Oakland is facing a surge in illegal dumping that is leaving neighborhoods buried in debris and residents feeling abandoned. The problem is not just about appearances, but is changing how the people of Oakland live and weakening confidence in city services.
Entrepreneur and former probation officer Ansel Troy has been documenting what happens when enforcement is limited, while Vincent Williams, cofounder and executive director of the Urban Compassion Project, shows how organized cleanups are making a measurable difference. In this episode, we see how community efforts, even if small, can lead to a marked improvement—even while larger systems work to catch up.
Views expressed in this video are the opinions of the host and guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of The California Insider.
In some streets of Oakland, trash is piling up and people are coming to Oakland to dump illegally,
but some residents are fighting back. Our guest today is Ansel Troy, who's been filming these
incidents and he has a lot of details about what's happening there. It's a public health crisis.
Rodents, motor oil, tires, discarded food, molded food, and then there's the psychological thing
that makes you feel like nobody cares about me if I have to walk through all this trash.
We have to take care of our community. We have to look out for each other.
We also talked to Vincent Williams, who has organized many volunteers to come and clean up
Oakland. We have removed over 441 tons of illegally dumped trash from streets, parks,
waterways, and other common spaces. I'm Siamak Kourami. Welcome to California Insider.
Ansel, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you for having me.
You're from Oakland and Oakland has some issues with illegal dumping and it looks like things
are getting worse and you've been documenting this. Can you tell us what's happening there?
I've lived in Oakland my entire life, outside of a couple years in college,
in Hayward, California, a couple of towns over. Most of my life, the city has always been a place
where I was happy to come home, to walk down the street. I started to feel a bit different
in the past few years where it was depressing. There's mounds of trash. Then you see people
sleeping on the street. Then it made me wonder, what is going on with our city?
Why is it that as soon as you cross the border into the next town, it's much cleaner? I started
to document it and share what was going on. I also went to certain neighborhoods that didn't
have this issue. I wanted to know, what is the city doing about this? I think that the issue
was very complex, but as a regular Joe Schmo citizen, I decided that it was unacceptable
because it's a public health crisis. Rodents, motor oil, tires, discarded food, molded food,
it brings so much with it. Then there's the psychological thing that makes you feel like
nobody cares about me if I have to walk through all this trash and then my child has to see this.
That led me to sharing images and video and asking our city leaders, hey, what's going on here?
We see it in our neighborhoods, couches and mattresses and construction material.
I could drive around my block and take a photo of everything and create a map
just to show the level of illegal dumping in residential neighborhoods.
It's just random, so people just come and dump at a random place and go, or do they dump these
things in certain areas? Well, there are hot spots where they're always going to dump there.
Sometimes it feels like there's a random corner, but what happens is when there's one piece
of trash, it balloons because other people see it and they'll say, oh, we'll just throw
off stuff there as well. Some of this stuff is a household. It's not always the construction
materials. Some people are taking trash from their homes and then dropping it. Every now and then,
I'll get in there and look at the addresses on the boxes and I'm like, oh, this house is right
around the corner and they forgot to remove the address sticker from the Amazon package.
You know that it's people in the community that are doing this as well.
Have you seen a significant increase in the last few years?
I don't have the data to substantiate it, but it feels like it's getting worse.
When you document this, do you see the people that are dumping? Have you ran into people that
are dumping? Who are they? You see people throw stuff out of their cars. I saw somebody come out
of their living situation, an encampment, and they had a bag of trash and they just threw it
right next to them. I also set up my own camera on a city street. I got a GoPro
and I bought an external battery from Amazon and then I went up the pole. I put my ladder
on the pole, on the power pole, and I documented everything. My friends said I was crazy,
but I wanted to see, you know, could I record this without any city infrastructure or funding?
What would it take to document it? And so I was able to record this van coming and
throwing everything out of his van. And I'm like, wow, this is a $500 setup that I was able to set
up. Just put it here and imagine what I could do if I had hundreds of thousands of dollars
and how I could capture it and document and get the license plates and get the full, you know.
So they came with the license plate, everything. Yeah, absolutely.
