“This Is A Matter Of National Security” | Keir Starmer Under Fire Over China Spy Case
Oct 18, 2025 #Keirstarmer #Politicians
I sort of was taking it in as I walked into the office this morning and the more I think
about it the more ghastly it is, you know, and I can't quite understand why it's been
allowed to happen and I also can't understand why Keir Starmer has put out a tweet saying
this is the wrong decision without seemingly willing to do anything about it.
Well it's difficult isn't it, I mean I couldn't agree with you more, I mean I think it is
a terrible decision and I agree with the Prime Minister, but I mean in this country you cannot
have politicians telling the police how to police their areas. I mean that would be crossing a line.
Well I would say I take that point, on the other hand however you would have to say
you don't want to interfere with the police and their operational command, however if their
operational command is coming up with such ridiculous ideas and ridiculous sort of decisions
then surely you have to correct them.
Well yeah, but I mean if this was something that you and I didn't agree with and the Prime
Minister was instructing the police as to what to do then that would be wrong wouldn't it.
Well I can't imagine what that would be though.
It's a difficult track for the Prime Minister to walk and I imagine that talks are going on
behind the scenes at the moment, I mean it's interesting I don't think we've heard from the
Home Secretary on this.
We haven't.
So I think this should be resolved today, I mean I think the police will realise they've
made a mistake and Birmingham Council I think, and I think the Prime Minister has made his view
absolutely clear, he can't intervene directly, he can't order the police about, but I think the right...
But the Home Secretary can because we've had this conversation before about the Palestinian
protests, the pro-Palestinian protests, that you know if the police were to come to the Home
Secretary and ask the Home Secretary to make a ruling the Home Secretary is empowered to do that.
That's right but the police have to ask, that's the catch-22 isn't it.
Yeah but if the police want to get themselves out of shtuk which is where they are right now
because I'm not absolutely sure what it is that they're saying is dangerous, I mean are they
saying that it's not safe for Jewish people to walk the streets of Birmingham, is that what they're saying?
Well no, I mean the thing is that Tel Aviv fans have a reputation for
how shall we put it, football hooliganism. Also Millwall, but they don't get banned.
Exactly, I mean that's why it's wrong, but I mean that's the
grounds on which the police have made their decision. Yeah but also the grounds
which I suspect they're basing that on is there was an incident in Amsterdam some months ago
at which Tel Aviv fans were said to have been committing acts of hooliganism but in fact it
wasn't that they were committing acts of hooliganism, it was the fact that there was a whole bunch of
football fans, as often is the case in Holland, having sort of various punch-ups around the town
because that's what they do. Well exactly and that's what British football
fans used to be like and the police ought to be able to cope with that kind of
situation. No, I mean that's why I think it's the wrong decision and I hope it'll be reversed.
And also the situation that I think I'm right in saying the police have described is
one which is about safety, right, but they're not saying whose safety, I mean whose safety
are they protecting exactly? Well exactly, I mean what they're saying is we don't
want to have to deal with clashes between rival groups, I mean you'll have
the Tel Aviv fans and you'll have some anti-Semitic...
I've got some bad news for the police in Birmingham, you know, because when Birmingham play Aston Villa
there's going to be some trouble as well, they're going to ban people from that.
Yeah, quite. You know what I mean, it's a bit like I've woken up from a coma and gone oh my goodness
Yeah, well I mean they do it a lot less nowadays and it's one of the great success stories that
hasn't been... Yeah but it still happens, I mean I can tell you because I live not very far from
Millwall's base and every time a Millwall play at home there is a section of Millwall fans
who arrange and they do it on a very sort of efficient basis, arrange on social media for a
place around the back of Surrey Quay's shopping centre to have a punch-up with whoever's having
to come and play them. Yeah, no I mean... It still happens. Yeah, the police decision was the
wrong decision and Prime Minister was right and I hope it gets sorted out. Yeah, let's hope so. So
you're optimistic are you that you think that this will be done and dusted by the end of the day?
Well I think it'd be really embarrassing if this is allowed to stand. Well I mean all I would say
is that given what's happened in the past, for example last weekend when in the aftermath of
the Manchester synagogue stabbing, Keir Starmer and Shabana Mahmood sort of urged people not to march
around in London because it might be a bit insensitive. Nobody paid any attention, they marched
around in London anyway and that was all they said and they just let it go on. Yeah but I mean again
because you know there are limits to what our politicians can do.
Quite rightly, we don't want our politicians to be able to ban marches just like that.
No but I think they have banned marches in the past and we know there is a precedent for it and it
doesn't mean that they're banning every march, it doesn't mean that they're going to ban
marches for no particular reason but on this particular occasion they could have, if they
wanted to, stopped it from going ahead. They chose not to. No I don't think they could, I think they
had because... Well there have been bans on marches before though, you know that. No but the police
have to request, the police have to say that they think there's a, I've forgotten what the
wording is, a serious risk. Well they've used the word unrest in the Birmingham case haven't they?
