攝影進階熱門話題 AI人工智能和科技會毀掉攝影嗎?【Duade Paton】【攝影進階熱門話題】

为什么爱摄影
6粉絲
8 次觀看·2025年10月4日
G'day and welcome to the channel
In today's video, I want to try and answer
Is AI and technology ruining photography?
Are cameras like the R5 and the Sony A9 III
reducing all the skill?
Is AI meaning we just don't know what's real or not?
I want to talk about the pros and the cons of AI and technology
and see how it's both helping us and hurting us
First, let's have a look at AI-generated images
If I'm completely honest, I never thought that a computer
would be able to replicate what I can take with my own camera
So I never worried about it
They always looked a bit like digital art
and I thought, nah, it's never going to be realistic
However, recently I tried out Adobe's Firefly
which is an image-generating AI
To say I was blown away is a bit of an understatement
And I want to show you two images
One image that I took
and one image that the computer generated
And I want to see if you can tell the difference
So if you're not aware, to generate an image
we have to give the AI a prompt
So my prompt was a kookaburra sitting in a gum tree
And let's have a look at two photos
The first one is a kookaburra sitting in a gum tree
And I quite like this image
The lighting's fine, the eye contact's good
The detail's good
It's a nice bird in its habitat
The second image, again, is very similar
It's a kookaburra sitting on a gum tree
In a nice habitat
And again, the bird looks good
One of these images I took
One of these images the computer took
Can you guess which one I took?
If you guessed the second image, you'd be right
The first image was generated by the computer
And at first glance, it's pretty hard to tell
But if we dive deep into it
In the background, a couple of those trees are inconsistent
There's a few little giveaways
But it's actually very, very good
I suspect if you showed that first image to a lot of people
They would just think it was taken with a camera
Not generated by AI
And just to show you the power of this AI generation
Let's jump in and give it a very Australian prompt
Let's ask for a sulphur-crested cockatoo
Sitting on a gum tree
Overlooking the arid Australian outback
With a river at sunset, with golden light
And as you can see
The computer just randomly generated these four images
And I'm pretty surprised with the quality
This image here is the one that appeals to me the most
I would like to take an image like this
This is what I'd have in my mind
If I had a vision of trying to capture a cockatoo
In the Australian outback
I can tell this isn't a photo
Because it's not quite right
But it's very close
And as a digital piece of art
This is really good
You'd probably print this and put it on the wall
And it just goes to show how far AI generation has come
And how much better it's going to get going forward
And I can simply change the bird to a kookaburra
Generate the images
Then I can change it to an emu
But the computer will do that for us
How about a wandering albatross
Flying through the sky with an island background in the rain
Put that prompt in
We hit enter
And bingo, we've got it
So at the moment, the AI is far from perfect
It's lacking a lot of reference material
If I put in crimson rosella
It doesn't know what that is
And so it needs to know what these things are
For it to create it
So in the future, I'm sure it will
But at the moment, there's a lot of gaps
But it's pretty extraordinary
How far it's come in a short amount of time
And how much further it's going to go
The obvious question is
Does it even matter
Why should we even care
Is it an issue
Well, it kind of depends who you are
And why you take photos in the first place
So to answer this, I asked my beautiful members
What they thought about AI and technology
And they gave me some amazing responses
And I just want to share the first one with you
So the first member had an amazing comment
They said, no amount of AI can replace the feeling
Of capturing the shot
Of learning and spending hours in the field
Mastering your craft
Photography is a feeling
Whether you're good at it or not
But as far as doing it for your soul
AI could never replace that
Bingo, fantastic comment
The next one from Mr. Bravo said
For me, the joy is being in nature
And capturing nice images
AI has no impact on that
And I 100% agree with these comments
It's why are we doing photography in the first place
For the majority of us
It's that feeling we get of being out in nature
It's that feeling of
Looking through the viewfinder
And watching an intimate moment of a bird
Or whatever it is
Behaving
It's just such an amazing, joyful experience
AI can't do that for us
Well, at least not yet
So I think for the majority of us
AI has no real impact
In terms of our experience in the field
Which is great and I'm happy about that
Now, of course, if your joy comes from sharing images
And getting feedback on social media
AI is a bit of a double-edged sword
On one hand, it's going to enable you to
Manipulate your images for them to stand out even more
And maybe you'll get some more attention from that
And I think the downside has already happened
I think social media, Instagram, etc.
