Financially RUINED After 1 Year? Here's How Our "Cheap" Land Rovers Have Held Up!

Family Auto
135 followers
#automobile #autos #cars #4wheels #luxurycar #sportcar #highspeedcar #testdrive #toyota #tesla #porsche #hyundai #rollsroyce #royall #suvs
Case and I both bought cheap used Land Rovers exactly one year ago and you all said we were
absolutely crazy idiots for doing so. Well this is how mine is doing. And I'll tell you how mine is
doing. And what the plans are to get it back on the road. So this time last year, Case, we both went
out and bought cheap used Land Rovers and why did we do that? Because they're awesome. Or as
videographer Alex says, because we're stupid. But no, we wanted to see what it was like
living with a vehicle that has probably the worst reputation online. They do have a bad reputation
and because of that, you don't see as many of them out there on the trails, which for us
makes them kind of cool. And the jokes that you guys have left have been endless. Oh yeah. And
tormenting. You know, if you want to go out in the Outback, you take a Land Rover. If you want
to make it home, you take a Land Cruiser. Take a Land Cruiser. Yeah. Ninety nine percent of Land
Rovers are still on the road. The other one percent made it home. Yes. But let me tell you
my experience. So this is a 2006 LR3 bought at auction for four thousand five hundred and sixty
seven dollars, which sounds like a horrible idea. And on paper, it is a terrible idea because this
has no maintenance history, no idea who the previous owners were. It's also a V6 powered,
which is actually the worst of the two motors in these. That's right. Yes, it has the wrong engine
and it had zero options. This car does not have automatic headlights. It does not have heated
seats. It does not have sunroof. I mean, this is the complete poverty spec LR3. It actually might
be to its credit. Yeah, to its credit. Exactly. And let me give you some stats. So in the past
year, I've driven this car eleven thousand miles, started at sixty eight thousand. Now it's at
seventy nine thousand miles. And believe it or not, it is still running. Really? And you've had
to do tens of thousands of dollars of maintenance. I'm coming on one hundred thousand dollars of
maintenance in the past year. Wow. Not bad. No. In this video, we'll walk you through exactly
what I've had to do with it. So started out as a bone stock LR3, popped the hood, bought this car
at the auction, sight unseen, didn't have a chance to drive it and got so lucky because it drove
just about perfectly. You like my dust? Yeah, it's very dusty, but you got hood struts and
they work. That's nice. I do. Yeah. And, you know, the only thing that didn't work
super well on this LR3 when I bought it was the A.C. So my dad had this crazy suggestion to go to
O'Reilly's and get those like A.C. repair in a can. Right. And I thought he was crazy. I thought
that was a marketing gimmick. Stuck a can of that in the system and it still blows perfectly cold.
Yeah, ever since. And then I know that you also took this to a shop and had them swap out the
transmission fluid on this, which is a bit of a process because these transmissions aren't really
meant to be regularly serviced. So they actually had to drop the whole original transmission oil
pan and replace it with a new one that does make it a lot more serviceable. So in the future,
that's going to be a lot easier. But that made that a bit of a big job. Yeah, that's right. And
basically all I've done to this vehicle from a reliability standpoint is maintenance. And that
is going to surprise some people. Believe it or not, nothing, literally nothing has broken on
this LR3 in 11,000 miles. Yeah. Just regular maintenance fluids, put tires on it. You did
spend some money on it by modifying it, putting some off-road things like you've got your winch
there. Yep. So I went out and bought this terra firma winch mount and 12,000 pound winch. Now
nothing is sponsored on this. This was all my money. This was a really affordable setup. Yeah.
Not super impressed with the quality. Like if you look at the fairlead here,
it is already rusting to hell. Oh, your hardware. That's fixable. The bigger problem though,
which I'm not too pleased with is they also got their rock rails. Yeah. And those are ugly. Yeah.
