6 times F1 champions got away with title fight stumbles

World Formula 1 Racing
14 followers
Oskar Piastri's place ahead of the 2025 F1 Drivers' Championship has gone from pretty comfortable
to pretty nerve-wracking over the four races since he left Zandvoort with the race winner's
trophy and a 34-point lead over McLaren teammate Lando Norris. A sequence of McLaren team angst,
that contentious post-pit stop team order at Monza, a crash-filled weekend in Azerbaijan,
that controversial hit from Norris on lap one in Singapore, a Turn 1 collision between the two
McLarens in the Austin Sprint, and then Piastri's anonymous race to fifth in the US Grand Prix has
resulted in Norris slashing Piastri's lead to 14 points heading to the next race in Mexico City.
But the most ominous looming shadow is reigning champion Max Verstappen, who has hacked a massive
64 points out of his deficit to Piastri over those past four troubled races for the championship
leader. If Mercedes' season had been more consistent, Singapore winner George Russell
might even be giving Piastri another thing to worry about, given Russell's recent points gain.
Considering how relentlessly strong Piastri's form has been for most of this season,
and the points cushion he still has over Verstappen in particular, he still goes into the final five
races of the championship as the title favourite, but not by anywhere near as much as you might have
expected a month ago. That said, Piastri is far from the first F1 title favourite to have a bit
of a wobble. Some of F1's all-time best have done it and got away with it. Lewis Hamilton had the
beating of Mercedes teammate Nico Rosberg during the first two years of the team's hybrid era
with Hamilton's 2015 title win particularly emphatic. But when Rosberg ended up winning
the first four races of 2016, while Hamilton's opening rounds were blighted by poor starts,
clashes and bad luck, suddenly Rosberg had a 43-point lead and a shot at the title.
However, Rosberg only won one of the next eight races, in fact he was only on the podium in three
of them in 2016's dominant car, as he clashed with Hamilton in Spain, slumped to seventh in
allowed himself to be forced off the road by Hamilton in Canada, clumsily collided with
Hamilton on the final lap in Austria and was penalised for pushing Verstappen off the track
in Germany. Hamilton, meanwhile, claimed victory in six of those eight races to eradicate all of
Rosberg's early season hard work. As F1 headed into the summer break, it was Hamilton who now
led the championship by 19 points, Rosberg having scored fewer points in those eight races than
during the first four. Everything pointed to Rosberg not being up to scratch to mount a proper
title challenge until his major wobble was arrested by a stunning second half of the season.
Four wins in five races from Rosberg and a crucial engine failure in Malaysia for Hamilton
allowed Rosberg to play the percentage game in the final rounds and take an unlikely F1 title
and a shock mic drop retirement. Max Verstappen was building a very good lead in the 2021
championship until his heavy crash at Silverstone after that controversial clash with title rival
Lewis Hamilton. From that point onwards there were swings back and forth and neither driver
took control until Verstappen won back-to-back races in the US and Mexico to open up a 29-point
lead with just four races remaining. Everything was on Verstappen's side. He had the margin,
a car at least the equal of Hamilton's Mercedes, and a rival who'd only won back-to-back races once
all season back in early May. Then at the next race in Brazil, Hamilton had a grid penalty for
the main Grand Prix for using a fresh engine and had to start the sprint race last after being
disqualified from qualifying. But somehow that all turned into the two drivers going into the finale
in Abu Dhabi three races later dead level on points. Hamilton's fight back in Brazil was aided
by it being a sprint weekend which meant he undid a chunk of his grid position damage on Saturday
then completed the turnaround on Sunday. His Mercedes was a rocket ship on the Interlagos
Straits, clearly upsetting Red Bull and rattling Verstappen. Somehow Verstappen escaped a penalty
for taking both drivers into the runoff in that race but it couldn't stop Hamilton passing him
for the win eventually. That was the first of three victories in a row for Hamilton,
a more routine one in Qatar than an even more explosive encounter with Verstappen in Saudi
Arabia. Frustrated after hitting the wall and qualifying and losing pole, Verstappen committed
multiple infractions in the Saudi race. He passed Hamilton outside track limits at a red flag
restart and went off track defending from Hamilton at turn one another time. Then came the famous
brake test after being ordered to let Hamilton back through following the second defence. Whether
Verstappen truly meant to make Hamilton drive into the back of him or just badly misjudged
an attempt to be difficult, only he will ever know the truth. But as in Brazil, it couldn't
stop a fired up Hamilton taking the win anyway. And this was probably the peak of Verstappen
having his own small head loss as the pressure of the title battle reached critical mass,
going to the now infamous winner-takes-all finale in Abu Dhabi.
