Teaching Kipling's "The White Man’s Burden" in a Postcolonialism Class

RUDYARD KIPLING
2 followers
Hello and welcome to my course on postcolonialism. I'm Masood Raja and in this brief lecture I'll be
talking about Rudyard Kipling's poem The White Man's Burden. Now the reason I start my courses
with this poem is because it's deeply important to read this poem carefully and understand the
imperial consciousness and imperial mentality and or colonial consciousness and of course the
phrase The White Man's Burden is used repeatedly in all these neo-colonial ventures and everything
else. So before I discuss this with my students in my classes we already build up a basic
understanding of postcolonial studies, an introduction to the history of scramble for Africa,
colonization of India and the Caribbean. So this kind of then becomes an example of the mentality
of a colonial poet. Now Kipling was pretty interesting. Most of his life he grew up in
India. Most of his work is set in India. His characters are Indian. You know who hasn't heard
of Mowgli the frog right or Kim from his novel Kim and he also had a deep affinity for India
but when he returns to England and in his politics he was an imperialist. He wanted
India to be part of the British Empire and that's the faction that he joins
and that's in Britain and those are his views. So it's kind of that ambiguous situation
of European orientalists and others who love the romantic aspects of India and its history
but couldn't bring themselves to love the natives themselves. That kind of quandary that Kipling
also represents. Now this poem The White Man's Burden and I'm just roughly reading an introduction
from an online source was published in 1899 and I'm just going to read and quote. In February 1899
British novelist and poet Rudyard Kipling wrote a poem entitled The White Man's Burden.
The United States and the Philippines islands in this poem Kipling urged the U.S. to take up
the burden of empire. So this is happening when 1899 that's when United States has launched its
offensive in Philippines and Kipling having realized that the British power is sort of
waning encourages America to take its role of bringing the so-called civilization to the masses
and the president the vice president Theodore Roosevelt who eventually becomes president
actually sends this poem to this one of the senators and he says and I quote it was rather
poor poetry but good sense from the expansion point of view. So if you had any doubt that poems and
novels and stories can launch empires you know here is a poem that gives you that example.
Now here is how I discuss this poem right now you know you can go into the structuralist aspects of
it formalist aspects of it but remember the main refrain in the poem the line that keeps repeated
is take up the white man burden that's where the poem starts. So if we read it stanza by stanza
here is the first beginning take up the white man's burden send forth the best you breed go
send your sons to exile to serve your captives need to wait in heavy harness on fluttered folk
and wild your new caught sullen peoples half devil and half child. Now this is fully loaded
with a kind of imperial view of the world right so the line is take up the white man's burden
right like it's offered as you know a job without any motive altruistic almost right that go take
up your job to do what first of all send the best you breed so send your best people out in the world
right to live in exile right and what to do to serve your captives needs so not live for
themselves in exile but to serve the lives of those that you have colonized and who are those
they are childlike they are sullen people right half devil and half child right so what kind of
juxtaposition is being made that the Europeans the white man right who have found these colonized
people they are altruistic they are noble they have a mission to bring light and civilization to
who to these people who are wild who are almost childlike or devilish right that's the juxtaposition
that is being set up here in this form now keep that in mind that this this way of looking at the
world is still how most North Atlantic regions justify their intrusions into the rest of the
world that we are there to bring civilization to bring light to bring development right the
natives of all these countries India Pakistan Bangladesh countries in Africa right Senegal
elsewhere they are assumed to be unmanageable they are assumed to be unintelligent and maybe
ossified in a past time right going on to the next stanza take up the white man's burden
in patience to abide to veil the threat of terror and check the show of pride by open speech and
simple and hundred times made plain to seek another's profit and work another's game
okay again there is an accentuation of the mission itself what is the mission
right you do all these things right to not be too proud and not be too violent but to seek
another's profit and work another's game that this entire project of colonization
is for the betterment of others your captives the sullen people the entire project is
for these white men for these Europeans is that we are doing a favor to you and we are doing it
at the cost of our own interest and think of it this way that's how the colonizers justified
themselves right look at Indian history I mean how do the British justify themselves we we brought
you schools we brought you the railway we brought you you know universities civilization right these
are the and the idea the way it is presented it as if it was done altruistically for India's own
good we all know that railway was built to extract Indian resources right take them to the mother