They are really not holding up well at all. Yeah. So in multiple places, you can see that black
finish is just flaking off. I like the design. I think it provides a lot of protection inside of
the car, but a lot of rust. Yeah. But these LR3s are kind of long wheelbase, at least compared to
my Disco 2. So having that rock slider is pretty nice to have. And I got to say for the money that
you spent and a couple of modifications that you've made, this is a vehicle that is really
nice and comfortable to drive on the road, albeit not the most heavily featured as you don't even
have heated seats, but it's also really capable off-road and you took it to Moab. And I do genuinely
mean this. I'm not being paid by anybody because everybody says I am. This has been, in my opinion,
my favorite SUV of all time because what it does is provide the best balance of on-road comfort
and sophistication and off-road capability better than any other SUV I've seen before or since the
LR3. I genuinely mean, I think that this is probably top three vehicles of all time in my
perspective from what it can do across the board. It's just so flexible. If you need to carry stuff
from Home Depot, you can. If you need to carry your mother-in-law, you can. If you need to,
you know, go drive up Hell's Revenge, you can. You can just do everything in an LR3.
Now, that being said, the reason our videographer Alex hates everything that we're saying right now
and is grimacing behind the camera is because he also has a first-year LR3, which has had several,
I mean, minor issues, wouldn't you say? Minor, very minor. Yeah, just too many of them. Yeah,
too many minor issues. Frequent things because I think it's had some deferred maintenance in the
past, previous owners just didn't mess with it a whole lot. And so these can become a headache
if you expect this to be a Land Cruiser with zero maintenance. You never have to show it any
new oil. You never have to take a wrench to it. It's never even blown as much of a fuse.
This is not going to be that, but this one in particular has been really solid. And actually,
a lot of these LR3s are surprisingly pretty, pretty durable. And I don't want to say I haven't
spent anything on this because I have the numbers here. Yeah. And I spent $2,044 on this LR3,
which sounds like a ton of money, but nothing has broken. All that money has been in maintenance.
So let me walk you through- Is that including your modifications?
Yeah. And like, yeah. So it's- That's not bad at all, man.
Yeah. If you include like the rock rails and the parts, it comes up to about three grand.
But what I've done to this vehicle has been preventative stuff. So like you talked about
the transmission, new transmission, full service, fluid, filter, and pan. That's a really big job.
From here on out, it's going to be really easy because these ZF transmissions were sealed for
life, which meant that unsealing them is paying the ass. But diff service, right? Front of rear
diffs. Transfer case service, right? It's gone through a couple of engine oil changes. And the
mistake that I've been making up until this point is I've been bringing it to shops to do that.
And you're paying, you know, $100, $120 an hour. Oh, absolutely.
So I could have cut down significantly on that if I did it myself, which is what I'm trying to do now.
Like I just did an engine oil flush and all these things. So look, I don't want that $2,000 to come
across as if it was nothing, because that's a lot of money. But I've only been doing stuff because
I know I want to keep this car long-term. Yeah.
So like servicing the diff, servicing the transfer case, the transmission, right? These are all
things that just need to be done at 80,000 miles on any car.
And now what you've invested into this for less than $10,000, you have a pretty modern,
very comfortable, and very capable SUV. It's awesome.
Well, let me show you how the inside has been holding up here. So 11,000 miles driven,
just less than the yearly average across the U.S., which is pretty good, I think,
case for me because I have a lot of cars to drive.
A lot of press cars too.
Yeah, I drive a lot of press cars, but I really love driving this thing so much that I've been
making it a priority. Interior's held up really well. It's got full power seats. So even though
this is a base model, it still has some nice features.
Oh, yeah, totally.
Leather interior, right? Power seats. It does have automatic climbing control,
which is really nice. And this interior is cool because it's not that luxurious.
So when everyone thinks Land Rover, they think of like really bougie, high-end Range Rover stuff.
These things are kind of like a Wrangler in terms of material qualities. And what that means is you
can take it out on a trip to Utah, get it filthy, and then you don't feel bad about it because you
just wipe down the hard-wearing plastics and move on.
It is. It's pretty rugged. It's funny, though, some of the things that they cost cut on because
Alex's LR3, for example, is highly optioned. And right here, he has a cup holder that pops out.
You do not. So that's one thing. They got rid of your cup holder.
I know. I know. And they got rid of like my aux port.
Yeah.
Right? So this is the basic radio. No aux port.
You've got a power passenger seat, but no heated seats. Where are their priorities at?
