BRRRR for Beginners: How to Do It With Little Money Episode #622

Business and Beyond
6 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 15, 2025
Welcome to another Rookie Reply, where Ashely Kehr and Tony J. Robinson answer questions from the BiggerPockets Forums and Real Estate Rookie Facebook group.
This time, we’re covering questions like:
A more beginner-friendly BRRRR method for those without six figures
Strategies to lower your premiums so your insurance bills stay reasonable
The “lazy” method experts use to increase rents
Have you ever heard of the BRRRR strategy? It's the real estate investing method that
actually scales your portfolio and fast. But what if you don't have the cash to complete it?
There's a more beginner-friendly BRRRR method for those without six figures,
and we're about to share it with you. But after you BRRRR for the first time,
chances are you'll be paying today's sky-high home insurance costs. But don't worry,
we've got some solutions to lower your insurance premium so your bill stays reasonable.
Finally, we're going to share the lazy method experts use to increase rents. It's so genius
that your tenants may even ask you to raise rents on their behalf. Once you hear about it,
you'll use it on every rental. This is the Real Estate Rookie Podcast. I'm Ashley Kerr.
And I'm Tony J. Robinson. And if this video gets 100 comments,
I'll finally share my nighttime skincare routine with all of you who've been asking.
Does it involve cucumbers?
It absolutely does not. So with that, let's go on to today's first question.
All right, so our first question today comes from Reese. And Reese says,
I've heard that the BRRRR strategy is dead. And just really quickly for those that don't know,
BRRRR stands for buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat. But Reese says, I've heard that the BRRRR
strategy is dead unless you have huge capital, like a minimum of $50,000 to $80,000 to start.
So if a new investor has $25,000 to $30,000, is there a way to pool this with a small group of
other investors to do a BRRRR deal together, almost like a small syndication? For example,
if there was a property that was $100,000 and it needed $60,000 in rehab, the amount needed
would be $160,000 in total. If there were five investors each putting in $32,000,
that would give us a $160,000. Then after repairs, we sell that property for $240,000.
Each investor would get a return of $40,000. Then after repairs, we sell the property for $240,000.
That will be a $48,000 profit, giving each investor $16,000 in profit, and then we just
repeat that process. Is this the strategy that some investors use? If so, where would I find
them? Once I built up capital and learned the process, I could then do it by myself,
but I think working with a small group of people might be the less risky way doing my first few
deals. All right, so there's a couple of questions in here, and I think something that I want to
clarify. The initial question talks about the BRRRR strategy, but then you talk about going
to sell this property for a profit, which would be flipping. In a traditional BRRRR,
you're keeping that property as a long-term buy-and-hold asset. You're going to buy it,
renovate it, refinance, get all your capital back, rent the property out, and then take the money
that you got from the refinance and recycle that into your next deal. It sounds like what you're
saying here is just buying a property in all cash, renovating it in all cash, and selling
that property as a flip, which is also fine, but it's just not the BRRRR strategy. When we talk
about BRRRR, it's about holding that property as a long-term asset. Yeah, so instead of selling
the property, you would refinance the property, and the goal would be to refinance it however
high you could. Most banks will lend on 80% or 75% of the value, the appraised value of the home,
so you would need it to appraise for more than what you actually put into it to get all of your
money back. That's one difference with the BRRRR, is you're actually refinancing because you have
rented out the property. In this, if you're going to sell the property, you probably don't want to
rent it out before you actually sell it, unless this is specifically maybe a duplex or something
like that, where it is a rental property and not a single family, because you're really going to
limit your buyer pool. If you have somebody in there that's on a one-year lease and they can't
move into it as their primary residence upon purchasing it. The first thing I thought of in
here is, first of all, there's laws and rules and regulations against investing and pooling your
money together. If you were to get five investors, each investor would need to be active in the deal,
where they would need to have some kind of job, some kind of role to actually be part of the deal.
Four of these are just passive investors. They're giving you your money and then you're investing.
