'Three Soldiers' (c. 1568) by Pieter Bruegel the Elder

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
16 Video Views·Oct 7, 2025
Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator Xavier F. Salomon discusses “The Three Soldiers” by Pieter Bruegel the Elder, one of only a few works by the artist outside Europe. Bruegel is best known for his lively and often comical peasant scenes, but here he takes as his subject three landsknechts, or German mercenary foot soldiers. Currently on view on the second floor of Frick Madison, this grisaille painting shows a drummer, a standard-bearer, and a fifer outfitted in flamboyant costume (and presumably urging their fellow soldiers into battle).
Good evening.
Welcome to this episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
I am Xavier Salomon, the Deputy Director
and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator at The Frick Collection.
Thank you for joining us this evening
and thank you for joining us already for 62 episodes
of Cocktails with a Curator for more than a year.
Most of what we do at The Frick,
in terms of research, in terms of programming,
is thanks to your support and thanks to your generosity,
the members and everyone who donates to The Frick.
So thank you for this.
We're reaching the end of our financial year
at the end of June, on June 30th.
And if you would like to donate to the annual fund,
you can do so by clicking on the right
and we would be very, very grateful for that.
Thank you.
For those who come and visit Frick, Madison,
one of the very first paintings that you see
on the second floor at the beginning of the installation
in the area dedicated to Northern European art,
which is art north of the Alps,
in the areas, the geographical area,
that is today the countries of Germany,
the Netherlands and Belgium,
you find a small little painting on the left,
which is a tiny panel painting
by Peter Bruegel the Elder,
one of the most important Northern artists
of the sixteenth century.
This was a late acquisition by the museum.
It entered the collection in 1965,
so long after Henry Clay Frick had died,
and it was acquired by the trustees
and the director of the museum at the time.
It is signed and dated at the bottom left.
Here you see Bruegel's name very clearly,
painted on the bottom of the panel,
with the date 1568,
which is just a year before Bruegel died.
The little painting is a grisaille.
A grisaille is a monochrome painting,
very limited use of colors.
In this case, it's black, brown, and white.
And as we will see,
this is directly linked to the world of printmaking
and, of course, also to drawing.
There are very few works by Bruegel outside of Europe,
and this is one of them.
And so we're very fortunate
to be able to show this painting.
It represents, as we will see, three German soldiers.
And because of that, I am drinking a Radler.
And a Radler is a very typical cocktail in Germany.
Radler means cyclists.
And versions of this exist, of course, in other countries.
In the Anglo-Saxon world, this would be known as a shandy.
And in Italy, for example,
it is known as a bicicletta, a bicycle.
It is equal parts of lager beer and lemonade.
But, of course, it can be done
with a number of other soft drinks,
other sodas, ginger ale.
And the strength of the drink,
the ratio of the lemonade versus the beer,
is something that is up to different people's taste.
I usually drink half and half.
And this is because, of course,
these German soldiers in Bruegel's painting
and Bruegel himself
would have mainly been drinking beer at the time.
I doubt they would have mixed it with lemonade.
But in honor of them, I am drinking my Radler.
Cheers.
This small painting entered the Frick Collection in 1965,
but it comes originally
from one of the most important collections
in Europe in the seventeenth century.
We actually don't know who it was painted for,
and we don't know where it was between 1568,
when it was painted,
and the first half of the seventeenth century,
when it first appears in the collection
of King Charles I of England.
Charles was one of the greatest collectors of the age,
and he assembled in London
and in the royal residences of England
one of the greatest collections of the time,
not only of paintings but also classical antiquities
and a number of other objects.
In the inventory of 1639,
the painting, the Bruegel painting,
appears in the Palace of Whitehall.
Here, of course, you see Charles I
in one of the famous Van Dyck portraits of him.
And we don't know exactly
how Charles got hold of the painting.
One of the inventories of the royal collection
mentions that the small Bruegel was a gift
by Indemian Porter,
who was a diplomat and a close friend of the king,
who had been ambassador,
had been on a diplomatic journey to the Netherlands.