Yeah. And this one doesn't have the heated windshield wipers.
It doesn't have the sunroof, which has been really good.
Yeah. And then the only thing I think that's gone wrong on this,
which is already starting to go wrong, is the paint on the roof is just shot.
Yeah. And especially here in Colorado and especially something in a dark color like this,
the paint tends to suffer. That's not a uniquely Land Rover problem.
If we were looking at an old Chevy Tahoe, you'd be in the same boat.
One of my favorite features about this, in case I think yours does something a little similar.
No, it doesn't. Actually, I lied. This has a split tailgate.
Yeah. So you've got the top portion and the bottom.
This has been really great. So like we'll go out to a park with friends or you'll be like at a
hiking trail or something and you can just sit on the tailgate.
You got a little shield here to put on stuff. Huge trunk. I actually took this vehicle on
right after I got engaged to this vehicle on a Thanksgiving trip with my
new family and it drove it all the way to the eastern part of Kansas. It's perfect.
And you can even get seven seat versions of these.
Yeah, right. Which is really nice.
And here's what I want to emphasize too, is like this car,
what I think cars are is a place to make memories. And I've had more good memories in this LR3 than
anything. I mean, I got engaged, I got married, went on that family trip. This car took us on
our mini honeymoon to Moab, Utah. Took us through all of Utah. No problem. Super comfortable.
Morgan, my wife likes it. She likes how high it sits. She likes how much space it has.
She took it on her bachelorette trip. I mean, so this thing's getting used to high help.
Here's the thing at the end of the day, because people like to make things
very simple. They like to generalize. They like to say these vehicles are good
and these vehicles are bad. But the reality of it is that it's very nuanced.
This is a particular Land Rover that is a really good Land Rover. And that's true of most LR3s.
Then there's the other end of the spectrum, which is the type of Land Rover that I bought.
Yes, that's right. So Case has had some problems. We'll get to that in a sec. I do want to show you
one cool thing about this off-road. So let's cut to that now. One of the things I like most about
these Land Rovers is a lot of new cars have buttons and modes like this, right Case? Yeah,
and they do exactly nothing. Exactly. But what's cool about this system is it really transforms
what this thing can do. So first of all, you've got the low range, which is awesome. That's a
pre-req for any off-roader. And then you got the suspension height, which can jack this thing up
several inches. But then these are the secret sauce. This is the first vehicle to launch with
terrain response. And if you dial it into like the rock mode, it behaves completely differently
than the sand mode, which is completely different than the snow mode. And that's pretty rare. A lot
of modern cars do this, but it's all the same stuff. Yeah, and on the subject of oversimplifying,
people talk about how the air suspension on these is so terrible. That's true of other Land Rover
products. But actually the air suspension on these seems to be pretty solid. So this Land
Rover is still on its original airbags, as is Alex's LR3 that he hates. It's at least still
on its original airbags. So Alex, a videographer, his LR3, 140 something thousand miles. I think
part of the reason he hates his is it just hasn't been well taken care of. Yeah, exactly. So like
his fuel door doesn't stay closed. Sometimes he gets an error with, I think, his map sensor.
Yeah, it's stuff like that that is annoying. Yeah, I will admit. And if you're not really
looking for a vehicle to pour at least some time into, something like this might not be the right
vehicle for you to get. But you were talking about air suspension, right? This thing's got
80,000 miles. It's 18 years old now. Yeah, 18 years old. Oh my God. So this is cool. So this
is a Trenches Courses. And Land Rover from 06, I think, had a better four-wheel drive system
than some modern vehicles. Yeah, it's amazing how quickly it works. I wish all traction control
systems these days were this good. The other thing that's really good is the way that this
air suspension works. Because this vehicle, even though it's fully independent suspension in the
air, it still articulates. Yeah, right. And it's because it's called a cross-link air suspension.
So it is able to shift air around to the different bags to simulate a solid axle,
basically. Yeah, and even picking up tires as we are, you really don't have to fuss around
with the vehicle lurching back and forth and not wanting to climb an obstacle. It just does it.
Absolutely. You just get lightly on the throttle, you stay on the throttle, and it just goes.
