#mysteries What if the biggest galaxy in the universe… isn’t? In this video, we explore Alcyoneus, the radio galaxy whose jets stretch over 16 million light-years, making it possibly the largest known structure of galactic origin. But here’s the twist: its host galaxy is totally average, smaller than the Milky Way, with a supermassive black hole that’s nowhere near the size of IC 1101’s. So how did it produce radio jets so massive they dwarf entire galaxy clusters? We dive into LOFAR radio telescopes, intergalactic plasma, Fanaroff-Riley classifications, and cosmic filaments of the dark matter web to uncover why Alcyoneus shocked astronomers everywhere.
But does that make it the largest galaxy? Or just the galaxy with the biggest radio structure? We compare it to IC 1101, the Phoenix Cluster’s starburst monster, and Rubin’s Galaxy UGC 2885. We’ll look at how galaxies are measured, radio jets, stellar components, ultraviolet arms, infrared dust, and dark matter halos. And we’ll question what really defines the size of a galaxy in the first place. This isn't just a debate about scale, it's a peek into how astronomy still wrestles with definitions in a universe that's far from fully understood. Hit subscribe and get ready to challenge everything you thought you knew about the cosmos.
Sometimes we get curious about questions we think we can solve simply by checking a book,
a website, or something else. Questions like, how tall is the Empire State Building? Or,
how big is the moon? We live in a world where everything seems to have been discovered and
determined, and for every curiosity we have, we expect a certain and absolutely precise answer.
But it's not always like that. If we ask ourselves, for example, which is the largest
galaxy in our known universe, well, we have the bitter surprise of finding ourselves in the
quicksand of absolutely imprecise or inconsistent data. You'll get proof of this from this video,
which will help you understand the enormous difficulties astronomers face in finding a
And in the end, you'll realize how pretentious and misleading certain statements are
when they say, this galaxy is the largest of all.
You might not believe it, but until a century ago, galaxies didn't exist.
Everything changed on one night in 1923 when Edwin Hubble, peering through the 100-inch
telescope at Mount Wilson, identified a Cepheid-variable star in the Andromeda Nebula.
An incredible stroke of luck, because Cepheids were already known at the time as reliable
cosmic candles. These giant stars pulse with a precise rhythm, and already in 1912 Henrietta
Swan Leavitt had discovered that the longer their pulsation period, the more intrinsically luminous
they are. So, by comparing their apparent brightness with what they should have based
on their period, astronomers could calculate exactly how far away they were.
Thanks to that single pulsating point of light, the universe suddenly expanded thousands of times
over. What for centuries had been considered simple gas clouds belonging to the Milky Way,
revealed themselves to be distant galaxies. Islands of billions of stars scattered across
a suddenly dizzying cosmos. And with this revolution, a question inevitably arose.
How big can these galaxies be? Which is the biggest of them all?
Our Milky Way, which for centuries had been our entire known universe, turned out to be a rather
modest-sized spiral galaxy. With its 100,000 light-year diameter, it suddenly seemed small
when compared to other island universes, as they were once called. Andromeda, the same nebula where
Hubble had found the revealing Cepheid, showed a diameter of about 220,000 light-years,
more than double the Milky Way. But the measurement was oversized because the distance was
underestimated. And this was just the beginning. In 1978, astronomer Alan Dressler of the Carnegie
Institute began a systematic study of IC 1101, an object that William Herschel had cataloged
as a nebula in 1790, without being able to imagine its true nature.
IC 1101 sits at the heart of galaxy cluster Abel 2029, about a billion light-years from us.
When Dressler and his team completed measurements using modern techniques,
they were stunned. This supergiant elliptical galaxy stretched for at least 6 million light-years.
To put this number in perspective, consider this. If IC 1101 were centered where our Sun is,
it would not only engulf the entire Milky Way, but would extend well beyond Andromeda,
which is 2.5 million light-years away, and would reach almost to the Triangulum Galaxy M33
at 3 million light-years. The entire local group,
the set of gravitationally bound galaxies that includes the Milky Way,
would fit comfortably inside IC 1101. But how did IC 1101 become so monstrously large?
The answer lies in its position in history. Located at the center of a rich galaxy cluster,
IC 1101 has had billions of years to fatten up by cannibalizing neighboring galaxies.
It's a process called hierarchical accretion. Larger galaxies grow by devouring smaller ones.
At the heart of IC 1101 also lies one of the most massive black holes ever discovered,
with an estimated mass between 40 and 100 billion times that of our Sun.
In the 80s and 90s, other contenders for the throne emerged. ESO 306-17, a fossil
elliptical galaxy, so-called because it had already devoured all the galaxies in its neighborhood,
showed comparable dimensions. Hercules A, a radio galaxy in the constellation of the same name,
also revealed dimensions on the order of 1.5 million light-years when measured in visible
light. But it was in 2013 that a new spiral galaxy champion was crowned. UGC 2885, affectionately
nicknamed Rubin's Galaxy in honor of pioneering astronomer Vera Rubin, who studied galaxy
rotation, turned out to be the largest known spiral. With a diameter of 832,000 light-years,
it's eight times larger than the Milky Way and contains about a trillion stars,
ten times more than our galaxy. What makes UGC 2825 particularly interesting is how it grew.
