The 2024 Nobel Prize in Economics- Explained

Finance & Beyond
21 followers
Why do some nations flourish while others remain trapped in poverty? 2024’s Nobel Prize in Economics goes to three economists whose groundbreaking work explores this very question. Join us as we dive into the theories and insights of Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and James A. Robinson, who have helped shape policy across the globe with their research on economic growth and inequality.
#finacialtips #finance
The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in honour of Alfred Nobel,
known more commonly but less correctly simply as the Nobel Prize in Economics,
is an annual prize awarded to economists who have made significant contributions to the social
sciences. The reason why the Nobel Prize in Economics technically has a different name
is because it was not one of the original prizes established by Alfred Nobel when he
set up the foundation to clean up his public image as a bomb maker. It was later added by
the Swedish central bank which funds the prize money separately from the other awards which
come out of the Nobel foundation. The joke is that economists wanted a seat at the table with
the real scientists and the only way to get there was to get a sovereign central bank to foot the
bell. Now that's a little bit unfair because, well it hurts my feelings, but also because
economics does genuinely have the capacity to massively improve the lives of billions of people
in the same way that the other sciences and disciplines do if they're implemented correctly.
There is probably no greater example of that ability for practical economics to make the
world a better place than the winners of this year's prize. It was awarded to these three
gentlemen, Darren Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and James A. Robinson. Beyond their specific
contributions to the social sciences that they won this year's award for, these three gentlemen
are genuinely some of the most influential economists in the world. Acemoglu and Robinson
are probably best known for their book Why Nations Fail, which is effectively a summarized
version of what they won their prize for, but their work, as well as the work of Simon Johnson,
goes beyond that. Their theories, studies, and recommendations have impacted policy in some of
the most vulnerable economies in the world and have also been used to make sure some of the
most prosperous countries in the world stay that way. These three men have had such a profound
impact on the field that when I congratulated them on their prize, I rather awkwardly admitted
that I assumed that they'd already won it. Yeesh. Anyway, by pure academic metrics,
Acemoglu himself is the third most referenced economist in the world, with his work being
cited more than Krugman, Friedman, or even Keynes. What they won their award for specifically,
though, is their explanation for why some countries are rich and some countries are poor.
So basically the biggest question in all of macroeconomics. Today the top 20% of countries
in the world are 30 times richer than the poorest 20%, and even though the world is growing wealthier
as a whole, the ratio is not changing, which means the poorest countries are not catching up.
Obviously the important question here is why, which this year's laureates have presented a
compelling solution to in their collective decades of research. Their theories address
a lot of macroeconomic results that just don't inherently make a lot of sense on a surface level,
like why some countries that are completely devoid of natural resources, arable land,
or even a good position for trade, are hundreds of times wealthier than other countries that are
literally sitting on top of gold mines. If all that wasn't enough by itself, probably one of
the biggest reasons that this year's winners were chosen was because they offer solutions to these
issues and workable strategies to avoid them becoming a problem in the first place.
So, what were the ideas that won this year's Nobel prize, where can they be seen in the real
world, and finally, why are they raising alarm bells about our immediate future?
To truly understand any country's modern economy, it's essential to examine its
historical evolution, including the significant political and economic shifts that shaped the
nation. But learning about the past isn't just for economists. Uncovering the truth
of your own family history can be just as fascinating and insightful. We've partnered
with MyHeritage, a platform that lets you discover the stories of your relatives and
your ancestors by searching through over 19 billion historical documents for you.
Charlie, one of our team at Economics Explained, used MyHeritage to find details about members of
his family, and especially of his grandfather on his mother's side, who was a holocaust survivor.
There aren't many basic records like his birth certificate for obvious reasons,
but by looking through connections he was able to create a pretty comprehensive map of his family
dating back to the late 1800s and find out his great-grandmother's maiden name and her extended
family, the Jacksons. The search doesn't stop there. With truly amazing insights like a newspaper
clipping about Charlie's great-grandparents wedding in 1895 and images of his grandfather's
engineering patents. And once he added a lot of his immediate family, the instant discoveries page
gave him the marriage records of his mother's parents from 1953 in Westminster in the UK,
and further research surfaced a beautiful picture of their wedding day that his family had not seen
before. It looked even better after using MyHeritage Picture Restorer to colorize and
sharpen it, and Charlie got it framed for his mom as a Christmas present.
