Uncover the Story Behind Michelangelo's Iconic Pietà

Michelangelo
23 followers
15 Video Views·Oct 5, 2025
You can follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stories.of.art/
Join me on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/Storiesofart/?ref=bookmarks
It was one of his first big commissions. He had only made one full scale sculpture before, yet he made one of the most beautiful and moving sculptures in history. And unbelievably, he was only 24 years old.
In this video, I tell you the whole story about this masterpiece by Michelangelo.
Hi, welcome to Stories of Art. My name is Karel Huidekoop.
Today I'm going to tell you the story of this incredibly famous sculpture called the Pietà
by Michelangelo. He made it between 1498-1499 and incredibly he was only 23-24 years old when
he made it. It is one of his earliest large commissions and it's the only work that he ever
signed. Today it's sometimes hard to imagine that someone like Michelangelo even had early work. I
see him as one of the greatest artists that ever lived. He was one of the greatest sculptors as
well as one of the greatest painters and architects not just of his age but of any age. He would
become this giant in the world of art and an inspiration to people not just in his generation
but all the way through the centuries and even nowadays people find inspiration in his work
some five centuries later. So it can be strange to realize that he too had humble beginnings and
he struggled as an artist at first. I mean he started of course as an apprentice to a painter
named Domenico Ghirlandaio and he was accepted at the Medici court where he lived for several
years and was partially raised there and it was at that court that he didn't just study painting
and sculpture but also philosophy and history and he would start his lifelong fascination with
the work of Dante Alighieri. Actually at some point he would be seen as one of the leading
experts of the subject but at that court he would also learn to write poetry and it's likely that
at some point he saw himself as a sculptor first and a poet second and then all the other things
came after that. But just like everybody else he had to start somewhere which meant that he had to
search for commissions and had to do smaller jobs in various cities before he got his first breaks
his first big commissions and one of the earliest successes that he had was making a forgery.
The story goes that he had sculpted a sleeping cupid. At that time he was back at the Medici
court after having been away for a couple of years and Lorenzo di Pierfrancesco de' Medici
who was then the big man of the family said of this cupid that it was as good as anything the
ancient Roman and Greek had ever made. So he suggested that Michelangelo could sell it for
a higher price if he made it look older and bury it in Rome and then he could have it dug up by an
And according to the story they actually did this and the cupid was sold to a cardinal called
Raffaele Riario and apparently Riario found out that he was being deceived or actually had been
deceived and he wanted some of his money back. Now this is the story we don't know for sure if
it's true the whole forgery thing that is but what we do know is that Michelangelo had gone to Rome
and sold a small sculpture of his sleeping cupid to Raffaele Riario and then Riario commissioned
Michelangelo to make his first larger-than-life full-scale figure which was this Bacchus or
Dionysus which is now in the Bargello in Florence and it was a widely admired sculpture that led to
the commission for the Pietà because that commission then came from a man called Jean
Biller de Logralas who was a cardinal but also a diplomat for the French crown. Biller had decided
he wanted a monument for when he was to be buried and decided that he wanted to be buried in a
chapel right next to old Saint Peter's because Saint Peter's as we know it today hadn't been
built yet I mean Michelangelo would eventually build it but that was half a century after he
made this Pietà. Now in this case Cardinal Biller wanted a tomb in the chapel of Santa Petronila
which was a structure that stood next to old Saint Peter's. This picture is a 19th century
reconstruction of old Saint Peter's which is the church that stood before the current Saint
Peter's was built. The original Saint Peter's by the way was built in the 4th century so by the
time that Michelangelo came to Rome this church had stood there over a thousand years and that
had started to show. Frankly it was falling apart and for decades they had been arguing over if they
wanted to restore it or just tear down the whole thing and build a new church. Obviously eventually
they chose the latter but when they first built the original Saint Peter's it stood in a necropolis
which is a fancy form of a graveyard. There were many large and small mausoleums dotted around this
part of the landscape that was just outside of Rome. In fact the reason Saint Peter's was built
there is because they thought and many still think that the actual Saint Peter was buried right there
but when they built it it was set in between several other funerary monuments.
