FULL DISCLOSURE: I am an Adobe affiliate, and I will earn a commission if you purchase using the link directly above. Please read my Code of Ethics Statement:
Hi everyone, Anthony Morganti here.
Recently you may have noticed that there have been a lot of videos on Nano, Banana
and Photoshop.
Also, you may have noticed that none of those videos have been from me.
There's two reasons for that.
The first reason is I'm really not into it.
I really don't care for using AI in post-production in this manner.
At the end of this video, I'll go into more detail about that.
The second reason why I haven't done any videos on Nano, Banana and Photoshop is because that
it was, until recently, only available as a paid plugin.
So you had to purchase a plugin and install it.
And the installation process wasn't trivial.
You had to get an API key, you had to load the API key.
So it was an entire process that I wasn't really interested in doing.
Also, to use it, you had to purchase credits from Google.
Well, now Nano, Banana is built into the beta version of Photoshop.
It's not a plugin that you have to install and you don't have to purchase any credits
from Google.
It just uses your normal Creative Cloud credits.
So in today's video, I'm going to show you how to use it.
Now as I mentioned, it's in the current beta version of Photoshop.
If you have a Creative Cloud subscription, you could download the beta version of Photoshop.
To do that, open up the Creative Cloud app and on the left-hand side, click on Apps.
Then at the top, click on Beta.
And then right here, you could download it.
And the beta version of Photoshop could run side-by-side on your computer with the current
version of Photoshop.
Now to use Nano, Banana in Photoshop, it's just like using Gender to Fill.
As a matter of fact, it's part of Gender to Fill.
To use Gender to Fill in Photoshop, you need to make a selection first.
So let's just say on this specific image, I want her eyes open.
So I need to make a selection of her eyes.
I'm going to use the Selection Brush tool to do that.
The Selection Brush tool is here with the Lasso tools, right at the top.
And it's just a brush.
I'm just going to paint right over her eyes, as simple as that.
Once I do that, on the Contextual Taskbar, you'll have Gender to Fill.
Click on that.
Now, by default, it's going to use Adobe's engine to do this.
That's Firefly.
We want to use Nano, Banana.
To use Nano, Banana, click on the little F5 right here.
And you'll notice that we have Firefly Image 3.
That's the current version of Firefly.
Firefly Image 1, which was a previous version.
Then we have actually two partner models.
One is Clux Context Pro, and I'll cover that in this video as well.
I don't think it works as well, in most situations, as Gemini 2.5, which is Nano, Banana.
That's the one we're going to use.
So just click on that.
Then we're going to tell it what we want.
We're going to write Open Her Eyes, all right?
That's it.
And then we're going to click on Generate.
So it's actually going to use Nano, Banana to do this.
Now, unlike Firefly, it will only give us one variation.
If you've ever used Generate, Fill, and Photoshop previously, you know that it gives us three
variations.
Those are three Firefly variations.
In this case, it gives us this single variation.
Now if you don't like it, you can come up here and click Generate again.
It will give you a second variation.
Of course, it's going to use more of your Creative Cloud credits to do that.
If you want to try a different model, go over here where we now have the G for Google.
Click on that.
Let's say we want to try this Flux Context Pro.
Click on that and click Generate.
Now it will use Flux Context Pro, which I think is part of Black Forest Labs, another
just partner they have doing this.
And you can see what this does.
And again, it will only give us one variation of this.
You can see this one's taking a little longer.
That one looks pretty good.
So there's Flux Context Pro, and there is the Nano, Banana, or Google version of the
image.
I kind of like the Flux one a little better.
Playing with this, I found that Flux for simple things like this often works very well, but
the blending isn't as good when you're doing larger things, and maybe we'll run into that
in this video.
As you know, it's kind of hit and miss.
Sometimes when you try to do a generative fill, it will be perfect.
Then you're doing it a second time on the same exact image, with the same exact selection,
with the same exact prompt, and it fails miserably.
Well, Flux Context Pro and Nano, Banana are no different.
Often they work perfectly, but then sometimes they fail miserably, and it's just kind of
hit and miss.
Now let's just, for the sake of completeness, compare this to what we would have got from
regular old Adobe's Photoshop Firefly.
