White Man's Burden by Rudyard Kipling: Historical Analysis

RUDYARD KIPLING
2 followers
Okay, today we're going to do a reading, a historical reading, of
the White Man's Burden poem by Rudyard Kipling. And we remember Rudyard Kipling as the author of
the poem we looked at, We and They. We use that poem as an example of a social Darwinistic writing
of the late 1800s, early 1900s. Kipling was an English journalist, poet, writer, also wrote
The Jungle Book and the poem If was the first Englishman to receive the Nobel Prize for
literature. He was classified as an imperialist slash social Darwinist, similar to Cecil Rhodes.
So, and thus his works are assumed not to be satire. It is assumed that he believed in the
concepts behind We and They and The White Man's Burden. And he did live in multiple different
places in England, United States, India, and South Africa. Now, the definition for the poem,
The White Man's Burden, is the title of the poem, but it's also taken to mean, in Kipling's term,
for the heavy load and task of, quote, civilizing and, quote, helping the colonies during imperialism.
Okay, the term became used as synonymous for imperialism or in place of imperialism by both
people who supported imperialism and also, more importantly, people who were anti-imperialist.
People who were anti-imperialist really took this poem, highlighted its racism,
highlighted this poem, whereas Kipling thought it might be everything good about imperialism.
The people who didn't want countries to take over countries used it to highlight everything bad
about the attitude of the people, the imperialist nations ruling the colonies. So, it was used
heavily by the anti-imperialist as an attack point to attack this poem and say, look what's wrong.
Look how people are thinking and look how it's wrong. We have this overview from George Mason
University, 1899 version novelist poet Rudyard Kipling wrote a poem, White Man's Burden in the
United States and Philippine Islands. In this poem, Kipling urged the U.S. to take up the burden
of empire as had Britain and other European nations. Published 1899, McClure's magazine,
the poem coincided with the beginning of Philippine-American War, U.S. Senate ratification
of the treaty that placed Puerto Rico, Guam, Cuba, and Philippines under American control.
Theodore Roosevelt soon become vice president and then president copied the poem and sent it
to his friend, Senator Henry Cavill Lodge, commenting that it was rather poor poetry,
but good sense from the expansion point of view. Not everyone was favorably impressed as Roosevelt.
The radicalized notion that the White Man's Burden became a euphemism for imperialism and
many anti-imperialist counts their opposition in reaction to the phrase. It's a very interesting
time right at the 1900s. So, the question is, is the United States going to follow in the
footsteps of the European countries? Now, by that time, 1899, the European countries had taken
direct control or indirect control over large swaths, almost all of Africa, South Asia,
Southeast Asia, spheres in East Asia, direct or indirect control, Australia. So, the question was,
was the United States going to be colonizing islands and countries and nations like the
Europeans did? And there was a lot of argument back and forth on this kind of expansion
in the United States. Regardless of the American history, we are going to use the poem to look into
European imperialist thought because Kipling is summarizing European imperialist thought
and urging the United States to be like them. From this point on, I'll just mention like,
be like Great Britain because Kipling was British. Okay, this is a scan of how that
poem would look in the magazine. Okay, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven stanzas. I guess
that's what they're called, stanzas, not being an English major. Let us remember that Kipling
is the narrator. So, we assume that he is talking, basically, and we assume he is talking to the
English or U.S. governments who are going to go and or already running colonies. Examples of some
of the colonies would be the Philippines, India, South Africa, Nigeria, Australia, etc., etc.
Okay, a little map we used from we and they. So, we, Kipling is British, so this would be
Great Britain. Everything in red here except the U.S. was territories, not all of them, but most
of them of the British Empire. And we're going to circle the United States because Kipling wants the
United States culture to spread just like the British culture is spread to South Asia, areas
in Southeast Asia, Australia, and Africa. And some British colonies still left over in the Americas,
not many though. And let's give ourselves a note. This poem is advanced. I ran it through
readability programs and the scores put it late high school through college. And those programs,
those tests are basically just using sentence length and syllables. Okay, when you look at
this poem, it's got short sentences and not so many syllables, and it's saying it's high school
to college. But remember, this is a poem from the 1900s. So, the word choice and the obscurity of
the sentences is going to add multiple layers of difficulty on top of just actually reading the
sentences with the words. So, you know, if the readability programs are saying that this one's
kind of difficult, you've got to add layers of difficulty on because it's a poem. It's
seriously complex. Okay, so what I'm going to do is I'm going to go stanza by stanza.
