Art Break: The Aesthetics of Body Fat in Greek and Roman Sculpture

Sculpted Rome
10 followers
Good afternoon, everyone.
My name is Roku Ramora, and I am the curatorial intern
here in the Antiquities Department
at the Getty Villa Museum,
home of the Getty's collection of ancient Greek,
Roman, and Etruscan art.
Today's program is part of the Getty's Art Break program,
in which we take inspiration from an object
or several objects in the Getty's collection
to encourage new conversations about ancient art
and cultures.
And today, we're going to be looking at
Greek and Roman sculptures depicting the human body.
And in this conversation, I am very pleased to welcome
Mark Bradley, Professor of Classics
at the University of Nottingham in the UK.
Welcome.
Hello, everybody.
Thank you, Roku, for inviting me along to speak to you today.
Of course.
So let's get started.
Mark and I are here to have a conversation
about a topic that might at first appear a bit unusual,
the aesthetics of body fat in ancient sculpture.
And we're going to do so by focusing
on two Roman sculptures,
a marble statue of the goddess Venus
and a small bronze statuette of Hercules.
We're going to look at the way ancient sculptors
have approached the depiction of body fat
and of fleshiness more broadly.
Both of these sculptural types
were immensely popular in antiquity
with dozens, if not hundreds, of known examples.
And as you can see from the prints shown on screen,
they are also popular in more recent centuries as well.
So right off the bat,
I think we'd like to emphasize that by body fat,
we don't mean fat bodies,
but rather what we mean is fleshiness.
So basically the bits of your body you can grab hold of,
whether it's flab, whether it's saggy skin,
whether it's soft muscle.
So I guess a normal bit,
a normal part of all of our bodies,
big and small of all genders.
And in particular, we're looking at this topic
as an artistic opportunity,
an aspect of the human body
that was available to ancient artists,
especially sculptors who were working
three-dimensionally to exploit,
to say something interesting about their subjects.
And I think what's even more interesting
is that there's no right answer.
Fat can mean lots of different things.
Yes, thank you for saying that.
And although our conversation today
is going to be rather brief,
it's part of a larger Getty Digital project
called In the Flesh, Body Fat in Ancient Art,
which is undertaken in collaboration
with Google Arts and Culture.
And we will leave a link to this digital exhibition
in the chat.
And I encourage you to explore this multimedia presentation
on Google's platform.
So in developing this project, Mark,
I was very much inspired by your work on obesity
and emaciation and corpulence in Roman art.
And I was wondering if you could share a little bit more
about your research and sort of what motivated you,
what led you to this unusual topic?
Yeah, sure, Rocco.
Well, I suppose just to begin by saying
that my research interests in the ancient world,
I guess, are fueled by what we might call
the compare and contrast exercise.
So how similar and how different
were the Greeks and Romans from us?
And I think I'm interested in really basic components
of human experience.
My early research looked at how ancients perceived color
and smell and different senses
and how that compared to modern sensory experience.
And I got interested also in body shape, in body size,
and the links that were drawn in antiquity and today
to things like character, behavior, and morality.
I've just finished some recent work on Roman noses,
looking at how nose shape and nose size in antiquity
influenced modern discussions about noses,
but also about how modern approaches to noses
departed from classical models.
And about a decade or so ago,
I got interested in fleshiness and slenderness
and how the ancients interpreted it.
And I found that actually nobody never really looked
at body fat in antiquity before.
And I remember spending a summer
at the British School at Rome,
wandering around the city's museums and galleries.
And I was looking not at the idealized bodies
of Apollo or Aphrodite,
but at the busts of chubby senators
hidden away in the corner of the museum,
at images of comic actors wearing fat suits,
at statues of emaciated old women.
And it opened up a whole world of artistic interpretation
that I just really never thought about before.
Yeah, I think similar, like after reading your article,
like once you start looking for it,
you actually do see it more and more.
So to kind of return to the broader issue
that we're discussing,
for many people, body fat is not necessarily something
that they connect with ancient bodies.
And in fact, if they have an idea
about what an ancient body looks like,
it's probably more like the chiseled torso
that you see on screen.
