Lars Trädgårdh: Kulturkanon handlar om verkan, inte verkshöjd

Svenska Epoch Times
4 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 27, 2025
Welcome to the Epoch Times booth
Today we have a hundred and reprinted guest here to talk with
My name is Reina Askestad I am an author
I have also been a cultural director and have been the cultural director at Epoch Times for two years back
I will try to raise the cultural burden to something that might resemble what existed in the World Cup and the Swedish team up until the 1990s
Oh the guest here is Lars Treckert
He's I guess not really in need of any presentations very well known primarily a historian
She has studied and lived a lot in the USA
Which we might get into how it has affected his leadership as manifested in the form of the cultural canon proposal
Oh that's where I thought I'd start and then I don't want him to feel forced to talk about the cultural canon
For it's one interview and conversation after another
But of course we'll get to it
Men from a starting point that I thought should begin
In 1977 I moved back or my parents moved back to Sweden
And back then as a teenager I remember politicians some of them for example Boman a moderate man
They continued to speak of the state as one thing and society as another
Lars Egger has written interestingly about a concept here in Henrikberg which I don't know if you have coined
Men in all cases actually have a special meaning namely statism
I thought I'd start by having him explain a bit about what this ideology is through this perspective on society and human beings
How do you think it influenced how this cultural canon came about
Yes that's a good entry point
When Henrik and I wrote this book about the Swedish People that you'referring to
Had I already written a bit about this before and coined two concepts among other things
For one it was state individualism and for the other it was the Swedish theory of love
They fit together one was existential and the other was institutional
The point was that we have created a social contact in Sweden that is very much based on an alliance between the individual the citizen the state and the institutions
I mean the state I mean quite broadly here the common institutions
But this must also be understood from an existential perspective
As you were getting at this issue of civil society versus the state
So what's in it for you As a citizen as an individual
Well the idea was there at the core this Swedish theory of love
To think that such values are present in Sweden that prize independence
Even from those who are very close to us
But that goes against I think more universal notions of love
It is more based on mutual dependence
He talks about his family and so on
In Sweden we have created a system that has maximized this independence
Also it is also important to respect freedom of choice even in close relationships
So if you ask an older person today in Sweden what do you look forward to in your old age
To be dependent on your own precious children or on the joint care
That is how one generally gets the somewhat scandalous answer
That one resents being dependent on these institutions
It could have to do with knowing one's own children very well
But I don't think that's fair
To ask another question do you want your children to visit you
Almost all say yes
The idea behind this theory about love is not that Swedes are so violently unsociable or unapproachable
What we value is our relationships built on voluntary action rather than duty and obligation
Is it not a very late historical stage as the one you are describing now
Something that is Swedish or more Swedish
Isn't that something that came with modernity
Before that people lived very close to each other dependent one another
What would you say about
it Yes and no I think it definitely makes sense
This has certainly not been static
We mainly look at the modern period
Men if you look at the Swedish family and marriage pattern from a broader perspective
so we have data going back as far as the 1300s showing that in Swede
We had a much stronger emphasis on the nuclear family as well as
on the situation where men and women were approximately the same age
Men in Southeast and Eastern Europe men were about 25 as in the North
The girls were actually the youngest
They were very very young 13-14
And they were part of larger more clan-like families
Sometimes people in Sweden think that we also had it before in the world
But that's not the case
There was much more emphasis on it
And that also means that when you had the relatively difficult families with a little land
So it was necessary to share the workforce
So people encouraged the children to move away from home during certain times
Harvest times and similar
So they encouraged this independence in a way that was much more unusual in other parts of Europe
I have lived in Häradsbygden outside Leksand for the past 12-13 years
I have also read about these villages
These very beautiful classic traditional villages
But it's quite clear that something happened in Sweden rather late
If we say that enlightenment modernity and industrialization came a bit later to Sweden
Then it was a completely different
So the community was extremely central
Everything the school a small grocery store
Everything is handled collectively or whatever term one should use
So maybe
When you elevate it as you do here
Now I have expressed an idea about the state as a prerequisite for individual freedom
Staten did not exist in principle until Perhaps visible
in any case in the 1800s among Swedes in general
They understood that the crown fund would come and would have some tax
Or they came and recruited soldiers
People lived in their own reality their immediate environment
Oh I think it might be something that possibly disappears when
you paint the picture just as the state against the individual
But then this more or less fortunate combination