I'll say the definitions that I think we need to know. First, I'll read the poem. I'll translate
it into simpler words, and then I will give my notes and observations as a social studies teacher.
Okay, take up the white man's burden, send forth the best ye breed, go bind your sons to exile,
to serve your captives need, to weigh in heavy hardness on fluttered folk and wild,
your new caught sullen people, half devil, half child. Kipling talking to the U.S. or English
government about the colonies. Burden is a heavy task or load. Heavy harness is the thing put
around an ox before it's ready to do work and plow. Sullen means gloomy and bad tempered.
So, what I get from this is a translation. Go do your duty, U.S. and England. Take up the white
man's burden. Go do your duty. Send forth your best citizens. Send them to the colonies to help
the indigenous people of the colonies. Your people will be like working animals trying to help
directionless wild indigenous people. The indigenous people are devilish and childlike.
Now, I want to say these translations are my translations, which is a master's degree in
education field of social studies. I am not a literature master's degree person, so I may be
wrong in some of my interpretations, but I get, I am sure I get most of it of this poem correct.
And some notes about that. I noticed that Kipling is once again setting up an us versus them. If you
remember in the poem, we versus they, he really did a lot of work to set up the we culture of
Great Britain and the they culture of everybody else and did a lot of his time in that poem
making the English culture superior and everyone else's culture inferior and over and over and
over saying about that. Well, he's setting it up again. So the us is good. The imperialist,
the best ye breed sent, send your sons, the awesome ones over to help those in need.
And then the them would be characterized as bad. He uses the term sullen, half devil, half child
wild. So he's setting up another tribalistic, ethnocentric, social Darwinistic idea, us
verse them. He also sets up the task. The main idea of the poem is the task of the white man
to help go to serve and to work for the people quote unquote helping. Okay. Stanza two,
abide means to act in veil is to hide like with a veil and to check is to stop checks and balances
different parts of the government check and stop the others when the others get too powerful. So
to check is to stop, take up the white man's burden in patience, to abide, to veil the threat
of terror and check the show of pride by open speech and simple and a hundred times made plain
to seek another's profit and to work another's gain. Okay. Translation. Um, I'm gonna, he says
this every time, take up the white man's burden. It means go do your duty, United States and
England. I'm going to stop saying that because he says it all the time. Go do your duty. Okay.
Act with patience towards the colonies, hide the fact that you are so much stronger militarily.
Don't show your pride and how you think you're superior to the colonies when you're helping them
and teaching them use simple words, like you're talking to a child by open speech and simple and
a hundred times made plain repeating yourself. Cause they don't repeat the lessons hundreds
of times because they, until they understand before they understand, because they don't
understand to seek another, you're there to help them to work another's game. You're working for
the colonies benefit. Okay. My notes and observations of stanza two, again, he's
contrasting the, we, and they, the, we, the English or the U S powerful and prideful militarily,
powerful, prideful, uh, superior culture. They being simple needs explanation, frustrating
to the imperialists. So he's making the, we, and they, uh, dichotomy right there.
Again, he's reinforcing that imperialism is for the benefit of the local people for the colonies.
Now he's no, he's totally ignoring all the dollars that the imperialist nations are making
all the money, all the resources, all the empire glory that great Britain and other imperialist
nations are making. So we're seeing a one-sided argument here. And this is what a lot of people
pick up on when, uh, when they reacted and didn't like the poem, um, they're saying, look, you're
not telling the whole story. Like you're focusing in on like takeover is only to help the colonies.
And you're totally ignoring that literally like the main idea countries are taking over
others is to make wealth. So, um, so a lot of people are at the time going to take a lot of,
uh, umbrage. They're not going to like this poem because they think he's being a propagandist.
They think he's being biased and he is okay. He stands at three. Um, cease means to stop
sloth is laziness. I think that's why we call them sloths because they move slowly.
Heathen means, uh, someone have a different religion. Folly means foolishness and not
means nothing. Take up the white man's burden, the savage wars of peace, fill full the mouths
of famine and bid the sickness cease. And when your goal is nearest the end for other sought
watch sloth and heathen folly bring all your hopes to not. Okay. Remember Rudyard Kipling
is talking to the governments of great Britain and the United States. So whenever he tells
someone to do something, when it sounds like campaign command was that called the imperative?