Unlike giant elliptical galaxies that grow through violent mergers, UGC 2885 seems to
have reached its colossal dimensions more peacefully, accumulating hydrogen gas from
surrounding intergalactic space. It's located in a relatively isolated region of space,
which may have contributed to its undisturbed growth over billions of years.
But now we come to the heart of the matter, to that fundamental problem that makes it so
complicated to establish which really is the largest galaxy. The main uncertainty factor
in calculating a galaxy's size comes from the difficulty of determining its boundaries.
It sounds like a joke, but it's not. Galaxies are complex astronomical objects,
made up of different elements, stars first and foremost, obviously, but also masses of
neutral and ionized gas and, at least in spiral galaxies, reserves of interstellar dust that
become increasingly diluted as you move away from the center. The mass, excitation state,
and distribution of these different materials varies depending on the type of galaxy and its
evolutionary history. Their greater or lesser detection depends largely on the instrumentation
used. Sizes change with the wavelength of light. A consequence of this variability is that there
are galaxies whose dimensions appear larger when observed in visible light rather than infrared,
and others that, on the contrary, reveal a larger diameter in infrared than in visible light.
In other cases, it's observation in ultraviolet or X-rays that reveals arms or tails of gas and
stars totally visible at longer wavelengths. A typical case is the barred spiral galaxy NGC 1512.
Arms of young, bright blue stars, probably born from perturbations generated by interaction with
the dwarf galaxy NGC 1510, are visible only in far ultraviolet and considerably extend
the apparent dimensions of the galaxy observed in visible light. In still other cases,
it's observation of a galaxy in radio waves that reveals otherwise invisible structures,
such as enormous gas jets extending far beyond the boundaries of the stellar halo,
powered by an active galactic nucleus.
Hey Curious Squad, before moving on, be sure to subscribe to our channel,
clicking on the notification bell, and leave us a thumbs up so you don't miss out on our daily videos!
So what is the measurable extent of a galaxy? There's no single answer. It depends on what
we decide to observe, that is, which frequencies of the electromagnetic spectrum we include or
exclude from the search, and even more importantly, the depth of the observation.
The fainter the luminosity that the telescope used can capture and the frequency range to
which it's sensitive, the greater, in general, will be the measurable size of the galaxy in
that region of the spectrum. This completely brings us to a fundamental distinction.
When astronomers talk about the largest galaxies, they usually refer to the extent of their
visible stellar component, what we might call the actual body of the galaxy.
According to this criterion, the undisputed champions remain two elliptical giants,
IC 1101 with its 6 million light-years stellar diameter and the central galaxy of the Phoenix
Cluster which reaches 2.2 million light-years. The Phoenix Cluster deserves special mention.
Discovered in 2010, this galaxy cluster hosts at its center a galaxy that is not only huge,
but is also incredibly active in star formation. While most giant elliptical galaxies are dead
from a star formation standpoint, the Phoenix Galaxy produces new stars at a frantic rate of
740 solar masses per year, a star formation rate almost 200 times higher than that of the Milky
Way. But here comes the plot twist that shook the astronomy world in February of 2022.
An international team of astronomers led by Martijn Ui of Leiden University in the Netherlands
was conducting a systematic search for giant radio galaxies using data from LOFAR,
Low Frequency Array, a network of radio telescopes distributed throughout Europe.
LOFAR is particularly suited to detecting low-frequency radio emission,
exactly the type of radiation emitted by radio galaxy jets.
During this search, which led to the discovery of over 8,000 new giant radio galaxies,
one in particular caught the team's attention. In the constellation Lynx, about 3.5 billion
light-years from Earth, an extraordinarily large three-component radio structure appeared.
After careful checks to exclude that these were separate structures overlapping due to
perspective effect, the conclusion was inevitable. They had discovered the largest structure of
galactic origin ever observed. They called it Alcyonus, after the giant from Greek mythology,
son of Uranus and Gaia, who, according to legend, was immortal as long as he remained in his homeland
and was defeated by Hercules. An appropriate name for a cosmic titan that redefines our
understanding of how large a galaxy can be. The numbers are simply staggering. Alcyonus'
radio jets extend for 16.3 million light-years, or 5 megaparsecs. It's a distance so vast it's
difficult to even conceive. To give you an idea of the proportions,
consider this. If we consider its radio jets, Alcyonus is at least 150 times larger than the
Milky Way, four times larger than IC 1101, and its radio lobes alone could comfortably contain
hundreds of galaxies the size of ours. If Alcyonus were centered on Earth,
its radio jets would extend well beyond the galaxies of the local group,
reaching distances we normally associate with separations between galaxy clusters.