So why not start building your family tree? You don't know if you don't look,
and you could even have living relatives you never knew about. You can get a 14-day free
trial of MyHeritage when you join using our link in the description or by directly scanning this QR
code. When looking at a list of national economies, it can be hard to determine some kind of common
characteristic between wealthy countries and poor countries. Places like Venezuela,
which are sitting on top of enough oil to make their residents generationally wealthy,
are poor, while Ireland, a country with very few natural resources,
has a GDP per capita almost 25 times greater. Similarly, landlocked countries are largely some
of the poorest nations in the world because of restricted global trade via ocean shipping,
which kind of makes sense, except for the fact that a few landlocked countries are some of the
richest places in the world, with Switzerland, Luxembourg, and Lichtenstein being particular
standouts. Finding a common trait that determines economic success or failure seemed pretty elusive
until this year's winners suggested that it wasn't natural resources, geographic position,
population sizes, or anything like that which separated wealthy nations from poor nations,
it was instead, almost universally, the stability and reliability of those countries' institutions.
At its most foundational level, an economy is really just a system for effectively allocating
resources between participants, and the best way to ensure that participants feel compelled
to create value for that system is for them to reliably be rewarded for their efforts.
Now this applies to all institutions, from something as large as central banks and national
treasuries, all the way down to local planning offices, small businesses, the media, and even
individual public servants. If an economy is full of well-managed, honest, and effective institutions,
then its people, potential investors, businesses, and the government itself can get to work producing
value confident in the fact that their investments, in whatever form they take,
won't be yanked away from them. A worker in an advanced economy with good institutions can do
something like confidently spend years studying for a degree that would give them access to a
skilled profession like engineering, because that country has institutions in place to make sure that
the degree they're getting is from a reputable institution, there are bodies in place to require
that degree to get a license, that license is needed to sign off on engineering projects,
and that engineering projects get paid for because there are fair and impartial courts to enforce
contracts. A worker from an economy without any of these institutions would find it difficult to
make a living designing buildings if contracts just go to whoever has the best government connections,
and if there are no systems in place to make sure that qualifications are met,
then there probably won't be the same investment into obtaining those skills in the first place.
Even something as simple as a government department that issues driver's licenses
based on reasonable and fairly tested standards means that insurance companies will have more
confidence in insuring truck drivers, which makes local trade more commercially viable,
which helps businesses operate, which employs people, who can pay taxes to an effective tax
agency to fund services, like a government department that issues licenses.
Now of course this is just one very oversimplified example, but the core idea is the same.
Advanced economies with good institutions let people invest a lot of resources into
becoming highly specialized, safe in the knowledge that if they efficiently do their specific job,
there are systems in place to make sure that they can trade that work in for everything else
they'll need. If everybody in an economy can become more specialized in something that they
do really well, then the economy will be richer. Now this is a sound theory that does hold true
across basically every economy in the world today. It's almost impossible to think of a
Likewise, it's equally difficult to think of a rich country that has stayed rich without
these institutions. Now this year's laureates weren't actually the first people to recognize
this correlation, but correlation doesn't equal causation. It's possible that rich countries
just have good institutions because good institutions are expensive.
A government that pays all of its workers well enough to avoid the temptations of bribery,
big well-funded education centers and financial systems employing well-qualified and competent
managers are all kind of expensive. What's more is that in an increasingly globalized world,
there is the temptation for individuals and businesses that do operate these institutions
to just move to rich countries where they can be paid more for their services in a global phenomenon
most commonly referred to as brain drain. So the first thing that the laureates had to show
was that good institutions made countries rich instead of rich countries just being able to
afford good institutions. The way they did this was by looking back through history and tracing
the scars of colonialism. In their research of economic history, the laureates found interesting
patterns amongst former colonial regions. The regions that were the richest before colonialism
were the poorest after colonialism. All other things being equal, this shouldn't be the case
because wealth before modern economic systems was primarily determined by how arable the land was
and if it had natural resources, not too dissimilar to the assumptions of today. The difference was
that when the colonial empire started operating in regions that were already wealthy and prosperous,
they had to establish institutions that would suppress the existing local populations
and turn them into a subservient labor force to help them with extracting resources.
On the flip side, less prosperous regions with less dense populations weren't quite as threatening,
but unfortunately for the colonizers, they had to do a lot of the work themselves.
The institutions that were established in the regions that were wealthier before colonialism
were all about controlling and taking advantage of the existing population.
This meant that when the colonial empires left or were forced out,
it was easy for new parties to come in and take advantage of the same institutions that were all
about controlling people. These institutions, on top of being more prone to poor management
and corruption, also encouraged economic exploitation rather than productive development.
Now back 400 years ago that was a perfectly good way to claim a lot of wealth,
but these days the wealthiest economies are those that can encourage value creation
rather than value extraction. It also didn't help that the empires running these militarized
colonies also mostly left after they were kicked out, creating a power vacuum and taking with them
their knowledge of how to run these institutions even if they were highly exploitative.
Now on the other hand, the regions that had smaller, less dense populations were simultaneously
less threatening to the colonial empires that didn't have to go up against a standing military,
but also less useful because there wasn't a ready-made labor force provided to them.