Just very comfortable. They just dropped the stuff and left, right? So you could
easily catch them if you. Well, that's a good question because the Oakland Police Department
has a directive that they are not to stop people for equipment violations.
So they're directed not to stop people. So if you have a busted tail light or if you have
a missing license plate back in the day, you would get pulled over. A license plate is how
we identify vehicles going down the street. There's a description of the vehicle. I should
mention that I worked in law enforcement for 14 years. I was a probation officer. So how do you
identify a vehicle that's dumping stuff? The license plate, you know, you can't get up on the
van unless you're like right up on it. It's the description of the vehicle, but primarily the
license plate. And we have license plate reading cameras. Well, in Oakland, there's no more
pulling cars over for missing license plates. So now you don't have to have a license plate
to drive through Oakland because the police aren't going to stop you. That is confirmed.
That's on the record. It's been said at city council meetings. And the reason why is because
there was a report that showed that the police department was stopping more Black and Latino
people. Instead of addressing the alleged discrimination, the officers were told,
we're not going to do it anymore. No more license plate stops. And I only found this out from doing
some research. So now anybody can dump anything in Oakland and you don't need to have a license
plate on your car. You just drive in, dump, and you drive out. You're not going to get pulled over.
Have you had any encounters with these people? Because you're going out there and you're
documenting, right? I have. I'm also mindful that, you know, I have to make it home
and it's not worth risking my life to confront somebody who's doing this because there was a
story that came out and you can look it up that somebody confronted some illegal dumpers and they
shot at them in Oakland. They shot at them. Actually, I want to say they followed them
in their car and there were some gunshots. So I'm not going to put my life at risk
because it can be dangerous. There are certain encampments that attract a lot of illegal dumping.
You can go there and see like, you know, this person may be sleeping in this tent and they come
and they just throw their food or whatever. They add it to a pile. It's kind of pointless to say,
hey, you just threw your McDonald's bag on this big old pile of trash. You shouldn't do that.
You're contributing to the problem. When this entire encampment is filled to the brim with
trash. And they're just doing a little bit more. You know. Are people making money from this?
Trash collection has historically been tied to organized crime in Oakland. If you are a hauler,
if you're helping people, whether it's a contractor or somebody is looking to just clean
up their garage, you can go pick up their trash and they'll pay you to take it to the dump.
And then you can just throw it on the street. And so now this is a business where, let's say,
for instance, you're making $500 a day. And then one time you get caught and you get fined
$1,000. Well, if you've been making money for years doing this and you only got caught once
and they fined you $1,000. Why would you stop? You've made hundreds of thousands of dollars
doing this. You've only been caught once. You pay the fine. They're not going to catch you again.
Our district attorney has not prosecuted illegal dumpers. Not to my knowledge. And even recently
they're saying that they're working on creating a unit to address illegal dumping, our current
district attorney in Alameda County. Obviously, I'm, you know, I'm keeping up with the research
and seeing what's going on with this. But there's really no consequences for illegal dumping in
Does the city come and clean? Because you try to call them like this.
Yeah, sometimes you can report it on a 311 app. And there was a time where, you know, within 72
hours, they would be on it. It seems like that has changed because as somebody who,
you know, reports illegal dumping consistently, and because it's like right outside of my house,
I also want to make sure that, you know, we're clear. I'm talking literally, I have to step
outside my house and walk around the corner. It's right outside your house, right? So I get to
drive past it every day. And if I was the one that reported it, I know that it's been sitting there.
There've been times where you report trash. I take a picture. Well, from the time that I've
taken the picture and reported it, there's more trash on top of it. And so the city says that
they cleaned it up. And so I've had to go out with my camera and move this to the side and say,
you never picked it up. This is the same trash that I reported. It's just covered with new trash.