But here's the paradox that makes Alcyonus even more fascinating, and at the same time
controversial. When astronomers examined the host galaxy at the center of this immense
radio structure, they found a rather ordinary galaxy. The elliptical galaxy SDSS J081421.68
plus 522410.0, that's its catalog name, has a total mass of about 240 billion solar masses,
half that of the Milky Way. Its central supermassive black hole has a mass of only
400 million solar masses, which is 100 times less massive than the giants found in IC 1101
or other supermassive elliptical galaxies. Alcyonus' radio power isn't exceptional either.
It's classified as a low-excitation Phanerov-Riley type II radio galaxy,
which means it gets most of its energy from relativistic processes in the jets rather than
from radiation from the active galaxy nucleus. In other words, there's nothing particularly
special about the host galaxy that can explain why its jets have extended so incredibly far.
So how is it possible that such a normal galaxy has produced the largest known galactic structure?
Astronomers have proposed several hypotheses. One possibility is that Alcyonus is located
in a region of space with particularly low density. In an almost empty environment,
the radio jets would encounter little resistance and could expand much more than they would in
denser regions. Another hypothesis is that Alcyonus is located along one of the filaments
of the cosmic web, the vast structures of gas and dark matter that connect galaxies on cosmic scales.
The particular geometry and density of these filaments could have facilitated the expansion
of the jets. There's also the possibility that Alcyonus's age plays a crucial role.
The radio jets could have been active for an exceptionally long time,
allowing them to reach these extreme distances. Unfortunately, determining the precise age of
radio jets is extremely difficult and remains one of the main challenges in studying radio galaxies.
But now we come to the fundamental question, the one many astronomers have asked since the
discovery was announced. Is it really correct to define Alcyonus as the largest galaxy based
on the extent of its radio jets? It's a question that touches the very heart of how we define and
measure galaxies. Traditionally, when we talk about a galaxy's size, we refer to the extent
of its stellar component, the stars, gas, and dust that form the visible body of the galaxy.
This is what we see when we observe a galaxy in optical light, and it's what most people imagine
when they think of a galaxy. According to this criterion, IC 1101 remains the champion,
even if nowhere near the 6 million light-years bandied about by some.
Radio jets, on the other hand, are transient phenomena on cosmic scales.
They're flows of relativistic plasma expelled from the galaxy's central black hole,
propagating through intergalactic space. Although they're certainly produced by the
galaxy and carry energy and matter from the galaxy into surrounding space,
they're not an integral part of the galactic structure in the traditional sense.
They're more like cosmic exhausts than structural components of the galaxy itself.
An analogy might be helpful. It's like measuring the size of a city by including the smoke from
its chimneys that extends for miles into the atmosphere. The smoke is certainly produced by
the city, but would we really say the city is as big as the extent of its smoke plume?
On the other hand, radio jets are undeniably part of the galactic phenomena. They carry
enormous amounts of energy from the galactic nucleus into intergalactic space, influencing
the evolution not only of the host galaxy, but also of the surrounding environment on
scales of millions of light years. In this sense, they represent the galaxy's influence and impact
on its environment much more dramatically than the stellar component alone does.
Furthermore, there's a precedent for including extended structures in the definition of galactic
dimensions. Dark matter halos of galaxies, for example, extend far beyond the visible
stellar component, and are considered an integral part of the galaxy when calculating its total mass.
So why shouldn't we consider radio jets, which are much more easily observable than dark matter
halos? The astronomical community remains divided on this issue. Many prefer to maintain the
distinction between the largest galaxy, IC 1101, based on the stellar component, and the largest
structure of galactic origin, Alcyonus, including radio jets. It's a subtle but important distinction
that reflects the complexity of defining the boundaries of objects as vast and multi-form as
galaxies. What is certain is that Alcyonus, regardless of how we choose to classify it,
represents an extreme phenomena that challenges our understanding of galaxy physics.
How can a relatively modest galaxy produce jets that extend for such cosmic distances?
What are the environmental conditions that allow such expansion? And what does this tell us about
the relationship between galaxies and the intergalactic medium that surrounds them?
The answers to these questions could revolutionize our understanding not only of radio galaxies,
but of galaxy evolution in general and the large-scale structure of the universe.
Alcyonus reminds us that, despite decades of observations and theories,
the universe still has many surprises in store for us.
And so, the crown of largest galaxy remains contested. IC 1101 maintains its primacy as
the galaxy with the greatest stellar extent, while Alcyonus holds the record for the largest
structure of galactic origin. It's a distinction that reflects not only the diversity of galaxies
in the universe, but also the complexity of defining and measuring cosmic objects that
challenge our very capacity for understanding. In the end, perhaps, the real lesson of Alcyonus
isn't which galaxy is the largest, but how much we still have to learn about the universe around us.
Every new record, every extraordinary discovery only opens new questions and reveals new mysteries.
And in this sense, Alcyonus is truly a giant, not just for its physical dimensions,
but for the enormity of the questions it raises about the very nature of galaxies and the cosmos.