seems to between state and freedom one might say
I understand how you're thinking
We can start with Norway
They celebrated the 750th anniversary of the first land law last year
We are not particularly far behind in terms of decades
Sweden is in many ways the first modern state
When we go back to the 1600s and even earlier
But it's based on the idea that the country should be built by law
It is a fundamental principle
You're right that this will change over time
But the interesting thing is that behind these changes
There is a strong structure with a very long history
But if we look at Britain's time in the 1600s
Sweden appeared as the first modern tax state
It also became a subject for imitation
Boys in Russia and so on
We can definitely have two boats in the air
I completely agree
We should not underestimate the long-term and lasting impact
It has also had an effect on me personally in the Culture Canon Project
I insisted as a condition for leading the investigation
Having not just a narrow concept of culture
I terms of literature and relationship types
I thought a bit like an old Marxist
It is important to understand both the foundation and the superstructure
The foundation is much like law and order
Our political culture our economic culture our religion
Regarding blacksmithism the Lutheran religion
She is highly individual and the state
It became an important part to understand this
Sometimes it is somewhat underestimated in today's modern Sweden
We don't like to think about it in that way
It became important not to focus solely on the art forms
But to think about these structures
You called it Marxism That was what I reacted to the most
I agree with splitting it up
To have a cultural history as a point
To have art works as another point
Then I can say that you applied the same
Social historical contextual assessment When you
selected what is art and artworks
They had a social historical perspective on what should be highlighted in a canon
I think you said somewhere that there was a woman at the press conference
When you presented this in Uppsala
Some had said that art and culture cannot be understood outside the political dimension
I don't quite remember the exact wording
The point here was that we wanted to be able to capture both of these aspects
This became important from another perspective
Namely what were interested in here
Now I'm talking about the committee
We should remember the choice of work
It was what the expert groups did entirely independent of us
But we created certain criteria based on fundamental values as an entry point
In my view it was important to emphasize that were not primarily interested in a kind of top 10 list
Regarding different types of art computers
The 10 best books poems musical pieces or whatever they were
We were not primarily interested in the height of the workshop
Rather the effect
What shaped Sweden historically
And one can actually have opinions on that
I will have an opinion now
For the artistic value of a work of art
It's not many who notice
Or how much it was talked about
Or actually what social impact it had at a certain stage in history
When we look for example at a Greek drama
So it's not the political
I will bring up this quote
Art can only be understood in a historical and political context
This Greek drama
If we define the artistic work itself based on such criteria
Historical political
No artwork would speak to us in the way a Greek drama does
Or even a fine Mexican culture
They date back 1500 years
That's a bit where I wonder
This idea of highlighting masterpieces within our culture
It is self-evident to me in the concept of canon
So if we are talking about the second point
Sometimes artistic so to speak
But you're probably not alone in that
I think there was an expectation of this
But I have tried to be clear from the beginning
It made me see this project in an entirely different light
That whole idea of state individualism and the entire view of human society
Where it is found as far as I understand in that theory
But it is not that theory that has been at the center here
Without it I think my historical perspective has been more my own
And I believe that has been important
I have not seen this as a kind of implementation
of my theories In Swedish
society In any way at all
Among other things
And I haven't had any influence here either
As for what has been
But the historical perspective
The question of what has shaped Sweden
What has become permanent organizational structures
It has been
important Yes
Now I'll check what my question was here
I think about it a bit more
Can we get into politics' pocket when we have this historical perspective
It's what has had an impact on society and its development
It ends up being a lot of politics
I see that it's in the government's assignment
That's how it is
Come up with a Swedish cultural commune that is a good tool
I find that interesting
For the word tool
When talking about artworks and culture
It's its own world
One does not reduce the artwork to a tool for one or the other
It kind of lies in the direction
of the tangent here Culture and
art become concepts They are to be used for political purposes
To solve other political problems
To create a common vision
As you also talk about
It's still a loss after all
When thinking about the concepts of culture and art
Possibly when thinking about the concept of culture
This is the more narrow interpretation
As you think I do
But not from my perspective
That's exactly why it was done
We have problems with Sweden today
It's a kind of thing that goes unnoticed
We also have historical experience
If we go back to the 1800s
Thus the creation of the modern nation-state
Where not only in Sweden but throughout Europe
A certain amount of energy was invested
Just on a cannon-like project
The instruments in Sweden and in the North were
especially refined sophisticated and democratic
It was a double movement
It was the people's education from within