Is now saturated or flooded with incredible images
They've got perfect skies
They've got everything's perfect about them
And it means it's very hard to stand out
Or even compete with these AI images
So if you're someone who doesn't manipulate your images
You're in for a tough battle
Because how do you make your image stand out
You can definitely still do it 100%
It's just a little bit more difficult
Because it's not a level playing field
If you don't manipulate
And everyone else is manipulating
It's very difficult for you to stand out
And that's a real shame
And I think it's important that we create spaces
For people who don't manipulate their images
Whether that's Facebook groups
Whether that's competitions
Just a place where we can put our images
That haven't been manipulated
So people can better judge the skill
Required to get those shots
There's definitely one thing we can do ourselves
As photographers
And that is be honest about how we manipulate our images
And declare when we do use AI
So when we share images
We should definitely divulge
If we've manipulated them
Because it's far too easy to deceive the viewer
How is the viewer ever going to know
Whether you've used AI
In a recent video
I shared this image of some pelicans
Floating through the water
With the sun coming up behind
And I really do like this photo
But if you saw it
You'd probably assume I took that in one shot
And you'd be thinking
That's pretty amazing
But in reality
That's two photos stitched together
The first photo I took
The pelicans were slightly out of focus
And it just didn't work for me
So I focused on the pelicans
And got a shot of them
But by the time I photographed them
They'd moved on
And the sun wasn't aligned with them
But I just simply stitched the two together
To create an image that I was happy with
And that I was pleased with
And it would have been very easy for me
To deceive people
By just showing the final image
Without sharing the raw files
But I do share the raw files
And I try to be as honest and open as I can
And I hope that encourages you to be open and honest
And declare in the description
Or just let people know
If you have merged or stitched
Or you've manipulated the image in any way
Unfortunately there's part of human nature
Where people will cheat
And people will do the wrong thing
And that's unfortunate
And if you followed the news online
There was a competition down here in Australia
Where somebody submitted an image
A drone shot
And it won a competition
And it later turned out
That it was just an AI-generated image
Nobody had taken that photo
And they declared it
Just to show how far AI is coming
And another photographer
At a very prestigious world photography awards
Submitted an AI-generated image
They won
And then they came out
And declined the award
Saying this should never happen
AI should never be competing with photography
Because they're two completely different things
And I 100% agree with that
And I think now a lot of these competitions
Are implementing a raw file policy
Where you have to submit a raw file
Which is helping eliminate or reduce
The amount of cheating going on
So I want to make it crystal clear
That I'm not against image manipulation
Or digital art
I do it myself
I edit all my images
And I think people should be able to enjoy
And express themselves
Through this medium
The problem is where do we draw the line
When does it go from photo to digital art
And I think that's what we need to agree upon
And it's going to be difficult for people to agree
I think anytime you manipulate the image
So that it's not representative of the raw file
Is when it turns to digital art
So what I mean by that is
We remove backgrounds
We replace the sky
Anytime we're altering the original file
I think that's when it goes into digital art
And that's when we should declare it
I don't have all the answers
And maybe it's open for discussion
And maybe we could have a chat about it
What are your thoughts
When does an image become art
And when does it stay a photo
It's a tricky subject
And it's one that needs a bit of nuance I think
All right that leads me on to the second part of this video
And that's the technology and AI inside our cameras
And how that's impacting our ability to capture images
This R5 Canon is completely different to this DSLR 1DX
Incredible cameras both of them
But the technology has come so far
In what 10 years or even less
And I can only imagine
What's going to be coming around the corner
With the R1 the R5 II etc
It's just going to get better and better
And the question is
Is that reducing our skill or ruining photography
Well if you believe a lot of the comments
I get when I review cameras
You believe this was the beginning of the end
These modern cameras
And I'll just read a few of those comments to you
So one comment reads
Pre-capture is not the skill of the photographer
But the technology of an engineer
You can keep it and I'll continue to work on my own skills
Second one is
The tech nowadays is genius
But for me it's terrible
What is even the point to go out there and hunt
When the camera will shoot
Pretty much by itself at this point
And another comment which actually made me laugh
It said it would be nice if the R5 II
Would do my dishes and vacuum the carpet
Sounds pretty good
In my opinion we are becoming slaves to technology