They need to be active in the deal. Maybe one's doing the bookkeeping, maybe one's managing the
contract or whatever that may be. I see this as a headache, as to now you have five people,
five opinions, all saying how this deal should be done. If you were going to do this, have this
many partners, I would make sure it is very, very clear as to whose each person's roles and
responsibilities are and who has say and how decisions will be determined. Is it upon a vote
because you have an odd number? How would that work? Just be very clear with having five different
people making these decisions. With this, I think you have many different options to actually do
this deal instead of taking on five partners or four partners if you're the fifth and just giving
equity to them and they're putting their cash in. There's different ways to partner without
actually having to put equity in the deal. Yeah. Lending I think would be a great option,
but just really quickly going back to your point, Ash, about the different roles and
responsibilities that folks would have to play. One way, I agree, the idea of five people all
being equally invested from a time perspective into a deal sounds terrible to me, too many cooks
in the kitchen. But I think one way to navigate that is in your operating agreement for your LLC,
you can just designate that there are certain major decisions that you guys have to vote on
as a group. Maybe it's the listing price. Maybe it's the selection of a general contractor.
Maybe it's the selecting of a listing agent. If there are any seller credits, if you guys were
to go and sell this property, those are the things you guys have to discuss. Any material changes to
the scope of work above a certain dollar amount would require a group vote. But anything outside
of those, maybe you can delegate to one person and say, hey, Tony's going to be the point person
on everything else except for these core decisions that we all need to focus on or to agree on
together. For our hotel, that's how we did it, where we have partners who brought the majority
of the capital. They're not interviewing cleaners. We've gone through six onsite managers. Our
partners haven't talked to any of those onsite managers. But if we were to sell refinance or
other major decisions, that's where they're able to come into play. Obviously, Ash and I are not
attorneys, so go talk to an attorney. Talk to a syndication attorney specifically. I think they
might have the most insight into what works and what doesn't. But going back to your other point,
Ash, about it doesn't have to be an equity partnership. Maybe you don't even need to
partner at all. In your example, you mentioned $32,000 from each investor. Could you maybe save
a little bit more and do this deal by yourself? If we use those same numbers on $160,000 in total
costs for your renovation and your rehab, call it 20% down. What is 20% of $32,000? Maybe tack on
another five-ish percent just for working capital. You're at $40,000, give or take.
If you've already got $32,000, could you get another $8,000 to $10,000 and then you can go
out and maybe get a hard money loan where they're going to cover the other 80% of what you need to
do this deal? I don't necessarily think that maybe it's even necessary because you're pretty close
at the numbers you're talking about with just being able to go out and get some hard money.
Yeah. One thing he says in here too is that BRRRR is pretty much dead unless you have
huge capital. The only way that really makes sense is if you're leaving money into the deal.
If you're putting a lot of money down, then you're doing the BRRRR deal. When you go and refinance
and you don't need to pull all your money back out, then yeah, the deal is more likely to work.
Anytime you put more cash into the deal, you're more likely to get better cash flow on the deal.
But it doesn't mean your cash on cash return is actually going to be better on the deal too.
I think there's a little confusion here as to like BRRRR is dead unless you have huge capital
because even if you're putting in, the numbers are the same on the deal. Even if you infuse
more cash into it, it's just going to change what your cash on cash return is on the deal.
It's not going to change the other numbers on the deal, such as the purchase price, such as
what you can rent it out for, for what the appraised value is. Those are all factors that
don't come into play if you're just changing how much cash you're putting into the deal.
You want to look at the overall numbers because Tony and I could purchase the same property
and say it's $100,000 and I put in $20,000 and he says, well, I want the deal to work,
so I'm going to put in $50,000. He's saying this deal, it's not going to be dead. This BRRRR isn't
dead because I'm putting more capital into it. And yes, okay, his cash flow is going to be more
because he has a lower mortgage payment because he only had debt of 50,000. For me, I have debt
of 80,000 and I have a higher mortgage payment, so my cash flow will be less. But there are other
metrics to actually analyze what's a good deal. And one of those is the cash on cash return.