How many people are going to get their hands dirty and dig through that? Not many. And then also,
how many people have the cameras or the time to actually do it and to document and say,
I can prove that this trash was never collected, even though they closed it out of the app and said
that we picked it up. I can absolutely prove it. It kind of makes me feel like I'm fighting against
my own city. And then also, I don't want somebody to lose their job because they lied about picking
up this trash. But I do want some accountability to say, you know what? You're absolutely right,
Ansel. We didn't pick it up and you proved that we didn't pick it up. And these are the steps that
we're going to take to make sure that this doesn't happen again. You're not going to get that.
You're not going to get that. You'd be lucky if you get a response to your email,
which leads us to, well, I guess I should post it on Twitter.
And then what happens when you post it on Twitter? Does it get resolved? I get invited
to the California Insider. What happens is I learned that after a couple of my posts went
kind of viral, 50,000 views, I said, oh. Then the city responded. There was a tennis court
that was covered in trash. Nobody could use the tennis court. Somebody was living on it.
And I posted a photo. And then the next week, city leadership, they were out there,
but only because of the engagement online. And then I discovered that, oh, OK, this is
this is what we're doing now. Right. I sent an email. I get ignored. I posted on social media.
Now we got action. That's really unfortunate because I shouldn't have to do that.
Like, I never wanted to be in front of the camera and speaking to the news and
in here talking to you. I just wanted a clean neighborhood and so a clean city.
And so you continue to post. And now, you know, people get familiar with who you are.
They want to talk. And then people are running for election. And now they're attacking me
because I'm sharing things during an election cycle and it makes people that are running
look bad. And so now there is this whole idea that I'm a political plant and that somebody's
paying me. And I'm probably going to take this interview and say, see, I told you.
As someone reporting on California's economy and policies every week,
unfortunately, I see the middle class shrinking in California. Some of it has to do with our
policies. And there is another side to this that we are facing major inflation here and across
the country. Unfortunately, the dollar has lost 10 percent of its value just this year to date.
That's why more and more people are turning to real assets to protect their financial future,
like physical gold and silver from American hard-fought gold. Unlike paper assets,
these tangible investments can't be controlled or devalued by inflation or bad policies. You can
have them delivered straight to your home or securely stored in a tax-advantaged gold IRA,
giving you a safe, reliable way to safeguard your wealth no matter what happens in California or the
rest of the country. American hard-fought gold has an A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau
and thousands of five-star reviews. And right now, when you call, you can get up to $15,000
in free silver with your first purchase. Call 866-595-2304. That's 866-595-2304 or text KALI
to 65532. Make sure to text KALI to 65532. Beat the system and protect your wealth with something
real today. So your area, East Oakland, it's a tight community, isn't it? A lot of us, you know,
natives are really prideful. The Oakland Coliseum is in East Oakland. So when the Warriors won the
championships, right, we were celebrating in East Oakland. The Raiders, the A's, you know,
all of these teams that are no longer in Oakland. It is something that, you know, I smile about
talking because, you know, it's my city, it's where I was raised, it's where I went to school.
I want to say that I absolutely love, you know, being from East Oakland. We have a lot of
celebrities, musicians, athletes, too short. And Raphael Sadiq, Tony, Tony, Tony, and, you know,
LeBron James played basketball when he was in high school for a team called the Oakland Soldiers.
A lot of people don't know that, but he had, when he was in high school, we played for the
Oakland Soldiers for one summer. So yeah, we got pride. Now we go to Vincent Williams with
Urban Compassion Project, who's mobilized many people to come to this cleanup efforts.
Vincent, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you for having me.
You have a project, you have a unique project, you're working on cleaning up the illegal dumping
in Oakland. What's the impact when you guys show up and clean up a street or an encampment?
So this year alone, we have removed, we have engaged over 3,500 volunteers,
and we have removed over 441 tons of illegally dumped trash from streets, parks, waterways,
and other common spaces. The impact is, it speaks for itself. It speaks for itself.
Beyond cleaning up the debris, we have incorporated in homeless ambassador program
that allows us to pay individuals $100 per week. Right now we have 12 people that we work with
and paying them $100 a week to ensure that these areas are staying clean and sustainable. We give
them the equipment that they need. But beyond that, what's really important to us is that
while we're working with them and they're ambassadors for us, it gives us the opportunity
to engage with them on a deeper level, to work with them on getting other services and resources.