So even museum goers,
they might expect to see fuller figures,
fleshier figures in paintings by Rembrandt or Rubens,
but not so much in the ancient galleries.
Why might that be the case?
That's a good question, Rocco.
Well, so it's sometimes argued
that this ideal of classical bodily perfection,
at least in male bodies,
had its origins in a Greek man called Polykleitos,
who was a fifth-century sculptor who wrote a manual
about how to represent the ideal physique.
And this manual, this idea,
was based on a system of mathematical equations
that prioritized tautness, symmetry, and balance.
And this model established by Polykleitos
was extremely far-reaching.
It had an enduring influence on figural art
across classical antiquity and beyond.
And this artistic ideal carried over into real life,
as you can see in this quote
by the ancient physician Galen, who said,
neither the overweight nor the underweight body
is in due proportion,
but the body which equals the canon of Polykleitos,
that man I've just talked about,
reaches the summit of complete symmetry.
So what Galen's doing here is emphasizing a connection
between moderate appearance, moderate bodies,
and moderate behavior.
And this idea became a mainstay of ancient medicine
and ancient philosophical thinking about bodies,
about identities, about behaviors.
Yeah, and that's sort of precisely
what also made it a moral issue as well,
this deep link that the Greeks,
and later on the Romans,
proceed between your physical appearance
and your inner behavior, your mind or your soul,
however you want to call it,
this link between that kind of outer beauty
and inner beauty, to oversimplify things a bit,
a good man has a good body,
and balanced behavior leads to a balanced physique
and vice versa.
And one of the reasons why this link is important
because it also functions in the opposite direction as well.
If you behave immoderately,
then your body looks out of balance in a similar fashion.
And on screen here,
you see a kind of illustration of this principle in action
on a Greek vase that shows actors
acting in a comedy on a theater stage.
And because in Greek comedy,
they are playing characters
who are very much behaving inappropriately
in ways that you don't want the citizenry to emulate.
The actors are driving this point across
by wearing costumes that are essentially fat suits.
And you can see, if you look closer,
these really exaggerated, overly round bellies and buttocks,
and these kind of sagging breasts.
They're meant to be perceived as the extreme
because they are, in a way, sort of emphasizing
how unacceptable the behavior
of the characters themselves is.
And on the next slide,
you can see a different kind of extreme.
So on the left is Geras,
and Geras is the personification of old age.
He's the deity who governs old age.
He's normally depicted in art, in vase paintings,
in a mythical fist fight with a much beefier Hercules.
And thin bodies in ancient art could be negatively charged
through associations with wasting, with disease,
and they could be bodies
that likewise could have fun poked at them.
So what I would say is that while these are extremes,
there are also numerous gray areas
in which bodies of different sizes
were not necessarily meant to be mocked.
So many representations of satyrs, for example,
and satyrs, these mythical half-men, half-gopes,
show these woodland deities
in very relaxing, life-affirming ways.
These were chubby bodies that, I suppose,
were very much in place in their context.
We can conclude that there is no singular meaning,
singular cultural meaning to fatness in antiquity.
The absence of a singular cultural position on body fat
allowed artists to play with it creatively
and sometimes provocatively.
And this brings us to one of the main objects
that we're looking at today.
That's the crouching Venus, the crouching Aphrodite.
So Rocco, what do we know about this particular statue?
I very much love this object.
It is a Roman statue
that represents the Roman goddess Venus, or Aphrodite,
as she was known to the Greeks,
in the act of taking a bath.
And she is accompanied by her son Cupid, or Eros,
who has unfortunately lost his head in this example.
And she is shown crouching down.
That's why the sort of usual title of the crouching Aphrodite
or crouching Venus.
This particular statue has a fascinating ownership history.
And we're going to leave a little link in the chat
to an article that shares a bit more
about how it sort of made its way
to Los Angeles and to the Getty.
For now, however, what is so striking
for our purposes about this object
is the way that the goddess's body is posed and positioned.
And you can see in these sort of views from all sides,
just how much attention the sculptor has paid
to the goddess's stomach.
And it sort of extends even into sort of the positioning
of the secondary character of the Cupid,
who embraces the goddess in a way
that draws the viewer's attention
precisely to the softness of her belly.