country but no this is the message that Kipling is repeating right as if colonizing is a noble
mission right and that's why I start with this poem because I think it speaks to even the
vocabularies that are used today so I'll keep reading I'll go to the next stanza here
take up the white man's burden and reap his old reward so now he's going to tell us that it's a
selfless task you're bringing civilization and profit for these people not for yourself but be
aware this is how these people will reward you right and reap his old reward the blame of those
you better the hate of those you guard the cry of hosts you humor all slowly to the light
why brought you us from bondage our loved Egyptian night okay that last two lines of course why
brought you out of bondage are a reference to Moses right here is Moses leading his people from
slavery to freedom into the desert and at a certain point after they are wandering in the
desert people basically turn on Moses and ask him you know why we had homes we had a place to sleep
why did you bring us out of there into this desert and what he's equating the colonial experience is
with that that here you are you're going to try to better these people's life but eventually they
will turn on you so also keep in mind there is a binary structure at work right the noble
Europeans have brought altruistically all this development and help to these sullen people
the people he is invoking who he thinks will reward with you know abuses and everything to
the colonizers they are essentialized they have essentialized qualities that he's invoking
there is no reference here to mutability that these people might change they are essentially
childlike they are essentially half devils and they will essentially turn against you and it
constantly then as you read these lines the white man's mission is offered as more and more noble
and altruistic which is up against these ungrateful people that they are trying to help right I'll go
to the next line take up the white man's burden have done with childish days the lightly proffered
laurel the easy ungrudged praise comes now to search your manhood through all the thankless
years cold edged with dear bought wisdom the judgment of your peers right I think this
particular part of so you know at the end is that what he's offering is that after you've done it
all after these people turn on you your venture will eventually fail because you will have to
leave and that is what makes it into a noble project right probably I think the online poem
that I was reading it skipped certain passages but overall here is the message that comes across
what is the white man's burden it's represented as an altruistic mission a civilizing mission
to go and help these people who maybe can't help themselves but that help is totally geared
towards that and these colonizers are doing it at the cost of their own health at the cost of their
own profit it's not a profitable venture it's a noble cause right and there is an understanding
that the people that these people are supposedly helping are going to turn on them but there are
no existential or material causes given for them that is essentialized as if these people are
naturally ungrateful now think of it you have watched some lectures on post-colonial theory
how does post-colonial theory come into this poem now if we didn't have post-colonial studies or
post-colonial theoretical ways of reading these texts from the point of view of the natives
this highly canonized poem could very easily be taught and read as you know the white man's
mission as being a noble mission there are so many people in the world in America in United States
Canada Australia elsewhere who actually think that what they do is a thankless job and they
are constantly helping these people in Africa and Asia India Pakistan right that's the colonizer
mentality and when those people start asking questions they feel offended as if when you go
and help someone they surrender their right to ask questions but we all know that the imperial
project the colonizing project was never about bringing light and civilization to these people
those were the ideologies that were used to normalize right the actual act of colonization
these were all capitalistic ventures military ventures here Kipling I'm pretty sure he knows
the truth but he's trying to offer a romanticized view of the mission of the white man's burden
in the white man's mission and then sending it to Americans right at the cusp when they're about to
colonize Philippine right and that teaches us something about not just the materialist material
and ideological basis of colonialism but how do poets and writers produce materials that help
build the edifice of an imperial system so I hope this was helpful this is like you know the first
lecture that I start with or first discussion of a literary text and I've already given you my
reasons and most importantly the reason is to pick up a poem which was produced during the contact
phase by an imperial poet and see how does that poem offer a representations of Europeans right
or their mission and then how can we point out the dichotomies and the essentializing of the
natives why and historically that colonialism wasn't all that about just being altruistic and
noble so that's all I have thank you so much and I'll be back with another lecture on another
primary text or a secondary text with my thoughts on it if you have any questions of course feel
free to send them my way and I'll be happy to address them and or you know any other suggestions
thank you so much and until the next time peace and love
