Sony Fanboy Perspective: Lumix S1II Is Just Better… Kinda

Technical Sea
259 followers
So I've been shooting everything with the Lumix S1 Mark II for the last two months
on my YouTube videos, my client projects, we even shot a whole music video with this camera
and I got to give a big shout out to Lumix for the long-term loaner so that I got some legit
time with this camera and I'm kind of happy about that because now I kind of want one.
So I really want to see if this thing could replace my now aging five-year-old Sony a7s3
which is my main YouTube workhorse which is what we're shooting with right now.
And after putting it through all kinds of shoots, I got a lot to say. I got a lot of
things on my mind here and in this video I'm going to break down my experience with video
as well as photography because I use this on a couple shoots and basically just the
usability aspects of the camera. I'll cover what I love and what frustrates me. So if
you're considering the S1 Mark II, this should give you a real-world rundown on what this camera
is capable of and this thing is packed. Like I said, it's got 6k open gate, 10-bit 420,
30 frames per second so you're getting the full sensor, 3 by 2 aspect ratio which means you can
crop, you can reframe, you can deliver in different aspect ratios without losing any
quality because you're shooting in 6k and probably delivering in like 1080p or 4k and
this also makes the obvious choice if you want to shoot anamorphic as well. And something I haven't
heard a lot of people say is that you can also shoot in 5.1k open gate at 60 frames per second.
Of course you can also shoot 4k at 120p in 16 by 9. That's all 10-bit with a tiny bit of a crop.
You don't really have to worry about crops with this camera unless you're shooting 4k 120. It
crops into like 1.2 or something like that. This camera actually has so many frame rates and
resolution options it's kind of overwhelming so I'm not going to go over all of them.
Oh and it also has internal ProRes and even ProRes RAW which is usually reserved for like
cinema cameras or most cameras just do it through the HDMI. This does it internally.
And at the heart of this camera it's rocking a 24 megapixel full frame half stack sensor.
The same one that's found in the Nikon Z6 III so you know it's not just about the resolution,
it's also about speed. This camera has really great rolling shutter performance, really fast
readout, crazy burst rates for stills and the other cool thing is Lumix collaborated with
so you can get ARRI log C in this camera which means you can shoot an ARRI log
and basically use any of the ARRI LUTs and get pretty much the same color science to make this
match with an ARRI. Now I'm saying that that's a paid upgrade but it's still cool that you can add
that to this camera. Now when it comes to the feel it feels pretty similar to the S5 II X which is
what I've been shooting with in the office up until now in my studio. Oh and by the way this
is the new office, the new studio I moved. I've been working on this for the last couple weeks
so this is where I spent most of my time. I'll give you a studio tour when I'm done with it but
this is where we're at. But yeah this camera feels like a proper professional workhorse camera. It's
solid build, all metal, weather sealed, it's like a chunky DSLR and it fits your hand nicely. I got
no complaints on the ergonomics. It's got all the IOU you'd expect, full size HDMI, USB-C for
charging or even using as a webcam. Got mic and headphone jacks and on the other side we've got
two dual card slots so we've got a CFexpress B as well as a UHS-II SD card slot. But yeah this
thing's built like a tank and that's something I've always kind of admired about Lumix cameras
all the way back to when I had a GH5. They're just designed to be workhorses. This camera has a three
inch tilty rotating four axis. The best screen you can get honestly. It's one of the best hybrid
screens in a camera right now. It's sharp, it's bright and it's awesome to see this being put
into all of the S1 lineup. That's perfect for low angle photography if you want to shoot it out like
that. You can flip it around for vlogging and stuff like that. So it's great for everything
and it's a touchscreen. So yeah when it comes to video this camera's a beast. Rolling shutter is
really well controlled. The IBIS is incredible. It's definitely hands down 100% the best IBIS you
can get in a camera and Panasonic has always done a great job with that. Like I said all the way back
to the GH5, dynamic range is some of the best I've seen in a hybrid camera. The files grade
beautifully. As I said I shot a whole music video with this thing. I did shoot it in V-Log though
because at the time I didn't have the Arri Log update with it and I'm super impressed with what
I got from it. I'm showing some of the clips here you can see what this looks like. I'll have a link
where you can see the full video. But yeah I've been shooting everything on this camera since
June. It's handled everything I've thrown at it. No overheating issues, 4k 60, 6k open gate. Now
there has been some people complaining about overheating while shooting 6k open gate. I haven't
done long enough continuous recording in 6k open gate to have that issue. So I'm not the guy to
come to if you have that issue. I'm just here showing you what this camera can do. I don't work
for Lumix. And this camera does have a fan in it. You can see the vent ports at the top and bottom
and then there's another vent underneath the uh well it's right above the mount. But I guess it's
not enough if it's a really hot day when you're shooting 6k open gate to deal with the heat.
