Medical examiner stands by ruling that Philly woman stabbed 20 times died by suicide

6abc Philadelphia
1.2K followers
39 Video Views·Oct 14, 2025
The Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office issued a report affirming its ruling that the 2011 stabbing death of a Manayunk teacher was a suicide.
S
CASE IS NOW BEING INVESTIGATED
BY HOMICIDE.
>> NOW TO A STORY OF TREMENDOUS
CONTROVERSY SURROUNDING THE
DEATH OF A PHILADELPHIA TEACHER.
A NEW REPORT RULED THE DEATH AS
A SUICIDE.
>> ELLEN GREENBERG DIED IN 2011
AFTER BEING STABBED MORE THAN
20 TIMES. AND NOW, FOR THE
SECOND TIME, DOCTORS SAYING THE
EVIDENCE SHOWS IT WAS BY HER
OWN DOING. TONIGHT, HER FAMILY
FIERCELY DISPUTING THAT.
>> ACTION NEWS REPORTER
CHEYENNE CORIN JOINS US NOW
LIVE OUTSIDE PHILADELPHIA
POLICE HEADQUARTERS WITH THIS
STORY TONIGHT. CHEYENNE.
>> GOOD EVENING, GRAY AND SHARI.
THIS REVIEW ISSUED BY THE
PHILADELPHIA MEDICAL EXAMINER
IS 32 PAGES LONG. IN THE END,
ELLEN GREENBERG'S DEATH WAS
AGAIN RULED A SUICIDE. TODAY,
WE SPOKE WITH THE FAMILY'S
LAWYER AHEAD OF ANOTHER HEARING
TOMORROW, AND HE CALLED THIS
REPORT AN EMBARRASSMENT.
>> DESPITE HAVING ANTICIPATED
THIS AND BEEN EXPECTING IT.
THERE'S ALWAYS THAT LITTLE
GLIMMER OF HOPE.
>> AFTER ANOTHER REVIEW OF HER
CONTROVERSIAL DEATH, IT WAS
AGAIN RULED THAT ELLEN
GREENBERG DIED BY SUICIDE ON
JANUARY 26TH, 2011. THE
PHILADELPHIA SCHOOL TEACHER WAS
FOUND IN HER LOCKED APARTMENT
BY HER FIANCE. SHE LIVED WITH.
AUTOPSY RESULTS SHOWED SHE HAD
BEEN STABBED 20 TIMES IN THE
NECK, BACK, HEAD AND HEART. SHE
ALSO HAD 11 BRUISES.
>> THE QUESTION FOR THE M.E.
WAS NEVER WHETHER HE DID IT. IT
WAS WHETHER SHE DID.
>> ACCORDING TO THE REPORT,
THREE SUPERFICIAL STAB WOUNDS
AND 20 MORE BRUISES WERE
REVEALED IN THIS REVIEW.
HOWEVER, THE MEDICAL EXAMINER
WROTE, WHILE THIS DISTRIBUTION
OF INJURIES IS ADMITTEDLY
UNUSUAL, ELLEN WOULD BE CAPABLE
OF INFLICTING THESE INJURIES
HERSELF, ESPECIALLY SINCE SHE
STRUGGLED WITH ANXIETY.
>> THIS REPORT, IF YOU READ IT
ALL THE WAY THROUGH, SEEMS TO
BE WRITTEN MORE TO EXCULPATE.
ELLEN'S FIANCE.
>> THIS LATEST CONCLUSION GOES
AGAINST THE LATEST STATEMENT
MADE BY THE MEDICAL EXAMINER
WHO ORIGINALLY CONDUCTED THE
AUTOPSY. THE PATHOLOGIST FIRST
RULED GREENBERG'S DEATH A
HOMICIDE. WEEKS LATER, HE
SWITCHED IT TO A SUICIDE, A
CONCLUSION THAT HAS REMAINED
FOR 14 YEARS. BUT IN JANUARY,
HE SAID GREENBERG'S DEATH
SHOULD BE DESIGNATED SOMETHING
OTHER THAN SUICIDE.
>> THE FIGHT ISN'T OVER.
>> WE SPOKE TO ELLEN'S PARENTS
RECENTLY BEFORE THE DOCU SERIES
ABOUT HER DEATH WAS RELEASED ON
HULU. THIS LATEST REVIEW CAME
AFTER THE OFFICE WAS ORDERED TO
CONDUCT AN INDEPENDENT AND
UNBIASED REVIEW, FOLLOWING THE
FAMILY'S LAWSUIT AGAINST THE
CITY.
>> THE STORY IS JUST SO
COMPELLING AND WE'VE DISCOVERED
SO MANY. INCONSISTENCIES.
>> AND THE FAMILY'S LAWYER SAID
THEY DID NOT EXPECT TO RECEIVE
THIS REPORT LAST FRIDAY BEFORE
THE NEXT COURT DATE. THERE
ACTUALLY IS ANOTHER SCHEDULED
HEARING TOMORROW, AND THEY SAY
THEY ARE NOT SURE WHAT'S TO
COME. LIVE AT POLICE
HEADQUARTERS, CHEYENNE FOR
ACTION NEWS AT TEN ON PHL 17.
SHAR
