iPhone 17 Pro Max vs Galaxy S25 Ultra vs Pixel 10 Pro XL Camera Video Test Comparison

Mobile Arena
1 follower
What's up everybody this is Danny and today I'll be doing a video comparison
between the new Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max versus the Samsung
Galaxy S25 Ultra and the Google Pixel 10 Pro XL.
So let me know what video looks better, what microphone sounds better,
but let me put this down because I want to show you what's new
with the iPhone 17 Pro Max's camera this year on the front facing camera because
it's definitely different. Okay so first off you can see that there's cinematic
video on the front facing camera on both of these phones the Galaxy and the
iPhone but for some reason you don't get it at
all when it comes to the Pixel. I'm not sure
why but check this out. Right here is called the center stage
camera and I can go straight into landscape without even turning the phone
so this is amazing. You can literally get whatever orientation
video that you want and then on photos it's the same thing
but you can also go ultra wide or you can go
cropped in and that's amazing. This is an absolute game changer
for the front facing camera and since that works on video
I don't know I think this is going to change the way that front facing cameras
look forever and it's definitely going to be copy.
Let's start with the daytime video and I'm going to use 4k 30 frames per second
as base but don't worry I'll show you higher resolution later on in the video.
iPhone brighter on the foreground and more accurate on the white balance where
the sharpest image but takes the colder approach to the scene
tames down the exposure on the foreground while accentuating the sky
with higher brightness and saturation while the pixel is very contrasty all
around for a more dramatic look. There's the transition into the ultra wide so
let me know which one had the best lens transition.
Same processing on the ultra wide cameras but the iPhone here is the most
accurate when it comes to what this actually look like.
If you pause the video you can see the ground texture is the most detailed on
the iPhone as well so let me know what you think.
I know you just saw walking stabilization but here's another example
they all pick up bounces from my walk so let me know if you can see a major
difference or not. The pixel seems to be doing the worst
picking up more micro jitters if you can see that.
When it's punched in you can see it's a lot worse where the other two are doing
much better. The details are also better so this
gives you an idea of image quality while walking.
After that I wanted to do a quick dynamic range test this is shot in 4k
HDR on all devices so you can get idea what this looks like side by side.
Sky renditions are all different but surprised to see a slight purple tint on
the sky on the iPhone at launch but the clouds look the most accurate.
The pixel is very saturated with the most inaccurate color where the Samsung
is in the middle but they all have fantastic dynamic
range as you expect them to. Let's take a look at the detail at 400%
scale crop. If you look closely the iPhone actually has the most noise in
the video but it seems like that is to retain more detail but I was surprised
to see this. The pixel has the most noise reduction
but that is because this is a boosted video
and I'll show you more of what boosted versus non-boosted looks like later and
the S25 Ultra is definitely holding its own but it seems to be hunting
for focus the most and that could have been doing with people walking in the
frame but it's crazy how different these three can be.
When I was testing out portrait mode video I also noticed this focus hunt
issue on the Galaxy S25 Ultra so I'm hoping this is just isolated to my unit
so let me know if you've been experiencing this as well.
The Galaxy S25 Ultra and the iPhone have higher quality portrait mode video at
4k resolution where the pixel is the lowest at 1080p.
The Samsung looks incredible in terms of sharpness and detail but I think the
iPhone has the best bokeh or background blur effect it's a little bit more
natural so let me know if you agree or disagree. The iPhone is the only one
out of the three that can't do 8k video but in reality the Galaxy S25 Ultra is
the only one that can do true 8k video because the pixel does this with
software upscaling so here's what the video looks like in 4k on the pixel
before it gets upscaled. When punched in you can see that it
lacks in detail in comparison to the iPhone so keep this in mind.
Now here's what it looks like after it gets boosted in the cloud now it's
changed to 8k resolution and it applies stabilization as well to take out the
jitters and it also gets brighter and sharper
and while it does have a slight over sharpened look you can't deny how
detailed the Pixel 10 Pro XL's video is after that. In this scenario it shows
how much more detail comes through in 8k so hopefully one day we'll see this on
future iPhones. The iPhone 17 Pro Max gets a new 4x
telephoto lens this year so let's test it against Google and Samsung flagships.
