordability. The
extending the ACA tax credits
permanently uh would be 10 times cheaper
than the billionaire first tax cut that
the Trump administration passed. Also,
the $40 billion bailout he gave to
Argentina would fund the ACA tax credits
fully for two years. So clearly, the
Trump administration is fine for finding
money to spend on billionaire tax cuts
and bailing out other countries. But
when it comes to actually helping
Americans afford healthare, that's where
they draw the line and that's where they
get budget conscious. Well, absolutely.
>> And that's where the optics are painful
because when you see that and you see
the president uh filing a complaint
trying to get $230 million from the
Justice Department, the optics for that
only play into the Democrats. And you're
right, they're trying to play politics
in all of this. The Democrats know that
that's their only strategy. The big
issue though, will all sides figure out
a plan to get this? Because as we all
know, Congress only acts when there is a
crisis. And my fear is we're heading
towards a crisis. Well, certainly a lot
to look out for, especially as we all
mentioned here, optics as well as policy
debates could play into the upcoming
midterm elections. So, let's see how
that goes um from here. Meanwhile, one
last topic I want to touch on before we
let you go here. The Pentagon announced
today that has deployed an aircraft
carrier, actually one of the largest,
the largest uh in the world to Latin
America to target drug trafficking and
cartels. So, first Steve, earlier a
secretary of war, Pete Hexf said that
the military carried out yet another
strike on a suspected drug boat, killing
six people. Some people say that
administration isn't being transparent.
Well, of course, we have heard officials
saying that these are terrorists.
They're trying to harm Americans and,
you know, they will be dead. What do you
say to that?
>> Well, that's 43 people who have been
killed and nine or 10 strikes. Um, we
have to take the Pentagon for its word.
We don't know. I mean, look, nobody
wants to see drugs in this country. So,
you want to do whatever you can to try
to fight this. But a lot of the fentanyl
is not coming from Venezuela. That is a
fact. And it's also a fact that
President Trump wants to see regime
change inside Venezuela with President
Maduro. And now we have the USS Gerald
R. Ford heightening the tensions in the
region. Uh clearly, if there is any
further military incursion, my hope is
the president does what he should do,
which is to get permission from
Congress. Drugs are a c a crisis in this
country, but you can't just willy-nilly
shoot down these boats without evidence
or proof. Again, we don't know. We're
taking their word. We don't want drugs
in this country, but we've not seen this
kind of action by a president in recent
years. So, it is concerning. Tensions
are rising. The military is going to be
in the area, and it's something that um
I think Washington is going to be on
edge the next 48 hours.
>> Mie, your thoughts?
Well, I think with President Trump's
continued uh reckless interventions
abroad, he's soon going to be called uh
Donald J. Bush. Uh we need to have an
effort to stop drugs from coming into
our country. But uh this saber rattling
and military strikes against uh you
know, drug boats is not the way to go
about it. It's inflaming tensions with
uh countries across the world. And I
also don't think it's an appropriate
long-term solution. Both legally, I
think there's serious issues with us
just having extrajudicial kill killings
without having a formal declaration of
war and without the military providing
evidence that these folks are who they
say they are. And then second, I think a
long-term solution should be a
diplomatic one where we focus on this uh
with a law enforcement approach and
strengthening our borders so drugs can't
get through.
Regime change doesn't work and mission
creep is always always dangerous for
America.
>> Amanda, what do you think? So the
administration says this action
including the strikes as well as now
deploying more forces over is having a
deterrent effect of force of preventing
more people from potentially trying to
harm the US by sending in fentinyl and
other drugs etc. What do you see of this
move? Is it an effective at least
short-term approach or do you think the
administration should go for something
more long-term and like Mali was saying
potentially creating less tensions
around the region?
>> Well, you can look at this a variety of
ways and certainly from the lens of
Republicans, there are different ways of
looking at this. Um, but I think the
saying goes, it's always better to be
feared than it is to be loved. So, of
course, you're creating fear, you're
instilling fear in that part of the
world. And so people are going to be
more cautious. That's the optimism.
That's the hope in that. Um there is a
drug crisis in this country. President
Trump won in a resounding
um vote this year, historical uh and won
all seven swing states. So you have to
look at what he campaigned on. One of
them was to make sure that narot
trafficking is not happening, that he
would secure the border. These are the
types of things that Americans voted
for. And if you look at where he gets
the highest marks, that's where they
are. And so, President Trump believes
he's doing what he had a mandate to do,
and that is to keep the American people
safe and to keep drugs, especially
fentanyl, out of this country. Um, now I
will bring in the perspective of some of
the hardliners that are saying, why are
we doing this? And why are we engaging
in war? And some are even blaming Marco
Rubio for being a neocon and wanting to
push Trump to war. And and one thing I
will say about President Trump in that
many Republicans voted for President
Trump because he was the Republican
president who wasn't pushing war. He was
a war dove, if you will. And so, um, it
is a little bit of a difficult thing for
Republicans to see it, um, happening
because so many backed President, uh,
Trump for being someone who did not want
to engage in war. And this certainly
seems like we're on the precipice of
that. But President Trump may not go
forward with this, but may just be doing
it to instill fear, which I think he's
done in other examples, too, in other
instances, too. So maybe that's just
what he thinks is best because I don't
believe he wants to send troops in even
if the Secretary of State does. Well,
instilling fear. Let's see how this
strategy will continue to play out in
the coming days and weeks as of course
we have seen more and more strikes
happening the past few weeks. Steve
Skully, Mie Smith, Amanda Mackey, thank
you all for coming on tonight. We
appreciate your perspectives.