The inventory mentions that Indemian Porter
gave the painting to the king as a gift.
However, on the back of the Bruegel painting
there is a mark with the initials C.P.,
which were the initials used by Charles
when he was Prince of Wales, before he became king.
So the dates of Indemian Porter's trip
and the possibility of him giving the painting
to Charles as a gift doesn't quite match.
It seems very likely, because of the mark,
that Charles already owned the painting earlier on,
before becoming king, when he was Prince of Wales.
Anyway, the painting remained in the royal collection
until the eighteenth century,
but not without some interruptions.
Of course, Charles I is also known,
apart from his art collection,
for the turbulent times that led to the Civil War,
to his beheading,
and to the institution of the Commonwealth
under Oliver Cromwell,
and the subsequent restoration
under his son, King Charles II.
The Bruegel was sold during the Commonwealth sale in 1653,
and it was acquired by a private individual
and then only later restituted or acquired back,
we're not sure, by Charles II
and returned into the royal collection.
It remained there until at least
the first half of the eighteenth century.
It appears in a number of inventories.
It is then moved to Kensington Palace,
and it is inventoried as being at one point in storage.
And this shows very directly, very clearly,
the fame of Bruegel through this period of time.
A great artist in the seventeenth century,
but by the eighteenth century very much out of fashion.
It seems that the painting then belonged
to a secretary of one of the kings of England,
possibly given to him as a gift,
and then it went through a number of collections in England.
And as far as we know, it never left England
between the seventeenth century and the 1960s.
In 1960, the painting reappeared on the market
in Wingham, near Canterbury,
and it was bought by a dealer from Ramsgate
and then subsequently through the dealer Agnews,
acquired by the Frick in 1965.
Peter Bruegel the Elder is one of the most significant
and important painters who was active
north of the Alps in the sixteenth century.
This is a very beautiful and famous drawing by him
in the Albertina in Vienna,
which shows the artist and the connoisseur,
or the collector.
It is probably meant to be a satirical work,
but it shows, of course, the prototypes,
the typical view of the two figures.
So on the left, the disheveled, creative genius
of the artist who holds his brush
and is in the act of painting.
On the right, the collector, maybe the connoisseur,
the critic, with his thick glasses,
and, of course, putting his hand into his purse
with the desire to buy the work of art.
It has been said, we don't know for sure,
but it's probable that this is also a self-portrait
by Bruegel, and so this is one of the rare images
and the only one by the artist
that we would have showing what he looked like.
We don't know exactly when Bruegel was born.
In the early sixteenth century,
we don't know exactly where.
He starts being active as a painter
in the late 1540s, early 1550s,
and he dies in 1569.
Most of his career is spent
between the cities of Antwerp and Brussels,
in Flanders, in today's Belgium.
But in the early 1550s,
he spends probably a substantial amount of time
traveling south, down to Italy,
definitely in Rome,
probably all the way to southern Italy,
with the intention, it has been said,
of traveling to Sicily.
There are a number of drawings
recording some of the sights
that Bruegel saw on the Strip.
But Bruegel, of course, is best known today
for his depictions of peasants.
This is the Peasants' Wedding,
and these are the type of scenes
that we usually think Bruegel is creating,
scenes that are very rich in details,
often very funny and humorous details,
but also often imbued
with allegorical or moral significance.
Bruegel also worked on subjects
of religious scenes,
but the religious scenes,
like this one, for example,
the building of the Tower of Babel,
become really an excuse
for these fantastic landscapes
that Bruegel depicted
and some of the greatest things
he ever produced.
So here is the great towering mass
of the tower being built.
But what is extraordinary
is the fantastic landscape
with the sort of minutest details
all the way down to the horizon
in the background.
And, of course, in the foreground on the left,
the stonemasons at work
on the blocks to build the tower.
Bruegel is an artist
whose sense of observation
is remarkable and astounding
even for us today.
Arguably the best works by Bruegel
are the set of the seasons
or the months of the year.