And you can even see in the corner
how the sort of rolls of her stomach
are rhyming visually, so to speak,
with the armband that the goddess is wearing
that is a kind of a helical golden snake-shaped bracelet.
Sculpting something like this took a lot of work.
And today we are maybe a bit overly used
to sort of a world of photography
in which bodies are captured,
quote-unquote, as they are.
But an ancient sculptor like the one who came up
with this particular composition
had to really sort of start from scratch
in depicting the body.
And this is something that your article emphasized very much
that every aspect of a statue,
we should take it to be motivated by a particular reason.
And I 100% agree, especially if you consider
how much work and time and money it took
to produce a finely crafted object like this.
So why would a sculptor want to go out of his way
to depict the goddess in this particular pose
and draw so much attention to the stomach?
Well, I mean, I suppose the traditional answer
is that the fleshy stomach alludes to female fertility.
It alludes to the ability to survive and to procreate.
So a little bit like those Paleolithic figurines
of inflated female bodies that were found all across Europe.
But I do think there's something more going on here.
So to an ancient viewer,
seeing Aphrodite kneeling down like this,
amplifying her fleshy folds,
would be pushing the boundaries
of what was essentially a cult statue.
It's kind of hard to imagine the effect.
And on this next slide,
you can see how different the crouching Aphrodite,
the crouching Venus is from more usual ways
of depicting the goddess,
which were limited to a couple
of relatively standardized standing types.
So by contrast, our Aphrodite suddenly appears
in a pose that is shocking precisely
because it's so immediately
and intuitively human and understandable.
And I think today it's difficult to imagine
how something so seemingly banal,
like a change in the way you're standing
or crouching might actually be transformative for viewers.
It's not like people hadn't previously thought
that Aphrodite was capable of crouching,
but nevertheless, after centuries
of seeing the goddess standing upright
in a pose like the Aphrodite of Cnidus on your left,
getting the same goddess to kneel down
can make an enormous difference to what you're looking at.
And it's not as simple as saying
that it makes the goddess more relatable,
but it does make her more lifelike.
It suggests a very real relationship
between skin, bone, and flesh
that you wouldn't normally associate with this goddess.
Thank you so much for saying that.
And in part, precisely to complicate
the sort of gendered aspects of understanding
and discussing body fat,
we can switch lanes a little bit
and look at our second object,
which is a very different kind of fleshy body.
It is a bronze statuette of the hero Hercules.
And if we compare it to the Crouching Venus,
to sort of piggyback off what you were saying,
if the Crouching Venus is an attempt by the sculptor
to make the statue seem more like real life,
in this particular type of Hercules,
it's closer to a sculptor attempting
to make the work seem more than real life,
to be more than is actually humanly possible.
His body is supposed to look
almost impossibly heavy and muscular.
And this little bronze figurine
is only about six inches tall,
but we know that it replicates a type
that is best known in really colossal replicas
from the city of Rome and elsewhere,
like the one that you see here in this early photograph.
Now, the type in question, the sculptural type,
is known in scholarship as the weary Hercules
or the tired Hercules.
Why is Hercules tired?
Well, let's look at this little bronze figurine
from all sides.
So this represents the Greek hero resting on a club
after completing his 12th and final task.
He had to fetch some golden apples that belonged to Hera,
which were kept in a garden guarded by nymphs
called the Hesperides.
He had to travel the world to find this garden.
He had to fight off monsters.
And this statuette depicts him exhausted
with the apples in his right hand held behind his back.
So here, he's shattered.
He's had enough.
He's at the end of his tether.
Yes, and once again, like in the case of the Venus,
this is not the only way to represent Hercules
in the actual mythological stories
and the kind of lore around Hercules as a figure.
He's always meant to be someone of superhuman strength,
incredible endurance, incredible stamina,
capable of all sorts of things that are impressive.
But often in sort of artistic representations
like this marble statue of Hercules,
also from the Getty's collection,
he is represented as what is essentially
an athletic, muscular man, like an attainable kind of body.
By contrast, if we look at the bronze statuette,
Hercules is way more than simply muscular.