So, you know, it's not so much about paying people to continue to be on the street,
to hold people accountable for illegally dumping. It's more so about, okay, we've gotten this far.
And once we get this far, there's a trust level that is built. And people start to ask us as
Urban Compassion Project, hey, you know, like, I'm tired of being out on the streets. I need
detox. I need mental health. Can you help me get some housing? So our impact is, like I said,
it's incredible. And it continues to grow. You have a lot of volunteers that help you,
right? How did you get them to help you? Yes. We took to social media. So it was suggested to me
early on. I was really against it to begin with, because I don't really do social media.
But I took the advice and the suggestion and we started posting, or I started posting on social
media. And it grew like wildfire. People started asking if they could get involved. And we went
from seven volunteers per cleanup to 150 or more per cleanup that we do. When you guys do these
cleanups, does the site get filled again with these dumpings? Some of them do. So if we look
at 100% of the cleanup locations that we have had in the last, let's say, 100 days, for the
most part, about 93% of those locations have remained debris free. Whereas the other 7%,
because of the placement of them in Oakland and the lack of capacity for City of Oakland to hold
people accountable, they continue to get dumped on. But in general, like looking at our KPIs and
our data, 93% is a great stat to have when it comes to areas remaining clean and debris free.
In terms of your volunteers, you have a big pool of volunteers. Who are they? Are they all from
Oakland? They're not all from Oakland. We have volunteers that are transplants to Oakland.
One of our volunteers doesn't even live in the Bay Area, drives from almost Sacramento every
Saturday to come out and help us at cleanups. Some are from San Francisco, Berkeley. We have a
lot of volunteers that join us that come here to travel. We recently had a volunteer that was here
on vacation from Canada. A large part of our volunteer base is Oakland based, but not all of
them. And I think that that makes Urban Compassion Project unique because volunteers are people that
are looking for opportunities to kind of just be part of something bigger than themselves,
seek out Urban Compassion Project to get involved. You mentioned someone that's going from Sacramento
to Oakland to help you guys. Why? This gentleman has been in corporate America for 30 plus years
and has worked for some major companies. It's interesting because we know that people that
believe in something will go to no end to get involved and to make sure that they show up.
And so with conversations with him, we understand from him that he sees the impact that we're having
and it's amazing to him, at least if you let him tell it, that he can be involved in something that
is having such a great impact in Oakland and is quite literally spreading like wildfire, not just
in Oakland, but like throughout the Bay Area in California with how people are showing up for
their local communities beyond what local city government is doing. Is there anything that you
can share with us that you have learned in this process of doing these cleanups? What's very
interesting about... I started this organization while I was still sleeping on a bus stop bench.
That's important to note. I'm 37. I've lived on the streets for 24 years. The struggle
or the fear in starting this organization was that nobody would agree with it because
the climate in the country for the longest time has been an infighting of sorts and
no one can agree on certain things and everybody has different opinions and political beliefs
and religious beliefs and what's ended up happening with Urban Compassion Project is we've been
able to create this space where it doesn't matter how you identify, it doesn't matter what religious
background you come from, it doesn't matter... like volunteers don't care of what side of the aisle
you sit on or who you support politically. One of our oldest volunteers was one that hit us up on
Instagram four years ago and was like you're enabling murderers and rapists and drug addicts
and I would never support your organization and we suggested that maybe you come to a cleanup. I said
hey maybe you come to a cleanup and if you don't like what you see after the cleanup then I'll quit
what I'm doing and I'll never do this work again and she came to a cleanup that we had and about
an hour into the cleanup we couldn't find her and I found her kind of sitting off on a side street and
I approached her and I said hey what's wrong this is a woman who owns multi-million dollar house in
the hills of Oakland and thought that you know all people need to be removed from encampments
and locked up or sent to an island and she said I can't believe like people have to live like this
and that we don't take any accountability and she still has her beliefs but with those beliefs
what she decides to do is she decides to come to cleanups and support regularly in community with
what she can do this is something that people can be involved in regardless of what walk of life
they are that has an impact that everybody can agree on and and and so that's what I would say
like our our biggest obstacle that we've overcome is actually creating a true compassionate space
where it doesn't matter all we want to do is do the next right thing and have integrity while
we're doing it. I see you're on the road Vincent and it seems like you're on the road a lot because
you're going from job to job and you're trying to clean places up how can people help you?
