The BEST All Season Tires For 2025/26 - Tested and Reviewed

Car Tires TV
5 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 4, 2025
This is the 2025/26 Tyre Reviews All Season Tyre Test! For this test, I have selected nine of the best all season tyres in the 205/45 R17 tyre size, and I'm using a Mazda MX-5 / Miata to find out exactly which all season tyre is best. I have also included an excellent summer tire and an excellent performance winter tire as reference, so you can see how good the all season tires are compared to their more specialist counterparts.
In this video, I'll be testing all of these all-season tyres
and I'll be comparing them to a winter and a summer tyre
to find out exactly which is best.
Well, for this autumn's all-season tyre test,
I've mixed things up a bit.
I will be using a tiny little Mazda, which is rear-wheel drive,
to see if rear-wheel drive really makes any difference
compared to the previous front-wheel drive tests I've done.
As usual, I will be testing all of these all-season tyres
and the summer and winter tyre
in the dry, wet, snow
and looking at comfort, noise and rolling resistance levels of the tyres
to find exactly which tyre is best for you.
An all-season tyre tries to do everything well,
but can it match a winter tyre in winter conditions
or a summer tyre in summer conditions?
Let's find out.
I might not fit in this little MX-5 or if you're American, Miata,
but let me tell you, it's a lot of fun.
Normally aspirated engine, rear-wheel drive, not much weight
and a manual gearbox is pretty much all you need on snow.
I'm sadly coming in here to give a quick warning and an apology.
I'm sorry to say that due to how the weather works,
we start planning these big tests around a year ahead of release
and the snow testing for this very test was performed nearly nine months ago.
This means that sadly the Michelin CrossClimate 3, 3Sport
and the new Nokian are not in this test.
It is still an interesting test to watch
and there will be a section at the end of the video
with some predictions based on the data we have for the new tyres.
Thank you very much if you still watch this test through.
It really does help the algorithm.
As for the all-season tyres in the snow,
well, thankfully there is quite a nice spread
Now I've said a thousand times before,
an all-season tyre, it has to try and be good in every condition
but you can't be good in every condition
because things like snow performance are a distinct trade-off for dry and wet.
So if you want your all-season tyre to be the very best in the snow,
you're probably giving up dry and wet performance,
dry or wet performance, depending on how you design the tyre.
Now I've said again, I've said before,
I don't think an all-season tyre needs to be the best in the snow.
It just needs to be a lot better than the summer tyre.
But if you think differently, you can go over to the Tyre Reviews website,
linked in the description,
and change the score weighting for this test overall to find the best tyre for you.
So having said all that, there were two tyres which were pretty bad.
It was the Tomcat and the Cooper.
Now both of these, I struggled to get into corners,
especially the snow corners.
And with the Tomcat, I found myself more often than not,
not only trying to lock up the rear with the clutch,
but reaching for the handbrake and trying to pull up the handbrake to get around the corner.
It was some moments where I thought I was going into the corners at walking speed,
and I still turned and it still did nothing.
So there is a big difference between a bad all-season tyre
and a good all-season tyre in the snow.
The Cooper, well, as you know, I often test blind.
I did this time.
And the Cooper, for the Cooper's notes, I said feels a lot like set eight.
Difficult to get into the corners, rear snaps out, down on grip.
Never guessed what set eight was.
Yes, it was the Tomcat.
Next up was the Ling Long.
Borderline good, but a significant step up on the other two.
Quite a nice rounded tyre to drive, to be honest.
Just a little bit quick at the rear to step out, but otherwise absolutely fine.
Then we had a trio of good, almost very good tyres.
It was the Bridgestone, Continental and Goodyear.
Now these were a significant step on subjectively.
Even if the time is only a second or two,
the subjective confidence you got in the tyre to just do what you wanted it to do.
Turn in, steer, accelerate out the corners without drama.
It really gave you the ability to enjoy the car a lot more
because they just felt like they'd been developed to be more rounded products.
The Bridgestone of the three, I did mark down ever so slightly
just because once it stepped out, once you'd lost grip or gone past the limit of grip,
it just came around a little bit more quickly.
But these are very, very small tyres.
And I would recommend any of these three tyres in the snow.
I think they were very good all-season tyres in the snow.
Then we had the Milever.
Milever, I'm not entirely sure how to pronounce it.
This is the cheapest tyre in the test and it was excellent in the snow.
No complaints whatsoever.
Does this mean cheap tyres are finally here?
Do you think they're finally good?
Maybe.
