Some Used Cars Prices Are CRATERING- These Are the 15 Biggest Money Losers This Year!

Family Auto
135 followers
#automobile #autos #cars #4wheels #luxurycar #sportcar #highspeedcar #testdrive #toyota #tesla #porsche #hyundai #rollsroyce #royall #suvs
Hey, Tom, you've got a really interesting list from our friends over at I see
cars. And basically it's the cars that depreciate the most.
Yeah, that's right.
So the study analyzed the pricing trends of over 1.6 million one to five year
old used cars sold in August,
2023 and 2024 to determine the difference in market values between used
gasoline, hybrid, and electric vehicles. And according to IC cars,
while used car prices continue to drop from their COVID era highs,
use electric vehicle prices are dropping much faster.
Yeah. And the great thing about this list is you can look at it as a half glass,
as a glass is half empty or half full. In other words, uh,
avoid buying these cars when they're new or pick them up at a bargain when
they're used. So should we get into it?
Yeah. So these are the top 15 cars with the biggest price drops August of
2024, the IC car study. So what's the number 15?
Yeah. TFL fashion. We'll do it, you know, from number 15 to number one.
So number 15 is the Tesla model S it dropped an average of 13.4%.
Yep. Year over year.
And that is a price difference year of a year of $8,255.
Now the overall average across the market is about a 4.8% drop,
um, with a dollar difference of 1500.
So when we're looking at the Tesla 4.8 to 13.4 and then 1500 to
$8,000, that's a big jump.
You know, that's not too surprising.
I kind of figure anybody who wants a Tesla model S has already bought a Tesla
model S. Sure. The car is old and it has been updated,
but it hasn't been substantially updated. So, you know,
I kind of figure if you've got one, you've had one.
So why would you buy the same thing over again?
I'm sure there's some people that do that, but for the most part, it needs,
you know, a ground up redo and not just a refresh in my opinion. Okay.
Number 14 is the BMW X two. I dropped an average of 13.5%.
Yep. Now that is a slightly smaller dollar difference because it's just a more
affordable car of 3,874 and the average price is now 24,878.
Now we do have a tendency to see this and we'll see this more in the list.
These entry level luxury products do not hold their value very well.
We're going to see that from other manufacturers, but um, yeah,
if you want to, if you want to save money,
it's good to buy something like an X to use versus purchasing it new.
Yeah. The other thing about the X two is, um, you know,
BMW has sliced that pie into so many segments, right? X one, X two,
X three, X five, X seven, right? There's just way too many of them.
I think I know people love crossovers,
but it's just kind of expensive and small.
Well, the next car on the list, also a luxury BMW crossover,
the X seven down 13.9% nearly $9,000 difference year over year.
Average price is 55, three, three, three. Um, you know,
same kind of thing that we were talking about a little bit earlier.
These premium vehicles typically have a harder time holding their value
relative to the market unless that, um,
premium vehicle starts with the P and ends in Porsche. Um, but yeah,
X sevens can be had for a bargain on the use market.
There's also a brand new generation, which isn't helping with use values.
Yeah. I like the X seven a lot, but you know, it's a three row, uh,
SUV crossover from a very luxurious sporty brand.
I kind of feel like if you're in America and you want a three row,
you're going to go big.
And of course I'm talking about the towel or the suburban or the Yukon, uh,
and you're going to probably pay less than you will for the X seven. All right.
Number 12, a Mercedes Benz AMG GT,
an average of 14.8%. Yeah, that's down 14.8%.
And that's a dollar value of 13,840,
which brings the sticker price to 79 808. Now,
actually this is an interesting product.
The AMG GT has been around for a couple of years now.
And if you want a super car for kind of premium car money,
this is a great car. I think it's one of the best looking cars on the market.
Incredible performance.
And I think a car that will probably longterm go up in value cause they didn't
make a ton of them and it's gorgeous, but that is a good used car value right
there. It's just terrible to buy one new and then lose that money.
Yeah. I mean, it's going up against a nine 11 Tommy. Uh,
and that's a iconic car that, you know,
people of my generation had on the wall. Uh,
and nobody of my generation had a Mercedes Benz AMG GT on the wall.
So it didn't exist when you were, I know that's what I'm saying. Yeah. Yeah.
So,
so it's not something that people of my generation who have that kind of
disposable income necessarily lust after. Uh,
and it's hard to go up against the Nikon. Okay.
Now the next one is surprising is the Ram 1500 classic.
Uh, it's down 14.9%. Yeah.
So that's a dollar amount of 4,634 and the average price is just $26,000.
Problem with the classic generation of the Ram 1500 is they kept building it
after the new gen came out,
which means that new you can get one for a pretty substantial discount.
But unfortunately in the used market,
they don't hold their value as well because even though you might have bought a
2022 Ram, it's the same as a 2014 Ram.
And that's going to hurt the value of the used market.
I would say that you couldn't get much of a discount on the new ones and that's
why they fall into this price. This is probably where they should be new.
