Is realism in art still relevant, or has it become overrated in the modern art world? In this video, we dive deep into the ongoing debate about realistic art vs. expressive, abstract, and stylized approaches. Whether you’re a beginner artist, intermediate artist, this discussion will challenge your perspective on the role of realism in art and its place in traditional and contemporary art movements.
If you’re part of the art community and love discussing art controversy, art styles, and artistic development, this video is for you and I can't wait for your personal opinion on this!
💬 What’s your take? Is realism essential, or should artists focus on personal style over accuracy? Drop your thoughts in the comments!
🔔 Don’t forget to LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and SHARE for more art discussions, drawing tutorials, and creative insights!
*Affiliate links – you can support me and this channel by purchasing through one of the links above which results in a small commission for me at no extra cost to you!
Does realism and art still matter? Is it outdated, meaningless, overrated? I think the essence of
this controversy is the two opposing sides of pure technical skill versus artistic expression.
In this video I want to explore both sides with a focus on the question whether realism still
matters in today's art with my perspective on it while you see me drawing a portrait study
on toned paper. I'm going to start this whole discussion with something a lot of people have
to say about this topic. If you draw realistic, you're just a copy machine. Redundant in an age
where technology captures reality better than any drawing or painting ever could. And I'm assuming
and hoping this is addressing hyperrealism. Hyperrealism is a field in art intending to
portray things from real life as realistically as possible with the outcome looking as real as
photos. That's why you could also call it photorealism. Now a lot of people argue since
the rise of photography there is no need for portraits anymore. No need to portray people
exactly how they look and capture it in the form of paintings or drawings. And I think this is a very
generalized statement and a bit too broad and not specific enough. When we talk about
pure photorealism, a piece of art so flawless you could mistake it as a photo with just the
intention of recreating one, then I would agree it might in some cases lack intellectual meaning.
That does not mean it provides no value. But when you recreate a photo with the intention of
creating an exact duplicate, there is just no intellectual intention and idea behind it. And
that's totally fine. It is after all a more than impressive display of technical skill. But if we
are comparing drawing from references with being labeled as a copy machine, then I have to hardly
disagree. I say this quite often and I get comments like this too now, where people refer to studying
from references or using them to create an artwork as copying from photos. And to this I say there's
a big difference between having the literal goal to copy a photo and to capture the core spirit of
a reference. The value of realism in art for me is the translation of reality through an artist's
mind. An artist is the interpreter of what said artist sees in a photo or in real life. He processes
the raw information and transforms it according to his interpretation. The big difference to me
between hyperrealism and other realism categories in the fine art industry is accuracy, precision
and determination to detail. For photorealism it is essential to include even the tiniest detail
to fulfill the dedication to recreate exactly what you see. Artwork which doesn't want to simply
recreate an existing image, on the other hand, doesn't need this level of detail. Oftentimes
you see great artists doing charcoal or graphite portraits which look stunning, but not because
they aim to be photorealistic, but because those artists focus on a very specific essence of the
model or reference. This can be a facial expression captured masterfully, the symbiosis of light and
shadow or composition. I will give you an example of my own drawing to visualize my talking point
here. This is a study I did last year and this is not photorealism. It may look somewhat realistic,
but if I show you the reference you can immediately tell that this does not look like
the source material. And I mean besides from it having obvious flaws in direct comparison,
I want to show you what I really wanted to capture with this. This was a study with a focus
being on capturing proportions, shapes and values. And although the right eye for example is way too
big and other things are off and not as seen as in the reference, it is still a somewhat believable
portrait. And I think this is what it all comes down to. Creating believable work. And with
believable I mean authentic and understandable. And you don't need to be photorealistic to create
a believable portrait. Values and proportions play a big role here and also learning to understand
and to use them for your advantage. In photorealism you will often see people like to use the grid
method or just straight up trace outlines for a drawing to be as precise as possible. Which again
is totally fine and valid. I don't judge anyone who loves creating photorealistic art. Actually
I think you can do awesome things with it. And before I jump to its defense I want to give you
a glimpse of the other side of the spectrum. And I mean the total opposite of what we just talked
about. Okay, just to get this straight. My first encounter with something which could not be any
further away from realism and technical skill was when I studied communication design. And there was
a very strong flavor of modern art involved. You might already see where this is heading. So let me
demonstrate to you what I learned from lecturers of the modern art industry in Germany on how
figurative art should look like. This was the gold standard of figurative art. And by the way
the teachers heavily encouraged you to often do this blindfolded. Actually the more limitations
you gave yourself the better. A+. How so? Well the art in this is supposed to be the process. Which is
a very big difference to photorealistic art in which the result matters most. But here on the
other hand the result doesn't matter really. It's the process. And I got to know this field of
generative art a little bit which is in my opinion the opposite pole of creating realistic art. And
I was really flabbergasted. It totally caught me off guard back then because I did not see
any meaning behind it. It is an approach to art where craftsmanship absolutely doesn't matter in
my opinion. It is purely about the process and algorithm you set up and you actively draw back,
learn techniques and knowledge. You as the artist express yourself only through what calculated
actions you set up and oftentimes with the help of technology. Generative art is mostly done with
the help of AI and programs. So there isn't even a craft involved anymore. You enter coordinates or
formulas into a program to generate an image which is then ultimately the artwork. And something I
don't fully appreciate in general about modern art is the injection of a superficial meaning
behind everything. To me this superficial meaning only or often exists only as a selling point and
advertising of the artwork. Oftentimes it is way too easy and convenient to just come up with
something to give the piece more substance after the piece is already created. Like for this here
I could say the blind movement of my hand represented naivety and innocence. Rejecting
the image of my great-grandfather before my shy I remember standing in front of him when I was
all too young and moving from left to right represents coordinates back to locations of
places. See what I mean? It's this pseudo poetry injected into an intentionally algorithmic image.