Five of them survive today.
It is unclear
if originally there were twelve
or most likely a set of six,
so there's probably only one missing.
These are large panels
that represent different moments
in terms of the seasons of the year.
Probably each panel was meant
to be identified
with two months of the year.
Here is one of the three in Vienna,
three out of the five
are in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna.
This is winter, of course,
this wonderful snowy, icy landscape.
The hunters are returning
from the hunt on the left
with rather meager results.
The wonderful detail of the dogs,
the sort of famished
and somewhat defeated dogs
who are trying to hunt in the snow.
And on the right, again,
the wonderful detail of the ice skaters
on the frozen lakes below.
A fourth painting,
which represents early summer,
is now in the Lobkowitz Collection in Prague.
And this, again,
shows a number of peasant figures
in the sort of early summer landscape,
the moment of haymaking.
And the only one of the seasons
outside of Europe
is the harvesters
at the Metropolitan Museum here in New York,
which shows, of course,
the height of summer
and the harvest in the fields.
This is arguably
one of the most important
Old Master paintings in New York City,
and it is a truly extraordinary work of art.
I've spent many hours at the Metropolitan
lost in contemplation of this painting.
Again, the extraordinary bird's-eye view
down to the far-distant landscape,
the men at work in the foreground,
but also the central area
with this group of peasants
resting under the tree,
presumably in the middle of the day
at the height of summer,
the height of heat.
They're resting, they're eating.
Bruegel is really an artist
who presents details
in such lyrical and poetic ways.
He is an artist
that encourages all of us
to view his paintings
for sustained and prolonged viewing
and noticing all these wonderful details
and these wonderful effects,
in this case also the beautiful,
foggy, distant landscape
towards this body of water,
possibly the sea.
Bruegel was also an extraordinary draftsman
and very involved in printmaking.
This is one of my favorite drawings by Bruegel,
which shows this group of figures
holding these large baskets.
And they're wearing
these remarkably strange outfits
with these hoods
and things protecting their faces.
This is because of the figure's job.
These are beekeepers.
And, of course, this is a protection
against the bees
as they move the beehives
around in this landscape.
We don't know if this was just
a finished drawing by Bruegel
done as a work of art by itself
or if this was preparatory
for an engraving or a print
that wasn't made
or even for a painting.
But there are a number
of very finished drawings
by Bruegel of this kind.
Our painting, of course,
relates to the world
of Bruegel's drawings
and Bruegel's prints,
mostly because of its monochromatic nature
but also because of its size
and its subject,
which was very directly linked
to printmaking at the time.
As I mentioned at the beginning,
these are three German soldiers.
There are only three figures
in this painting.
They're all doing
slightly different things.
Their costumes are very similar,
but the man on the left,
seen from the back,
is playing a drum.
The central one
is holding a flag, a standard.
The one on the right
is a fifer playing the flute.
Everyone at the time
would have recognized
these characters as Lansknechts.
Lansknechts were a type
of mercenary German army,
foot soldiers of the time.
The word Lansknecht
actually means servant of the land.
So here they are
with their typical swords.
Here is the one
that you see very clearly
in the foreground on the drummer.
Their hats,
they have these plumed hats
that are often usually worn
on top of a second headgear,
which is a net, a fabric net,
over the hair,
on top of which then
the hat would be placed.
The fifer has
a slightly different hat,
a fur-trimmed hat.
But again, you see
that the costume
with the sort of slashes
in the fabric,
the sword, again,
which here appears in the back
rather than at the front,
are very typical of these men.
Bruegel probably took inspiration
from a number of prints.
This is a print,
much earlier print,
a print from 1519
by Lucas van Leyden
showing the so-called dance
of Saint Mary Magdalene.
There are a number
of couples and figures
doing a number of things
in this print.
But in the middle ground,
at the back near the tree,
in the center,
you see a drummer and a fifer.
Very similar in many ways
to the depictions,
not quite the same costume,
but similar in their actions
to the ones
in the Bruegel painting.