This meant that they had to provide their own labor force through colonial settlers,
even if their work would be heavily supported by slave or convict labor imported from elsewhere.
The institutions set up in these kinds of environments, most notably the modern-day
USA but also Canada, New Zealand and Australia, had to support these independent operations
rather than treating the whole colony as a worksite there exclusively to produce spices or tea or
whatever. These settler colonies had to encourage people to travel from Europe to make a life there,
so they created systems to protect their investments, dish out property rights and
give them political liberties that were clearly not afforded to the indigenous inhabitants of
the other colonies. Again, when these colonial empires took a step back or were forced out,
these regions that were less prosperous before colonialism just inherited these institutions
that were more conducive to running a sound economy.
The settlers also tended to remain in these colonies and adopt them as their own homes
after claiming independence, which means that there was more continuity and the knowledge
of how to manage these institutions was maintained in the new country.
Now it's important to recognize that just because the nations that formed in these regions are more
prosperous in the modern day doesn't necessarily mean that the indigenous population fared that
much better, and tragically there is of course still a divide between these groups within
these economies just like there's a gap between these economies.
Now with that essential piece of context, one of the clearest examples of this playing out in the
real world was actually outlined in the announcement of this year's winners in something that they've
The city of Nogales is divided by a fence that runs east to west.
In the north, Nogales, Arizona boasts incredibly high incomes by global standards,
a long life expectancy, good access to education, and of course they have good,
reliable institutions that provide property rights, legal protections, a stable currency,
a relatively corruption-free system of rules and regulations, and all of this is overseen
by representative governments all the way up from the local mayor to the president.
On the other side of the fence, Nogales in Sonora, Mexico is considerably poorer,
doesn't enjoy the same quality of life, and has significant issues with organized crime and
corruption. These are two halves of the same city that share the same culture, the same geography,
the same climate, and even the same heritage. The only difference is whether they are operating
under the institutions of the USA or the institutions of Mexico. Mexico was home to
the Aztecs which during the Spanish colonial period was something that needed to be controlled
and has contributed to institutions that are less representative even to this day.
It was this historical context and dozens of other examples they've studied across the world
that allowed this year's laureates to back up the idea that good institutions do create
rich economies, it's not just that rich economies can afford to have good institutions.
Now that might sound like a lot of background research just to prove a causal relationship,
but with stakes this high it was essential, otherwise their advice to nations focusing
on creating these robust institutions would be like telling a homeless person to just buy a home.
Instead they've been able to do what a lot of economists would never dare to do
and actually make some constructive recommendations to improve a bad situation.
So Acemoglu, Johnson and Robinson demonstrated a causal connection between running good
institutions which means that good policy can be recommended to support those institutions.
The problem is that's easier said than done. If setting up fair well-managed institutions
could make an economy wealthier with no trade-offs then obviously every economy would do it.
The problem of course is that unfairly run institutions often benefit the people who
make the policy and even if they have their people's best interest in mind,
running these institutions takes a lot of skills and experience.
Now the first part is obviously the biggest hurdle for a lot of economies.
The elites that make the rules receive an economic benefit from making those rules to favour them
at the expense of their people and they don't want to give that up unless they can be sure
their economic situation would improve. Now often times it actually could by giving back
a bit of control. Institutions almost always run better when they are beholden to the people.
It is theoretically better to be a national leader of a highly prosperous economy than
the despot of a failing state, but there's no guarantee that those people would keep
their positions of power and wealth if they introduced fairer systems.
This puts a lot of economies into a vicious stalemate where both the ruling class and
the people would be better off in a more egalitarian society,
but neither side can trust the other to make the first move.
Now what the laureates found throughout history is that the most effective way
for economies to transition from one with poor institutions was through the peaceful,
non-violent transfer of power rather than revolutions which tend to create a whole
new ruling class and are just generally more trouble than they're worth.
Now these might not sound like insanely cutting-edge ideas,
but it's important to remember that this prize was awarded for work done over decades,
empirically showing that fairer and better managed institutions were not
only one of the causes of economic success, but probably the biggest cause was huge.
And before the work of these men there was no clear consensus on the economic value
of a democracy with checks and balances versus something like a benevolent dictatorship.
Now obviously it's incredibly hard to distill the work of literal nobel prize winning research
into a concise video, but if you want more details I can wholeheartedly recommend their
nation's fail. It goes into fascinating historical case studies in a style not too
dissimilar to the way we do on this channel, but instead of some random guy on the internet,
it's written by two nobel prize winning economists.
We were also lucky enough to speak with Professor Asamoglu earlier this year and
he set the record straight on exactly what has been holding Africa back
from the economic success that it's capable of.
You should be able to click to that video on your screen now,
or if you want to listen to our full interview with him,
it's available on Spotify and most other streaming services.
Thanks for watching mate, bye.