His body is shown with a kind of fleshiness
that you could almost describe as engorged.
And if we think back about sort of what the meaning
of exaggeration was in those Greek vases with comic actors,
can we be certain that something like this,
a kind of exaggerated physique like this
would have been interpreted as a positive thing?
Well, as ever, Rocco, it's hard to say.
And in a sense, that's the point.
So in antiquity, athletes that competed in heavy categories
such as boxing or various feats of strength
were frequently criticized precisely
because of the extreme amount of food
that their dietary regime required.
They were literally meatheads.
They required quantities of food and sleep
that far overshot the moderate balance
that was promoted by the polyplitean ideal
that we talked about earlier.
And in the case of Hercules specifically,
opinions were divided.
So on the one hand, some authors described him
as an incredible glutton.
So the Greek grammarian and author Athenaeus, for example,
argues that Hercules' hunger was insatiable.
He cites a quote from a play saying that,
if you should see Hercules eating, you would die.
His gullet thunders inside, his jaw rattles,
his molar crackles, his canine tooth gnashes,
he sizzles at the nostrils, he waggles his ears.
It's a great quote, isn't it?
But you see, from this perspective,
his exaggerated physique is, once again,
a reflection, a proxy for his exaggerated behavior.
Others had the exact opposite opinion,
rejecting the beefy artistic representations of Hercules
as being unrealistic, disingenuous.
So Dio Chrysostom, for example, says,
Hercules did not look at all like any of these athletes,
for where could he have penetrated
had he carried so much flesh or required so much meat
or sunk into such depths of sleep?
No, he was alert and lean like a lion,
keen of eye and ear, wrecking nought of cold and heat,
having no use for bed shawl or rug,
clad in a dirty skin with an air of hunger about him.
Yeah, I mean, in other words,
he can't possibly be that beefy
because you would only get that much flesh
if you ate in the extreme.
And to the ancients, a powerful muscular body
that nevertheless required extreme amounts of food
was still liable to the same kind of criticism
that extreme behavior brings along.
And that's what's so interesting from today's perspective
because today we tend to criticize,
and I mean we sort of as a general society
of the 21st century,
we tend to criticize overeating
mostly when it leads to fatness
because we consider being muscular and being fat
as these sort of two separate categories.
But the example of Hercules shows us
that the ancients had a very different way
of thinking about heavy bodies of all sorts.
It's almost in the case of Hercules,
like the sculptor is asking with respect to his feet,
is it worth it?
How powerful of a body is he at the end of the day,
this exhausted hero?
Sure, and I think all this shows us
that well, fat is complicated
and it's impossible to tell a simple story
about fat being beautiful
or fat being ugly in ancient art.
Fleshiness though is unusual.
So we're used to seeing classical statues
slim and beautifully proportioned
and so were the ancients.
So whenever we see fat or thin bodies in ancient art,
something's going on.
So body fat, in a sense, it was like a costume.
It transformed the meaning of the body.
It was there precisely to get us thinking.
I think we could really go on like this for a while,
but at this point, it's probably a good idea
to see if we could answer some of our audience questions.
And I have a question here lined up
that we could start with.
Would an artist have perceived body fat
as quote-unquote fat?
Now, this is a great question
because it really depends on how we think
of what the word fat means.
In many of today's languages, English included,
we don't really think about flesh that much.
Like today, the category of flesh,
like meat in the human sense,
is very rarely discussed outside of horror movies
and sort of very specific considerations.
But in many of the ancient discourses,
this idea between sort of medical distinction
between body fat in the kind of sense of fat tissue
and flesh in the sort of more general sense of muscles
combined with fat tissue,
especially in the example of Hercules,
wouldn't have been that much
of a societally recognized tradition,
in part because simply the medical awareness
of the population, including the artists,
wasn't necessarily or wasn't certainly
as advanced as it is today.
Now, would an artist consider it fat?
The perfect place to look for that answer
would be in Polykleitos' treatise.
Unfortunately, we do not have it.
And so we don't know exactly what they would think.
Yeah, I think that's a good answer.
And I think the point is actually
that when an artist is sculpting fat or flesh,
it's something extra.
