"China’s Car Scam Shocks the World: Fake Sales, Fake Cars, Worst Build Ever Seen
China’s auto industry is facing global scrutiny as shocking revelations of fraud and poor quality continue to surface. What was once promoted as a symbol of innovation and national pride has now become a cautionary tale of deception. Investigations have exposed fake sales figures, inflated export numbers, and cars rushed to market without proper safety standards. Industry giants have been accused of reporting tens of thousands of “phantom orders” to secure subsidies and boost investor confidence, only to cancel them later. At the same time, consumers are sharing disturbing footage: steering wheels peeling in the heat, air conditioners spraying white powder, and electric vehicles bursting into flames after minor collisions. Mechanics say the build quality is among the worst they have ever seen, with hollow frames, rusty parts, and dangerously cheap materials hidden beneath flashy exteriors. These scandals reveal a deeper crisis: a market addicted to subsidies, obsessed with appearances, and willing to cut corners at the expense of safety and trust. As word spreads internationally, China’s car industry is no longer seen as unstoppable, but as a global joke—one that risks collapsing under the weight of its own lies and failures.
Chinese auto industry uses scam to inflate vehicle sales numbers.
The Chinese auto industry is on the verge of bursting like a bubble after years of
artificially inflated sales and brutal price wars. The scheme involves registering new vehicles in
China and then selling them abroad as used cars, even though they are essentially zero-mileage
vehicles. This allows automakers to report sky-high sales figures even as the market teeters
on the brink of collapse. Chinese automakers are embroiled in a new scandal following reports of
fake sales. Recent investigations reveal that China's auto industry has been inflating vehicle
sales for years under the lenient eye of the Chinese government. One of the most common
schemes involves registering new cars right off the assembly line and shipping them overseas as
used vehicles. This is how zero-mileage cars became the open secret of China's auto market.
Adding to the controversy, a separate scandal in the electric vehicle EV sector has exposed how
easy it was to cheat the subsidy system. An audit covering 2016 to 2020 revealed that approximately
864 million yuan, about 121 million dollars, zero cents, in EV subsidies were distributed to
automakers that didn't meet qualifying criteria among the implicated companies.
BYD and Cherry Automobile reportedly received funds they weren't entitled to, with BYD receiving
143 million yuan, 20 million dollars, zero cents, for just 4,900 cars, and Cherry claiming 240
million yuan, about 33 million dollars, zero cents, for around 8,860 electric and hybrid vehicles
that failed to meet requirements. Chinese Ministry of Industry and Information Technology has not
confirmed whether these misused funds have been repaid or deducted, leaving the issue unresolved.
Reports of zero-mileage cars have appeared in the news for years. Initially, these vehicles were
dumped into the Chinese used car market as a result of the brutal price war. However, as the
market became saturated with zero-mileage cars, automakers sought new solutions. According to
reports, zero-mileage cars are now being exported to markets such as Russia, Central Asia, and the
Middle East. The EV subsidy scandal further complicates the picture, as China's generous
incentive program, offering up to 60,000 yuan, 8,400 dollars, zero cents per car since the early
2010s, has been exploited. In 2016 alone, dozens of companies fraudulently claimed around 9.3 billion
yuan, approximately 1,300,000,000 dollars, zero cents, in subsidies, highlighting how the system
was ripe for abuse. Manufacturers received these rebates in bulk, using them to slash prices for
customers, but the lack of oversight enabled widespread fraud. Zero-mileage used cars are now
under scrutiny in China. The practice has been known for years but only gained national attention
in May, when Hua Jianjun, CEO of Great Wall Motor, criticized it. In an interview with Sina Finance,
Hua Jianjun referred to the Evergrande of the auto industry, alluding to the high-profile collapse of
the Evergrande real estate empire. Although Jianjun did not name the company, everyone understood he
was referring to BYD. The zero-mileage car practice grew large enough to attract the attention of
China's top Communist Party leaders. On June 10, the People's Daily newspaper condemned the sale
of zero-mileage used cars domestically, and criticized the price war that risks crashing
the Chinese auto industry, calling for strong regulatory actions to restore order. Government
officials are keeping a close watch on the local EV market, urging car brands to stop the ongoing
price war and halt the use of shady sales targets to boost volumes. It was recently revealed that
many companies are providing new cars to traders and dealers in bulk, who then register them as
sales, only for these vehicles to re-enter the market as zero-mileage used cars. Everyone benefits
from selling zero-mileage used cars. This is easier said than done, as everyone benefits from
selling zero-mileage used cars. Local governments have a direct interest because the practice helps
them meet ambitious economic growth targets set by Beijing. Dealerships also receive bonuses if
they meet sales targets imposed by automakers. Finally, consumers can buy the same cars at roughly
half the original price. According to reports, an entire regional network has been established to
fast-track the sales of zero-mileage used cars and recover tax rebate claims. They have also invested
in export infrastructure, turning it into not only a legitimate business, but a vital one.
