Spear and shield - overarm vs underarm

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 1, 2025
Hi folks, this is potentially quite a big topic but I'm just going to do a sort of very
brief intro to it and it is the subject of the spear and the shield in use together and
really the topic that I'm quite interested in that there's been a lot spoken about is
the difference between underarm use of the spear and overarm. Now what's very evident
is when you give people spears and shields and you get them sparring, most people one
on one feel much more comfortable using the spear underarm. It's kind of like how you
thrust with a sword most of the time. It just feels more natural, it's less tiring on the
arms. I think most people find it's got longer range as well as I certainly do. I find I
can hold the spear further towards the back and thrust it like a great big long sword.
However, in artwork for a huge period of time, whether you're looking at ancient Greek vases
for example or whether you're looking at a Dark Age, Vanglo-Saxon, Frankish, Viking period
art, or indeed whether you're looking at 15th century art where they're still using the
sword and shield, particularly in Southern Europe, in Spain and Italy, it's very, very
common to see the spear held up like this. We all know it was often used like this in
African countries and Asian countries as well. So overarm with the shield here. Why might
that be? When you hold it like this, you can't hold the spear as far back because the head
kind of becomes unwieldy and heavy for most people. Your forearm and your wrist just doesn't
really work very well to support it. So you have to hold the weapon further forward which
gives you less reach. It's more tiring on the deltoid muscle on your shoulder. So why
would it be that it's so common throughout history and across the world to see spears
used like this? As a first thought, and I'll talk about this more in future videos and
other possible thoughts and theories and ideas, and please share yours in the comments below
here, I think there are two things that are probably the dominant reasons why this is
such a common position to see spear and shield used in. Firstly, it's the throwing position.
And in a lot of places in a lot of periods of time, this spear has not only been a hand
weapon but it has also been a missile weapon. It's been the only missile weapon. And whether
you're looking at fights between ancient Greek warriors or whether you're looking at fights
between Maasai tribesmen, it's common to have the spear as both the stabbing weapon and
the throwing weapon. Of course the opponent doesn't know when you're going to launch it
and throw it. And I've sparred in tournaments where throwing the spear was allowed and I'll
tell you it completely changes your tactics when you know that your opponent might throw
the weapon at any point. It makes you much more cautious to close in and your legs are
very vulnerable especially to throws. So even if you protect your high parts with the shield
very effectively, if they suddenly throw it down your leg there's not an awful lot you
can do to avoid it unless you're really quick on your feet. So I think that's one reason
why it's often held up here because it means that you've got the option to stab or throw
at an absolute blink of an eye with no hesitation. You can do either and your opponent doesn't
know which you're going to do. And it's important to mention that most cultures that sometimes
do their spears have a secondary weapon like a short sword for backup. So once they throw
this and probably immediately after they've thrown it they draw the sword and go straight
into close combat with the sword before the opponent can regather their guard position
and such. The second reason why I think this position was very common in history is if
you imagine that rather than just me standing here I'm surrounded by my mates, my fellow
soldiers who are fighting on my side and we're all hemmed in and we're all in a fighting
force together. Our shields are maybe touching in a shield wall and clearly I don't want
to hit the guy behind me or the guy next to me in the face with the back end of my spear
or the side of my spear. Now if I'm holding my spear up here it's perfect. I can fight
the opponents in front of me or to the side of me, either side of me here. I'm not going
to hit the guys next to me or behind me. The back end of my spear is sticking up in the
air safely away from the guys behind me and my arm is up so no matter how many people
were squashed around me I can still operate my weapon. I can still stand and importantly
it stabs downwards towards their face and chest over the top of their shields. Now if
I switch grip to this grip that feels more comfortable when we do sparring that's totally
useless for standing in a group because my arm is now down at the height where it's going
to get squashed against my compatriots either side of me. The back end of my spear is poking
the guy behind me in the face and chest which he's not going to like and in fact I don't
really have space to operate the spear because I don't have enough space behind me to operate
it and it just doesn't work. So there we go. I think those are the two main reasons why
in historical artwork and anthropologically in different cultures around the world this
holding the spear up here is so common to see. Firstly because it's very versatile for
both hand to hand combat and throwing and secondly because if you're fighting in a close
formation in a close group it makes far far more sense than holding the spear like this
does. One on one in a dueling situation I love this position, it's great. But in a battle
situation I can see why it was maybe not so popular. Okay, thank you.