Now, you brought up something interesting, Case. The funny thing about LR3s is I talk to a lot of
you guys who watch this channel, and a surprising number of you say, A, I bought my LR3 because I
watched some videos about it. Thank you. That's very kind. Or sorry, depending on your situation.
But B, hey, I've got 260,000 miles on it. It's been perfect. And then we get the comments that
I had one new, and after 30,000 miles, something crapped the bed. And it really seems that a lot
of the initial teething issues that these things had were when they were new, and sometimes people
just got a bad one. I see that a lot, too. Like, oh, I had one, and it just was a lemon.
Yeah, and a lot of these cheaper Land Rovers that are still around are well, at this point,
into the area of reliability. One of my good buddies even has a Discovery 2, which is,
by the way, not one of the good Land Rovers. Don't recommend it unless you're doing what I'm
doing with it, which is using it as a platform to build something else. And we'll show you that
in a second, in case it was a little crazy with his. But my buddy's Disco 2 is at 220,000 miles,
and it's driving well, and he daily drives it, and he absolutely loves the vehicle. He does have
to pour time into it, but then it drives fine once he keeps up with maintenance, and it's great.
You're right, and like, LR3s, I wouldn't hesitate most people to buy, because they're pretty solid.
Discovery 2s can be, yeah, you should probably avoid that. Really problematic. Same thing with,
like, early L322 Range Rovers, what they're called. Really bad. P38. P38 Range Rover's
terrible. Yeah, Range Rover Classic. Also bad. Also bad. It's mo stuff. Yeah, it's mo stuff,
but there are some gems. Like, LR3 is really good. First-gen Range Rover Sports. Yeah,
absolutely. What are they, that 06209? Yeah, you're right on the money, yeah. Basically anything
Ford-era. Yeah, exactly. Pretty good. Because they're running Ford engines. Yeah, more or less,
you're right. Yeah, sure. Well, folks, that's all I have to say about my Land Rover. I'm in it.
Just did all the math with the tires included. Right about $9,000. Gets about 15 mpg,
but we'll cut over to Case's and talk about what he's doing. Yeah, very different story. Yeah.
Unlike Tommy's Rover, mine needs a little bit of extra love, because these Disco 2s are not
known for having the best powertrains. When I bought this, that was always the plan, was to
put a different motor in it. And yeah, as you can see, I am not in the motor. I'm standing where the
motor should be. So what do you think, Tommy? Well, Case, we should rewind a little bit. So
did your old engine explode? What the heck happened? Why is it out of the truck?
No, it was having some, honestly, relatively minor issues. It was having a pretty persistent
misfire, which was annoying. And it's not a fun motor to work on, the original motor that's in
these, the 4-liter. So I decided, hey, now's as good of a time as any, because I've wanted to put
a different motor in this since I bought it. That was always the plan. So that was the reason that
I was like, all right, it's not driving well enough for me to want to really take it anywhere.
So I'm going to go ahead and tear that stuff out. Now, Case started with this vehicle completely
stock. He did the lift, wheels, and tires. And then what exactly was the misfire? Do you remember
what started happening? Yeah, I mean, it started having a more minor misfire not too long after
I bought it. And I did new plug wires on it. I didn't do the coils, which would have been smart
to do if I plan to keep the motor long-term. Doing the plug wires helped. And then it started
misfiring again after a while. It was running on seven, and I was still just kind of running it.