And maybe that'll be fixed in a firmware update. Today's video is sponsored by Artlist and they
keep pushing the bar on what they offer creators on this platform. But they literally just added
VO3 and this is insane because this is way better. This is text to video. Well it's text to video and
audio and it's cool what we can do with this. So now we can come up with whatever creative ideas we
want. Type in our text prompt and it'll generate audio and video. So let's jump on the computer
because I want to show you what it can do. Alright so as I've shown before we've got our text to
image generator here. But if we go to the video icon uh down here we have three options now. So
we have light which is going to be fast it's more efficient uses less credits and you can still
generate some really good quality videos. Now if you go to standard it's using VO3 fast it's gonna
pump out a much better quality video. But if we want the most cinematic best looking quality we're
going to try out pro here. And as you can see as you come down the list the credits change. So it's
gonna take a little bit more credits to pump out a version from VO3 pro. I've come up with some
prompts that I thought would kind of work well for this. So let's try out this first one.
You know what just for speed sake I'm only gonna do 720p and let's generate this and see what
happens. Alright so just finished. It's time to go for a late night cruise and listen to some music
that your mother wouldn't like. Alright so just finished generating the third clip I asked it to
do. I'm gonna put these all together into a little sequence so you can see what that looks like.
It's time to go for a late night cruise and listen to some music that your mother wouldn't like.
So that's pretty wild what you can actually do with this. Now as I mentioned they keep pushing
the boundaries on what they keep offering with their subscription. So you get so much new stuff
all the time and I personally feel like they have the best royalty-free music as well. So if you
want to find out more or try it out for yourself make sure to check out artlist.io. The link will
be in the description. You know what I should actually switch out cameras. So I'm shooting
with the Sony a7s iii right now. Alright I'm now switched out. You can see the autofocus how it's
working here and we are in re log c so you can see what the colors look like and I'm also shooting
in open gate so you can see we got a more headroom as well as like more room down here. Now I could
crop it to 16 by 9 which is what I was using on the Sony a7s iii here and yeah you can kind of see
what that looks like and I think it looks great. So when it comes to autofocus for people and faces
I find that it's rock solid it locks on it tracks well definitely feels confident but when it comes
to like products and objects other things I'm trying to film sometimes it loses tracking and
gets confused and I'd like to say that Panasonic has fixed it in the S1 line because I know that
the S5 2x had kind of the same issue. It's still not 100% something I could rely on. It's definitely
not as bulletproof and reliable something like a newer Sony camera or like a Canon camera. Now that
said on the photography side of things the autofocus is excellent it's quick it's accurate
it's super sticky I didn't really have any problems tracking in a portrait session I did
we did some walking towards camera and stuff like that and so the autofocus in the photography side
of things is awesome and because this is a stack sensor you can rip off bursts up to 70 frames per
second with the electronic shutter which is pretty wild. We don't even see that in most flagship
cameras right now but the mechanical shutter is 10 frames per second and that's how I actually shot
majority of the time just because I prefer shooting with a mechanical shutter and the cool
thing is it's also blackout free. When it comes to the photo image quality the files look great
lots of detail the colors look great straight out of camera and the sensor is honestly kind of the
sweet spot for a hybrid camera. It's enough resolution for client work, prints, professional
jobs, it's good in low light and you're not going to be drowning in like massive file sizes so if
you're someone who wants one body that can handle serious video as well as photo so maybe you're
shooting sports, wildlife, fast movement stuff this thing's going to deliver and it holds up really
well it's definitely one of the best hybrid cameras you can buy right now especially for this
price. So I want to take a quick second and talk about the Lumix Lab app because you can actually
make your own presets in it which is really cool I haven't seen this in any other camera
and then you can transfer those to the camera and basically get something like a Fujifilm recipe but
something that you can actually create in the app. So I've already connected the camera to my phone
and I already have a bunch of images that I shot so if you go to transfer images
it's going to load everything that's coming straight off that SD card or the CFexpress card
from here you can pick your images and download them I'm going to download this one image and
then kind of edit around this one shot so transfer it to my phone in the gallery you'll see it here
and then you'll see a bunch of preset LUTs that they've made already and from here you can go in
and dial in your settings so you've got HSL you've got curves you've got exposure settings pretty
much everything you'd have in kind of like a mini light version of Lightroom which is really cool
and you can even add grain and different things like that and once you've done that you can save
this out as a look and this will now save this as a LUT right to your phone so you can access this
and edit the images the same way now we can give it a name I'm going to call it Edelia that's the