Here is another print
slightly later,
from the 1530s,
by Jakob Bink,
which also shows
this engraving,
three langsknechts.
And again you see
the same combination
of the standard bearer,
the fifer in the center,
and the drummer on the right.
So why would you have
these three typical figures?
Now, langsknechts
were always accompanied
by these three figures
at the head of their groups.
Mercenary armies existed in Europe
all the way back
to the Middle Ages,
and they were
usually Swiss mercenaries,
but later on,
as in this case,
also German.
They were paid
by whichever ruler
needed an army.
In the sixteenth century,
the langsknechts were used
by the emperor
and by the King of Spain,
which, of course,
for a large part
of the sixteenth century,
in the person of Charles V,
it is the one and same person.
Charles V was both
King of Spain and emperor.
Charles uses the langsknechts
on a number of occasions
and on a number
of great battles
that he fights and wins,
and a number of other rulers
also used them
before and later on.
But the langsknechts
were always headed
by the standard bearer,
which, of course,
after the captain,
was one of the most important
figures of the militia,
of the group.
And, of course,
he held the standard
they were fighting for.
And he was accompanied
by two musicians,
a drummer and a fifer.
And that is really
to sort of enliven
the marching of the soldiers,
but then also
to encourage them
to get into battle
and to fight.
So the representations
of langsknechts
are often related
to these three figures
as a group together,
as in this case.
And, of course,
also in this print by Bink,
you have the figure
from the front,
the figure from the back,
the figure in the background
in a slightly different order
and with slightly different roles
than the Bruegel.
Here is another
sixteenth-century print
of langsknechts.
And here again
you see the slashed fabric
of the sleeves
and the trousers
of the figures,
the plumed hats,
the fifer,
the drummer,
the standard bearers.
Many of these costumes
would have been
immediately recognizable,
and these figures,
to Bruegel's public
at the time
and even probably later
in the seventeenth century.
Now, the langsknechts,
of course,
were known
for their fierce fighting
and battling.
As I said,
they were foot soldiers,
usually armed with spikes
and large swords.
And they become very famous
in sixteenth-century Europe
for a rather dark moment
in the history of Europe,
which is the sack of Rome
in 1527.
The Emperor Charles V,
for a number of reasons,
unleashes his mercenary army
on Rome
and basically pays them
by allowing them
to sack the city
and take anything they want.
And so for several weeks
in the spring of 1527,
Rome is sacked.
Many buildings are destroyed.
They're set on fire.
Here you see,
for example,
in the background,
a view of the Tiber
with the Castel Sant'Angelo,
where the Pope took refuge.
And you see the smoke
and the flames
of the sack around it
and fighting on the right.
And, of course,
this represents one
of the key moments
of the sack in the center.
Mercenary armies
were very much part
of European life
until fairly modern times.
And one of these armies
still exists,
and of course
is the Swiss army
of the Pope,
the Swiss Guard.
And the Swiss Guard
was created
in the early 1500s
by Pope Julius II.
It is always said
that the costume,
of course,
of the Swiss Guard
was designed
by Michelangelo,
even though
there is really
no evidence for that.
But the Swiss Guard,
as it still exists today,
is composed
of young Swiss men.
They have to be
Swiss citizens.
Right now,
they have to be
between the age
of 19 and 30.
They have to be unmarried,
and they have to be Catholic.
And they are
in the service
of the Pope
as his private bodyguard
and as the army
in charge today
of defending the Vatican.
It is the only
last survival
of this tradition,
which, as I say,
goes back
to the Middle Ages.
But Swiss Guards
existed in a number
of other countries
in the 17th
and 18th century.
The King of France,
especially,
also had Swiss Guards
protecting him.
These remain,
of course,
planks, necks,
and a number
of other mercenary armies
of the 16th century
don't exist anymore.
Bruegel painted,
as far as we know,
at least three
grisaille paintings,
so three black-and-white
monochromatic paintings.