It's stuff on top of a kind of basic prototype
that they're working with following the Polykleitos ideal,
but it's how you interpret that
that makes it particularly interesting.
Okay, so Stephanie has asked in the chat,
so Mark, you mentioned making connections
between ancient and modern slash contemporary ideas
and ideals of body size and shape
related to personality and moral characteristics.
Have you encountered the field of fat studies
as you've been doing this work?
If you have, have you considered looking at the artwork
you engage with through this lens?
And I think, Stephanie, I mean,
I was reading what I could when I did this research
because, I mean, it was so little based
on what fat and fleshiness meant in antiquity,
but I absolutely had to look at medieval,
Renaissance, early modern, and modern depictions of fat.
And there's an enormous quantity of really good material
reflecting on what fat means
and how the meaning of fat oscillates over time
in different ways.
And I think one thing that,
one striking thing that emerged for me
from looking at this research
was this precise kind of ambiguity and ambivalence
that placed in a particular cultural context,
fat could mean lots of different things.
It could mean multiple things at the same time.
And, you know, and I think this idea that it functions
certainly in an artistic context like a costume
is absolutely applicable to what we're seeing in antiquity.
So I think that's a really good question.
And the answer is yes, probably not, you know,
not in as many manifold ways as I ought to have done,
but it was extremely instrumental in my research.
Our next question is one that sort of connects
to a lot of what we were already mentioning.
Wasn't corpulence thought of as indicating
that a person was well-to-do or rich?
Yes and no.
In a sort of simple, literal sense,
there was like a logical connection
between, you know, being able to eat more food
and being able to afford more food.
And that sort of stands true.
However, the relationship between richness
and corpulence is one that was both positively
and negatively charged.
And often it is the negative kind of connotations
of that connection that are brought up more commonly
in the written sources.
And this connection is one that is based often
both in Greek and in Roman writing
with sort of unease about certain kinds of wealth,
material wealth, and how it is being used
in a social setting.
And so an overly rich person isn't by any means
in antiquity something that is unquestionably positive.
It is often something to fear, to be wary of,
or, you know, in correlated sense,
to kind of shun ridicule and kind of other in many ways.
And there, the connection between a kind of
fattened appearance and a kind of fattened wallet,
if you will, was one that could be exploited
to show the in moderation of such a person.
And there is a very interesting link that we can,
you know, talk more about how that relates
to kind of femininity and a lot of sexual behaviors
and attitudes that are similarly kind of criticized
for their immoderate intensity or like exaggerated,
taken to excess.
Yeah, I think I'd just add as well.
I mean, so I guess that discourse of a corpulent body
being well-to-do or rich,
it's a very kind of masculine kind of prototype
in a sense, it makes you think of a traditional example,
I guess, in England is the portraits of Henry VIII,
you know, who's very overweight, well-to-do,
eats a lot, enjoys his life.
That's exactly the discourse
that we're meant to get out of that.
That same discourse you get in portraits
of Hellenistic rulers, so these are kings of Egypt
following the death of Alexander the Great,
who were also frequently depicted
as being really quite fleshy and well-to-do.
And that translated across into some phases
of Roman emperors who, you know,
sometimes they were kind of slender and Greek
and ideal and slim, like the early emperors.
And then you get a round of emperors
who were a bit like those Hellenistic rulers.
They've got double chins
and they've got eye bags and thick necks.
And that kind of oscillation of types
goes all the way through Roman imperial portraiture.
I think that really leads to this other question
that one of our viewers had.
How do modern ideas about unruly
or undesirable bodies, such as fat, old, or ill bodies,
affect the preservation and display
of ancient statues with these bodies?
Sort of to connect it more
to kind of what Mark was just talking about,
they do affect it a lot because often,
in a very unexamined way,
we take up a lot of that discourse from antiquity
and then apply it back to the object.
And a great example of that
is the portraiture of the Emperor Nero.
He's a figure who is certainly, in historical sources,
you know, accused of all sorts of negative,
like unquestionably a very disliked ruler
who has historically been seen as responsible
for everything from, you know, burning Rome
and all sorts of immoral behavior on a personal
as well as administrative level.
