Al-Mamun, the Scholar & the Inquisitor | 819CE - 833CE | Abbasid Caliphate #05

Indian Ancestors
19 followers
8 Video Views·Oct 12, 2025
In the early 9th century, the Abbasid Caliphate was just coming out of a long and bloody civil war.
After Harun al-Rashid's plan of succession failed spectacularly, his two sons picked up the sword
for their claim to the throne of the Caliphate. All edges of the Caliphate parceled out of control
but eventually, Al-Amin was killed by Al-Mamun's forces and Al-Mamun was installed as the sole
Caliph. After having ruled from Merv in the distant province of Khorasan for six years,
he decided to return to Baghdad, the city founded by his great-grandfather, Al-Mansur.
Since the end of the war in 813CE, Al-Mamun had been reigning from Merv in Khorasan. It was far
from the richer provinces of Iraq and Egypt. Controlling the western parts of the empire
from there proved nearly impossible. So, Al-Mamun decided to return to Baghdad after six years,
in 819CE. Once there, Al-Mamun had to pick up the debris of the civil war.
Al-Mamun had brought his own entourage and court culture from Merv which was proving
incompatible with the court of Baghdad. The first thing that the Baghdadis didn't like
was that Al-Mamun's court wore green rather than the Abbasid black. Black had been the
colour of the Abbasids since the revolution almost 70 years earlier. While green was a
colour associated with the Ali's, Ali's descendants. In fact, despite popular belief,
Al-Mamun was very close with the Ali's. Two of his daughters were married to the Ali's. One of
them to Ali al-Ridha, a man he had once declared his heir but who had died on the way back from
Khorasan. It's commonly believed that he was poisoned by Al-Mamun but it should be kept in
mind that Ali al-Ridha was 20 years older than Al-Mamun. He was Harun al-Rashid's age. The
Abbasid dynasty was not comfortable with all these changes and pressured Al-Mamun into reverting to
However, he refused to incorporate Al-Amin's establishment into his own and decided to keep
his own Khorasani bureaucrats in power. During the war, Al-Mamun had two prominent generals,
Tahir ibn Hussain and his superior Al-Fadl ibn Sahl. And in Al-Mamun's absence,
Baghdad was controlled by ibn Sahl who sent Tahir into semi-retirement in Raqqa.
Al-Mamun ordered him to return to Baghdad and serve as his right-hand man. Initially, Al-Mamun
resided in the Golden Gate Palace which had been built by Al-Mansur but later he built his own
palace. Golden Gate Palace was never occupied by a Caliph again. Tahir and his family were given a
palace in Baghdad as well but soon, Al-Mamun realised that he couldn't bear to look at the
man who had killed his brother, the previous Caliph, Al-Amin. Hence, he sent Tahir to govern
Khorasan in 821CE. Tahir died the next year. His son, Abdullah ibn Tahir brought Syria and Egypt
back into the Abbasid fold in 825 and 826 respectively and became the Caliph's new
right-hand man. Normal Abbasid rule was restored and Al-Mamun decided to continue an annual
tradition of the Abbasids. He decided to attack the Eastern Roman Empire.
The heart of the Abbasid army had been made up of the Abna till now. The Abna were descendants
of the soldiers who had led the Abbasid revolution. Although, during the civil war,
they had been with Al-Amin and so, Al-Mamun decided not to use them for his own campaigns.
He recruited a new army from Khorasan and he started adding Turkic slave soldiers in his army.
His brother, Abu Ishaq had a private army of some 5,000 Turkic slaves by this time.
