🇫🇷 French SYRAH vs Australian SHIRAZ 🇦🇺

Review Wine
59 followers
Syrah and Shiraz are actually the same red grape variety.
It's most commonly known as Syrah all over the world,
although you'll find in South Africa and Australia
it named Shiraz.
Syrah is the fifth or sixth most planted
red grape variety in the world, depending on the sources.
It's a very noble grape variety,
although it doesn't have the cachet
as Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Pinot Noir.
It's really unfortunate.
Even in California, where there's some beautiful Syrahs,
a lot of producers say they can't even move Syrah,
and I noticed that you get some excellent wines
that if they were Cabernet Sauvignon,
they'd be three, four times as much.
Syrah is one of those grape varieties
that once you get addicted to the flavors,
you just get really hooked on it.
Its home is the Rhone in France.
There was a debate for a long time
if it was from Shiraz in Persia,
what is now modern day Iran,
which at the time was producing
some of the most renowned wines in the world.
Obviously not these days.
There are other legends that said
it originated in Syracuse in Sicily,
which I've been there, it's a beautiful town, by the way.
But we now know it's from the Rhone.
The most coveted examples are from the Northern Rhone,
places like Hermitage, Cote Rotie,
Saint Joseph, Cornas, Croze Hermitage.
Those are the most coveted appellations
in the Northern Rhone.
The grape was brought to Australia in 1832 by James Busby.
Australia kind of adopted it.
Don't quote me on this exactly.
I think I saw somewhere that 50% of the world's Shiraz
in France and 20% of it is in Australia.
In Australia, it's the leading planted grape variety.
However, that's not the origins of the term Shiraz.
The late, great Paul Lukacs wrote a book
called Inventing Wine, which I recommend to everybody
if you're a wine geek, well researched.
And he noted that it was actually called Shiraz
in South Africa before Australia, which makes sense.
Grape vines came to Australia in the early 17th century.
Shiraz obviously came to Australia
in the early 19th century.
It's not only in that book.
I remember one time I was at a wine writer's symposium
at Napa Valley and that quiz question came up
and my group was the only group that got it right
because I said South Africa instead of Australia.
Shiraz can be made in a variety of different styles
in the Northern Rhone, which we have one here today.
It can be more peppery, meatier, more savory.
Yes, you can have black fruit flavors,
but I find sometimes it can go to red raspberry.
It can even go to more sour cherry type flavors,
which I absolutely crave.
When you go down to Australia,
they're gonna be less tannins.
They still gonna have some meatiness,
but really a lot of blackberry, black plum,
peppery fruit flavors.
It is full-bodied.
Generally, Australians like their wines
with a little bit less tannin,
a little more round, creamy mouthfeel.
Whereas I find the Northern Rhone Shiraz
to have a little bit more of a chewy tannin type texture.
You have wines like Hermitage, Colt Roti,
some of the rarest Shiraz that are really tough,
need a lot of bottle age.
I, in fact, have a Shiraz video coming up
where I have 10 different Shiraz from all around the world.
I'm gonna blind taste them.
But here today, I have some extra ones.
I have one from the Northern Rhone
and I have one from Australia.
I'm pumped to do this tasting.
Let's get it.
Tasting out of my Riedel 002 Red Wine Glass.
I love this glass.
It's a multi-purpose red wine glass,
but it really has the shape of a more Shiraz glass.
Riedel makes a Shiraz glass as well.
That's why I'm gonna use it for this.
It's not inexpensive, but it's not expensive.
It's worth checking out.
I'll leave a link in the description box.
I'm trying to make my videos more friendly to you.
So let's start from this side and move our way over.
As always, I Coravin these
and then had somebody mix them up for me.
I do know what the wines are beforehand.
There is a big difference in style
between French Syrah and Australian Shiraz.
So I think it's gonna be pretty easy to spot the difference,
but we'll see.
We'll see.
Let's start with wine one.
Syrah, Shiraz can also have some violet notes,
which I get out of this.
This is leathery.
This is black raspberry.
This is peppery, which I like.
This smells really, really, really good.