Yeah so just a quick background I I am wearing the same clothes I wore yesterday because I have
not been home yet last night we were at a location where we were able to huge note actually in the
last year the city of Oakland has not held anybody accountable for illegally dumping not one person
has been fined or cited and last night for the first time because of the work that we're doing
the first person was cited and fined for illegally dumping because we caught them
we contacted PD we provided them with video and proof and they were able to capture the person
while they were still on site and so yes we we need a ton of support we are an extremely small
organization when it comes to the amount of staff that we have that are regular hugely if anyone's
in the Bay Area in California in the San Francisco Bay Area sign up for a cleanup come out and join
I always say that you may think that we're not having an impact until you actually come out and
join a cleanup and actually see in real time the impact that you can have as a volunteer.
You guys have had some crime issues too right how's this dynamic work you guys care about your
community but then there's issues too can you tell us more about it? The way I see it is that if you
look at any city LA, New York, Chicago, Miami you can absolutely enjoy these places and the culture
but you have the good you have the bad you have the ugly there's always going to be crime less
crime in the Oakland Hills more along the flatlands and so going back to what I talked about with the
Oakland Police Department where the way that they engage with motorists or you know just citizens in
general it's kind of hands off so I got I'll tell you an example my car got hit there was a hit and
run on the 4th of July a couple years ago I have dash camera I got it on video I got the license
plate me being from Oakland something told me that that car was from that area so I drove back
to the area and I found the car that hit me it was a block away from where I got hit they were doing
donuts in the intersection they left they came back and did donuts and then they hit me I was
at a stoplight and so I got this video and the car's right here and I called the police department
and for a month nobody did anything they didn't tow the car it took almost a year for my police
report to come back because you fill out the report online so what happens is Oakland then
becomes a destination for people who want to commit crimes because they know that well I don't
even need a license plate I'm not going to get pulled over right it's easy for me to get away
with it and then when you have a a police force that's having difficulty with recruitment I think
this is a statewide issue where there's not a lot of people going in the law enforcement
so your numbers are down your academy and now there's no funding now this is another issue
that some areas don't have funding well I would say I know that in Oakland our police budget
continues to grow I'm not a budget expert but uh but the number goes up and and that also
was related to the cost of salary and and you know ammunition and things is going up inflation
the Oakland police department continues to be funded I don't think that that's the issue I think
the issue is they just can't do what they need to do back in the day if you were driving in Oakland
when I was growing up and the police car got behind you
you were like oh my god right which is not really what you want right we don't want people that are
so afraid of their public servants but we do want people who are planning on doing bad things
to say the police are here and they're gonna find you and they're gonna arrest you if you do
something Oakland is not the place where you're going to get away with things because we do our
job and we do it well but today it feels like they are restricted on what they used to be able to do
it's like something as simple as saying hey I pulled you over because you don't have a license
plate you can't do that anymore they don't they don't do that anymore such a basic form of of
law enforcement you know but your neighbors think of the situation there do they see that happening
a lot of my neighbors are are frustrated with the city they complain I am the chair of my
neighborhood council so we meet with the Oakland police department once a month we have an officer
that we meet with we have a relationship with they give us crime statistics we can bring our issues
to them and so there's very few people that come to our meetings and I think that that's just
because people don't like showing up to meetings the frustration from a lot of my neighbors are from
people that are a little bit older they are often retirees they are not necessarily as savvy
tech savvy so they're used to calling and emailing and not getting a response and then they'll just
be frustrated and then you just get back to living life because you got to go to work tomorrow you
got bills to pay so people will you know express their frustration but there's not a lot of action
behind it and um when I say hey can I interview you or let's put out a video nobody wants their
face shown they're fearful of retaliation I find myself alone a lot of times when I say hey
I can put this on social media it might go viral and the city might address it but some people are
like nope I don't want any attention I don't want the trouble so what you have is a lot of people
that are just mad and they channel that through just speaking out and complaining at meetings