And it was the people's school from above
They actually worked based on similar thoughts
And that as a historian has been an explanation for it
We have a certain type of democratic tradition in Sweden
Which has served us very well
Some are the reason we have had an elite society
Both here and in the other Nordic countries
We distinguish ourselves from almost all other countries
Except for the Netherlands
And that project
It can be said that it was about both flexible values
That is maximizing the flexibility space for the individual
They also built with that in mind That we can only
be free if we have a functioning society around us
Otherwise it would be the whole sea in a storm Everyone's war against everyone
And this thought pattern will permeate a great deal
Both folk education and public school
And in this there was also this community cask
For were not just a geographical patch There were
different individuals running around doing this and that
Without any notion of a collective "we "
A community in society
They laid a very strong foundation in our institutions
This tradition of established order
The law was also internalized as norms So we
did not need this maximum police surveillance
I think that's a bit important
After the Second World War we have basically put that project on hold
First and foremost in our schools
And that leads me to an interesting conversation
Because I see the relationship that we as individuals have in society in two directions
It is what I call the civil society
There are the same rules for everyone
You cannot pick and choose among the laws
It is not about diversity or pluralism
Then we have civil society
There you have the opposite
Here diversity and pluralism are an end in themselves
Oh man you can see it that way when we looked at the layout for Kano
We tried to create a space for both of these logics
It was a way to create a fuller richer understanding
Of our cultural and historical heritage
When I hear you here I think along those lines
There might be a superstition about the laws
Laws reflect people's values
People's views on even metaphysical issues
What is the meaning of life Where is God
So the laws are a more superficial dimension
What holds it together what constitutes a culture
These are the values I
think it's the wrong words
The view of life and so on that one shares
But what is happening now is that it is politically
It has politically shattered the community
We had cultural unity
With our native language and so on
Now they are trying to solve this splitting problem
With political decisions
Where they define a lot
From my perspective
Concepts such as culture and art
As tools as stated in the mission
To achieve any form of new community
It is not a political project to create community
Community exists there
And then we get a common policy and common laws
Because we share the values that uphold the laws
But I think it's a bit
I have a mindset
We have always had
power We have always had politics
One of the strengths in our society
That this has been a red thread
And it is an interaction where
It's not that culture comes first and politics later
I was just talking about the
towns in the 1800s in Dalarna Politics
I don't think they will understand what it's about
Much of Sweden's historical
experience speaks against you And I don't see any problem
with that either Of course
We have created various forms
to come together And make
decisions about our common concerns This is politics
Some practices have gained legitimacy over time
Which makes them part of a culture that you carry with you
You don't need to reinvent it every time you do it
You have trust institutions
The Swedish Tax Agency is the most popular authority in Sweden
It has to do with the fact that we have confidence in a social contract
Those who build on people who work hard pay taxes and deserve rights
You would say that we have ended up where we have ended up
If we agree that it is deeply problematic where we have ended up
Also in the rest of Europe
Large parts of it
Because we have had too little politics
Has everything been overly
politicized No I don't think so
For we have had a very crazy policy during certain phases in Sweden
It's not that we are currently endowed with the
kind of wisdom and intelligence among politicians that one would wish for
It was actually different in Sweden if we go back to the 1920s and 1930s
So politics itself is not a solution A wisdom
prudence knowledge and education are also required
The political class we had was just the product of the people's school and public education
This has been replaced by people who were raised in the modern school after 1968
Where we have consistently devalued education and knowledge
If you keep at it long enough
Then there are consequences
From my perspective I think everything has been politicized
It lies within the Marxist perspective
Doing everything into politics is about a struggle
It is a kind of negative community
It is based on the idea that everyone is oppressed and some are oppressed
The polarization I mean has been too simplistic when looking back in time
It has rather been about dividing at the core
If one has had one's religion one's mother tongue and so on
Because of historical reasons these very strong conflicts arise
For me politics has become more and more
Politics is using things and objects as means to an end that one has set for oneself
Everything has its own independent existence and its own value
Everything becomes a means for a political purpose
I think that's what we see every day
That's how one is treated from the beginning above all
As a means for one thing and another
Now they are forcibly mixing the population because they have an idea that it is good
To take advantage of people's lives and believe oneself to have the right to do so to people in general
It's hardly anyone notices it anymore
It's interesting what you're saying