And in his portraiture,
Nero is distinct in showing himself on his coinage
and in his portraits as a fat man.
You can 100% see that he is shown
with like a very thick neck, you know, with a double chin.
And up until quite recently, I mean, even, you know,
I remember when I was in high school,
it was perfectly okay to sort of just say,
like, you know, you can see in examples like this,
like what crazy, you know, unstable man he was.
And the unstated part was like,
because who in their right mind
would want to show themselves in this manner
unless they were unwell?
And this is a very much the kind of discourse
that today we're trying to move away from.
And I know in the UK,
there was recently an exhibition on Nero
at the British Museum that caused a lot of controversy
precisely because it started poking at some of these things
where, you know, to what extent are we continuing
others' projections of certain behavior
back onto the objects themselves?
And so as we're talking about ways to display these objects
in museum spaces and, you know, broadly in scholarship,
we really have to kind of step back
and re-examine like what exactly counts as negative?
And is there anything on the object
that warrants that interpretation for the public?
And I think a very basic answer to that question
is absolutely yes.
And I mentioned the research that I'd done in Rome
and some of the most interesting things by far
were actually sort of buried away in a basement
and not displayed at all,
or they were in rooms that were closed off to the public
so the public weren't particularly interested.
So I think there are lots of assumptions
that are feeding into the way these, you know,
the way these statues are selected and displayed.
Wesley has asked,
it appears in some of these sculptures
that musculature is strongly emphasized
and not at all adipose fat tissue.
And I think that's absolutely right.
But, you know, you get that weary Hercules
on the right on the slide here,
and you make him, you stop, you know, slunching over,
you make him stand upright,
throwing the knee and lying around,
and all of that, you know,
what looks like kind of flabby muscle,
it becomes real muscle, right?
So it's not just about, you know,
the tissue that the body has on it,
but it's how the body is, what the body's doing,
how it's posed.
And that just makes an enormous difference
then to how you associate,
what you associate that fleshiness with.
But it's, you know, the artists,
these artists are really clever.
They know exactly what they're doing
when they're sculpting particular kinds of poses.
I think there was a question that Bonnie asked
about thinness,
was being very thin and fit ever admired?
This is something that I think your article
really spoke about wonderfully,
that thinness is very much a modern concept
as a positive thing,
that the primary kind of connotations of thinness
in classical antiquity and in many pre-modern societies
was as a step on a kind of rolling scale
that leads towards wasting away and towards death.
And often, you know,
this idea that a thin body is desirable
is not like an actual sort of,
what we would today consider an underweight body
is desirable,
is not present in the written sources
or in the artistic sources.
But what is, I think, true is that
even though it is undesirable,
you don't see it as like nowhere nearly as criticized
as the overweight bodies are.
Like, it's not that writers are sort of spending,
you know, pages and pages going on about how,
you know, inappropriate or, you know,
morally wrong thin bodies are.
So why do you think that opposite extreme
wasn't as viciously critiqued?
I suppose, I mean, I'm sort of thinking about
the famous Farnese Hercules,
which is a sort of, you know,
he's not slouched over in the way that we've got here,
but he's, you know, he's the kind of bodybuilder.
It's, you know, he's larger than life.
It's a colossal statue.
It's found in the baths of Caracalla
where people are not only bathing, but exercising.
And in a sense, it's easy to fall into the interpretation
that this is a kind of, you know, bodybuilder aesthetic
that people in the baths of Caracalla
are meant to look at.
These Romans are meant to look at it,
say, I want a body like that.
But actually what's really interesting
about how that statue works in that context
is it becomes a talking point
because, you know, bodies like that
are not straightforwardly positive
or straightforwardly negative.
But in a sense, there's a sort of aspirational element to it.
There's also a bit of a warning, actually,
that, you know, if you know anything about Hercules,
he comes to a sticky end and things go downhill.
So I think, you know, rather than talking about
images of thin or fat figures
being either positive or negative,
I think what's really interesting
is to see how those sculptural types
open up a conversation.
And I think we can see the baths, Roman baths,
as being a place where, you know,
clever people sit and they have conversations.