Or does this mean it's actually just a single compound across a whole range of tyres?
So they've essentially put a very heavy winter bias compound
into an all-season tyre and just called it an all-season tyre to sell some tyres.
Maybe it's that.
I guess we'll find out when we get to the dry and wet
because that's where the balance is going to be of this tyre.
Next up, we had the Clever.
And once again, the Clever was absolutely outstanding in snow.
Little bit sluggish reaction on the front axle.
I'm talking fractions here.
But very, very good in traction and braking.
A very, very safe tyre to get around the lap.
And then finally, we had the Pirelli Citroën all-season SF3.
Once again, was the fastest in handling.
It just felt racy.
It was very rounded in the grip circle.
It was very, very good laterally.
And you just felt like you had the ability to really push on.
As for the summer and the winter tyres,
now, as promised, I did get a summer tyre around this lap.
Almost twice as slow as the best all-season tyre.
Maybe the worst all-season tyre.
It was a pretty poor experience.
It wasn't fun.
You think, oh, summer tyres and snow on a rear-wheel drive car.
Absolutely no fun because you had to be so delicate,
super snappy.
Once it went past the limit of grip, you couldn't slide it.
And there is a very small hill on this.
And I only got up here because I had a lot of momentum.
There's no way I could get up there and stop and start,
as you might have to on the road.
And then you had the winter tyre, the Continental Winter Contact TS870.
This is an excellent winter tyre.
And it was the fastest, thankfully, but only by a small margin.
So it just goes to show how good the best all-season tyres in the snow are
compared to a European winter tyre.
I'd imagine with a Nordic winter tyre,
which I didn't have time to test,
or the type of winter tyre you get in the US,
the gap would be fairly significant.
Snow traction was also led by the winter tyre,
with the Continental All-Season Contact II the best of the all-season tyres.
The Mielewa continued its impressive run
as the second best all-season tyre in traction
and the best all-season tyre in braking.
Kleber, Goodyear and Bridgestone were also strong.
You know what?
In wet handling, this MX-5 continues to be a lovely little test car.
Anyway, the tyres.
The slowest tyre around the lap was the Tomcat.
However, it was actually really lovely to drive.
And I say this bearing in mind it has reduced grip,
but its balance, its predictability was really good fun.
It was not snappy like that.
It was just easy to drive, even if it didn't have the most grip.
If you're ever going to do a wet drift day in your MX-5,
fit the Tomcat.
You'll have an amazing time and I'm pretty sure you won't get anywhere.
The next tyre was the Mielewa.
Mielewa, I've forgotten how I said it in the winter section.
This tyre was a little bit quicker, so it had a little bit more grip,
but it was a really disastrous tyre to drive handling-wise.
It wasn't predictable.
It was like the complete opposite of the Tomcat.
So you can see, even at this sort of like cheap,
not so grippy end of the spectrum,
you still have tyres that give you a better driving experience than others.
Quite a bit ahead of the Mielewa was the Cooper.
Now this tyre, like it had good, acceptable levels of grip.
I'm not going to say good, acceptable.
It was a little bit snappy when cold,
but once I'd done a lap or two, it warmed up and got better,
which is a bit of a curious quality for an all-season tyre,
but that's what I experienced.
And then we had the Linglong and Clever.
Now, both of these had pretty much the same lap time.
The Linglong was slightly more difficult to drive.
The Clever is a very understeer, primary, safe, balanced tyre.
And the Linglong was a little bit more peaky,
but otherwise like acceptable levels of grip.
I'm going to use that word again, acceptable.
Now, the Linglong, that's the Chinese butterball,
Chinese tyre jokes, like you've got a Linglong,
you're going to end up in a ditch.
And they are rapidly progressing, at least in terms of grip.
It's the same in some other test this year.
It's a good job to Linglong,
especially when you consider they've matched Clever,
which is a Michelin sub-brand.
And then we had the four premium tyres in their own little bubble of excellent.
The Bridgestone, Continental and Pirelli all finished on pretty much the same time,
and they did have slightly different driving characteristics.
I would say of those three, the Pirelli had the most grip in the wet,
but at the very limit, you lacked a little bit of detail.
So the tyre was just, I guess, a tiny bit numb in this size.
However, you're probably not going to experience that on the road.
So I'm not downgrading it for that.
I'm just telling you what I found.
The Bridgestone, again, was excellent.
However, it was just a little bit like when you were sliding like this,
you just held on to the slide a little bit longer than the other tyres,
which probably cost it a little bit of lap time.
And then the Continental, holy smoke.