Oh, Syrah, when you get great Syrah,
when you get the leather peppery notes,
it's just amazing that wines can taste like that.
And the palate, oh, it's a good one.
I thought it was more Syrah-y, but it's creamy.
Low amount of tans.
The fruit is really intense.
This is the type of wine that I think
everybody's gonna love.
This is a hell of a wine.
That's a good wine.
Let's move on to wine two here.
Two has a lot of menthol type of notes.
I usually associate menthol and red wines
to come from Australia, so that might be the case here.
Tons of menthol.
Black pepper, black cherry, black raspberry.
The fruit profiles are quite similar actually,
but I do think this is Shiraz.
Has a little bit of leatheriness,
but this is a little different on the palate.
Lots of blueberry fruit type flavors.
It's more full body.
Tannins are a tad softer,
although these tannins are soft too.
These wines in terms of complexity,
length are extremely similar.
I think it's really just gonna be towards your style.
Fruity, a little friendlier, but still complex.
This one's just a tad savory.
That's why I think I like it more.
You ready for the reveal?
These are two excellent wines.
I mean, super highly scored.
I wanted to do this video about some of the differences
you're gonna find, although what I think
is the Australian Shiraz, which is wine number two here,
it's not as fruity and big and loud
as a lot of Australian Shiraz's that you expect.
I knew what these wines were beforehand
and they're not super expensive, but they're not cheap.
They're really good wines.
I'm gonna go 93, 93 plus.
I mean, it's that close.
It's just preference.
Wine two, I think it's definitely Australian.
The menthol note, that's what really sets it apart for me.
We'll see.
Oh, I can feel the screw cap coming.
This is the Clonakilla 2021 Oriada Shiraz
from Canberra District.
Canberra's the capital of Australia.
It's its own district.
This comes in at 49 bucks.
This is an exceptional producer.
The Clonakilla Shiraz Bionier
is one of the greatest Australian wines I've ever tasted.
Actually showed up in my Australian Shiraz video.
Did super, super well.
I think this is delicious.
The menthol note, it stood out, 49 bucks.
I think this is a really good wine.
You're kind of getting what you pay for.
And this is the type of wine ready to drink now,
but man, I'd like to see it with five,
six years of bottle age.
I think everybody is just gonna really love that wine.
I want this with more stewed meats.
I want this with more grilled meat.
I know that Clonakilla, the founder,
was really inspired by the wines of Cote Roti,
so they wanted to make a more Rhone-style Shiraz.
And they've really,
when you taste Clonakilla Shiraz Bionier,
it's very distinctive,
as is this wine's a little more plush than Shiraz Bionier,
but it's more dialed back than a lot of Australian Shirazes.
Australian Shiraz is one of the wines
that got me hooked on the wine.
I was visiting a friend in New Zealand.
He was Australian, actually.
Going to school in New Zealand.
Used to work in a wine shop.
He was cooking me dinner.
I was traveling around the world.
He's like, Matty, do you want a wine?
I said, yeah, sure.
He opened a Margaret River Shiraz.
I still don't know what the producer was to this day.
It was a big glass,
and I remember smelling the glass
after where I was done forever.
We finished the wine really quickly,
and I wanted more.
It was so good.
Okay, Northern Rhone.
This is a 93-plus, a classic.
This is the Gigal.
This is the St. Joseph, 2019,
so it has a little age on it.
39 bucks for a wine that I think's 93-plus points.
I think it's exceptional.
Talk about Northern Rhone Shiraz Hermitage Cote Roti,
or the real rare ones.
They're right at the top.
You're also gonna have Cornas,
and then the two more value-driven appellations
are Crow's Hermitage,
which are grown more in the flat scent.
Joseph is a steep slope.
I think it's the biggest region by geography
in the Northern Rhone.
The wines are made to be a little softer,
a little more approachable when young.
I think this is an excellent wine.
Really gives you the taste of Northern Rhone.
This is exactly the type of Shiraz I wanna drink,
and this style of Shiraz being made in California,
which I really enjoy.
So tell me, do you prefer the Shiraz style
or the Shiraz style?
Bigger fruit, more savory?
I'd love to hear.
Drop it in the comments below.