The Pixel has a 5x optical zoom so we'll start there
and the new iPhone has a 2x crop like all the other phones do
and then there's the 4x lens and the S25 Ultra has the most flexibility
when it comes to the zoom ranges including a 3x optical lens and a
5x optical lens which is awesome. We will move the Pixel to 10x which just
doesn't look good at all without processing
and the 8x on the iPhone is a crop from the 4x but it still looks great in
daytime but the 10x on the Galaxy S25 Ultra has
crazy detail as you can see the max zoom is 24 times on the new
iPhone very solid performance here so that is a nice step up from the 15x
on the iPhone 16 Pro Max. 20x is the max on the Pixel and the
Samsung so the iPhone gets more zoom than the other two on video but the
Galaxy S25 Ultra remains the sharpest. A few more tests before we move on to
nighttime they all have super high frame rate slow motion so let's test it.
Apple and Samsung both have 4k 120 frames per second options but sadly the
Pixel is still in 1080p and you can see it's the darkest out of
the three as well. No boosting option for the slow motion either.
If you punch in you can just see how bad the Pixel slow motion video is
very noisy. The S25 Ultra I think has the best balance of dynamic range and
exposure and the iPhone looks great as well but
it's a little bit overexposed in this scenario.
The iPhone 17 series gets dual capture this year where you can record from the
front facing camera and the rear camera at the same time.
The Pixel 10 Pro XL does not have this feature at all but we have seen this on
Samsung devices for years now so it's not anything new but I'm glad iPhone
users get to use this. You can see just how long Samsung has
been doing this with the software maturity.
You can record it in split view if you want or the picture in picture style
like you can on the iPhone but you can also choose from two lenses
that you want to use for this setup which makes it much more flexible so
that's awesome. Now I know that some people use it so I wanted to test out
the extreme stabilization for action scenarios and sports.
Here's me running with no special modes on and you can see that the Pixel picks
up the most movement here. It's almost unusable. The iPhone
remains the most stable in this scenario but the S25 Ultra does pretty good as
well. With active stabilization modes turned
on they all do really well. The Pixel in 1080p,
iPhone in 2.8k and Samsung in 2.5k so let me know which one that you think
looks most stable. Unfortunately these modes still don't
work at night so it's impossible to test them
in low light. Last thing is the flare test. I know a lot of you complain about
the iPhone green orbs and I don't love them either
but I wanted to test them out against Google and Samsung. As you can see flare
is natural on all camera systems but if you look at the flare
it might actually be worse on the Pixel 10 Pro XL so that is surprising to see.
And just to note you can see how much better the dynamic range is on the iPhone
in this scenario. Look at the sun here and you can just
see how weird the stabilization is on the Pixel as well. It's very unnatural.
Against the Galaxy S25 Ultra you can see the flare is still there but it's a
different color. The coating is better so as you fade
from the light source it gets smaller and the dynamic range is also closer
especially compared to the Pixel but the new iPhone has next level
dynamic range. Alright here we go we're going to move on to night time so you're
going to be able to see what the front facing camera looks like
at night and this is 4k 30 again just to keep everything uniform across the board
so from what I can see on the screen looks like the Pixel's a little darker
oh it just kind of shifted but the iPhone definitely looks the brightest
and looks the sharpest as well and the Galaxy does look a little bit
soft so let me know which one looks better at night.
Okay here we go before we start with low light let's get the Pixel Boost video
thing out of the way. The Pixel 10 Pro XL's video doesn't look
great at night without it and the stabilization can suffer too so
I would recommend filming in HDR or with video boost on because if you
don't have it on you're going to be extremely disappointed
with your vacation videos. I mean just look at the noise it's awful and to be
honest I think the video should look like these boosted videos right after
you capture it. It should be done on device and the reason why this video
didn't come out earlier is because I had to wait six hours for all of this footage
to be backed up and boosted so that's just too long in my opinion.