I mean, when you think about it, a Ram classic,
which you can still buy as a three generation old truck.
Now I'm not saying they're making it, but they're still out there. Uh,
and you know, paying, well add 4,000 to that $30,000 for a truck that was
designed what? 20 years ago. Seems crazy. All right.
Number 10 is the Land Rover Range Rover Velar. It's down 15%. Yeah.
So we actually have a string of three JLR products at four JLR products in a row
here. Unfortunately,
Jaguar Land Rover still struggles on the retail side of thing.
I think in recent years they have vastly up their quality from where they used to
be maybe 15 years ago,
but unfortunately the market does not see that in the same way.
So the Velar is down 15% year over year or nearly $6,700 average price is 37
grand. The Evoke is that number nine down 15% $5,395.
The average price is just 30 grand for an Evoke.
So you can get pretty decent deals on Evokes. And then of course,
the Range Rover sports is down 15.2% nearly $10,000 and the average price is 53
grand. And then the Jaguar E pace is down, um,
16.3% now outside of the Jaguar E pace,
the Velar Evoke and the Range Rover sport are basically the same car, Tommy,
just different sizes.
Well it's interesting that you are not seeing any of the kind of flagship JLR
products. So no full size Range Rover on this list and no defender,
no F type. That's right. No defender.
So it's clear that as we saw with like that BMW X two more entry level premium
crossovers simply just take in value after a few years of ownership.
So they mark number 10, nine, eight, and seven JLR.
And then number six we enter the world of electrics again,
dad with the Chevrolet Bolt EV.
So the percent year over year is down 18.3% that's $4,000.
The average price, 17, 863.
Now that actually is interesting because I have seen a bunch of bolts around
that $17,000 point used online,
but you really don't see many under like 12 or 13.
So they all kind of seem to hover right around that $18,000 price point.
And as you know, we owned a bolt on, it was a very good car, plenty of range.
Um, certainly a, certainly a great runabout in the city.
And I would say that this, uh,
reflects the fact that GM had a really bad experience rolling it out.
As you know, they did a stop sale, Tommy, uh,
they told people not to park them inside. And that is, you know,
pretty much the death toll for any vehicle when the manufacturer says don't park
this inside because it may start your house on fire.
Well, they, first of all,
I think it was a total of like 12 or 13 bolts that had any kind of,
um, thermal problems out of the hundreds of thousands that they sold.
I mean, if you look at it on a percentage basis, it was tiny,
but the damage had been done.
Well, they also had to replace the batteries on those first gen.
Great used cars to buy because they all have new battery packs. Um,
so really good. You know, you're getting a fresh battery in a bolt and actually
same thing with the number five car on the list, the Kona electric,
another car that saw new battery packs as well down 18 and a half percent down
to 21,000, four 66 Kona EVs also had similar problems when they,
when they first launched. Also excellent cars, maybe a little bigger,
you get a little bit more of a crossover shape, which is desirable.
Same problem with number four, which is the Nissan leaf.
Those didn't start fire though. They were just bad.
They just had bad battery packs.
I'm just saying you have like one chance to make a first impression.
And if that first impression is, you know,
the battery needs to replace after you've driven it, you know,
500 miles because it's not climate cooled with the leaf.
Or if you have to replace the battery pack as with the Kona and the Chevrolet,
I think it just gets the reputation out there.
The car is not something that you necessarily want to invest in.
And people are afraid of it because there's a lot of choice.
So why would you invest in something where, you know, your neighbor's like, Hey,
did you hear that that thing starts houses on fire and whether it does or not
almost becomes irrelevant because at that point the reputation actually precedes
the vehicle.
Yeah. I mean,
Leafs do have battery degradation issues because of the lack of climate
controlling. I don't think it's 500 miles. I think that's,
I'm just joking. I'm being, yeah, that's pretty extreme.
But it is true that after 50, 60, 70,000 miles,
especially in hot climate leaf battery packs do degrade.
It's a really big problem with Leafs that not a problem with ball TVs,
not a problem with Kona electrics. They hold up really well,
but leaf specifically the grade pretty substantially,
which is why it's down 20.2% year over year and average price is 16,243.
Now we actually leased a leaf this year for $9 a month and it is a great little
car. I really fell in love with it. And if you can get one on a cheap lease,
if you can get one on a cheap deal, new, like after incentives in Colorado,
you can get a brand new leaf for like 14 and a half grand,
great little cars to run around in,
especially if you don't live in an extreme climate like Arizona where it gets a
hundred. Yeah. And then look,
there's a lot of folks that live in temperate climates that get a lot of miles
out of the leaf batteries before anything happens. But, um,
and also it used to be that headline that, you know,
the leaf needs a $30,000 battery replacement. It's not the case.
It's actually come down quite a lot, especially in the aftermarket, but still it's,
it's worth noting.
All right, here we go. Top three, Tommy.