They were very capable in the battlefield as they could shoot arrows from the back of galloping
horses, a useful tactic in that time. The importance of the Turkic slaves and Abu Ishaq
in Al-Mamun's military structure cannot be exaggerated. This would prove very fatal to
the Abbasid Caliphate. From 830 to 833CE, Al-Mamun led a campaign against the Eastern Roman Empire
every year. Famously, to make peace in one of these campaigns, he asked the Eastern Roman
Emperor to hand over as many scientific manuscripts as he could find. Al-Mamun would raid Southern
Anatolia in the summer and retreat for the winter. However, instead of returning to Baghdad,
he preferred Damascus, which was the old capital of the Umayyad dynasty,
who were overthrown by the Abbasids. It was around this time that he had Umayyad Caliph
Abdul Malik's name replaced by his own in the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem. He also visited
Egypt in 832CE and became the only reigning Abbasid Caliph to do so. He famously ordered a tunnel dug
into the Great Pyramid to see what was inside. Now, here, let's talk about Al-Mamun and the kind
of ruler that he thought he should be. By this time, there was a disagreement that was starting
who, if anyone, had the right to declare judgment on God's behalf. Some believed that the Imam,
which literally means leader or guide, had divine guidance and jurisprudence. In other words,
God speaks through them and whatever they say is God's will. Most of these people believed that
the Imam belonged to a line of men in the Prophet's family. Ali al-Ridha, Al-Mamun's
designated heir was one. This group later became what we know as the Shias. The other group did not
believe in the Imam's divine guidance. Rather, anyone can be an Imam with enough study on the
Quran and the Hadith, the Prophet's sayings and actions. Also, you didn't have to be from the
Prophet's descendants. Today, there are four main schools of Islamic jurisprudence among the Sunnis.
The Hanafi, the Maliki, the Shafi'i and the Hambali. All four of these would be founded
before Al-Mamun's reign was over. This group later became what we know as the Sunnis.
Al-Mamun had been exposed to the idea of the Imam having divine guidance as a child
and he had taken to it. Abbasid Caliphs thought of themselves as Imams as well but they had never
really tried to pass judgement on behalf of God. They had judges on that matter who interpreted
the Quran and the Hadith. Al-Mamun wanted to change that. He wanted to actively influence
Islamic jurisprudence. He wanted to be like a Shia Imam since he was from the Prophet's family,
although the Proto-Shias believe that you have to be a descendant of the Prophet.
But, well, Al-Mamun just ignored that part. He was very pro-Walid. Among other things,
he restored some of their property in Arabia and he legalized public cursing of Muawiyah ibn Abu
Sufyan, the founder of the Umayyad dynasty. He even allowed the practice of Nikahl Mutah,
which is a fixed-term marriage based on, sometimes, oral contract which is still
practiced among the Shias. As Michael Cooperson writes,
as a way to bring all factions together for the good of the faith. During this discussion,
he had argued that the practice of the Prophet's companions could not be accepted uncritically.
Some of the companions, he had said, were worthier than others. Moreover,
some of their legal rulings were contradictory. Therefore, it was necessary to judge each case
on its merits and overturn the rulings of certain companions if necessary. Afterwards,
he complained that some of his guests had understood his argument to mean simply that
he preferred Ali ibn Abi Talib over the other companions. Such reasoning, he said, was typical
of those who collect students, declare themselves leaders, summon their followers to one innovation
or another and cry out for the blood of anyone who opposes them. He expressed the hope that
these misguided rabble-rousers might be persuaded of the errors of their ways by means of reason
debate. If they refused to listen to reason, however, they would be brought around by force.
The proto-Sunnis, who were the majority, were very literalist when it came to the
Qur'an and the hadith. They didn't leave much room for interpretation. Al-Mamun was against
that. While he maintained that the hadith were credible, he also said that some hadith were more
credible than the others. The whole issue came down to one debate. Was the Qur'an created by
Allah or had it always existed? This question was an oversimplification of the debate by Al-Mamun.