The All-Season Contact 2 on this little MX-5,
the front and rear balance was absolutely stunning.
Like when you turn, the car just turned in one motion,
and you don't get that often with the car and tyre package,
unless it's an OE tyre.
And it felt like a spec race tyre.
Like if you put that tyre on an MX-5 in the wet,
you would have such a freaking blast, man.
Like really enjoyed the Continental.
But it wasn't quite the fastest round the lap.
The fastest was the Goodyear Vector 4-Season Generation 3,
and that was only like 1.4%,
but it's pretty significant when it's so tight.
And the Goodyear, it wasn't the most sportiest.
It wasn't the sharpest to turn in.
It didn't offer the most feedback.
However, it just gripped.
And laterally, especially, you'd really notice it
coming into the corners and out the corners.
There was a lot of stability when turning,
which is very impressive from this tyre,
especially when you consider it's the oldest of the bunch.
So this tyre continues to impress.
Good job, Goodyear.
But honestly, of the top four,
you would have absolutely no problems
with any of them in the wet.
They're all fabulous.
Now, how about our reference tyres?
Well, I ran the winter tyre,
the Continental Winter Contact TS870,
pretty much matched the best of the all-season tyres.
Now, why is this?
Firstly, the TS870 has always been
an excellent winter tyre in the wet.
So that's a score one.
Secondly, our ambient temperature today is about four degrees.
So we're testing at pretty chilly temperatures,
but not out of spec, obviously,
for an all-season or a winter tyre.
And thirdly, lateral grip is always easier
than longitudinal grip.
So we might see in the braking that the winter tyre,
that's where the disadvantage comes from all those sides.
And how about the summer tyre?
Now, I know I said the Continental all-season tyre
should be the spec race tyre in the wet,
but that was before I'd driven on the summer tyre.
Holy smoke.
It was fast.
It was sporty.
It was pointy.
It was predictable.
It was such a nice experience.
Honestly, one of the most pleasurable days testing
I've had on this little Mazda on a summer tyre in the wet.
It was just fabulous.
The Premium Contact 7 is excellent,
but here's a little story I want to talk about quickly
before we move to braking.
I actually practiced,
and I'm now driving on the tyres that came with this car,
the OE tyres.
There is the Bridgestone Potenza SW01,
and it is the OE tyre.
Now, the SW01 is a slightly older pattern,
but the lap time and the grip levels
were comparable to some of the worse all-season tyres.
Now, why is that?
Firstly, the SW01 is an older pattern,
but mainly OE tyres are now pretty much tuned
for rolling resistance and dry grip,
which means you do lose out some wet grip.
So not all premium tyres are created equal.
Not all summer tyres are created equal.
I just thought that was an interesting lesson
because it was such a delta
between the Continental aftermarket replacement summer tyre
and the Bridgestone OE tyre that came on this vehicle.
So if you own a little MX-5
and you're wondering why it's not great in the wet,
well, the good news is you can put on
one of the good all-season tyres
and have a huge increase in wet grip,
but you can put on a summer tyre
and have an even bigger increase in wet grip.
So keep that in mind
when you're thinking about tyres for your MX-5
and you're thinking about OE tyres
to replacement market tyres.
There is a big delta these days
and I'm going to make a piece of content
around it specifically in the future,
but for now, let's move on.
Wet braking was another impressive display for Bridgestone
with the Pirelli a very close second.
Both lagged behind the summer tyre
and the heavily-cycled winter tyre
struggled to slow the car,
but it still beat three of the all-season tyres.
I'm including the residual speed calculations
to really highlight the difference a tyre makes.
Feel free to pause the video and dig into the data.
In the deeper water,
the impressive Pirelli led both aquaplaning tests,
with Bridgestone taking second place in each.
The snow-splash-less Mileva really struggled
to deal with the standing water,
significantly behind.
Thanks to weather difficulties,
I ran out of time to film my dry piece in the car,
plus the Mazda is pretty noisy at speed.
As usual, I did a lot of sub-limit handling,
lane changes, all those kind of things
that really give you a quality of life
perception of the tyre.
And obviously, I did a lap time,
which is somewhat less relevant on these tyres,
but still fun and insightful to do.
For the steering response and lane change stability,
there were basically three groups.
The Cooper's steering was not ideal.
It had a very non-linear ramp-up of steering force
and was vague on the lap,
with an oversteer balance.
I'd also categorise the Clever in this bottom group,
but for different reasons.
Its steering was absolutely nice sub-limit,
but when pushed really hard during a lane change
or on a quick lap,
it just ran out of dry grip.