So what we'll do is we'll go here, click on this, and we'll go to Firefly Image 3, keeping
the same exact prompt, and we'll click Generate.
Now because we're using Firefly, it's giving us three variations of this.
Now it doesn't overwrite, and you won't lose the other two that we got, the one from Flux
Context Pro or the one from Nano, Banana.
Those are still there.
But you can see how that is horrible.
That, she looks kind of funny, and that is horrible.
But if we scroll down, there's the original Nano, Banana, and here's the one from Flux
Context Pro.
So you can see those worked out better, much better than the Firefly versions.
Now let's do something a little more complex, and let's maybe talk about how it can fail.
For example, let's just say I want these two people in this scene to be facing the camera.
You may be tempted to just go up to the contextual taskbar and click on Select Subject, and what
it will do is it will get a selection of them, and it's a pretty precise selection.
Then we'll click on Generative Fill, and then we'll go over here and we'll make sure we're
using Nano, Banana, and we're going to type in the prompt, is have them face and look
at the camera.
That's going to be our prompt, and we'll click Generate.
Now again, this is hit and miss, but when I tried this in practice, it cut off part
of the man's face, and I actually did it twice.
One time it cut off about half of his face, and then the second time it cut off maybe
a quarter of his face.
So you can see here it cut off part of his face.
So you can see that that didn't work out well at all.
Now I actually wanted them turned and face the camera, so I kind of screwed that up.
So to make this work, let's undo this totally.
Just hit Command Z on my Mac a few times, or Command Z, Control Z on a PC.
So we're right back kind of where we started.
Now to make it work properly is you need to get a selection of them, but it's a loose
selection.
So again, we'll use the Selection Brush tool.
I'll get a larger brush, and you're just going to go like this.
So don't try to get exact selections.
Often the exact selections won't work as well.
So get a complete selection of them like that.
Then we're going to again go to Generative Fill.
We're going to again go use Nano Banana, and then I want them to actually turn.
Oops.
If I could spell right.
Have them turn and face the camera.
All right.
So we'll try that.
And we'll Generate, and we'll have them turn and face the camera.
This way, every time I tried it, it worked perfectly, but again, it's hit and miss.
I don't know what we're going to get, but let's see.
And once it does it, again, it just gives you the one variation here.
This is a little better.
Now one thing about blending, you can see the blending here is pretty bad.
You can see that up above, it's kind of all like very hard edge.
By default, when you use the Selection Brush tool, it's going to have a hard edge.
So what you need to do, I'll undo this again by hitting Command Z, is you need to go up
to the brush, and at the top right here for the brush itself, you want to take Hardness
all the way down.
With Hardness all the way down, then do your Selection like this.
So it's a softer brush, and this will help it blend better.
You notice too, when other people were doing the demos on Nano Banana, it always worked
perfectly every single time, and I found a lot of times it didn't, and it's because
they weren't telling you these little tricks you need to do to make it work better.
So once we have our selection, click on Generative Fill, again, we're going to use Nano Banana,
and I'm going to write, have, gosh darn, I can't type.
Have them turn and face the camera.
All right, just like that.
We'll click Generate.
Now this should work a lot better.
Also, from what I understand right now, this is going to be relatively low resolution,
only like a thousand pixel resolution, so it's not going to, if you have a really high
resolution image that you're doing something to, it might not look right.
Now you can see how this one blended much better.
They are facing the camera, and if I zoom in by hitting Command Plus on my Mac, Control
Plus on the PC, and I kind of move around a little bit, you can see it blended pretty
good, so it's a lot better.
So make sure that when you do this, that you use a soft brush, and this will make it look
a little more effective, better.
Now you may be wondering, well, how is this with one of the other models?
So let's try this Flux Context Pro, and we'll click Generate, and again, it doesn't show
our selection, but it knows what to do, it's using the selection, and in practice, I tried
this with Flux Context Pro, and it didn't blend as well at all, and it didn't look right.
But again, it's hit and miss, it may work better for, you know, this time around, you
don't know.
But we'll go, and you can see now they are facing the camera, and it does look pretty
good.
Now, supposedly, from what I've been reading, the Flux Context Pro is a higher resolution
than Nano Banana.