Yeah, do you want to look like that?
Why do you want to look like that?
What are the consequences of looking like that?
So I think that's broadly what I'd say in response to that,
which I think answers one or two of the other questions
that I saw on the list.
Bodies in art that were meant to be mocked,
and does that align with body shaming today?
I think so, actually.
I think there were some figures
that were meant to be the subject of humor and comedy.
And we talked about images of comic actors in fat suits,
and that is an obvious context
in which that kind of body shaming takes place.
When we get to Hellenistic art,
that's Hellenistic art is art
around the fourth, third century BC,
there's a lot more provocative playfulness with bodies.
Bodies that don't fit the kind of classical ideal,
emaciated old women kind of crouching down,
or there's more emphasis on satyrs,
those half men, half goats with pot bellies,
which, you know, in a certain context,
that's what you expect,
but they're meant to be kind of looked at and derided.
And there was a whole brand of Greek plays
called satyr plays,
where it was about looking at what the world looks like
if you turn the world upside down
and stop behaving like normal people.
And part of that is drunken behavior
and letting your body go.
So I think there's all sorts of examples
where body shaming is one way
of interpreting what's going on.
Our next question is an interesting one.
Does the attitude towards corpulence differ
between Roman and Greek culture?
Presumably the Roman enterprise of conquest
would have elevated fitness.
Does it differ between cultures?
The short answer is yes.
However, the cultures themselves,
go on for centuries, are very complicated,
go on, you know, there are changes that happen.
However, there are, we could point to the existence,
even within antiquity, of certain stereotypes
where particular cultures are stereotypically perceived
as fatter or heavier, like bigger.
And a great example would be this sort of ancient trope
of the obese Etruscan,
which is a kind of longstanding kind of trope
that has sort of been taken up in scholarship as well,
because we have a couple of mentions of Etruscans
as being sort of obesos etruscos,
is kind of a set phrase.
That does not actually mean
that the Etruscan people were obese.
And, you know, scholarship has gone to the point
of actually performing very complicated,
you know, bioarchaeological testing
on Etruscan, you know, funerary remains
to sort of show like there is no,
as far as we can tell, indication
that this population was fatter or less fat
than any other ancient population.
However, a lot of these stereotypes, as is the case today,
come about through complex processes
where they are linked with all sorts
of other negatively charged behaviors or appearances.
And in the case of Etruscans,
that's probably also the case.
Now, as for the issue of Romans and conquest,
the question of fitness is an interesting one
because, you know, fitness is very different
from the appearance of your body.
You can be a very, I mean,
if you look at the range of bodies represented
in different athletic disciplines today,
vast majority of them are fit,
and yet they kind of end up looking different.
They have, some are very slender, some are very heavy.
How this would correlate with Roman ideas
about conquest is hard to say,
but we can for sure say that there were anxieties,
gendered anxieties about the appearance of bodies
on the military battlefield.
And one way that we see this is,
you can still see that today
in representations of emperors and generals
that wear these bronze breastplates
that are then, you know, in marble sculpture,
they are shown in marble,
and the bronze breastplates are sculpted
as if they were kind of shaped to this,
you know, chiseled, you know, six-pack abs,
you kind of well-defined pectorals,
and you can, you know, they have nipples indicated
and very much kind of create the illusion
that this bronze was just cast, you know,
over the body directly onto the body itself.
Often this has led to people saying like,
well, they must have been that fit underneath,
but you can say the exact opposite,
that much like the fat suits are a costume
that you can put on to kind of take on
a different kind of body than the one you have.
This bronze breastplate makes you seem to others
or makes you seem to yourself
to kind of inhabit this kind of polyclide and ideal
in a very literal way.
You kind of, you put on the body that you want to have,
and it sort of shows you in a kind of Photoshopped way,
either to others or perhaps even to yourself.
So this is something that we do not see in the same extent
with any kind of tropes of female portraiture.
And because it appears in military context,
it's probably linked to gendered expectations
on the battlefield.
Yeah, I just want to add to that as well.
Those are B-Citruscans.
One thing they all have in common is they're all dead,
right?
They're all in the afterlife.