Al-Mamun believed that the Qur'an was created and sent down to the Prophet and so, it had room
for interpretation as time changed. However, if it had always existed, then time does not factor
into it and so, no room for interpretation. The literalists didn't exactly believe that
the Qur'an had always existed as Al-Mamun insisted that they believed. But the debate
got out of hand as the mihna came to be. Mihna means test or trial. In 833CE, the year Al-Mamun
was to die, he wrote a letter from Raqqa to his governor in Baghdad to question officials of the
court, judiciary and the scholars on their belief on the createdness of the Qur'an. We don't know
exactly how many people were questioned. The majority of the population disagreed with Al-Mamun's
beliefs but they had no choice. Those who initially resisted later caved in when the caliph ordered
their execution. All but two people changed their position for the caliph. One of them was Ahmad
They were put in chains and sent to the caliph. Although, in the middle of their journey,
news reached them that the caliph had died. The two scholars were released by Al-Mamun's successor.
Today, Al-Mamun is considered a Sunni caliph and his mihna is seen as some misguided deviance
rather than a systemic attempt to change the core of Islam or at least the Abbasid Caliphate.
No Abbasid Caliph is now known as Imam. Rather, those four men who formed the schools of thought
are called Imams by the Sunnis and those in the lines of the Prophet's descendants are called
Imams by the Shias. Ultimately, the mihna would fail and the proto-Sunnis would prevail.
Al-Mamun was also very interested in the sciences and personally knew and studied various subjects.
One of my favourite stories is that he read Ptolemy's work where the earth's circumference
was noted as 180,000 stadia. He asked his translators how long a stadion was. Unfortunately,
no one knew. It had been lost in translation. So, Al-Mamun commissioned a team to conduct
new research and find the circumference of the earth. Their result was around 20,160 miles.
We now know that it's actually 24,900 miles. Although, we don't know how long they considered
a mile back then so, we kinda have the same problem that Al-Mamun had with stadia.
On one of his campaigns against the Eastern Roman Empire, he commissioned another experiment to
calculate the circumference of the earth by measuring the time between sunsets at sea level
and atop a mountain. Unfortunately, the result of that experiment hasn't reached us.
While in Khorasan, he had taken it upon himself to have the three sons of his astronomer,
Musa ibn Shakir educated after he died. Those three boys would later be known as the Banu Musa
brothers and they made immense contributions to the field of mechanics. Their book of ingenious
devices contains hundreds of diagrams for machines that, in one form or another, we still
use, for example, the crankshaft. A story for another time. Obviously, Al-Mamun's role in the
development of algebra through the patronage of Al-Khwarizmi has already been discussed in another
video. He also commissioned a complete work on geography, once again, building on older works.
The geography of Al-Mamun, as the book was called, has not survived in its original form
but we have some bits and pieces. For example, he measured the coordinates of Mecca and Baghdad
which are very close to modern calculations. Ultimately, he is remembered for his contributions
to science more than anything else. He has a crater named after him on the moon after all.
In 833CE, Al-Mamun was determined to make permanent gains in Anatolia. He decided to occupy
the city of Tyana which is called Qamar Hisar these days. Weirdly, he recruited troops from
Syria for this campaign. However, the permanent advance he aimed to make never came. On 9th of
August, 833CE, Caliph Al-Mamun passed away. He had a sudden fever and died within a day or two
while on a campaign near the modern-day town of Pozanti in Turkey. He was 46 years old.
It's said that he was buried in an inconspicuous grave as most Abbasid Caliphs were.
And according to one story, when Eastern Roman troops reconquered the region,
they thought that it was the grave of a saint and built a church on top of it. Although,
I could not confirm the story. The matter in its succession was complicated to say the least.
His son, Abbas was a decorated commander and was a leader in this campaign as well.
However, Al-Mamun's brother, Abu Ishaq, the leader of the Turks was with Al-Mamun when he died
and he declared that Al-Mamun had made him his heir. Abbas did not want to plunge the empire
into yet another civil war so he decided to swear allegiance to his uncle. Abu Ishaq took
the regnal title or Laqab as it was called of Al-Mu'tasim. See you next time.