When he tells someone to do something, he's telling the governments to go and serve the
colonies. Do this, do this. He's telling the English people to go and do it. That's who he's
commanding in this poem. So he's saying, go do your duty, create peace in the colonies,
stop local wars, teach the local people, new farming. So they are not starving,
whether they were starving before or not is immaterial. Kipling says, go teach them how
to farm. Even if they know how to farm, teach the local people about Western medicine,
bid the sickness cease. And when you're almost done with all the work helping them,
when your goal is nearest the end, the end for other saw watch as their laziness and foolishness
ruin all the work you did for them. Watch sloth and heathen folly bring all your hopes to not.
Notes for this stanza, he's listing enunciating the benefits that imperialism will bring an end
to war, an end to famine, an end to sickness. And he's also saying what will happen. He's predicting
what will happen. And by saying that the local people will ruin all the work because they are
Now is a good time after stanza three to bring up the point reading this poem today in today's
context, in today's world, with how the world thinks about different cultures today, would
this poem be considered racist today with how he talks about different people? The answer is yes,
definitely. But it is also incredibly worth noting that would it be considered racist in 1900?
Also, yes, by many people now, not by everybody. Because this was an idea social Darwinism in 1900.
But there was a good on number of people that believed in equality of cultures and would
consider this poem racist and over the top and not welcome. And that's why there was so much
pushback and people writing in response against this poem. Okay, stanza four, the definitions are
toil, which means work. Surf was a European medieval worker. Ports are cities where the
ships are docked or parts of the city, really. And to tread is to walk. Kipling talking to the
government of the US and England, take up the white man's burden, no iron rule of kings,
but toil of surf and sweeper, the tale of common things. The ports you shall not enter, the roads
you shall not tread. Go, make them with your living and mark them with your dead. So go do
your duty, US and Britain, he says. Not as conquering kings, but send your people as workers for the
colony. I don't know. I don't know these next lines. I'm not that good. Here's my best guess
of what he means. You won't stay in already made cities and use roads. You'll be the ones making
the cities and the roads. Bring urbanization, bring infrastructure. Maybe that's what he means.
And it's probably going to be so much work, it'll work some of your people to death. Make them, build
them with your living and mark them with your dead. That's the best I can do for that. That's
what I think he means there. And if I am correct, my notes and observations about this is it's a
stanza about how much work it's going to be to build the colonies. It won't be a rule, a kingly
rule where someone goes in and has a luxury life of a king. It'll be the rule of a worker building
a colony. Okay, number five. To reap is to gather. To reap is to gather things up. And to humor is a
verb, is to act to keep someone content. If I'm doing things to keep someone happy, I am humoring
them. Take up the white man's burden and reap his old reward. The blame of those ye better, the hate
of those ye guard. The cry of hosts, ye humor. Ah, slowly, towards the light. Why brought ye us from
bondage, our loved Egyptian knight? Okay, translation. Go do your duty, U.S. and Britain.
Same thing every time. Here is the thanks you will be getting for helping the colonies. The
locals will blame you, even though you're better than them. The locals will hate you, even though
you're helping them. And even though you are trying to keep them happy, they will yell, why did you
change our culture? Question mark? I'm not really sure this part. The cry of, I get the cry of host
ye humor. The people you're trying to keep happy will yell at you. But this part, towards the light,
why ye brought us from bondage, our loved Egyptian knight. I get, I translate that into why did you
change our culture? I don't know. I'm not that good. Cut me some slack. This is some tough stuff.
Uh, this is some tough stuff when you don't read other interpretations and you, and Kipling's gone
and I can't ask him what it means. So, uh, cut me some slack. That's what I think it means.
My notes and observations. Um, Kipling uses this stanza to predict how the colonies will react to
the help of the imperialist nations. Put the help in quotes. He predicts they will not be grateful.