The advantage of a democracy is that people have different opinions and viewpoints which they express
If you're now talking about the social democratic proposals which are somewhat misrepresented
But at the same time these elements that you're talking about do exist
There are many protests against this
And discussions and debates about it
It's not as if we don't have a political democratic dialogue in
Sweden Then again one might think the same about the interior and the rest
It is an aspect of a free society
But that it is a protest against it speaks a bit to what I am talking about
So that the political and social have gone beyond all boundaries
When one thinks one is going to outwit people
We were talking about an example with the pandemic and the vaccines
Not just in Sweden so much
Even if there was a huge demonization of those who went out and said I don't want to take these
They are too experimental
I don't trust that this will work
But the state was extremely aggressive
Especially in other countries but also in Sweden
No not on this point
I'm not anti-vaxer myself
I really liked that in Sweden we mainly chose a
voluntary approach That's indeed a huge strength
Oh and I often remind my American friends that in Sweden we actually don't have a vaccination mandate
Men they are actually
building on volunteerism And that is a strength
For now
There are still strong forces
It could be
I don't know right now but I'm damn well out there somehow
Just read what you have to say
The important thing is that we have over a long period built a society that has created a large space specifically for volunteer work freedom and enthusiasm
A policy that has been able to accommodate different perspectives
That's obviously a huge strength to me
I agree with you
I think the difference is that I might see greater dangers with an ever-stronger state
But saying that it's naive to think the state could guarantee our freedoms might be an option
But remember we should keep in mind that one of the strengths of the Nordic countries is that they are not a confusion like a DRC
Namely that we mix society and the state
And this can be seen as an otherwise unconventional form of terrorism
They can also say that this is like a sign of a quite democratized state
So I became worried in the USA after I had lived there for 40 years
When you kind of have a completely paranoid view of the state
It is almost by definition poorly crushed
Oh and a kind of glorification of civil society and the family and so on communities
Because I mean that's what's important here
I kind of understand that if you want a functioning society you also have to see the state as your own
So it's a democracy right
So we actually don't live in a dictatorship right
Oh that's what makes these institutions we've built up over a long long time
Like our institutions we are involved in them we cannot separate ourselves from them
We have built the society we have
We can't come and point fingers at some overzealous social engineers you know
Someone has dug our grave That's not how it looks at all
I think unfortunately there are very many people today who do not experience the political establishment
The system as the state as their friends
So there is a problem here
But it's interesting
We have slightly different views on it
I thought I'd end by asking you
What happens now
With this cultural camera
What has it followed
The answer is that something has already happened
We have had a huge very funny breakthrough
I found out from one of my former colleagues that over 1900-700 articles have been written in the media
I didn't count TV and podcasts and similar things
A small example but still one that says something
I was called by Lokalradion in Borås yesterday when I was here
They interviewed me because they
were about to create
a local Boråskanjon I love it That's absolutely wonderful
This popular interest in our culture
To have an open and lively debate and discussion
That's what I think is wonderful
What happens next
We have several suggestions in the last chapter of the Report
It will then be published
There you would be very satisfied
One of the main proposals is to create an independent foundation that will own him
Not allowing it to become part of any political authority
I think that's probably a slightly different perspective
There are also proposals related to the school on the other hand
Remember what I said earlier
I divide it into the civil society and the voluntary society
We as citizens have a responsibility to raise our children as parents
I think we have a responsibility to raise our children in
school This is really true We
must upgrade the Swedish school
A line with what it once was
There you have several suggestions in that direction
This also applies to those who arrive as new immigrants to Sweden
Then there is the voluntary sector
That's my thought rather that it should be stimulating exciting and tempting
This small example gives a glimpse of what is happening in the market
It is already happening in many places around the country
It is only a source of joy
We also think that this foundation could work as the National Trust in England
It is an incredibly creative institution
It makes our cultural heritage accessible
Without any political agendas at all
It's two different directions one could say
I usually say that I'm too old to be naive and overly optimistic
Staltipset is always accompanied by investigations
This is a failed attempt at political conflict and ends up in a trash can
I stay away from predicting anything here
The matter will go to a
consultation round There is interest
from both political sides regarding these issues We'll see
It might serve as an inspiration for a deeper discussion about Swedish culture and cultural heritage
Perhaps something happens at school
We don't know We'll just have to see
I'm just as anxious as you about the answer
It was crazy
I would like to thank Lars Stränggård for this interesting conversation Thank
you very much