If you want to share something right after you captured it it's just not
going to look that good and I'm not a fan of this method but the video I'm
going to show you in the rest of the comparison is boosted video so keep that
in mind. My rant is now over so let's keep it
moving. Let's first start with this scenario very dark here as you can see
they're all struggling in their own right but first let's examine the noise
levels all three have noise but the iPhone is the cleanest out of the three
when the fireworks start going off you can see the camera's adjusting to the
brighter light source and the iPhone and Pixel do better than the S25 Ultra as
you can see the noise artifacting happening on the Samsung so I hope they
can fix this in future software updates. When you zoom in to telephoto lenses you
can see it more clearly not that the iPhone doesn't do it but it just has
better processing as a whole when it comes to these type of scenarios. This is
going to be pure personal preference but the iPhone is the most accurate when it
comes to nighttime replication. This beach area is very dark and the iPhone
reflects more of how it is in real life where the other two try to make it into
daytime but it's all about what you prefer. Walking up to this net barrier
you can see that the iPhone is much darker but it does not lose detail on
the net or the wood but the Pixel is impressive with that boosted video the
brightness and detail are insane but the S25 Ultra didn't need to boost at all to
get to this so let me know what you think about that. Here's another example
of noise in that same beach environment punched in you can see how much cleaner
the iPhone is but I know what you're going to say look at the shadows here
they're crushed so I pushed down the mid-tones to match and yes it does help
but look at the detail and noise it's still there on the other two so it's not
just that. When it comes to color accuracy I do like the sky color better
on the S25 Ultra in this scenario it's a little bit too saturated on the
iPhone but the skin tone on the S25 Ultra is just too saturated and it's
picking up way too much of the yellow light it just doesn't look right. The
iPhone skin color is the best out of the three and the exposure is also one point
and the Pixel looks nice too if you're going for that look it's a little too
bright in my opinion but I wouldn't blame you if you think this looks the
best. Seriously let me know in the comments I'm genuinely curious how you
feel about this. Here's another example of the sand detail again the boosted
video on the Pixel looks absolutely insane without seeing the other two
cameras it would be difficult to tell just how dark it was. The S25 Ultra again
in this scenario just picks up way too much of that yellow so some color tuning
is definitely needed. You can see that color difference again in portrait mode
video Samsung's just look so off here where the iPhone's is brightened so I
think people like that best but the Pixel is the most accurate in this
scenario and the details on points so they all have their strengths and
weaknesses. Let's continue with a zoom test in a very dark environment going
from the ultra wide to the main sensor all of them show a major difference when
it comes to light intake and that's expected. The 2x crop on all the phones
stay consistent I have to note that the S25 Ultra does the best when it comes to
the green orbs. Pixel 10 Pro XL's 5x is next. The S25 Ultra has that three times
that all other phones do not have and then after that the five times which
looks the best out of the three when it comes to noise and clarity so this is a
big win for Samsung. Let's go 20x on the Pixel 10 Pro XL, 24x on the iPhone and
20x on the S25 Ultra and Samsung again wins the zoom so if you like zoom the
S25 Ultra is the way to go. Next we move to 8k video maybe not a fair
comparison since the iPhone caps out at 4k but let's check out the detail when
you crop in heavily. The iPhone is definitely the most saturated this time
around but the detail is great for 4k. Now the S25 Ultra is darker and looks
more detailed but the difference isn't as big as it is on the Pixel 10 Pro XL
that boosted 8k video again has insane detail so kudos to Google on this I just
hope that they can do this on device very soon. After looking at more video I
did notice that the iPhone could use some tuning at night because it does pick
up a lot of that purple that is coming off the walls where the other two do
better in terms of the walls. The S25 Ultra looks the most accurate here with
the watercolor, the Pixel's water rendition is the most saturated and the
video is very clinical white but I don't blame you for liking this more
since it looks the most pleasing. I had to test the slow motion here on this
water and the iPhone 17 Pro Max looks the best here in terms of noise and
clarity. The slow motion on the Pixel can't be boosted so you can see the
video in its true form it's very noisy and the resolution is 1080p so that
doesn't help for sharpness and the S25 Ultra does have more background blur
here which I do like but the iPhone's is the sharpest overall. So let's test
stabilization at night because the iPhone does have a square sensor look
I'm walking to the beach I'm walking pretty quick there should be some
bounces here so let me know which one looks better. I can't tell on the screen
so far but you'll be able to see what the stabilization looks like. When it
comes to video they all have features that make them worthy of being a
flagship device but the Galaxy S25 Ultra holding its own being an older device
really shows Samsung did its job so with some color tuning it will continue being
considered one of the best still. The Pixel with video boost is great for the
most part but we really need to do this processing on device and not rely on
uploading and processing in the cloud but I think in the end the iPhone 17 Pro
Max still has the best video overall it has the best balance processing during
the day and night and while this will need some software improvements this
just launched so I think this will be the phone to beat in 2025 and 2026 when
it comes to video. Alright there we go so let me know which one has the best video
are the results of what you expected or did one of these phones surprise you?
Thanks for watching let me know what you think in the comment section below and
I'll see you guys in the next comparison there's a lot more coming stay tuned