So if you can get away with using Flux Context Pro, you may want to use that instead, because
it will give you a higher resolution, like, replacement in the middle there, so that
it will look better.
Again, we'll hit Command-Plus a couple times, kind of zoom around, and it doesn't, I don't
know, it looks kind of low resolution to me, it doesn't, their faces look funny, and if
I go back to the Nano Banana version, their faces look more natural, as you can see.
Now, just in order to be complete, let's go up here and let's use the current Firefly
model, and click Generate, and we'll see what this does, and I suspect this will probably
fail pretty bad, because I haven't tried this, actually, in practice, but I'm just got a
feeling, yeah, it replaced the people totally, so, obviously.
Nowhere near as good as the other versions.
There's the Flux Context Pro, and here is the Nano Banana version.
Now, this one, I only did this one, I only did once, and it worked so beautifully, I
just couldn't believe how good it was, but again, who knows what's going to happen here,
so I'm going to just get a softer brush again, and select the woman totally, like this, alright,
so we have a selection, and we're going to click Generate a Fill, I'm going to click
here and make sure we're using Nano Banana, and I'm just going to type have her face the
camera, alright, and then we're going to click Generate, and I only did this once, and it
hit or turned totally towards the camera, and it looked like perfect, but who knows
what we'll get, you know, when you do these things, and that's part of the reason why
I don't care for this AI, but you can see it looks pretty good there, not bad, overall
it kind of bent the window a little bit here, you can see that bend in the window, sometimes
you always look at fingers, if you're ever doing any type of AI thing, and a person's
hand is getting generated, you always want to look at their hand and make sure they have
all their fingers, or not an extra finger, or maybe a distorted finger, or something
like that, so again, let's try it with the Flux Context Pro, I think I said Flux before,
because that's what I actually wrote on my notes for some reason, but we'll do that one,
and we'll see what that one looks like, and I tried this in practice, and it didn't blend
well at all, it was really messed up, and her face looked funny, and let that do its
thing, this takes a little longer, as you can see, and that one actually doesn't look
too bad this time, she's got some more blemishes on her face that probably aren't there in
real life, but overall, and the background looks funky right in here, and again, it's
going to fail miserably, but let's try this with Firefly, the current version of Firefly,
and click Generate, and this is going to give us three variations, and it's probably going
to replace her with an entirely different person, yes it did, alright, so there's one
variation, there's a second variation, third variation, here's the Flux Context Pro version,
and then here is the Nano Banana version, I like that one the best, I think of all of
them, I think that one looks pretty good, still kind of messed up the background a little
bit, but it looks pretty decent.
So that's Nano Banana built into the current beta version of Photoshop, and I mentioned
that at the end of the video, I mentioned why I don't care for these things.
If you put photography on a scale, and on one side of the scale you have documentary
photography, and then at the other side of the scale you have like creative photography,
like you know, dreamscape type photography, I personally would lean more towards the documentary
side, I like things to be more realistic, it's just my personal taste, I'm not saying
that anyone who likes this type of thing, or any type of dreamscape photography, anything
that is surreal, I'm not saying that they're wrong for it, I'm just saying it's not something
I care for, so because I care for more realism, naturally I wouldn't care for something like
this, but if you are someone who is really into dreamscapes, or into doing things, making
situations that aren't really there, this is just the tip of the iceberg, this is only
going to get better, and it's going to get better exponentially, so I think in another
year or two, it's going to be like flawless, and it's going to be at a much higher resolution,
at what cost I don't know, but if you're really into that, you should be very excited, because
I think you'll be able to do things like the photo of Salvador Dali, like water flying
and cats flying through the air, you know, photography actually did that scene, and they
had cats flying through the air, and terrorized some cats, well now you can do it without
terrorizing any felines, you could just have it, you know, have someone's image, and then
have that scene created for you using AI, and I think it's going to be very high quality,
very soon. So with that said, that's my take on AI, this type of AI used in post-production,
and again, in the description of this video, I'll have a link to my current newsletter,
the current issue of my newsletter, in there I write about AI and photography, and some of the
things we should be worried about, and some of the things we should be excited about too,
for that matter. Thank you everyone who watches my videos, I really do appreciate it, talk to you
guys soon.