What else could Tony be doing with that $50,000 that's actually generating more income from him
than that cash flow from that one property? So I just want to make sure that you guys know that
infusing cash into your deal doesn't always make it a better deal. There's more metrics to look at
than just cash flow on a property. Yeah. I think the last thing to add to that, Ash,
is just circling back to what you said earlier about private money lending versus equity
partnerships. And if you've got four other people who are interested in investing in real estate,
but don't want to do it themselves, don't have the cash, could you pull from some combination
of those folks, all of those resources, those capital resources, and they're just now private
money lenders for you to be able to go out and do flips or burrs yourself. And now you've got
100K that you can go out and redeploy over and over and over again to help you build your own
portfolio. And then they're happy because they're getting a nice fixed return on the capital that
they're lending out to you. So I don't think that a partnership with five people is the only
possible route. It is a route, but I don't think it's the only route that you should consider.
Today's show is sponsored by Baseline. They say real estate investing is passive,
but let's get real. Chasing rents, drowning in receipts, and getting buried in spreadsheets
feels anything but passive. If you're tired of losing valuable hours on financial busy work,
I've found a solution that will transform your business. It's Baseline, a trusted BP Pro partner.
Baseline is an all-in-one platform that can help you automate the day-to-day. It automates your
rent collection and uses AI-powered bookkeeping to auto-tag transactions for instant cashflow,
visibility, and reporting. Plus, they have tons of other features like recurring payments,
multi-user access, and free wires to save you more time and money. Spend less managing your money
and more time growing your portfolio. Ready to automate the busy work and get back to investing?
Baseline is giving BiggerPockets listeners an exclusive $100 bonus when you sign up at
baseline.com. Our next question comes from Sam in the BP forums. It's 2024 and I received a
renewal notice on two single-family home properties with a 33% and 28% increase,
respectively, without any claims over the life of the policy period. This is after a double-digit
percentage increase last year. The only two options if I want to hang on to these properties are
increase the deductible, change carriers to a lesser reputable carrier,
is there anything I am missing, and how are you coping?
One of the short-term rental policies was quoted and it was double what my current insurance policy
is. They both have completely different things that they're each covering. It's not even like,
oh, this one has it all, this one is missing some of it. They're like two completely different
things. I'm also in the midst of trying to figure out what insurance I actually need and
if it's even worth increasing my deductible at this point.
Shopping for insurance is not easy. Like you said, there's a lot of language and caveats
and carve-outs. Unless you spend a lot of time talking to your insurance agent or broker,
I think it is sometimes hard to understand what you need and what you don't need. But
I think in general, we're seeing rising insurance costs as a more common reason that deals aren't
penciling out, especially in certain parts of the country. If you guys have been around the
podcast for a longer period of time, you'll remember my property back in Shreveport.
The reason that we ended up needing to sell that property was because the insurance premiums like
4X'd from one year to the next. We shopped it around and every insurance provider that we
gave us roughly the same quote. Nothing had happened. It was our flood insurance. There
was no flood. Nothing had happened. The property didn't flood. There was no flooding in and around
that area. But for whatever reason, the premiums went up and we made the decision to sell the
property. But I think between the floods, the hurricanes, the wildfires in California,
insurance is just more risky for the providers. I think as we talk about scaling our portfolio or
understanding where to start investing, insurance just simply has to be part of that conversation
in a way that maybe it wasn't five or six or seven years ago because it is rising and there's just
not a lot of options, unfortunately. I bought this property. I ended up buying it, but I had
talked to the seller before I purchased it and I asked how much he paid in insurance every year.
He said he was self-insured. He said that he owned the property free and clear. I was literally
buying it for $37,000. He's like, I self-insure. If something happens to the property,
I'm going to come out of pocket and pay for it. Or whatever's left of the property,
if it burns down, then I'll just pay to have the lot demoed and I'll sell the lot because the lot
is worth probably as much as the house was, which was pretty much true at that point.