Then there was the Pirelli.
Its steering was fine,
but on the lane change,
the rear came into play a little bit more than ideal
on the Mazda,
but the grip was amazing.
And then the Goodyear and Mileva.
Both feeling great on lane changes,
but just a little bit imprecise.
Then there was the Tomcat,
Linglong,
Continental and Bridgestone.
In terms of steering feel,
all of these were great for an all-season tyre.
However, the Bridgestone and Continental
were better around the lap.
If I was to pick one tyre as the most summer-like,
as you always ask me,
it would once again be the Bridgestone Terenza
all-season 6.
But obviously, the most summer-like was the summer tyre.
It was a full 1.5 seconds ahead on a very short lap
and it felt very, very lovely.
Interestingly, the winter tyre was faster
than a bunch of the all-season tyres in the dry too,
although we do know the TS870
is a strong winter tyre in the dry.
Dry braking had the Pirelli back at the front,
with the Linglong and Bridgestone close behind.
None of the all-season tyres could match the summer tyre though,
and the extra siping of the winter tyre
once again hindered braking performance,
showing the careful balance a tyre manufacturer
has to make when developing all-season tyres.
Noise and comfort testing was led by Cleber and Cooper,
but the Continental was very comfortable too
and the Pirelli was very quiet.
As always, it was a close group overall.
Apart from the cheapest tyres in the test,
they really showed a lack of refinement in comfort,
even if the noise levels were good.
It would impact your day-to-day life.
Finally, the rolling resistance.
Impressively, considering the grip in all the other tests,
the Continental was the lowest,
but the Cleber the next best.
The Pirelli was 10% worse than the Continental,
which in the real world would be about 2% more fuel use
when the tyres are new,
but that gap would actually shrink as the tyres wear.
Even though 10% is significant in the real world,
it doesn't impact you that much.
On the subject of wear,
sadly I didn't have the budget to do wear for this test.
However, there is plenty of data on tyrereviews.com
for wear for most of these tyres
and I think most of them now have this new
estimated tread life widget I've put on the site.
It's well worth checking it out.
I think it's really cool anyway,
but I'm a super tyre nerd.
So the overall results.
The Tomcat All Year 3 finishing last place
was a little bit disappointing to me
as while it is classified as a budget tyre,
it isn't an ultra cheap Chinese budget.
Its dry performance was nice subjectively,
however, it didn't have the grip to match.
It was over 10% down in dry braking,
nearly 20% down in wet braking
and honestly not that great in snow.
Although it was a lot better than the summer tyre.
Its rolling resistance was okay.
It wasn't much better for the Mille Evo All Season
versus that MC545, which is quite the name.
It was also weak in the dry and wet,
but it did have winter tyres levels of grip in the snow.
You can tell this is basically a winter tyre
with an all season cycle, which it's cheating.
So for some strange reason,
you really want to run just an all season tyre
in snow only, this might be the pick.
But if you do want that, just go and buy a winter tyre.
Next up was the Cooper Discoverer All Season
and while Cooper is a brand most of us have heard of
in this test, it did not really perform like that.
It was a little better in the dry and wet
compared to the previous two tyres,
but still 10% off in wet braking,
which is less than ideal.
It also had the highest rolling resistance
and the worst snow performance
of all the all season tyres.
It was a difficult test for the Cooper, sadly,
although it was a very comfortable tyre,
so it's got that going for it.
A fairly significant step ahead
was the Linglong Sportmaster 4S,
which is the new name for the Gripmaster 4S,
which you might see on the sidewall in the pictures.
Linglong were one of the original budget manufacturers,
but they've been making huge investments in development
and it's really paying off
with a sixth place finish overall,
significantly ahead of the other cheap tyres
and almost matching the premiums.
Linglong has chosen a dry wet bias for this tyre,
which I'm all for in an all season tyre,
as it was the best in the dry overall.
In the wet, it was still 6% back in wet braking
and a little peaky in wet handling
and it definitely wasn't the best in the snow,
but as I've said about other tyres,
it was way better than the summer tyre in the snow.
It rounded out the test with good comfort levels,
average noise and a pretty high rolling resistance.
If you're tight on cash,
you could do a lot worse than this tyre.
It's an impressive tyre from Linglong.
They're definitely on the up.
The Clever Quadraxer 3 finished fifth.
Now, as we always find with the Clever,
it was a powerhouse in the snow.
It had excellent comfort
and a very low rolling resistance.