And what gives it most away for me was that one of the lecturers in a private conversation with
me actually basically confessed he wished he could draw anatomically correct. This to me just
showed that this form of art can actually be used as an excuse to not develop skill. Because what's
really keeping you from improving and becoming better? Or do you just not want to deal with the
frustrations and setbacks which come along with it? To me personally art also includes the craft as
such as well as discipline, education and tradition. Now I am someone finding joy in drawing the human
figure and face and if you see yourself as someone who creates in some way realistic figurative art
I think we should go back to the fundamentals. And there is nothing wrong with studying references to
learn how those real things work. I still have a long way to go and I know I have a ton more to
learn to be able to visualize my ideas properly in the future. I actually have big respect for
hyperrealism artists because of their dedication and hard work and I want to defend them in a way
now. Within hyperrealism there are also multiple categories. There are artists purely finding joy
and purpose in copying photos with like I said no intellectual meaning. But there are also others
who use their master skill level to implement subtle messages in the form of arrangements,
color and themes. This might be controversial but I think some hyperrealism artists are actually
really creative in their execution of whole artworks. Besides from that I think the appeal
of realism as a whole is that it can be really beautiful. There is beauty in portraying real life,
humans and nature and art should have a right to be beautiful. In modern art there is this belief
that beautiful artwork is shallow and empty. It lacks substance and is superficial and only chaotic,
ugly and uncontrollable visuals transmit truth. I disagree. To me beauty in art has meaning because
it triggers something within people and after all this is one of the big aspects of art right?
So to answer my initial question. Yes I do believe realism and art still matters in modern times and
I hope it will continue to matter. Humans and nature are fascinating subjects and have always
been essential to art. But I want to add on to this by giving you my personal view on this. I think
realism thrives most when used in combination with our fantastic creative minds to create
something truly unique. I think what makes art interesting for people or potential buyers is a
story behind it, an emotion or a connection they can build with the audience and that requires
creative skill. So where am I standing in all this? Well in all honesty I think I'm pretty
much on the beginning. Last year I really gave myself a boot camp to study and learn a lot of
fundamentals desperately needed to create I'd say semi-realistic art. I always knew I wanted to do
figurative art and portray humans in some way and well to be able to do this I need to know my
fundamentals. This year however will be a bit different for me because I want to as well put
thought into the creative side of things. Even when I do studies like I'm doing right now I like
to at least implement some imaginative free elements to infuse more creativity in my drawings.
Ultimately I want to create big artwork with a story or emotion behind it but I still have a
long way to go. I'm doing this step by step. Studying realism has already taught me so much
about basic knowledge which I refused to learn back then when all I wanted to do was to create
stylized drawings. I think every artist can benefit from learning realism and as you might know many
huge artists like Picasso first learn how to paint realistic in order to stylize it. What I'm saying
is realism can be beneficial. It doesn't have to be the end goal although for some it might and
totally can be. There is a lot of skill and knowledge behind it and sometimes studying
these things means you're spending quite some time working with references or even recreating photos
but it doesn't have to mean you're forever stuck in it. But to be able to for example draw from
your imagination you have to build up your visual library. You can't pretend you can draw anything
without ever looking at the source unless you make it so abstract people recognize the intention
and that would pretty much sum up how I would define decent art. Being very intentional. To
me it's as easy as that. If you aim to draw or paint realistic, semi-realistic or stylized like
for example comic style you're part of the game and studying realism will give you a lot of value.
It has at the very least a very educational purpose and therefore I 100% say that realism
and art still matters. But where do you draw the line and what's your take on all this?
I would love to hear it in the comments and until then I'll see you in the next video.