Right and the police have to ask the Home Secretary to ban it and on that occasion they
didn't. Well the police won't ask anybody to ban a Palestinian march because they're in favour of it
aren't they? The woke police, I mean if it was a far-right march I'm sure
they would manage to find a reason to ban it. Well I'm not quite sure about that. Well they
banned an EDL march I think in 2014. Yeah but you know they don't always get it right and...
You say that again. I mean they very rarely get it right it seems to me. Should we talk about
China because here's a story that you can get your teeth into. Let's play you a couple of clips.
Is Keir Starmer admitting that there was a meeting that previously had been denied? Here we go from
meeting in September. That did not involve the National Security Advisor discussing the evidence
in any way nor Mr Speaker one further piece of evidence. The final statement in this case
was submitted in August 2025. There was no further submission of evidence one way or the other after
any discussion in September. This is a red herring, a completely scurrilous allegation made by the
opposition. Now he may say that but I'm not sure that's entirely correct because of course
this is the same meeting that was denied by Dan Jarvis on Monday ever taking place. He's now
saying yeah there was a meeting but we didn't talk about China but it was about China but we
didn't talk about it. Well no but the point that he was making there was that it was out it was
after the last submission to the court so that meeting cannot have had any bearing
on the collapse of the court case unless it was to discuss you know giving further
material to the court in which case but I mean he says he says it wasn't so. Yeah but you're
not going to dissuade that are you? I mean you are a journalist John. I mean even you must admit that
he's in trouble on this isn't he? No no no I don't. You don't think so? All right we'll have a look at
this clip. This is Kemi Badenock asking him why Deputy National Security Advisor Matthew Collins
acted all of his own. On Monday the security minister repeatedly told the house that ministers
did not take decisions, that it was the Deputy National Security Advisor who had full freedom.
Is the government seriously saying that only one man, the Deputy National Security Advisor,
had anything to do with this failure? Is he seriously saying that the deputy did not discuss
with the National Security Advisor, did not discuss with the Home Secretary or with anyone
in Downing Street? Is the Prime Minister seriously saying that? Yes. Yeah I mean I've got some
swampland in Florida to sell you as well by the way if you believe that because you know it's just
not credible is it? It was a slightly surprising answer. I thought Kemi Badenock did
it extremely well. I thought so. She couldn't quite sort of break through the Prime Minister's
defences although the point, what was really significant was immediately after saying yes
to that list of questions, the Prime Minister then said I'll have to double check, I'll double
check this. Right. Which is unusual for the Prime Minister at the dispatch box to admit that he's
not quite sure if he's... I think it may be the first time he's ever done it. I think it's the
first time he's ever done that because when I had Kemi Badenock sitting in this very studio
and I said to her why does he not answer your questions when you're in Parliament and when
you're asking the Prime Minister's questions, she said I think it's quite often because he doesn't
know the answer actually because I think and I wonder if that's true because he you know he does
seem to be somebody who is not across all of the detail despite the fact of his legal background.
He quite often comes across as a guy who doesn't know the detail. Well except on this on this case
I think he has been briefed up to the eyeballs and... Well he has now but he's claiming he wasn't
before which is even more ridiculous because this is a matter of national security, two people
you know and the Speaker of the House was pretty worked up about this the other day,
two individuals inside the Houses of Parliament spying for China right and yet you're telling
me that the Prime Minister isn't informed about every single step of that prosecution?
But the question is whether whether he was involved in collapsing the prosecution. Yes
yeah but surely if he's involved in in what's going on with the prosecution he must have known
what was going on around the prosecution. No but the question is whether he interfered in the in
the court case. Yes. And that is I mean this all sort of goes back to what we were talking about
before with the police. It would be quite wrong for politicians to to get involved in court cases
like that and put pressure on the Crown Prosecution Service to drop the charges. Yeah but that's not
what they did. He used to run the Crown Prosecution Service. Yeah but he's exactly right and yet he
doesn't want to cooperate with them because what we know. No but the allegation that that that Kemi
Kemi Badenoch is making is that he interfered, he put pressure on the Crown Prosecution Service.
Well no he didn't need to put pressure on them he just made sure that the person who was briefing
them from Downing Street, Matthew Collins, didn't give them the information they required. He didn't
they didn't ask them to collapse the prosecution all he did was not give them the information which
would suggest that China was a threat. And if you don't say China's a threat but what he did
manage to do was to put something from the Labour Manifesto into the message that was sent to the
Prosecution Service and that was written supposedly by a completely independent and neutral civil
servant. How did he end up quoting from the Labour Manifesto? Well because well Mike I mean the Labour
Manifesto is government policy if if Labour are then elected at a general election. Oh is it?
Really? Yeah. I thought they said that we're going to have strong... That's how democracy works Mike.