name of the model and it works well for a LUT name and once you're done it'll save it to the
phone and if you go over to LUTs you can see on camera here it's going to be a bunch of open
empty slots that you can save this to the other cool thing is too if you go to LUTs you can see
that they have a bunch of pre-made ones that you can download even a bunch made from different
creators but we're going to save our own LUT and transfer that to the camera so we're going to pick
a slot here I'm going to go to set four and LUT transfer and that's going to send it over to the
camera and super easy super quick and now to access that you go into the camera and you go to
looks and you can see here it's going to be right after real time what's going to be my photo style
and I wish this was more intuitive but we got to scroll all the way down to the list here and we're
going to find it near the bottom where it says LUT one then go let's select and then you can
scroll through the LUTs that you've transferred to the camera all right so I want to talk about
what I like and what I don't like and let's start with the good obviously I mentioned the frame rate
resolution bit rate options for video it's so impressive they pack this camera full of stuff
and they also brought that update with the Arri Log-C that you can add to this camera as well
which really sets Lumix apart from the rest of the options out there especially for video
in a mirrorless camera right now it's got a killer screen awesome EVF the Lumix Lab and
Flow apps are really good it's got amazing photography performance and overall has been
actually really reliable now let's talk about what I don't like that's that's the good stuff I want to
the menus the menus are kind of a maze like there's HDMI options in different sections when
they should all be in the same area and there's so many resolution and codec and frame rate options
buried in this long long list you got to scroll through it's not laid out really nice like what
they should have done is have you pick your resolution then pick your bit rate and then
your frame rate kind of like how Sony or Fuji does it the way it is now it's definitely not good like
you got to scroll through the menus to find the stuff you're looking for hundreds of different
frame rate and bit rate options now obviously you can customize the menu with your customize options
or your even custom mode settings on top which would make it easy if you just want to access like
certain things like say you just want to do 6k open gate or 4k 120 you can have the dial set for
that and the second thing is this giant big face and eye detection box overlay in the UI like why
do we have to have this box and then the crosshair on my eye if it's focused on my eye why can't we
just have a little box on the eye it just seems so distracting like why does there have to be a
huge crosshair that fills the whole box around my face and Panasonic has always done it this way
but it's it's so distracting maybe they can fix it doesn't have to be like this Panasonic why you
got to do it like this I also noticed uh that through HDMI and you're using an external monitor
there's a little bit of latency and it's only a few milliseconds but if you're sensitive to it
you're definitely going to notice it and I heard that turning the audio over HDMI helps with this
I haven't tried that to confirm it but yeah definitely you'll see a little bit of latency
when you have an external monitor hooked up to it outside of those things those are all firmware
things I think Lumix really nailed this camera it's an incredible hybrid camera honestly outperforms
a lot of competitors in terms of features for value and if you're a hybrid shooter doing both
stills and video this could easily be the only camera you need like you could buy two of these
and do anything with it it's kind of the jack of all trades it's kind of the camera that uh
you know the Sony a75 should be we don't know what the Sony a75 is going to be when it comes out but
it's going to be kind of the competitor to this and I don't know if Sony can deliver what Panasonic
has done in this camera and personally for me I haven't really decided whether I want to replace
my Sony a7s3 just yet because I don't know if I can rely on that autofocus for behind the scenes
YouTube stuff I would say though if I'm in control of the camera shooting on manual focus or cinema
lenses it's definitely the perfect little cinema camera when you rig it out but if I'm in front of
the camera like I am right now I don't know if I could 100% rely on the autofocus to not randomly
lose me and throw things out but that's just my thoughts and you can play with the autofocus
settings and tweak them I got it on the default settings right now which does work pretty good
yeah the s12 definitely has me excited to see where Panasonic or Lumix is headed with their
cameras right now and as I mentioned when this thing's rigged up in a cage and everything on it
it's incredible as a little mini cinema camera especially if you're shooting anamorphic video
and that's kind of how I'll be using it for the most part and then when I need to shoot
YouTube content that's also for shorts and like short form content that's vertical shooting open
gate on this thing we can get our vertical frame as well as our horizontal frame is really nice
to have because we don't have that in any Sony camera right now and yeah all the things that I
kind of don't love about it are mostly just firmware things which could be fixed so yeah
that's my last two months with the Lumix s1 mark ii let me know what you guys think in the comments
are you planning on switching to Lumix or are you planning on getting one of these cameras
let me know I'm curious to hear what you guys think if you like this video give it a thumbs up
if you dislike this video give it a thumbs down twice don't forget to hit that notification bell
see you guys in the next one