So this probably is not much of a surprise,
but the Maserati Levante is going to be at our number three point down 20.2%
$11,000 a year over year for an average price of $43,000.
Yeah. The problem with the Maserati is there's more FCA because that's when it
was introduced. Then, um, Maserati and the thing, right? There's a lot more,
too many product parts sharing went into that.
I remember when we reviewed ours and I thought to myself, Oh my God,
this has the same switch gear as a Chrysler. Um, you know,
has the same Uconnect as everything else. Uh, and it was unfortunately one of
those, uh,
I would call it a money grab where at that moment in time,
Porsche had shown that you could make a lot of money by being a sports car
manufacturer and building an SUV. Uh,
and so everybody kind of jumped on that bandwagon, including Maserati,
and they kind of built a half baked SUV. Uh, that was really, like I said,
not much Maserati.
They did a fantastic version of the Levante called the Trofeo,
which had a 580 horsepower twin turbo 3.8 liter V8.
That was actually a really cool version that not a lot of people know about,
but you're right. The standard Levante's suffered in quality.
They suffered with not having bespoke materials and switch gear.
And that definitely is reflected in the price drop.
Yeah. And let's face it.
Maserati has never had the same reputation as Lamborghini or Ferrari.
They're kind of like the, uh, the Italian sports car in this case,
Italian SUV that you buy, uh, if you want to impress your neighbors,
but don't have, you know, the budget for a Ferrari or a Lamborghini.
All right. Number two, Tommy, the Kia Niro EV, uh, down 21%.
So similar platform as like the Kona electric front wheel drive only great
little runaround cars. They really are nice to drive. Um,
year over year difference is down 5,700 bucks.
Average price is just $21,000.
So roughly the same exact, uh, use price as like a Kona EV.
Um, but yeah, they, they saw pretty significant depreciation year over year.
So a good car to buy used. Um, there's a new generation now as well,
which just recently debuted. Um,
so we'll see how that does compared to the first kind of a funky design,
isn't it? Yeah. It's kind of, it's not everyone's taste.
It's a funny looking car. It's a little weird. Yeah.
It's a little roly poly and weird, but good deals to be had used.
And number one, another electric vehicle,
the Tesla model Y has the biggest difference year over year down model three.
Oh, model three. Yes. Not Y three.
The Y is doing well. Cause it's a crossover. The sedan is not doing so well.
It's down 24.8%. Yes, that's right. That was a bad flub,
but that's a year of your difference of $8,500.
And the average price on a model three is $25,931.
16,000 on our model three performance.
So we, we definitely beat the average there in one year.
We bought ours at like 51 and sold it at like 36, something like that. So yeah,
we lost a ton of money on a model three as do a lot of people that buy them new.
However, if you can find them used for that mid $20,000 point,
very little battery degradation, excellent cars,
very fast and not a lot of reliability problems.
So they're doing really well from a car standpoint,
just not from a value standpoint.
There's a lot of things that are happening here and it's kind of the perfect
storm. Obviously, you know,
we hit a moment in time when electric cars became out of favor.
A lot of people felt like they were being forced to drive them.
So there was a lot of pushback. Then of course,
Hertz dumped I think a hundred thousand of these things on the market because
you know, Hertz wasn't doing very well renting them.
And then perhaps another factor is that, you know, Mr. Musk, you know,
who is synonymous with Tesla gave a giant middle finger to the state of
California and to most of the buyers of his model three for some mysterious
reason. And I think you combine all those three things and you've got a car that
is actually really good, but that has lost a boat ton of money.
So if you're out there thinking you want to dip your toe in the electric market
and you don't want to spend a lot of money,
a Tesla model three is actually a really good place to start.
If you can live with the amount of space that a sedan has versus, you know,
a crossover like the model Y.
Now, interestingly enough,
there were 15 cars with the biggest price gains as well.
Let me give you the top three.
Chevy Camaros are actually up in value of 8.4% or 2,700 bucks.
Um, the Volvo S 90, which is a really weird one.
That's a big kind of flagship sedan,
really popular with livery services though, up 16% or $5,000.
Maybe people are missing those big old American, uh, or in this case, uh,
Swedish sedans, but that is a big old, uh, sedan.
And then interestingly enough, the Porsche 718 came in up 21.4%,
up $17,000 to an average price of 99 grand. So really fantastic list.
Um, over at IC cars,
if you want to see what cars are seeing the biggest price increases as well.
Couple like the M five Porsche Panamera, uh, Mitsubishi Outlander P have Lexus,
GX four 60 is up. So check out that list over at IC cars.
If you want to see the cards going up.
Yeah. And if you're looking for a bargain, uh, you know,
I would definitely look at the model three. Uh, if you want to, like I said,
dip your toe in the electric car world and not do it, uh,
with a lot of money at stake. Anyway, guys, uh, thanks for watching.
And as always, where should the head to tell me all TFL.com.
We've got more videos over there and we'll see you next time. Ciao.