I mean, to editorialize too, if you didn't want your country taken over and someone's come in
and they've taken over your country and they're making a lot of money off of you
and changing your culture, are you going to be grateful? Do you want them there? A lot of people
don't. And because this poem is so biased and it's not giving the other side of the story,
this part of the poem is where everyone who is against imperialism, everyone who doesn't agree
with imperialism is just screaming at the page. Of course they are not grateful. You just took
them over and are making tons of money off their countries. Okay, stanza six. Sullen again means
gloomy and moody. Stoop is to lower one's morals, to stoop down, to go under the bar of moral
goodness. Weariness is tiredness. Take up the white man's burden. Ye dare not stoop to less,
nor call too loud on freedom to cloak your weariness. By all ye will or whisper, by all
ye leave or do, the silent sullen peoples shall weigh your gods and you. Oh, sorry. Shall weigh
your god and you. Again, in this translation, I have one sentence I'm not sure of, so I just do
my best. Go do your duty, U.S. and Britain. You shouldn't ignore this challenge. Don't become
tired and try to use freedom, either your own freedom or theirs, as an excuse to stop. I don't
know whose freedom he's talking about. Be aware of all your actions and your words because the
locals will be judging you and your god, and you have to be an inspiration, a role model to them,
promoting the British or U.S. culture. They will weigh your god and you. You know, this brings in
the social Darwinistic idea, right, that the culture is a role model to the rest of the world
and everyone wants to be that culture. So, you know, in this sentence, weighing you, judging you,
he's saying, be the role model that you know you are because you're promoting the social Darwinism
and the culture. Some notes and observations. He mentions it's a moral obligation to change
the civilization, so the idea of not stooping to less really brings in a moral obligation.
Recognizing it will be hard and there will be weariness, and he says to be an inspiration and
a good role model, even when tired. This is kind of bringing in the ideas of parentalism,
acting as a parent a little bit. He's hinting at it in this, where even though you're tired,
you can't quit, and he's hinting at a sort of parental, being a role model. He's hinting at
parental relationship, and we're at the take-home stanza, the last stanza. The definitions are
proffered means offered. Feel free to use that word at any time. Just take offered if you offer
something and put a PR in front of it. Proffered. It's still actually used today in a lot of
literature, so feel free to use that one. Laurel is an award, like the old laurel wreaths, I think,
in Roman Greek times. Ungrudged means willing. That was a tough one. And peers are those who
are like you on your own social level. Take up the white man's burden. Ooh, exclamation point.
That's different, isn't it? Yep, yep. That's a literary thing. That's not historical, so
I'm pretty impressed that I found a literary thing right there. Tell the English professor
friends of mine I found something literary. That's a first. It's the end. It's the last
stanza, so we put an exclamation point on that. Take up the white man's burden, exclamation point.
Have done with childish days, the lightly proffered laurel, the easy ungrudged praise.
Come now to search your manhood through all the thankless years, cold-edged with
gear-bought wisdom, the judgment of your peers. Translation. Go do your duty, U.S. and Britain,
exclamation point. Stop, okay, stop being child, have done with childish. Stop being child nations
and be adult nations with responsibility. Lightly offered, probably easy on. When you're a child,
awards and praise come easy, right? Everyone awards children stuff. Everyone praises children.
Now you're a man, an adult, and you have to earn the awards and the praise. How do you earn it?
Earn it with years of thankless work. No thanks from those you help. And a little tough on this
part, I'm not really sure. But someone, probably you, is going to obtain wisdom through your years
of work, and your efforts will be judged by your fellow countrymen, your peers back home, and other
imperialists who do the work will judge you. I'm a little shaky on the end of this, but I got the
first off of it. Have done with childish days. Now you're an adult. Now you have responsibility.
You're going to actually have to work for your rewards and your praise because you're not a
child anymore. So you've got to earn it with years of thankless work. I'm dead set that that's
correct interpretation. And then there's going to be a lot of experience and there's going to be a
lot of praise from peers. And I don't know exactly how that works. Notes and observations. All
nations were like children, I think he's getting at, but then the industrial revolution happened
and the whole, well not the whole world, but countries with factories changed. They grew up.
And this was the idea of the social darwinistic people, that those countries with factories
adapted to the new world and they grew up. And now it's time for them to take responsibility
for humanity because they're the adults in the world. Social darwinistic. And then the adult
responsibilities is hard work. Once you do grow up, you have to take on the burden of responsibility.
But with it comes judgment of a job well done. Earned praise and earned rewards. So basically
he's saying grow up and start changing the world. So here's our wrap-up. In my opinion, basically the
poem sets up a scenario that it's time for the industrial cultures to take cultural control of
the world and spread their culture. Sets up a moral excuse for taking over. And that excuse
is helping others. Helping other cultures. He's not going to say Great Britain's taking over for
the money. He's not going to write a poem about that. You know, people who responded to him
wrote poems about imperialists taking over for the money. That was the argument against Kipling
that it was all for the money. He makes the argument that it's all for the good of helping
others, whether they want it or not. He recognizes that those in the colonies probably won't want it
and will not be happy with the takeover. And he reinforces the idea that the industrial cultures
are superior in the culture and the colony cultures are considered inferior social darwinism.