Two of those were these circular structures that you can still see on this picture where they thought
that some emperors had been buried although still we're not entirely clear which ones but these
structures were then repurposed to become the sacristy of Saint Peter's and the second one
became a chapel where various prominent people were buried and from the 9th century onwards many
French kings had been buried there and by that time it was known as the chapel of Saint Petronella
but with that French connection it wasn't surprising that Cardinal Billet wanted his
monument to be placed there and so that's what they did. He was eventually buried there and
the Pietà was part of his funerary monument. Later and by that I mean decades later when they
really started working on rebuilding Saint Peter's first one of these two circular structures was
demolished and then the second and I think it was the chapel of Saint Petronella that was kept
longest so that's probably this one in this drawing by Martin van Heemsker.
So that was what it was going to be made for and now Michelangelo set to work making his iconic
figure out of the best marble that money could buy which is from the Carrara quarries. By the way
we call it the Pietà that's because it's so very famous but technically it's a Pietà because it's
a familiar regular normal subject in art. It's a scene that is of course not mentioned in the bible
I've mentioned this in many videos but in the gospels of course the crucifixion is mentioned
and described and then the plea to bury Jesus and burial itself is mentioned but there's nothing
about what happened from the moment Jesus died on the cross to his burial. I mean we assume
obviously that his body was taken down but in the popular imagination scenes like this were added
where the body of Jesus was placed on the lap of his mother and she laments his death. Over time
it became one of the stages of the cross stage 13 and it's one of the seven sorrows of the virgin
but because it's part of those stages and of the sorrows it is something that has been depicted
quite often even though as a scene to depict it is quite awkward because of course you want to
have a Mary who is of a normal size who has to sit up with the body of an adult man sprawled across
her lap and it's incredibly difficult to make that into a coherent scene which is why it's often done
like this. In this version by Giotto actually called the lamentation she can hold his body while
it lays on the ground but when you look at this version which is from Austria from the 1420s
you start to see how difficult it is to balance this composition and there are several painted
versions like this one by Perugino that show this problem even clearer. I mean how do you fit a grown
man on the lap of a small woman and that is where we see the genius of Michelangelo because here we
can see that you can actually balance these two things. He managed to make the Virgin Mary hold the
body of Jesus in a seemingly natural way. All she has to do is to hold him up with one hand as he
lays across her legs. I mean it looks like such an effortless composition and that's the reason I
showed you the other ones. It is of course helped by the fact that she's wearing billowing clothes
because then so much of her anatomy can be hidden in all of these different folds because that way
he could secretly make her legs a little bit bigger than would be completely natural and with
all these great big folds in clothing even the priesthood could not be offended by the fact that
she spread her legs because her feet are wide apart of course and just look at how brilliantly
he made all of those folds in her clothing and of course the loincloth that Jesus was wearing.
Now when we focus on the body of Jesus Michelangelo made him look quite fit. It is an idealized body.
