Latest Developments in National Guard Deployment

NTD
11.9K followers
174 Video Views·Oct 23, 2025
To discuss the latest legal disputes relating to ICE arrests, we're bringing on Bobbie Anne Cox, a Fellow at the Brownstone Institute, a legal analyst, and a civil rights attorney.
--
🧶More NTD Programs:
https://www.ntd.com/programs?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=SocialM
--
🇺🇸 Stay updated with breaking news, special reports, and LIVE COVERAGE on NTD: https://ept.ms/NTDlive_
--
🔵Sign up for our newsletter to stay informed with NTD News. 👉https://www.ntd.com/newsletter.htm?utm_source=YouTube. If the link is blocked, type in NTD.com manually to sign up.
--
🔵 Watch more: https://www.ntd.com/?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=SocialM
🍀 Support NTD: https://donorbox.org/ntd
--
© All Rights Reserved.
To discuss the latest legal disputes relating to ICE arrests, we're bringing in
Bobbie Ann Cox, a fellow at the Brownstone Institute, a legal analyst and a civil rights
attorney. Bobbie Ann, always great to see you. Thank you for joining us today. To start off,
can you give us an overview of the latest legal disputes surrounding Trump's deployment of the
National Guard? Sure, yes. So there was just the other day a decision by the Circuit Court,
so the Court of Appeals for the Northwestern District of our country. So this is regarding
the case with Oregon. And basically what's going on there is the court, which was the appellate
court, ruled that, yes, President Trump does have the ability to deploy the National Guard
to Portland, Oregon, and that the lower court, the federal district court, which had stopped Trump
and told him he did not have the power to deploy the National Guard in Portland,
they have now overturned that lower court decision. And this just happened two days ago.
So as of right now, President Trump, it has been declared by the Court of Appeals in that
particular area of our country that the president does have the power to deploy the National Guard
into Portland, Oregon, whereby overturning this lower court decision. But I do want to point out
that we are really facing some scary times that we have courts trying to tell the executive branch
how and when they can govern this country. So these cases brought against the executive branch,
brought against President Trump, trying to stop him from deploying the National Guard
to keep Americans safe and to carry out federal law enforcement operations is completely ridiculous
and wholly unconstitutional. I mean, the Constitution doesn't say that the courts
get to determine whether or not the president can do his job. So I do think the decision
by this court two days ago at the circuit court level was correct in lifting the injunction that
the lower court had put on President Trump's deploying the National Guard. But the case
shouldn't have been brought in the first place, in my opinion. So, Bobbi-Ann, can you clarify for us
exactly what does the law say about when a president deploys the National Guard when a
governor opposes it? Yeah, well, you know, we have this clause in our Constitution,
it's called the Supremacy Clause, and it clearly says that the supreme law of the land
is the Constitution and the federal government does have the power to do certain things as per
our Constitution. And one of those things is to keep Americans safe and to protect Americans
from enemies both abroad and domestic. And with the Supremacy Clause, the notion is that state
governments can't overrule the federal government in an area where the federal government has
specific power. And this is one of those cases, as I just mentioned, where the federal government,
the executive branch, the president specifically, has the power to carry out and enforce our
federal laws. That's actually part of his job, is he has to enforce our laws, which will keep us
safe. And so, to answer your question directly, the governor of a state or the legislature of
the state doesn't have the power to tell the federal government, to tell the president,
hey, we don't want your federal agents in our state, go home. So that's just not the way it
works. The president is wholly within his power to deploy the National Guard into a state or city
that is having civil unrest. And this is something that has been done numerous times in our history.
This is not something new. And yeah, so really, the governors have no say. They can talk a talk,
but there's nothing they can do to stop the federal government from deploying, in this instance,
deploying the National Guard or other federal agencies, sending an FBI, for example,
to enforce our laws. This is clearly a power that falls to the executive branch.
All right, understood. There's another argument that I've heard against Trump's deployment here.
Does the president, and can you clarify for us, does the president need an emergency in order
for this deployment? Well, so his whole premise here, and not just in the Portland, Oregon
situation, but in other states around the country where he has deployed the National Guard or
militarized their local police, as he did in Washington, D.C., not too long ago, the whole
premise here is that he is enforcing the law, right? He is doing what needs to be done because
the local governments, whether it's the city or the state, are not doing what they're supposed to
be doing. In the instance with this decision that was just issued two days ago from the
9th Circuit Court of Appeals regarding President Trump's authority to send the National Guard into
Portland, I read part of the decision where they were going through the factual background of the
case. According to the court's decision, it says that ICE agents at the ICE detention facility
in Portland were being attacked. They were being assaulted, personally assaulted.
The building itself was being attacked. They set fire in the driveway. Protesters set fire in the
driveway to the ICE facility. They were setting off fireworks. They physically assaulted a couple
of the ICE agents. They had to actually close down that ICE facility to repair it from the damage
that was caused by protesters. Then they reopened it, so it's functional again now.
This is not a situation where you scratch your head and say, gee, I wonder why
the president is sending the National Guard in. These ICE agents are trying to do their job.
They are tasked with enforcing a specific federal law that says you cannot illegally
come into our country. They're doing their job. You have protesters attacking them,
attacking their facility, setting things on fire. One ICE agent was confronted by a protester
with a knife. We can't have this. If the governor of Oregon is not going to do anything, or the city
mayor of Portland is not going to do anything to stop these riots and these unpeaceful protests,
then yes, absolutely, the federal government, the president does have the authority to come in and
say, you know what? You're not doing the right thing, so I'm going to make sure that these ICE
agents are protected and that they can carry out their duties. This is wholly a situation where
the state government and the local government are not doing what they're supposed to be,
and so it is the jurisdiction of the federal government to step in.
So Bobbi-Ann, you said earlier that these legal challenges shouldn't be brought upon
the president in the first place. So I'm wondering, what impact
are these court cases and appeals having on law enforcement trying to do their jobs?
Yeah, it's terribly restrictive. For this particular instance, let's say,
with Portland, you've got the trial court judge saying, nope, Trump doesn't have the power to
send in the National Guard to quell the unrest and to protect the ICE agents and the ICE facility.
Then you have the ICE agents fending for themselves and getting assaulted
and attacked. Then you have the appellate court now saying, oh wait, no, yes, they can send in
the National Guard. There's enough unrest here, and Portland's not doing anything about it,
and Oregon's not doing anything about it. So yes, the federal government can come in with
the National Guard and protect the ICE agents and the ICE detention facility.
So it's a ping-pong back and forth. So it's very disruptive to law and order, and we shouldn't
have this ping-pong effect. We shouldn't have the courts deciding whether or not the federal
government can carry out their duties under the Constitution. The Constitution is clear.
There shouldn't be a challenge to the executive officer of our country, that would be the
president exercising not just his authority, but his duty. The president of our country swears an
oath to our Constitution, swears on Inauguration Day that they will uphold our laws and enforce
our laws. And that's what's happening in this instance. So the fact that you have local
governments suing the federal government saying, no, you can't do this, is completely absurd.
Read the Constitution, folks. The Supremacy Clause is very clear. So yes, it's very disruptive to the
activities of these federal agents that are trying to do their job and keep Americans safe. This is
ridiculous. We're fighting against the people that are protecting us and enforcing our laws.
It makes absolutely no sense.
Well, okay, Bobby-Ann, thank you for explaining it very clearly here today. Thank you for your time.
Yes, thanks for having me on.