Both Micka Hakkinen's F1 World Championship wins became way more nerve-wracking than it
looked like they'd need to be when he and McLaren were romping all over everyone with a massive raw
pace advantage in the early stages of those seasons. It was mainly McLaren's technical
fragility that initially let Michael Schumacher into the 1998 fight, but as Ferrari and in
particular its tyre supplier Goodyear started making big development strides, Hakkinen was
reeled in until they were level on points with two races left. A brilliant win from behind at
the Nürburgring steadied Hakkinen's title bid even before Schumacher's Suzuka stall and puncture
settled it. And at least in 1998, Hakkinen himself hadn't done much wrong. That wasn't the case in
his very sketchy 1999, which also counts as by far the bigger wobble because he wasn't even up
against Schumacher. Schumacher's broken leg at Silverstone took him out of a title fight that
had been tense-ish up to that point, but in which Hakkinen still looked favourite. So was Schumacher
gone? Micka could cruise to crown number two, surely? No, somehow Hakkinen found himself
scrapping frantically against Schumacher's unheralded deputy Eddie Irvine, and also coming
under pressure from both David Coulthard and the wily wildcard package of Heinz-Harold Frentzen
and Jordan. A punt from Coulthard in Austria and a dramatic puncture in Germany were out of
Hakkinen's hands, but spinning tearfully out of the Italian Grand Prix lead wasn't, and he didn't
help himself with his handling of the Nürburgring weather either. Hakkinen and McLaren dropped the
ball so often that had Schumacher stayed fit, or even Ferrari kept up its development pace in his
absence, then this surely would have been a title defeat. As it was, despite Schumacher blitzing
everyone on pace but handing Irvine the win on his return in Malaysia, Hakkinen's commanding
Suzuka performance meant he still got the championship over the line, just. But Schumacher
himself wasn't immune to title fight wobbles either. You could see most of the 2003 season
as a wobble amid Ferrari's domination of the era, but were filing that year under close title fight,
as there wasn't a clear Schumacher mid-season stumble. The biggest point swing against Schumacher
in one of his championship seasons was a dramatic loss to his enormous early 1994 points lead,
as he went for winning six of the first seven races and having more than twice as many points
to being just one point ahead of Hill going into the finale. But it's not really fair to
characterise that as a wobble, because disqualifications and bans played such a huge
part, with Hill's four game-changing wins coming on days when Schumacher either wasn't there,
or was wiped from the results afterwards. The story of that wobble period was still that if
Schumacher was actually on the grid, his Benetton didn't break down and he didn't do anything dodgy,
he'd win by miles on raw pace. It was only in the Suzuka and Adelaide showdowns that Hill
really got Schumacher on the ropes, but he got away with it in messy circumstances with their
Australia collision. So for a proper Schumacher title fight wobble, you have to look at 2000.