And then I think it was running on six at best. So at that point, I was like, okay, I can barely
merge in with traffic. So yeah, I rolled it in here, put it back on the stock wheels to get it
in because it's a four-inch lift. So my off-road tires are sitting in the backyard
because otherwise, yeah, it would not have fit in the garage. We tore out the old
four-liter Rover V8 and the four-speed ZF transmission. And now we have this guy, which
is an LS2 out of a C6 Corvette specifically. Here, I'll scoop behind you. We've been doing
a little bit of refreshing on it. So I did a new timing chain, a new oil pump,
some new sensors, some of the ones that are a little harder to get to,
new plugs, got a new alternator in a box, a new water pump to throw on it,
new starter motor, all that kind of stuff. But yeah, it is the real deal. I sold a Corvette
in order to buy this Land Rover and do this whole build. So part of what I wanted to do with it was
put a genuine Corvette motor back into it. So one of the cool things that I'm learning about
this project is when you hear folks, I'm going to LS swap something, I always thought that meant the
same thing regardless of the LS, but Case actually went through quite the process of determining what
motor to put in this Disco 2. So walk us through the options and why you went LS2. Most people put
5.3s in this, which would be the easiest way to go, especially because I've got a 6L80 transmission
there. So this is a six speed and this one's totally rebuilt, which is pretty nice. Six speed
GM transmission that this motor was not originally made it up to, which generally poses some
challenges. But again, I wanted a Corvette motor under the hood. It's just part of what got me
excited about the project. Because like I said, I used to have a Corvette. So in order to run this
Corvette motor and that 6L80 in, actually, I think it's this box. Let's see. Yeah, Holley. I've got a
Holley Terminator X Maxx electronics system that's going to run all of this, which is going to be
pretty sweet. That system super plug and play should make things a lot easier. And then I've
got some pretty cool parts. The nice thing about doing an LS swap, because people will talk about
a lot of times, oh, LS swap is boring. Everyone does that. It is boring. We're not those kind of
YouTubers. I'm not going to put like a Lamborghini V10 in this. I'm building this not as a YouTube
series, but as my actual personal daily driver. So because LS swaps are so common, you can get
parts like these, which is going to adapt my 6L80 transmission to the Land Rover transfer case.
And those transfer cases are actually pretty solid. Wow, dude. So this is, well, it's a chunky piece of aluminum.
Yeah. But all this is, is basically allows you to run that 6L80, which case is like, that's like a GM
heavy duty truck transmission, right? Exactly. Yeah. So it's a pretty hefty transmission, six speed,
which also here in the mountains compared to a four speed is going to be really nice.
That LS is not going to be any worse on fuel, really, than the stock motor. Twice the power, more
reliable. It doesn't really weigh much more, even though it's a six liter versus the old four liter.
Yeah. We've got cool pieces like this that will help us go from the output on the transmission
into the transfer case. Cool pieces that you can get because these LS swaps are so common
that make this a really easy process, which was kind of the goal. Yeah. And then once all this
stuff is in place, that plus the four inch lift and eventually going to lockers, I think this is
going to be a pretty sweet rig. Now, for those of you guys wondering, Case kind of went out and did
this the hardest way possible because there are kits online, which you can buy to adapt a small
block General Motors to the original transmission, and then even keep some of the OEM electronics in
play with like the throttle pedal and with the shifter and that kind of thing. But Case is going
to have to go all custom with that, right? Yeah. So you could do what a lot of people do is they'll
do a Gen 3, 5.3 LS to the stock transmission. And the stock transmission, most people say,
no problem in handling that extra power. And that is a big power boost from the stock motor. But
since we're here in the mountains, like I said, having that six speed is going to be really nice.
And to run that 6L80, you basically need to have a Gen 4 LS, which is going to be throttle by wire.
So necessarily, you're going to be getting away from the cable operated throttles. So all this
stuff is going to go away. This is not the best look for us talking about how our ownership
experiences with our Land Rovers has been. The cool thing for me is that this was always the idea.
These vehicles, they drive fantastic. They're awesome to drive. I love the way they look when
they're all done up. They're great off-road, just bad powertrains. But because LS swaps are so easy,
yeah, that can be solved really no problem at all. So I've got a bit more cleaning up to do
on the frame. Then we'll weld up these engine mounts. This all came from an Australian company
called Mark's 4WD. That does a pretty nice swap kit. And so this will sit over top the original
engine mounts, weld those in place, and then everything bolts together like big Legos.
Nice, dude. So this is going to be a pretty heavy-duty setup when it's all said and done.
Now, let's talk about where you went out and found a Corvette engine. Are there
sites that specialize in that? Where do you go and get one of these guys?
eBay.
eBay. Do you know the history when it comes from eBay, or is it kind of just a crapshoot?
A little bit. A lot of people, they're not putting up compression or anything,
but they'll tell you how many miles it supposedly has. They did have the VIN for the car that this
came out of, so I was able to basically confirm the amount of miles they said. It had about 88,000.