Now, because it's a skill we teach, I'm going to detect some bias in this poem.
Well, some of the biggest bias, the one-sidedness of it, he leaves out the other causes of imperialism.
And I would argue the real cause of imperialism, economic gain and empire glory, having the glory
of an empire, I think those two are really the reason that imperialism happened. And the idea
of helping a civilization is tertiary, third, or just an excuse made up to hide the fact that it's
really about the money and the glory. So that means it's biased. He's leaving out other causes.
The unbelievably large amount of negative stereotype words describing whole groups of
people, basically everyone who's not British, the just negative stereotypes, just the whole,
that's incredibly biased, one side. And it's not by accident because he gives all the positive
stereotypes to the imperializers. So he's one-sided argument there. Hyperbole, exaggeration is all
over the place. And he leaves out any arguments of why not to imperialize. He's making this whole
poem of why they should imperialize. And he doesn't have any arguments of why imperialized
imperialization is bad. And there's plenty of people in 1900 who are arguing imperialism is
bad. So this is a one-sided poem, only the good about imperialism and because it's one-sided,
biased. So what was the poem's reception at the time? Well, I don't have the percentage of people
who liked it, the percentage of people who didn't like it, but I know there were all sides. Fans of
imperialism did like it. They used it as a moral reason to go imperializing. It's much better to
say you're doing it to help somebody than you're doing it to make money off of somebody. So the
fans of imperialism liked it. But remember, there was plenty, plenty of anti-imperialists that
didn't like it. I mean, a very, a very quick look can find four to five rebuttal essays,
rebuttal poems, or rebuttal essays directly responding to Kipling in the negative saying
he's wrong. And they were by prominent figures. I mean, famous people at the time published in
famous papers and magazines. So it was a very public rebuttal of Kipling and there was public
support. If GMU is to be believed, George Mason University, Teddy Roosevelt kind of liked his
ideas of imperialism. Can we judge this poem by today's standards? I guess that should be
in reception today, right? Yes and no. We can judge it a little. So sometimes you look back
at a poem and say, well, that's just what everybody thought at the time. So it's tough to judge the
person because everyone was thinking it. That is not the case. There was a moral debate in 1899.
There were people who said imperialism is wrong. There are people that called for the equality
of cultures and the equality of different people from different nations. Okay. There is,
there is religious theory at the time that everyone was the child of God. There was
enlightenment ideas that people are born equal. There are people voicing the opinion of equality
and not these racist stereotypes. So we can judge Kipling a little because he had a real choice.
People in 1899 had a real choice. There was the choice to be anti-imperialist and the choice to
be imperialist. So people made conscious choices to take over other countries. There was the option,
there was the thought, there were people working to say no to imperialism and to promote equality.
So what are the numbers and the percentages of imperialist versus anti-imperialist? I don't know,
but I do know Kipling, Cecil Rhodes and Kipling and all the other pro-imperialists were educated
enough to know the arguments against imperialism and they chose to still support it. So we can
judge a little bit and we can say that even for the time, even for the time this poem was a little
over the top, a little bit really pushing the edge even for its time. So we can judge that.
What would this poem have as a reception today? It is very, very simple. This would be seen as a wholly
racist poem. It would not be published in serious journals. It would not be given awards. It would
not be accepted by the literature community. It would not be accepted by political scientists as
even an idea that we would be looking at. It would not be accepted by social scientists.
The world has changed a hundred percent in the other direction from this poem in 120 years.
Further, the main idea, so not only would the words and the implications of different cultures
be totally rejected, the main ideas of cultural superiority and forced help and civilizing
missions and taking over other countries are ideas rejected by the world nations today.
The world nations come together in something called the United Nations and the United Nations
and the nations that make up that group have rejected taking over other countries, the idea
of cultural superiority, and the idea of forced help and forced change of culture. Those three
ideas found in this poem are 100 rejected by the countries of the world today. And so that leaves
Rudyard Kipling's poem, The White Man's Burden, as a historical source non-relevant to the world
today used only as an insight as to the thinking of some imperialists at the turn of the 20th
century. All right, thanks for watching!