I think about that as to is there going to be a point in time where people do just decide to
self-insure? Banks and lenders aren't going to allow you to do that. They're going to want you
to have a policy in place and to be listed on the policy. But if you own a property free and clear,
I wonder if there is going to be a transition of people who are just going to say, hey,
instead of sending my premiums in every year to this insurance company, I'm just going to
keep funneling this high yield interest savings account and that is going to be my insurance
policy. Then just getting liability coverage on the property and not actual property coverage
for that. I don't know. It would be interesting to see the data on that as to how many people
are actually self-insuring the physical property. I think, Ash, maybe if we hit on just what can
this person actually do in their situation? Because it is a tough spot to be in. They brought
up two options. It's increasing the deductible, which is an option. Just for folks who maybe
aren't super familiar, your deductible is what you would pay in case there were a claim. You can
increase or decrease your deductible and that'll have an impact on what your actual
insurance costs are. Typically, a higher deductible would lead to a lower payment
and the inverse would be true where a lower deductible would lead to a higher payment.
This person is saying that if they increase their deductible, the actual monthly cost or the annual
premium would go down, which is an option, or changing carriers, which yeah, different carriers
offer different options at different costs. I think maybe just taking a step back,
one of the things that I would do is just shop around and not necessarily looking for a
budget or lesser reputable, quote unquote, insurance carrier, but if you go talk to an
insurance broker and give them your profile, your property's profile, and let them go shop around to
a bunch of different carriers, I think that in and of itself would give you a better idea of,
hey, let me get some apples, apples quotes on the coverage amounts, the deductibles,
what's included, what's not. Maybe it is a case where every person that we go talk to,
they're within five or 10% of each other. That's what it was for us, and that was a sign that,
like, hey, there's no way around these new costs, so our best option here is to sell,
and maybe that's the same conclusion you come to, or maybe you go to a different carrier and you
find that, hey, for pretty much the same coverage, we can cut our premium costs by 25% or 30% and
undo this increase that we're seeing, but I don't think you'll really know until you shop it around
to quite a few different options. All right, Tony, I just pulled up an example of a quote I just got
that shows the deductible options and then what the premium would change to, so for $1,000
deductible, the total cost would be $3,300. For a $5,000 deductible, it would be $2,800,
but it also, it goes up then all the way up to $50,000 deductible and a cost of $2,136.
I bought this property for $15,000, but I mean, I renovated and stuff, but still, I think it's
put total $130,000 into it with the purchase and the rehab into the property, but
yeah, so that just shows you, it's almost like I think of buying points for your mortgage rate.
They'll show you like, okay, you pay two points. This is what your interest rate is now. You pay
two and a half points. This is what your interest rate is now, and you got to try to find that happy
medium. $50,000 deductible is crazy, and that was only to save how much annually? 800 bucks.
Is that even worth it? But yeah, I think it's math that they'll have to go through.
I think something else too, and I've never done this, but I wonder, a lot of times when you shop
around for your insurance, they'll ask you questions like, hey, what's the age of the roof?
When's the last time you replaced this thing? Do you have a pool? Do you have this? Do you have
that? And maybe just making sure that your insurance provider has the most up-to-date
information, because if you bought these properties, and like Ash, you said you bought
it for 50, you invested another 70, $80,000 into the rehab, you probably improved a lot of the
things that insurance companies might lose sleep over. And if you say like, hey, did you actually
know we replaced a roof last year? Did you know that we added this thing or that thing? Or did
you know that we filled in that pool that you guys were worried about? Just making sure they've got
an accurate picture of the current property and any improvements you've made. Sometimes that can
reduce the cost as well. Or maybe sometimes it's the simple fact of removing something that could
reduce your insurance premium. And I'll give you guys an example. Two different examples, actually.