They're relaxing, they're enjoying life.
That's sort of, you know,
that's in place when you're enjoying the afterlife.
Living Etruscans in Etruscan funerary arts,
they're all quite thin.
They're warriors, you know, so they're active.
So even in Etruscan art, it's really quite complicated.
And as I said, there are kind of rhythms and differences
between different cultures,
but actually what each phase, historical phase,
has in common is within every context,
there's always a kind of bilateral interpretation.
There's a double interpretation.
As I said earlier, you know,
you can have successful military emperors
conquering the world,
and they're all thin like Augustus and his successors.
And then you have another regime,
and they're all beefy.
And both of them are, you know,
they want to project that association
with successful conquest and imperialism.
Carly's asked something about,
and I may have misunderstood the question.
Is there a potential conflict
at looking at fat Venus figurines
as inherently fertility-based?
Same goes with Venus.
Not to say each identical figure
was an IRL woman,
but fertility elides the reality of fat bodies.
So I think, Carly, if I understand you there,
I mean, what is interesting is that,
you know, it's very old-fashioned view
that you look at a depiction of a large female figure,
particularly in prehistoric phases,
and see it as a depiction of, you know,
female fertility and procreation.
Actually, we've got no idea
what those inflated female figurines from Europe
actually meant, what they were used for,
what the associations were.
And they're actually called Venus figures,
like the Venus of Willendorf.
They're called it ironically
because they look so different
from traditional depictions of Venus in classical art.
So I think we should be cautious.
We're looking at classical art here,
and ambiguity is our key theme.
I think we should be cautious
about associating fleshiness and fertility
straightforwardly in any artistic context, actually.
And I think that is sort of what the question
really puts so succinctly,
that fertility elides the reality of fat bodies.
I think that is precisely kind of why
we wanted to have a program like this
to say that, yes, the fertility aspect
in, you know, the case of, you know,
childbearing individuals is a real thing.
Like there are certain kind of,
there is a certain threshold of body fat
below which you do not menstruate,
and you kind of, procreation and fertility
in the literal sense is sort of linked
to kind of how, to the body fat percentage
in a way that is not, as far as I understand, cultural.
But it is true that, like,
to simply kind of consider any female reading body
that is in any way curvier or bigger
as being inherently about fertility,
that's precisely the easy cop-out answer
that, you know, you could apply to anything.
And by kind of unpacking this more
and looking at it as an artistic problem,
it gets us away from kind of these sort of
simplistic readings of like fertility
as a kind of catch-all that answers any questions
and really makes us sort of confront the situation
that the sculptor who represented the Venus like this
could have and maybe did represent her also
in those kind of much more standardized standing poses,
but this one offered something artistically interesting
that was appealing as opposed in its own right.
And that's a separate question from a kind of fertility
aspect that might have been culturally emphasized.
And perhaps just briefly to add to that
and to pick up one or two of the other questions
in the chat about the pose of this crouching Venus.
Somebody asked, can you say something about
the spiraling movement, the twisting movement
of the crouching Venus?
We've got lots and lots and lots of these
and they're copies of an earlier prototype,
but every time you copy them,
it's not just like creating a plaster cast
and just look exactly the same.
They're changed subtly every time
the sculptor wants to reproduce this.
So they're twisting more, she's bending over more,
she's got a different pose.
And actually counting the number of fleshy folds
is really interesting as time goes on.
When you get to it, there's a very famous one
in the Villa of Hadrian at Tivoli.
And I think there are something like six or seven folds,
which is more than you've ever had before.
Every time you depict this Venus,
you do something a bit different with it.
And every time you do something different,
you're conveying a sort of different type of interpretation.
So there's a sort of shifting discourse over time
about what this means.
Well, I think it's time to wrap up,
but before we leave,
I wanted to just say a very, very big thank you, Mark,
for joining me and having this discussion.
And thank you all viewers
and to everyone who has submitted questions.
We encourage you to check out
the Google Digital Exhibition on this topic
that brings in a lot more material,
many more objects from the Getty's collections.
And you can visit getty.edu
for information about upcoming programs
and to see what's on.
Thank you all once again, very much.
