Smart English Learning: The Realism Approach

LangAdvance English
110 followers
Sep 28, 2025
Discover the Realism Approach to smart English learning in this video. Learn how authenticity can enhance your language skills and make learning more effective.
Hello and welcome to another lesson. Today we are going to talk about realism. This is the second
era of American literary culture that we are going to look at out of five. We are not going
to investigate the colonial period because it's very difficult English. So we did romanticism
last time. We're doing realism this time. So let's get started. First, a review quiz over
romanticism. Number one, romanticism focuses on thought over feelings, true or false. Number two,
romantics were trying to escape modern artificial life, true or false. Number three, who was most
important to romantic authors? Number four, romantics primarily wrote stories about love,
true or false. Number five, romantics utilized logic, true or false. Pause if you need to.
All right, your answers here. Number one is false. Okay, they focus on feelings over thought. Romantics
were trying to escape modern artificial life, true. Nature was the moral. Nature was the standard
for which we should strive. So they often returned to nature. Number three, the self, the individual,
was the most important to romantic authors. That's why feelings had such a high
standard for them, was such a high thing to go after for them. Romantics primarily wrote stories
about love. This is false. There are romantic things because love is a huge emotion that we
have as human beings. However, it is not the primary purpose. Despite the fact they're being
romantic, think of romantic as in the ideal, not just romantic love. Romantics utilized logic.
Not as much as you would think. They do work on introspective speech. They do look at going through
how the character is going to wrestle with an idea, and they're wrestling with their feelings
and the intense emotions that they're feeling, like the princess in The Lady and the Tiger.
However, they do not use logic as much. It's not like the character sits down and makes a plan
and weighs their options and tries to think of, you know what, what if we just break him out
of the arena and then he never has to face it. We can run away together. No, that's not something
that she thinks about. Instead, she wrestles with her feelings. So this is what we get with the
romantics. It's very deep. It's very high type of literature to listen to and to think of because
it's all so abstract. However, it still makes sense because it's still relatable because these
are feelings that we can understand. We can understand these feelings of intense hatred,
even maybe we've never felt them ourselves, but we can understand them because they are still
somewhat relatable. That's what makes romanticism so potent. Now, realism is pretty much the exact
opposite of romanticism. This is a movement that began in France in the mid 1800s right after
France's romantic period fizzled out. You see, what happened is people started to get tired of
all of this idealism because honestly, you still have to live, you still have to work, you still
have to pay taxes and people still die. So what was the point of going for the ideal and living
for feelings and making rash decisions when we could just take life for what it is and keep going?
How much more responsible is it to be able to take care of the next generation
if we prepare for them today? So you get realism here. Realism presents life as it should be. So
details, not life as it should be, but they present life as it is. There we go. So realism
has a lot to do with the mundane. A lot of, you know, this is a person and this is what they saw
today. This is what happened to them today. The end. What? Is that a story? It sounds more like
a story than a plot. You see, with realism, it's unique because what they do is they describe
something that's completely normal and completely non-heroic, non-ideal. There's no
feeling wrestling. I mean, there's a little bit of wrestling going on, but nothing
crazy like romanticism, nothing to the extreme that you would find in romanticism. So just
something more like you would find nowadays, something that you would struggle with, like,
should I choose pepperoni pizza or supreme pizza? It's the same kind of thing. You can write a
realism story on that. And what you have to do as the reader is you decide what the plot is. You
decide the intent of each character in the story and why they're acting the way they are. Basically,
if you want a good example of realism, go to a shopping mall, sit down on a bench, watch people,
and then create a story in your mind on what's going on. That's a pretty good example of realism.
So very simple, very direct writing from an objective author. It's very reader-centered
rather than the author-centered. Romanticism is very author-centered. Whatever the author perceives
to be true, perceives to be ideal, perceives to be true from nature is what they're going to write
about. It's the author's feelings. But realism is reader-centered. It allows you, the reader,
to determine meaning. It just gives you the tools. It gives you the setting. And what happens in your
job is to create the story and to make assumptions and to comprehend. So very interesting how
opposite these are. And the fact that they're opposites happened back and back. Like, people
got tired of romanticism, so they went straight into realism. It was so interesting to me that
they did this. Now, I want to point out that when realism happened in America, it was between the
1860s and the 1890s. Now, in American history, the 1860s is the American Civil War. Okay, so you have
between 1860 and 1865 is the American Civil War. Lots of terrible things happening. So many people
dying and just destroying so much of the natural farmland that's around, the natural forests that
are around because a war is happening. But in the 1890s, you've got monopolies taking place,
you've got oil things taking place, you've got a lot of the Industrial Revolution in full swing,
you've got all kinds of innovation and craziness happening leading up to the turn of the century.