This is one
at the Courtauld
Institute of Art gallery
in London,
which shows Christ
and the woman
taken in adultery,
a gospel scene,
of course,
very similar in technique
to our planks, necks,
but very different
in terms of subject matter.
And the third
and the largest of the three
is the death
or dormition
of the Virgin.
So, again,
another biblical gospel story.
In this case,
this is also
in the United Kingdom
at Upton House,
a country house in England.
The three grisailles
by Bruegel
were brought together
in 2016
in a beautiful little exhibition
by Karen Serres,
which, for the first
and only time,
reunited all three
of Bruegel's grisailles.
We don't know
if more were made,
and we don't know
what they were painted for.
They're clearly not a series.
They're different formats.
They're obviously
very different subject matters,
especially ours.
It is unclear
if these were preparatory
for engravings,
in which case
no engraving survives
after hours,
or, more likely,
they were paintings
in their own right
as sort of single works of art,
painted probably
for specific patrons
and for reasons
that are unknown to us.
What is the moment
represented in our little Bruegel?
Is this just a march
through the countryside
of the Landsknechts,
led by the drummer, Pfeiffer,
and standard-bearer?
Or is it a more dramatic moment,
the sort of entrance into battle?
Is this the moment
where they're preparing for battle,
the standard-bearer
is raising the flag
as the others
incite the army to fight?
We don't know.
And what we don't know either
is if this is just a painting
representing a genre scene,
a scene of everyday life,
three soldiers,
three figures
that Bruegel would have observed
in Flanders at the time,
in the same way
that he would have observed
peasants or beekeepers
or ice skaters on the lake.
Or is it imbued in some way
with a moral meaning
of some kind
or an allegorical meaning?
We're not entirely sure.
But the fact that prints
survive of this subject
from Europe at the time
shows that it was
a very popular subject
and something that was represented
in Northern art
a number of times.
It is still a mysterious picture
in many ways.
Many questions
around this little work
are still impossible to answer,
but more research
hopefully will allow us
or our successors
to be able to find out more
about this work.
Research of these works
is, of course,
very, very important.
We find more information
as people study them
and try to answer
some of these questions.
Of course, we're very proud
to have this Bruegel at the Frick.
It's not clearly
as important or marvellous
as the Harvesters at the Met,
but it is the only Bruegel grisaille
in the United States
and one of the very few paintings,
autographed paintings,
by him in this country.
Thank you for joining me
this evening.
As I said,
it's been more than a year
that we've been working
on Cocteaux with a Curator
and that we've been sharing
these stories with all of you.
It has been
an incredible experience
and it has been a real pleasure
to share all of this research,
our love for these works of art
with all of you.
And the response from the public
has been absolutely extraordinary
and for this,
we're very, very grateful.
The programme started
very much as related
to the pandemic,
to the closure of the museums,
to us staying at home
and not being able to travel.
After more than a year,
the light seems to shine
at the end of the tunnel.
We hope that we're all going
in the right direction
here in New York City,
but also across the United States
and in the rest of the world.
We are heading,
it seems at least,
we hope,
in the right direction.
Many things are now possible again.
Of course, museums have been open
for a while
and now are welcoming people
from all around the country
and abroad.
Frick Madison has been open
since March.
And we're all beginning
to travel again
and to go back
to our normal lives.
So as summer is approaching,
we will be bringing
Cocktails with a Curator
to a close
on the 16th of July,
in the middle of July.
So we have three more episodes
after this one,
which will bring us
to 65 episodes,
65 weeks that we've been sharing
this journey with all of you.
And again, we're so thankful
for you to follow us in this.
Not quite with a drummer
and fifer
and a standard-bearer,
but maybe in some ways
I think this painting
could be somewhat allegorical
of Amy, Giulio, and I.
I can see the three of us
working as a team,
leading all of you,
all of us in some way,
marching through this dark time
of the pandemic.
In the next three episodes,
Amy, Giulio, and I
will say our goodbyes
and we'll present
three last works.
And we look very much forward
to these next three weeks
and to seeing you again
for the next three episodes
of Cocktails with a Curator.
Cheers!