I don't want the camera to get all the credit
For a great bird shot
I would rather spend money on great glass
And challenge my skills to do more with less
Very interesting point
And there's just numerous
I get these comments all the time
And my takeaway from this is
I think there's a fear among people
That these modern cameras
Will enable people to capture images
Or good images that took them years to do
On their older DSLRs
And maybe they feel like that's unfair
And maybe they think people shouldn't be able to
Buy that ability
And I can concede and see where they're coming from
If you've got the funds
And you can afford a Sony A9 III
With 120 frames per second global shutter
Pre-capture
That camera is going to be able to capture images
That we could only dream on with our DSLRs
So you do have a big advantage
If you can afford these really amazing cameras
But there's one extremely critical important point
It still requires a person
Or somebody behind the camera
Being in the right place
At the right time
And using their creative abilities
And their imagination
To capture these shots
I can't tell you how many bad shots
I've seen on the very best gear
And how I've seen some of my favourite images
On old gear
The photographer's skill
Will always be important
We always need to understand the light
Composition
Behaviour
Exposure
Setting
There's a whole range of things
That go into capturing a good photo
Not just the camera itself
Now remember Mark put it best when he said
I have no issues with cameras
Having eye tracking or predictive focus
These advancements are no different
From auto exposure and auto focus
Does it take the skill out of photography
Heck no
I can still take bad photos
With all this assistance
And he's completely right you know
Auto exposure and auto focus
Film photographers are saying
That ruined photography
So it's just where do we draw the line
Which technology do we embrace
And which ones do we say is no go
So it's a difficult one isn't it
I want to demonstrate this
I'll show you a photo
From one of my recent videos
This is the one of the worst photos
I've ever taken of a Eurasian coot
And that was taken on my R5
And my 500F4 worth $10,000 plus
A lot of money
And compare that to this image of a coot
Which was taken with my $40 40D
And a 400 5.6
This image is so much better
It's there's no comparison
What's the difference between these two images
It's the experience and the knowledge
Of the photographer behind the camera
To get themselves in the position
To make a good shot
Now a great comment I got
They said Dwade
If you believe your skills are so good
Why did you spend thousands of dollars on an R5
Why aren't you still using your old 40D
And it's a great question
And to be honest for me
It depends on why you're taking photos
And what you're trying to achieve
For me I'm trying to capture behavior
Uniqueness
And I want a really detailed image
With great image quality
And all the tricky light
And all these different situations
And an R5 is the camera
That does that the best
It makes my job the easiest
I could probably try with a 40D
But it's just going to be a lot more harder
I'm going to get a lot less keepers
And it will just ultimately be frustrating for me
I think we need to switch this around in our thinking
And just think how lucky we are
To live in an age
Where the photographer can choose the challenge
If you want the ultimate challenge
Shoot on film
If you want a bit more of a challenge
Shoot on a DSLR
If you want the least amount of challenge
Then use these modern cameras
And it's entirely up to each and every one of us
Which ones we decide on
And which ones we use
Now I have to admit I do have a privilege
I'm very lucky that I can afford this camera
So it's easy for me to sit here and say that
And I do respect that
Some people just can't afford these
But I think if we start comparing ourselves
To other people
We start looking at the cameras they're using
Looking at the photos they're creating
It's a surefire way to a bit of envy
And a bit of disappointment
And that is not healthy for us
Whatsoever
We should just be trying to get the very best we can
With the gear that we have
Enjoy the process
Get out there
And just enjoy yourself
Alrighty so that brings this video to an end
In conclusion
I do not think AI and technology is ruining photography
In fact I think it's expanding it
I think it's creating new ways for people to enjoy
And express themselves
Whether that's AI created images
Manipulated images
Or images shot on film
I think there's enough room and enough space
For all forms of photography
We just need to be open
Honest about it
And create safe spaces
Or spaces where people can share
These images that they've worked hard for
On old DSLRs
I think that's really really important
So I would love to hear from you
What are your thoughts
Do you think it's all doom and gloom
What do you think we need to do
Have I covered off on all these topics
Feel free to leave your comments below
I love reading them
Other people like reading them
And just let's get a conversation going about this
Because it's not going away
Technology is only going to keep improving
We'd be naive to think otherwise
So I think we need to embrace it
And just figure out what we enjoy
And just keep doing that
So until the next video
Take care
Happy birding
See you later