So notice that realism fizzles out the more powerful big companies become. Very,
very interesting to me that that's how it coincides in history and what's going on at the
time. So without further ado, let's get into some more. An author of realism, a realistic author if
you would, if you believe that, he takes an interest in the details rather than the story.
So they describe what the setting is, they describe the little looks between characters,
they describe how they look, they describe their behavior, but they're not necessarily
talking about the story itself. They're not explaining the plot. They're just explaining
things as they change and as it goes, and that's for you, the reader, to put together the plot.
They try to be extremely faithful in how they describe reality. You are not going to get a
fairy tale setting. You are not going to get an idealistic setting. You are going to get just a
very mundane explanation of what you would normally see. For Americans out there, it's
like going to Walmart. They would describe the things you would find on the shelf and the types
of people you might run into. It's not going to talk about like this hero bursting or this anti
hero or this evil bad guy. It's not going to be anything like that. In fact, you're not likely
to see a pure evil person in realism or a purely good person. You're not going to see an anti hero.
You're not even going to see any type of hero. You're going to see normal people going about
daily life. Number two, they turn away from the noble and the heroic of romanticism toward familiar
everyday aspects of life. Less like a fairy tale. In fact, the author of realism, you're likely,
I guess, one of the things that would most draw on this parable. Because parables use extremely
relatable events that we can all understand in order to explain a complex truth. Well,
the author of realism is not trying to explain anything. They're trying to give you the tools
in order to create your own story out of it. As such, people reading realism might understand
character behavior completely differently from one another. Another beautiful thing about realism.
It's really interesting. Number three, the author of realism prefers a straightforward and matter
of fact manner of narration. Nothing crazy, nothing flippant, just straightforward matter of fact.
He focuses on common people and adopts a critical attitude in the portrayal of their life.
It tends to be rather critical. You kind of feel like the author is acting like a very strict
father sometimes when they're describing the people and the stories. But at other times, they're just
they're just so matter of fact, so simple. I'll get into showing you what we mean here very soon.
All right, differences between realism and romanticism. Realism is objective while romanticism
is subjective. And the point of this is realism is striving to give you, the reader, the details
and the faithfully so. Think of realism like a journalist in many ways. They're reporting what
they see. And romantics, they're very subjective. It's all about what they see. It's all about what
the author sees and what they want to paint and create. Realism is very reader-centered while
romanticism, author-centered. Three, simple matter-of-fact writing, whereas romanticism,
as we saw in The Lady and the Tiger, deep, confusing, and difficult writing. I'm sure you
picked that up as an English language learner. I'm sure you really picked that up. Number four,
presenting real life. Romanticism presents life how one thinks it should be, how the author thinks
life should be. All right, we're going to use O. Henry's Witches' Loaves. And as crazy as that
sounds, I understand. By the end of the story, you'll understand why it says witches. So let's
get into it. Make sure you pause and read before you hear my voice. Miss Martha Mecham kept a little
bakery on the corner, the one where you go up three steps and the bell tingles when you open
the door. Miss Martha was 40. Her bank book showed a credit of $2,000 and she possessed two false
teeth and a sympathetic heart. Many people have married whose chances to do so were much inferior
to Miss Martha's. Two or three times a week, a customer came in whom she began to take an
interest. He was a middle-aged man wearing spectacles and a brown beard trimmed to a careful
point. He spoke English with a strong German accent. His clothes were worn and darned in
places and wrinkled and baggy and others, but he looked neat and had very good manners.
He always bought two loaves of stale bread. Fresh bread was five cents a loaf. Stale ones were two
for five. Never did he call for anything but stale bread. Once Miss Martha saw red and brown stain on
his fingers. She was sure then that he was an artist and very poor. No doubt he lived in a
garret where he painted pictures and ate stale bread and thought of the good things to eat in
Miss Martha's bakery. Often Miss Martha sat down to her chops and light rolls and jam and tea she
would sigh and wish that the gentle-mannered artist might share her tasty meal instead of
eating his dry crust in that droughty attic. Miss Martha's heart, as you have been told it, was a
sympathetic one. In order to test her theory as to his occupation, she brought from her room one day
a painting that she had bought at a sale and set it against the shelves behind the bread counter.
It was a Venetian scene. A splendid marble palazzio, so it is said on the picture, stood on the
rather forewater. For the rest, there was a gondolas with a lady trailing her hand in the
water, clouds, sky, and chiaroscuro in plenty. No artist could fail to notice it. Two days afterward,
the customer came in. Two loaves of stale bread, if you please. You have here a fine picture, madam,
he said while she was wrapping up the bread. Yes, said Miss Martha, reveling in her own cunning.