This wouldn't make sense in a free economy. However, for China's centrally planned economy,
it's a way for local officials to attract funding, save face, and get promoted for meeting economic
targets. Failure to do so can lead to the demotion of local officials. Rough estimates indicate that
90% of the 436,000 passenger and commercial vehicles China exported in 2024 were zero-mileage
cars. The majority were combustion vehicles, which are less attractive to Chinese customers.
However, this doesn't mean that electric vehicles aren't being exported as zero-mileage used cars.
The EV subsidy scandal underscores the ease of manipulation, with big names like BYD and
Chery benefiting from inflated figures, while the industry's explosive growth, fueled by over
$230 billion zero cents in government investment, according to a study, has come under scrutiny for
its reliance on questionable practices. The limits of the scheme and emerging quality concerns.
As lucrative as it seems, dumping zero-mileage cars abroad won't last much longer.
Many countries have started to push back, especially where they have local automakers to
protect. For instance, Russia in 2023 issued a government decree banning zero-mileage imports
from brands that already have official distributors in the country, including Chery,
Chonggan, and Geely. The ongoing EV subsidy scandal and the zero-mileage car controversy
highlight the fragility of China's auto industry, which risks collapsing under the weight of its
own deceptive tactics if regulatory measures fail to restore integrity. Adding to these issues,
recent videos have exposed significant quality and technological flaws in Chinese automakers'
offerings. A video showed foreigners in China struggling with the Huawei Mate 9's remote door
opening feature, with the door failing to open despite multiple attempts, requiring patient
assistance from sales staff. Similarly, a car owner posted footage of a Huawei M9 owner practicing the
same function on the roadside, repeatedly failing while oblivious to curious onlookers, sparking
Critics online have labeled these features as low-tech gimmicks, questioning their utility,
comparing remote door opening to automatic toilet seat openers or glass doors,
and arguing they complicate simple tasks without solving real problems. Much like the phone's air
swipe feature, this has led to growing skepticism among Chinese consumers about whether domestic
cars are losing their direction, with flashy but impractical designs driving up maintenance costs
and malfunction risks. Further concerns arise from Huawei's autonomous driving technology,
heavily promoted as a key selling point with real test videos claiming it can handle any situation.
However, a Huawei M9 owner uploaded a video on August 6 showing the system malfunctioning on a
highway when a large truck turned ahead, nearly causing a collision. The owner noted the airbags
didn't deploy and said, the M9's smart driving system didn't fail to brake, it didn't brake at
all. There were two lives in that car. If I hadn't stepped on the brake, the consequences would have
been unimaginable. Comments highlighted the system's inability to distinguish the truck's
direction, causing delays, with similar incidents reported, including a fatal crash in Wuhan in
October 2024, involving an M9 and a truck, resulting in one death and two injuries.
Analysts attribute these accidents to overhyped claims by Huawei executives,
like Yu Qingdong, who boasted the technology allows hands-free driving for thousands of
kilometers while cost-cutting amid a price war has led to quality declines.
Quality issues extend beyond technology. A mechanic repairing a BYD Han Plus discovered
a burnt-out air conditioner compressor emitting smoke, an anomaly after 20 years in the field,
possibly due to a rag inside, raising safety concerns about toxic reactions.
Another owner reported an empty front bumper casing in a BYD Han,
designed for energy absorption but made of cheap rusty steel with gaps,
lacking proper safety measures. Additional complaints include noisy doors and peeling
steering wheels in models like the Song Plus, with a dealership admitting they couldn't fix
the issue. A BYD Dolphin owner faced white powder from the air vents, linked to an abnormal
evaporator and identified as aluminum hydroxide by BYD. Though a doctor warned of inhalation risks
despite claims of harmlessness, a severe case involved a woman in Shantung whose husband
developed leukemia after two months driving a new car, with formaldehyde levels testing at 0.3,
triple the safe limit of 0.1, exposing widespread use of substandard materials.
The industry's credibility is further eroded by falsified sales data. Chinese media reported
BYD's overseas sales exceeded 70,000 units in March 2025, a 88.4% increase, with a shark pickup
hitting 5,000 monthly exports. However, a vlogger revealed actual sales were under 35,000 units
across Europe, Brazil, Southeast Asia and Australia, half the reported figure. Auto
personality Wu Pei criticized the industry's over-10,000 orders myth, alleging pre-planned
campaigns and fake screenshots to create urgency, while former Avida VP Li Pangchen noted 50 million
small orders this year, exceeding last year's 30 million retail sales. Suggesting massive inflation,
small orders 2,000-3,000 yuan refundable boost market confidence, but big orders 10,000-20,000
yuan non-refundable still allow cancellations, muddying true sales data. Professional teams
orchestrate fake orders with employees and influencers, fueling a market bubble that
misleads consumers, erodes trust and risks long-term damage if unchecked.