One time where we did do what they want us to do, and the other time where they didn't. But when we
launched our hotel, the previous owners used to let guests rent bicycles for free. It was just
like a perk of staying at that hotel is that you got bikes you could ride around. And every insurance
carrier that we got said, that's a huge liability for us. So you guys can keep the bikes if you want,
but your premium is going to go up by X percentage. And we said, hey, it's fine. Let's just get rid
of the bikes. It's not that big of a deal. At one of our single-family Airbnbs, we have a slide
that goes into the pool. And the initial carrier that we were going with, they were like, hey, we
like everything about this property. Here's the quote, but we actually won't underwrite you if
you keep the pool in place. Or if you keep the slide in place. And we're not getting rid of the
slide. So we went to a different carrier who charged us more to account for the fact that
there was a slide going into the pool. So sometimes you can ask the carrier, hey, is there anything
that I can remove from this property that would allow me to bring my premium cost down as well?
Yeah, that's one thing I've learned is what do carriers like and don't like in your area?
And you can talk to your insurance broker about this as to what are red flags like,
wood-burning stoves, row houses, trampolines. These have all been things that have been like
red flags on my insurance or will increase the premium. So things they won't lend on and things
that will increase the premium, I think is also a great starting point. And not only
for your current property, but when you're looking to buy properties in the future of knowing what
an insurance carrier would like and what they don't like too, I think can go a long way with
helping you keep that insurance cost down. Ash, just really quick, because you said the word
trampoline, I just found this out yesterday. If I say Q-tip, right? Q-tip is a brand name,
but it's actually called a cotton swab. If I say, I don't know, like jacuzzi, jacuzzi is a brand
name, but it's actually called a hot tub, right? Trampoline, do you think is that the generic name
or the brand name? Well, now I don't think that it, I thought it was the generic name, but now
I'm not. And also that jacuzzi, I did not know that was a brand name because my kids literally
asked me the other day and I was like, I think it's like something with the Jets or something
Jacuzzi is a brand name, but trampoline is also the brand name. I want you to try and guess
what the, like what the generic name is for trampoline. Those are all great guesses,
but not correct. It's a rebound tumbler. Never in my life. Anyway, trampoline's a brand name.
So maybe I just, you know, you were today years old when you found that out for all
of our rookies that are listening. You know, and we, like people study brands of like
Apple and like different things. People need to be studying jacuzzi
and trampoline as to like how to become a household name.
Let's jump into our last question. This one comes from Jimmy and Jimmy says I have a three bed,
one bath family house, which is rented at $1,400 per month. The current comps in the area are around
2000 to $2,500 per month. And I should be able to easily get that amount. My current tenants
have been there for almost 10 years now, and they always pay on time. In fact, they're usually
several days or even one week early paying the rent. They are great tenants and rarely ever have
a maintenance call and small stuff. They just take care of on their own and don't even charge me or
let me know. I've already went a couple of years without even talking to them. I've been slowly
raising the rent, like 50 bucks a month every year, but it's still way under market value by
at least 500 to a thousand dollars a month. It's an old house and does have its flaws,
which is expected on a 100 plus year old home. But what would you do, or how much should I raise
rent at renewal? It's a yearly auto renewal lease. All right. So we're talking about raising rents and
what's the best way to do this? You know, Ash, I'll defer to you here because obviously you got
a lot more experience than I do when it comes to raising rents on folks. I think that just from
like a, there's some level of value that we should give to peace of mind, you know, as a real estate
investor. And you said it's been, you you've gone a couple of years without even talking to them.
How much is that silence worth to you? And maybe it's not a thousand dollars, but maybe it's 500.
So maybe instead of raising the rent by a thousand bucks, you raised by 500 or maybe raised by 250
on their next renewal. But I think there's something to be said about the peace of mind
that comes along with having great tenants who don't say anything, don't make a fuss,
and they just pay their rent on time and leave you alone. Right. And maybe you can go out there
and get that thousand dollar premium that you're looking for. But if it now requires you talking
to that tenant every month, and they're always complaining about something, you've got the
vacancy you have to worry about of like, okay, they've been in it for 10 years. Now you've got
to go and maybe renovate this place to get it up to standards, to be able to run out at the, the,
the amount you're, you're asking, is it worth all of that? And is there a better way to maybe
meet in the middle with these tenants where you both kind of get what you want? They get to
stay at this place. They've been out for a decade, maybe slightly under market rents.