I do so admire art, and no, would not do so to say artist, thus early, and paintings,
she substituted. You think it is a good picture? Their balance, said the customer, is not good
drawn. Their perspective is not true. Good morning, madam. He took his bread, bowed, and hurried out.
Yes, he must be an artist. Miss Martha took the picture back to her room. How gentle and kindly
his eyes shone behind his spectacles. What a broad brow he had. To be able to judge perspective
at a glance, and to live on stale bread, but genius often has to struggle before it is recognized.
What a thing it would be for an art and perspective if genius were backed by two thousand
dollars in a bank, a bakery, and a sympathetic heart, too. But these were daydreams, Miss Martha.
Oh now, when he came, he would chat for a while across the showcase.
Often now, when he came, he would chat for a while across the showcase. He seemed to crave Miss
Martha's cheerful words. He kept on buying stale bread. Never a cake, never a pie, never one of her
delicious Sally loons. She thought he began to look thinner and discouraged. Her heart ached
to add something good to eat to his meager purchase, but her courage failed at the act.
She did not dare affront him. She knew the pride of artists.
Miss Martha took to wearing her blue-dotted silk waist behind the counter. In the back room,
she cooked a mysterious compound of quince seeds and borax. Ever so many people use it for the
complexion. One day, the customer came in as usual, laid his nickel on the showcase, and called for
his stale loaves. While Miss Martha was reaching for them, there was a great tooting and clanging,
and a fire engine came lumbering past. The customer hurried to the door to look, as anyone will.
Suddenly, inspired, Miss Martha seized the opportunity. On the bottom shelf behind the
counter was a pound of fresh butter that the dairyman had left ten minutes before.
With a bread knife, Miss Martha made a deep slash in each of the stale loaves,
inserted a generous quantity of butter, and pressed the loaves tight again. When the customer
turned once more, she was tying the paper around them. When he had gone, after an unusually pleasant
little chat, Miss Martha smiled to herself, but not without a slight fluttering of the heart.
Had she been too bold? Would he take offense? Surely not. There was no language of edibles.
Butter was no emblem of unmaidenly forwardness. For a long time that day, her mind dwelt on the
subject. She imagined the scene when he should discover her little deception.
He would lay down his brushes and palette. There would stand his easel with a picture he was
painting in which the perspective was beyond criticism. He would prepare for his luncheon
He would slice into a loaf. Miss Martha blushed. Would he think of the hand that placed it there
as he ate? Would he? The front belt jangled viciously. Someone was coming in, making a
great deal of noise. Miss Martha hurried to the front. Two men were there. One was a young man
smoking a pipe, a man she had never seen before. The other was her artist. His face was very red.
His hat was on the back of his head. His hair was wildly rumbled. He clenched his two fists
and shook them ferociously at Miss Martha. At Miss Martha?
Dummkopf, he shouted with extreme loudness, and then Talsendorfer, or something like it in German.
The young man tried to draw him away. I will not go here yet, said he angrily. I shall, told her.
He made a brass drum, a bass drum, of Miss Martha's counter. You have spolt me, he said,
his blue eyes blazing behind his spectacles. I will tell you. You von vis medding some old cat.
Miss Martha leaned weakly against the shelves and laid one hand on her blue-dotted silk waist.
The young man took the other by the collar. Come on, he said. You've said enough.
He dragged the angry one out at the door to the sidewalk, and then came back. Yes,
you ought to be told, man, he said. What the row is about? That's Blumberger. He's an architectural
draftsman. I work in the same office with him. He's been working hard for three months on drawing
the plan for a new city hall. It was a prize competition. He finished inking the lines
yesterday. You know, a draftsman always makes his drawing in pencil first. When it's done,
he rubs out the pencil lines with handfuls of stale bread crumbs. That's better than India
rubber. Blumberger's been buying the bread here. Well, today, you know. Well, man, that butter
isn't—well, Blumberger's plan isn't good for anything now except to cut it up at the railroad
sandwiches. Miss Martha went into the back room. She took off the blue-dotted silk waist and put
it on the old brown chair serge she used to wear, and she poured the quince seed and borax mixture
out of the window into the ash can. Okay, so, which is loaves, which in English can be used
as an insult. It means you are mainly women, being just a terrible woman. There's other words too,
but to call a woman a witch right now is not a good thing. So, what kind of narrator do we see
in this story? We see—he's talking from Miss Martha's memory or her mind, maybe. We can see
her thoughts, but we don't see the thoughts of anyone else. We only see people and see the world
as she sees it. Therefore, we are dealing with a third-person, limited-omniscient narrator.
What kind of setting is this? It's realism, so remember setting is very important.