Looks like that's about right. And then when the motor shipped, it actually had oil in it,
so I sent off the oil to get analyzed by Blackstone, who Andre uses sometimes when we do
break-in oil on company-owned cars of ours. And the oil analysis turned out good. Thumbs up. No
red flags. Everything seems like it should be fine. So just some light refreshing on this motor,
and I think it's going to be happy as can be.
And these are rated at, what, 400 horsepower?
Yeah, six liter, LS2, 400 horsepower, aluminum block. I'm doing stock cam, all that kind of
stuff, and not doing anything crazy as far as power adders, because I just want this to be
powerful enough to cruise uphill, up I-70 on 33-inch tires and not have any issues. And that,
plus the six-speed, it's going to make this in the mountains way more drivable,
way easier to live with. Now let's talk about the interesting part about this. So the whole
truck was, what, just over three grand you paid for it, right? Bought it for three. Now,
what do these LS engines run? What's kind of the price differences?
This one I got for about five grand plus shipping. Yeah, and then I've done a fair amount of
refreshing on it. These motors, it doesn't really seem like they're as cheap as they used to be.
Obviously, a lot of people do LS swaps, so they just get to be more and more desirable. And yeah,
it's not the $1,200 junkyard motor that they maybe once were. Yeah, and then the transmission,
that's going to be a couple grand as well. Yeah, so that one fully rebuilt, plus the fact that I
didn't have a core to bring them, that one was three grand. Okay, and then you've got all the
other bits that really add up. So you've got like the Holley systems and that kind of thing.
Yeah, the Holley system, I still need to buy a radiator, an electric fan, going to get an oil
cooler. It seems like the transfer case, the stock Land Rover transfer case is going to move back
about three quarters of an inch. So I might bring my driveshafts over to a driveshaft shop and have
them just adjust the lengths on those a little bit. So this is not a money saving activity.
No, no, not at all. Part of my reasoning behind doing it this way is because out here in Colorado,
the smart choice would be to get like a 100 Series Land Cruiser, but there's lots of those
out here. I just kind of wanted to do something that's different from the rest of the stuff that
I see parked in parking lots. Great thing is we've got a buddy, Charles, who's been on the channel
before, who's kind of gone through this exact process. Yeah, he's done a very similar swap.
And then one of my good friends, he's done a couple of swaps. This is his BMW. It's got an
800 horsepower 2JZ under the hood. He's also done a 2JZ swap on a Tacoma. So he's done quite
a few engine swaps. Yeah, Charles did an LS swap Gen 4 with a six speed into one of these. We've
got a buddy, Jordan Townsend, who does a bunch of LS swaps. So we got really good resources
for whenever I get kind of stuck. Nice. All right. Well, in case I want to do one more thing,
let's go outside and show them that old four liter. We'll close this up. Yeah, the paperweight.
All right. So this is a four liter that came out of Case's Land Rover. And the problem with these,
it's actually a really compact engine and all aluminum design. But they have a lot of
head gasket problems, right, Case? Yeah, head gaskets. Slip liners as well is a common issue.
So look, I know a lot of folks in the UK love these engines. And I think that's cool. And I
know that there's a big tuning community around these overseas. But here in the US,
there are just much better options that are much more serviceable.
Well, and as you can see, this is not a pristine example. The whole motor is soaking wet
with oil. It was leaking. Every single seal on this is bad. Look, you could do this up and make
it good. And I'm going to sell this powertrain to someone who wants to refresh it for a couple
hundred bucks. It'll be good for someone. 120,000 miles on the whole rig. So this is a relatively
low mile powertrain that could use some refreshing. But for what I want to do,
being here in the mountains, getting rid of this is going to be the best thing that I've
ever done for that vehicle. Best thing that I could do short of not buying it in the first
place, as most people would probably say. But I'm really excited about this project.
It fits exactly what I want out of the vehicle. And again, at the end of the day, that's all
that matters. Well, folks, let us know what you think. I'm sure you will anyways in the
comment section below. And this has been Tommy and Case. Head over to altfl.com. We got more
videos coming.