but there's not really much follow-up or an action or a plan of okay how do we take this energy
and let the city know that this is unacceptable people are less inclined to uh showing their
faces on camera and getting on social media what kind of retaliation is there people have
came for my business I build and design tiny houses I share my home with travelers people
book my space my place and people book my place for photo shoots so uh people will say oh he is a
landlord and he lives here and his son lives here we call it doxxing so I post a photo of trash
and so somebody doesn't like it because it makes their friend who's an elected official look bad
so then they go and look up my background to see if somebody's paying me so then they found out
well nobody's paying him well what can we do to this guy to make him stop and then they put out
my private information and I'm just like why what am I doing that's making you so upset
that you want to attack me as a private citizen I care about my community and I want a clean
community and I'm tired of being depressed when I drive home and look at trash so the
retaliation is it's really with online anonymous accounts because they never put their face behind
it like I'm not here to for people to agree with me I do think that we can have respectful dialogue
and we can respectfully disagree because that's okay and we can learn from each other but when
you attack somebody you know viciously and then you hide behind an anonymous username
and I can't find out who you are and I can't subpoena a platform to expose you because in
in this wonderful country of ours the first amendment allows people to say and do a lot of
things and it's very hard to prove like defamation and stuff like that it's very hard so they attack
you online anonymously and unfortunately you know this is the nature of social media these days
so how do you keep going with with what you're doing well eventually I've learned that they're
they'll stop so if you let if you allow people to silence you then they win right and if you
continue to you know they say sunshine is sunshine is the best disinfectant or something like that
when you actually engage with them and say hey can you come to my neighborhood council meeting
I want to meet you can we walk through my neighborhood to show you what what's going on
then those people they disappear as well so you got the anonymous folks and then you have the
people that are not anonymous but they're still saying that hey I heard you were a political
plant and say hey well I'm not you want to meet me you want to come let's clean up this trash
together let's let's work together and then they don't show up either so it's just noise
it's just noise and then also there are times where you have to file you know a legal complaint
when people cross the the line between the first amendment and then harassment and defamation
and thankfully you know we have online tools that will help somebody like myself who
may not necessarily have the money to hire a law firm I can talk to chat GPT and it'll help me
draft my complaint so the game has changed where we can still hold people accountable for telling
lies and then I also learned that I can simply talk with people and see if they're serious about
trying to clean up the city or if they're just they just want me to stop because it makes their
friend look bad and they may not get elected again if I keep posting you know now and so are you
making progress based on what you're seeing yes and no the trash is still there but I'm meeting
people the elected officials know who I am when I send an email I'll get a response now I have the
phone numbers of elected officials they know that I'm serious and they've all and they've done their
research the progress is now we're having conversations and and I can share my ideas
about how we can fix this the actual dumping I haven't seen any progress because that's above me
because I can't enforce the laws I'm not the DA I'm not the city I can't do any of that and if I
pull out my camera and go up to somebody and say hey you're dumping in my community
it puts me in harm's way I'll say this I am a CCW holder I have the right to carry a firearm
concealed in Alameda County but I don't want to use it like I don't want to I don't ever want
to have to use my guns outside of the gun range right I don't ever want to feel like somebody
wants to harm me and my child so you have to be very very very careful when you're documenting
these folks that are doing these things because you know who's going to protect me when they
retaliate so the progress is made and that now we're having conversations about how can we fix
this we're in Silicon Valley where we solve things we're so we're solution oriented there's no way
that you're telling me that I can put satellites and astronauts you know in space but I can't stop
people from dumping trash there's so much technology here that's available for us and
the fact that we're not leveraging that to to solve something as simple as people dropping
dumping trash I think it's a conversation that's not being had the progress is not good enough for
me there's a lot more work to be done like there's a lot of work to be done before we move forward
with the rest of this interview let's take a look at the key headlines this week at the Epoch Times
newspaper on the California section state lawmakers wrapped up their session and about 1200 bills