You get to keep these amazing tenants, but you get a little bit closer to what it,
what it would demand on the open market. So just my initial two cents, but I'm curious
what your thoughts are, Ash. Yeah. I always like to include the market rent in the area and show
them like here are comparable markets in the same area, and this is what they're going for.
So example, if their rent is $800 per month, everybody else is paying 950. So not only are
you having $150 per month increase, but you're having to pay moving costs. You're having to
all your utilities. You're having to forward your mail. Like there's a lot that actually
goes into moving besides just paying new rent. So just the convenience of being able to stay
where the person is, I really try to capitalize that and to show them that like, I'm still very
competitive. I'm not trying to overcharge them. And like, if there is a drastic difference in the
rent, sometimes I'll do like the step up method where it's like, okay, let's start with a $50
increase for three months, and then we'll go to a $100 increase and keep doing it that way.
So it's over time. I do that mostly for inherited tenants where I'm taking over the property and
their rent is below market value already instead of just this big shock of here comes a mean old
landlord raising our rents right away. I try to do it a little bit over time because there always is
that like fear factor, your property that you're living in as a rental, it's selling and you have
no idea. Like sometimes when I've gone and looked at properties, like you can see the terror in
these tenants face, like not knowing, are they going to be asked to leave? Is their rent going
to increase? Like who is going to buy it and what's going to happen? Like it has to be a really,
really scary and uncomfortable feeling. So I try to not be, you know, like first impressions I
think are always like a very, very big thing. So I try and just do the step up thing instead of
just slapping them like, you know, $500 right now. So you could always do that over time.
And with, you know, putting the market rents, they're going to see that even if they move
somewhere else, they're going to be paying the same amount unless they find a great deal somewhere.
So that's kind of how I handle it. But I 100% agree about the point of if they are great tenants,
take care of the property. You don't really hear from them. They don't have issues. They
don't put in a ton of maintenance requests because they're actually taking care of the property.
You know, if someone's putting maintenance requests in and it's actually legitimate things
and not just like them trying to nitpick at things that have literally been there the whole time
they've lived there and all of a sudden one day when they get a rent increase, they're deciding
to bring it up to your attention. But I think that's like a good starting point.
And also think about it too. Like you can give them options. So you could do, here's a one-year
lease with, you know, $800. Here's a two-year lease at 750. So you could even lock them in longer,
you know, showing them like, okay, you can actually, I'll increase it by just a little bit
if you are going to actually stay in the property for another two years.
But I've had a tenant that has lived in a property for, let's see, it will be nine years,
I think right now, nine years. And I've never raised the rent once because they have always
paid on time. It's like a different, unique property to me that like, I want to keep forever.
I never want to sell it. And they take great care of it. And they have paid the same amount
of rent every time. And they've stayed there for the whole nine years and there's never,
ever, ever been an issue. We've interviewed Dion McNeely a couple of times in the podcast,
and I really like his approach where he puts the onus on the tenant to say like,
hey, what do you feel is a fair amount? You're currently at $1,400 a month in rent.
Here's five properties that are within walking distance of your unit that are renting at $2,500
a month. This is a big gap. What do you feel is the best way for us to address this?
And he said a lot of times they'll end up saying a number that's higher than what he even thought.
So I think just showing them the facts and letting them lead that conversation is always a good way
to go. But yeah, for me, peace of mind. I think there's a lot of peace of mind that comes along
with great tenants. So I would try to hold onto them as long as you can. Thank you guys so much
for joining us. Make sure you're subscribed to our YouTube at Real Estate Rookie and you're
following us on Instagram at BiggerPocketsRookie. We'll see you guys on the next episode of
Rookie Reply. I'm Ashley, he's Tony. Thanks so much for joining us.