We're looking at a physical setting. We have a shop with three steps up to it and a bell
that tingles when you open the door. We have butter that was put on a lower shelf. We have
shelves behind her, and she stands behind the counter, and there's batches of bakery stuff
around. So, we have a physical setting. We have no idea where it is or anything else. Her customer
is German, but she speaks English, so we don't know even where she is, honestly.
Divide the story into parts of plot. Use one sentence each. What was Miss Martha thinking
throughout the complication? Okay, let's get into the next slide a little bit. That's where I think
it's going to help us out, and the elements of realism in the story. So, if you can think of it,
pause before, answer the questions, and then come back for the answers. Okay, let's get going on the
answers here. So, we have the exposition, Miss Martha Owns a Bakery, and then there's this whole
description of the bakery. The complication is when she thinks of this German man. He comes in
regularly. She describes him, then she starts thinking about him. She starts assuming that he
is an artist and all these things. The climax is when she's brave enough to try to help this poor
artist by putting butter in the bread, and she's trying to do it to be kind, but he comes in very
angry, and he just blows up at her. He calls her an idiot, basically, in German. He's telling her,
you're an idiot. How dare you, basically. You are a meddling cat, and then his friend takes him out
and explains to her the resolution, which is he is a draftsman. He was in a competition. He's been
drawing for three months for the new city hall. He just finished with the lines, and the butter
and the bread ruined it because he uses stale breadcrumbs to erase lines. So, there you go.
That is the story in a nutshell, basically. So, what was Miss Martha thinking throughout the
She fantasized about the man being an artist, and she even had a crush on him. She was thinking about
possibly backing him up and being with him. She started to put a special wash
for her face and started wearing this fancy blue silk waist. Yeah, she liked him, but
she ruined things pretty easily with her generosity. You know, she should have been
talking to him. She should have learned more about him before jumping the gun, as we would
say in English. So, what are the elements of realism in the story? Lots of daily life. Notice
that this story, there's nothing crazy happening. This story is about a classic misunderstanding.
That's it. A lady who's older and well-established, she sees this guy coming in about her age, and
they have very charming conversations, and they meet each other often, and all of this stuff, and
she starts to fantasize about him because she has a crush on him, and then she totally
misunderstood him. Putting butter in the bread actually ruined his competition piece, and now
he's angry. What are the implications of that? What's going to happen next? Well, she dumps the
face powder out, and she took the silk waist and took it off, and so I guess she's giving up now.
She's just going to keep doing what she was doing before. So, basically shattered her fantasy, her
thoughts, her high hopes. So, it's the simple and the ordinary. Very simple story, just explaining
what's happening, and then it's left up to us. What happens after this? Where does the German guy go?
What does Miss Martha do? Do they ever see each other again? Do they reconcile? Do they try to
talk it out? Or do they just remain embarrassed of each other? Who knows? Who knows what happens?
So, I want you to practice realism now. I want you to explain what in the world is happening in
this picture, and do it the way a realist author would. A realist author would just explain the
setting, basically. It would tell the reader what's going on, but not why, not the plot. It's
going to tell you what's going on. Give it a try. Okay, if you have not done so yet, you can pause
and do so, but I'm about to move on and give you an example. A little girl's birthday party is bright,
fun, and busy, but the birthday girl's best friend is not having the best time. She doesn't smile
unless someone talks to her. After three hours, the party is finished. Everyone goes home. The
birthday girl and her best friend clean up the party quietly. Very, very short, simple things
that happen all the time anyway in normal life. There's no explanation of why the one girl isn't
smiling. There's no explanation of why they're quiet after the party. Nothing. It's up to you,
the reader, to determine. This is a great example of realism. All right, so remember that realism
was most alive in American literature between 1860 and 1890. This does not mean that realism does not
exist even today. It does. We have some movies with realism elements. We have all kinds of stuff
with realism, but the main period for realism as a movement was 1860 to 1890 in American history.
So, realism focuses on daily life. Slice of life details is your keyword there. There are no heroes,
just normal people, simple writing, and the reader gives the piece meaning. In some cases
with comprehension, you, the reader, will be giving meaning. You, the reader, will determine
what it means within a context. The important thing for you to know, though, is that you,
the reader, have to acknowledge the context in which something was written and delivered. Who
is the intended audience? When was it written? What is the time the author wrote this? For example,
this story with witch's loaves definitely seems to be an older piece because that's not exactly
a bakery's work anymore anyway. And draftsmen, I'm not sure that they still use breadcrumbs,
stale breadcrumbs, to do the work that they're doing. So, the way she described the way he was
dressed also makes me think this is an older story. So, definitely keep these things in mind.
How the story describes it then is not necessarily what would happen now. So,
keep all this in mind as you practice comprehension. And next, we're going to
get into naturalism. So, I will see you in the next lesson.