He's very thin but also quite muscular. This particular Jesus was in pretty good shape and
also you can barely see his wounds. The one in his side is just a little line a scratch and there's
small but clearly visible holes in his hand and his feet and she only props him up with one hand
and if you look at that hand under the armpit you can see that she pushes up because his skin is
that way and this emphasizes that his body isn't responding it's limp but it also shows us that
she's almost pulling him towards her as if she's going to hug him in this sort of unsure moment of
grief and wanting to hold her child and that little gesture to me makes it such a moving
sculpture even more than her face because that is somewhat unmoving. She isn't crying at least
not visibly. She holds her composure and in that she is part of the tradition of sculptures and
other depictions of the Virgin Mary where she's not just a mother of a human but also a mother of
God and the Queen of Heaven and that is what makes this not just a great sculpture but one of the
greatest ever. The fact that he combined a grieving mother and a regal figure all in one that is what
makes this absolutely amazing to me and it must also be noticed that she is very young. She looks
like a teenager and there's a good reason for that. In literary sources Mary is often described
as being forever young because of her virginity and her lack of sin and in particular this is
mentioned by Dante and it's quite possible that that influenced Michelangelo's decision to make
her so young and without flaws in her face and no wrinkles either. Now in 1499 this sculpture was
installed in the chapel of Saint Petronella and soon after it was placed there a famous story from
the life of Michelangelo took place. According to the story and you always have to take stories of
Michelangelo with a grain of salt because he dictated them to his biographers but the story
goes that there were two people standing in front of the Pietà. They were admiring it and Michelangelo
overheard them discussing who made this sculpture and one of them said that it was Cristoforo Solari
who was another Italian sculptor and this angered Michelangelo so much that he had himself
locked in the chapel that night so that he could carve his own name on the sash across the chest
of the Virgin Mary which now says Michelangelo Buonarroti Florentinus Faciebat which translates
to Michelangelo Buonarroti the Florentine made this. Of course we don't know if this story is
true but it is significant that it's the only work that Michelangelo ever signed and in his
biographies he expressed regret for doing that because he thought that that was blind vanity
although personally I think it's probably even more vain to assume that everyone will always
recognize your work even without it being signed. Now this sculpture stood in that little chapel
for a long time well actually for several decades until the whole chapel was demolished because
new Saint Peter's was going to be much bigger and needed the space and I'm actually not sure
where it was in between but at some point in the 16th century it must have been moved to its
current location in Saint Peter's and in one of the instances where they moved the sculpture
it was damaged the fingers of her left hand were broken off but it wasn't until the 18th century
1736 to be precise that that was restored and four new fingers had to be carved because the
old ones were lost actually that was not the only alteration that was done to it
in the 17th century Pope Urban VIII gave her a canonical coronation for that reason it was to
be crowned with a jewel crown and for that they drilled two holes in the back of Mary's head to
fix the crown to her later they decided to make two cherubs that could carry the crown over her
but luckily they have removed these two cherubs they're now elsewhere in Saint Peter's but we
know that at some point probably at the end of the 16th century it was moved to new Saint Peter's
and nowadays when you walk into the church and you turn right you see her in the first chapel
she's placed behind very thick protected glass which is a pity because you can't approach her
very closely but understandable because she was attacked back in 1972 by a mentally disturbed man
i'm not entirely sure why i have to specify that i mean if you attack sculptures like these
you're by definition mentally disturbed in my humble opinion but a man attacked Pieta with
a hammer while shouting i am jesus christ i have risen from the dead in english apparently as he
was australian but i'm not going to mention his name because i don't think idiots like that should
be mentioned but he managed to hit it 15 times before someone intervened and that was done by
an american man who i will name his name was bob cassilly who's there on his honeymoon he later
said and i quote i leapt up and grabbed the guy by the beard we both fell into the crowd of screaming
italians it was something of a scene and afterwards it turned out that people in the
crowd had taken the bits of marble that had fallen to the ground some of these bits were returned
later but notably not her fingers and not her nose the nose had to be reconstructed and for that they
carved out a little bit of marble from the back of the sculpture but i take a little bit of
satisfaction in the idea that the people who stole these fingers thinking they were the originals by
actually stole the ones made in the 18th century so nowadays you can see her but from a little bit
of a distance but let that not deter you she's still as beautiful as ever and if you want to go
there make sure you take a bit of time out of your itinerary because these days getting into
saint peter's isn't just walking in there's a lot of security checks and therefore a very long line
to wait in but obviously it's still very much worth the effort and of course when you are there
you are already in the vatican which is in rome so in my opinion you're already winning at life
now before you go there let me remind you that you could of course support this channel you can
do that by liking and subscribing and you could also share my videos with people you think might
be interested but you can also support this channel financially by hitting the thanks button
just below this video any support you can give is very much appreciated anyway thank you very
much for watching and i hope to see you again soon bye