As he won the first three races, it looked like Schumacher was finally on course to end Ferrari's
two-decade driver's title drought after three seasons of near misses. McLaren still generally
had the faster package, but it was less reliable. Even with some costly pit chaos in Spain and
melted suspension when leading in Monaco, Schumacher looked comfortable in the championship
lead heading into the summer. But three straight zero scores changed that. Engine failure just
after losing the lead to Coulthard in France was followed by first corner tangles in both Austria
and Germany, then straight defeats to Hakkinen in Hungary and Belgium, the latter famous for
Mika's bold pass as they went either side of Ricciardo's onto. Suddenly Schumacher's points
lead was gone, but Ferrari wasn't going to be robbed again. Four Schumacher wins to round out
the season and a bit of help from another engine failure for Hakkinen at Indianapolis meant this
time there was no last gasp heartbreak. Having crushed the opposition in 2023 with arguably
the most dominant F1 season by a single driver, Red Bull and Verstappen appeared to start 2024
in the same vein, with four wins in the first five races. But then McLaren unleashed a huge
upgrade in Miami, a 10-part development package that transformed its car from third best to a Red
Bull beater. Norris won in Miami and McLaren should have done more damage thereafter, but Verstappen
outfoxed Norris at a damp Canadian Grand Prix and clashed with him in Austria where the red mist
returned over Verstappen. He was slapped with a 10-second penalty and we got the first sign since
2021 that he was feeling some title pressure. This wasn't helped by Red Bull's car development
taking a nosedive while McLaren established itself as F1's new benchmark, sparking a string
of unproven theories about McLaren's rise from Red Bull. Water in the tyres, anyone? Verstappen's
brilliance in the middle part of the year stymied much of the points loss, but even he could only
finish 5th at the Hungaroring and a lowly 6th at Monza. It was after Monza that McLaren threw its
weight behind Norris' title bid as he got to within 62 points of Verstappen with a car that
looked capable of winning all the remaining races. After Norris dominated in Singapore,
the duo came to blows again in Austin and Mexico as Verstappen did everything he could think of to
stop Norris in a slower car. Many saw their Mexico collision as a tactical foul on Verstappen's part
to stop Norris winning that race, but either way, Norris had nibbled Verstappen's lead to 48 heading
into the final four races. But then came Brazil, where it was Norris who wobbled in the wet with
multiple errors while Verstappen charged from 17th to one of his greatest victories. That ended
Norris' title hopes, which some will argue lacked any credibility in the first place. But as it
shrank from F1 dominator to a paranoid second best, 2024 undoubtedly featured a major Red Bull
wobble, one only saved by the performances of its generational talent. Everyone remembers the
tale of Ross Brawn rescuing the Honda F1 team, turning it into Brawn GP and benefiting from
Honda's massive spending on the new aero rules, the double diffuser trick, and McLaren and Ferrari
neglecting 2009 development amid their colossal 2008 title scrap to take a scarcely believable
title double with Jenson Button. And most probably also remember that the title win was found in the
early domination before things got tougher. But how many remember just how bad things got for
After taking 6 wins from the first 7 races, it wasn't just that Button didn't win again after
Turkey in June, he was only on the podium twice more in the remaining 10 races. In its only season
of existence before turning into Mercedes, Brawn was getting eaten up by bigger budgeted rivals
in the development race, and soon pretty much everyone else had a functioning double diffuser
too. Button has suggested that Brawn actually had more development budget that it was reluctant to
spend, but whatever the reason, the car certainly wasn't dominant anymore and Button was having
particular angst with tyre warm-up and qualifying, struggling at times to even break into the top 10
on Saturdays. But there was also a suspicion within the team that Button was simply tightening
up as the pressure grew, and that after all the twists of his career so far, the fear of this
golden and totally unexpected title opportunity being in sudden jeopardy was weighing heavily and
affecting his driving. After all, his teammate Rubens Barrichello started winning races in the
middle of Button's wobble having been blown away in the opening rounds. Potential rivals taking
points off each other helped. Red Bull was rising but both Sebastian Vettel and Mark Webber were
winning races. McLaren and Ferrari were popping back to the front but not consistently, and in
what became an ultra close season full of form flips, things got so wild we even had Giancarlo
Fisichella's Force India on Belgian Grand Prix pole. All of which helped Button still get a title
over the line with a brilliant 14th to 5th charge in Brazil that ensured the Brawn fairytale didn't
turn sour.