You put your programme to the people and if people vote for it they put you in government. Let me just
remind myself let me just remind myself of some of the things that they said in their manifesto
like for example um a country first party second I think that was in there somewhere wasn't it and
you know he says that quite often yeah and he does say that quite often but he doesn't mean it
he also said I think what was the other thing? You disagree with it? Well it's not a question of
disagreeing with it he clearly doesn't put the country first he puts the party first and he puts
himself first and then of course we're going to have a transparent government weren't we
um but we don't seem to have had much of that either there's plenty of things I can quote from
the manifesto uh which are not government policy and to say that that's the reason it made its way
into a document presented by a civil servant who's meant to be neutral is ridiculous. No it's not
that is actually how our system works I mean there are all sorts of uh things that were in
the manifesto to do with uh to do with tax uh that uh that the government has not stuck to but then
uh that's a that's a separate argument uh well true um I'm going to be speaking to Dan Hodges
a little bit later on in the show um and his version of what this story is is completely
different to yours and I don't know whether you know he's gone a little bit he's gone a little
bit over the top I think on that I'd be interested to hear what he has to say well I'll put that to
him but I mean he basically was saying yesterday that this you know ridiculous farrago of lies
effectively and I'm paraphrasing here um is completely and utterly unbelievable and it can't
surely it cannot stand uh the the scrutiny that it will inevitably have to come under
because nobody believes a word that he says um yeah he's basically said uh that you know
Labour have got no way of keeping this house of holding this line I'm just trying to find it
uh as I as I talk to you he does he does tend to use I mean that Dan's a a good friend of mine
but he does tend to use the L word uh which I I disapprove of in politics uh and especially
even though they're all they're all liars I mean I I actually said especially if they're all liars
because you know you you know it's it's it's no way to conduct politics is to to well let me read
you I found you the the line that I want from the government story has changed a number of
times over the China case I suspect that within the next 24 hours it will have been forced to
admit that Powell was involved in the process the idea that Collins acted unilaterally is now
so untenable I don't believe number 10 can hold the line well we'll see about that I'm not sure
that's right but you differ you one thing that you don't agree with that no the one thing that
Keir Starmer does know about is how is is is how the Crown Prosecution Service works and how
how cases like this how the government has to behave in cases like this they put the Prime
Minister and Ministers and Special Advisors are not are not allowed to put pressure on the Crown
Prosecution Service yes but that's a bit like saying but that's a bit like saying you're not
allowed to go over the speed limit John people do it you think the government doesn't interfere
I mean you'd have to be a man that I could sell as I say Swampland in Florida to if that's what
you really believe because of course there's a rule that says you can't do it doesn't mean it
doesn't happen well yeah but I mean I think it is it is embarrassing for the government that this
this case collapsed I'm not sure that that's what they wanted to happen although on the other hand
they don't want to upset the uh the Chinese the Chinese I think that's the key isn't it I think
that's the bottom line they don't want to upset the Chinese government and I think they've got
it wrong and I think you know understand that it's a delicate balance and you have to you know
do trade with them and you have to do business with them and you have to borrow money from them
and you have to sell things to them and buy things from them all of that but you know they should be
a bit more grown up you're sounding like a pragmatic Blairite all of a sudden like well
listen I've always been pragmatic John you know that this is progress yeah no but I mean I think
that all that is right I mean you know Keir Starber is is is trying to uh is trying to
be tough with the with with the Chinese on on spying but to maintain good relations with them
and they'd say it's sometimes a slightly tricky balance it's a bit like my relationship with
it's a bit like my relationship with Downing Street you know um I'm going to tell you a story
in a minute but carry on sorry no but I do think we need to take one more one more further step
back on this and and ask whether this case should ever have been brought in the first place because
I mean one of the things we saw in in Matthew Collins's uh witness statement is some some of
the things that these these so-called alleged spies are accused of um were you know like passing
on passing on incorrect predictions that Tom Tugendhat was going to be promoted to the cabinet
or that Jeremy uh Jeremy Hunt was going to support his leadership bid I mean this is this is I mean
the Chinese are obviously interested in Tom Tugendhat because he's particularly vocal critic
of China well he's one of the people I think who's been sanctioned by them isn't he yeah
absolutely but you know making wrong predictions about Tom Tugendhat's career is not what most
people would call spying no but that may not necessarily be what they were doing that may
just be what we found out that they were doing but they might have been doing some other terrible
things I mean look at the picture on the front pages of the Telegraph and the the Mail today
um you know that ghastly individual um uh who's got nothing but his own interest at heart nothing
to do with Britain uh Prince Andrew uh is meeting up with a Chinese spy boss I mean you know imagine
they've got no shame at all these people even pictures done with Prince Andrew absolutely
shocking anyway listen I'm going to tell you a story about Downing Street complaining about me
in a minute uh and the and the L word that you don't like