I would personally like more dry and wet grip
from an all season tyre,
but I know there are lots of people
who love this snow heavy balance
for an all season tyre.
And if that's your thing,
the Clever's a great option.
Next up was the Goodyear Vector 4 Season Generation 3.
So you'll know we're in the section
of really, really good all season tyres already.
As usual, the Goodyear was not the best in dry braking,
but worked very well in dry handling.
It's an odd quirk of the Goodyear.
It was great in the wet and it was solid in snow
and it had good comfort.
If I'm honest, I'm shocked it's only fourth overall.
It just shows how good all the tyres are getting.
Its overall placement was impacted a little bit
by rolling resistance,
whereas eighth and 16.3% behind the best.
But overall, it's a fantastic tyre.
In third place overall was another really strong result
for the Bridgestone Trends All Season 6.
This tyre tied for the best in the dry,
feeling the most summer-like
and had the best wet braking,
a good lap time and good aquaplaning resistance.
And it was even better than usual in the snow.
Its comfort was not the best,
but it honestly wasn't bad,
but its rolling resistance was pretty high.
Given that that was its only weakness,
I'm again really highly recommending the Bridgestone.
I love that tyre.
In second place overall was the excellent
Continental All Season Contact 2.
As always, this tyre was super consistent
across all of its tests.
Its only wins were snow traction,
rolling resistance and comfort tests.
And as we've previously found,
its aquaplaning performance was weaker than the best.
But in terms of dry, wet, snow grip, it was excellent.
All Season tyres should be consistent across all categories.
It's in their name, All Seasons,
and the Continental does this really, really well.
It is a super impressive tyre.
Finally, the winner was once again
the Pirelli Citroën All Season SF3.
There's honestly not much this tyre can't do.
It had the best grip in the dry
with the shortest dry braking
and the quickest dry handling lap.
It was essentially tied best in wet braking
and very close in wet handling.
It had the best aquaplaning resistance
in both straight and curved aquaplaning.
It was the best in snow handling,
had one of the lowest noise levels and good comfort.
I guess to answer my question,
it can't be the best in rolling resistance
as it was fifth overall, 10% off the Continental,
which was best,
and it was 8% off the Continental in snow traction.
But everything else was excellent.
Another test win for the SF3,
but the Continental and Bridgestone are both awesome options.
Honestly, you'll be happy with any of the top three,
even the top four.
The Goodyear's always a safe bet.
The Clever is excellent if you live in a snowy climate.
And honestly, the Ling Long is getting right up there.
Impressive work from all of these tires.
Finally, I do know you're all disappointed
I didn't get the new Cross Climates into this test.
Trust me, no one is more disappointed than I am,
but it's just how it goes sometimes.
At the time of recording this,
I am the only person in the world
that has published data on the new Michelins against rivals.
I will link that in the description, go watch it.
However, as that test does include data
from the Bridgestone and Pirelli from this test,
we can do approximate calculations
to see where the tires would finish
in certain tests that match.
Now let me stress, this is not perfect.
We are comparing different tire sizes on different vehicles
in different test locations,
but based on the existing test data
we have for both the crossover sets of tires,
the Cross Climate 3 Sport
would have slotted fourth in dry braking,
third in dry handling,
second in wet braking,
fourth in wet handling,
seventh in snow braking,
third in snow traction,
second in snow handling,
and third in rolling resistance.
When I run the calculation of overall placement
based on the matching test,
accounting for my own score weighting for this test,
it would have finished in first place overall,
just a little bit ahead of the Pirellis.
Something to think about.
The Cross Climate 3 would have been fifth in dry braking
and seventh in wet handling,
seventh in wet braking and sixth in wet handling,
seventh in snow braking,
third in snow traction,
and first in snow handling,
and one of the best in rolling resistance,
placing it fourth overall in the test.
And the prediction for the Nokian Season Proof 2
slots it into third overall.
But as I've said, this comparison is not perfect.
We need more test data for these tires,
so let's hope some are published soon.
I did delay publishing this video
to see if more tests were coming with these tires in,
but nothing so far.
I will be testing all of these tires together in my test,
I guess, starting at the end of this year,
start of next year,
for publication this time next year,
so subscribe for that.
But maybe I'll publish it early
because everyone's so,
so obsessed with the Cross Climate 3 and 3 Sport.
Anyway, I will try and get the predictive tool
live on the front end of the site
so you can play with it
and slot your own tires into your own test
to see where things come.
Thank you so much for watching.
Any questions, please do ask below.
And as always, safe motoring.