passed in California last year the governor's office vetoed about 15.7 percent of these bills
we'll see which ones would get vetoed this time another key headline was that cap and trade was
extended till 2045 and now it's called cap and invest the idea is that the state would charge
fees for polluters or companies that have emissions and then invest these funds into
green initiatives there could be a major change for faith-based homeless housing and some of these
faith-based homeless housing are the most popular and the most successful in the state now they
might be getting a lot more government funding there's a new bill in California that is training
law enforcement on transnational repression essentially teaching law enforcement how to
deal with foreign governments coming here and doing their own operations one of these examples
is the Chinese Communist Party and as you know we are a sponsor of Shen Yun and Shen Yun as a show
has faced a lot of challenges in the U.S. because the Chinese Communist Party is coming after them
they're threatening sometimes the theaters they're having bomb threats and this is one of the
examples that this bill will cover in California there is a lot more headlines in this newspaper
it's not just a newspaper there's a 24-7 platform with many news articles these issues we cover are
multifaceted we have a lot of voices in these articles we have more voices than we have on the
show make sure to get the newspaper subscription right now you'll be surprised by the quality of
journalism that we have in this paper it's very unique now let's go see the rest of the episode
what are some of these solutions so you mentioned surveillance is one of them
what else is there that Oakland can do tomorrow to start solving this problem
if I were the mayor tomorrow I would hold a press conference with the district attorney
and I would say that we are actively prosecuting people for illegal dumping
there are a couple videos there's somebody in the cyber truck there's a video that went viral
there's a guy in a cyber truck I like the cyber trucks by the way you know
Elon if you're watching this give me a free one license plate clear and everything dumping trash
they know who it is why didn't we prosecute that person and it doesn't mean hey you go to jail for
the rest of your life it means that we we have a tool and whether it's you're going to do community
service or whether you're going to be fined you're going to stand in front of a judge
and answer to why you felt the need to throw your trash in this community because the appearance of
somebody in this luxury expensive vehicle like those cyber trucks are a hundred thousand dollars
they didn't throw it in front of their house they drove away from their home to dump it in my
community why aren't we prosecuting that person now what about your your community members you
mentioned it's a tight community right people people care about each other right absolutely
what can they do to to expedite this I think the the missing piece is more voices
more loud voices the emails are effective when there's a lot right so if you ignore my email
is one thing but if you get 200 right that sends a message that sends a message
so I think that as community members if we organize and we're on the same page
then we can let city hall know this is these are our expectations and it's not an attack it's not
an attack to let somebody know that this is what I want from you but some people might frame it as
if we say these are our expectations and if you don't meet them then we're going to consider
looking for new representation I think that's the way recalls work when the voters are unhappy
with what they're getting so they take the necessary steps to get new representation
because we live in a democracy and as a public servant I worked in law enforcement for 14 years
I always knew that my job was to serve the public I always knew that this wasn't about me this was
about the people that pay my salary and I left as a supervisor and I told my officers that we
work for the people right give that person your cell number it's a government phone give that
person your email they need to be able to reach you for anything that they need because we are
here to serve the public the only thing that I can do is is try to motivate people to jump on
board I think that is the hard part is asking people to volunteer their time to do stuff
what's the impact of all this on oakland when you see this illegal dumping this trash how do you
it's impacting oakland who wants to open up a business in a neighborhood that's filled with
trash who wants to purchase a home in a neighborhood that's filled with trash who wants to
have their sports franchise in a city that is filled with trash who wants to raise their kids
there so now we have a lot of vacant commercial properties where we're not generating the tax
revenue that fund all of the things that we need and now there are people that are fleeing the city
to look for a better place to raise their family keep in mind oakland is still a part of the larger
silicon valley right still right next to san francisco right location is so important you
know we have a very good transit system this is prime real estate right oakland is still prime
real estate like we're right next to san francisco we have a major port we have an international
airport like it's a wonderful place to be but it can be so depressing that people would rather
not spend their money here not raise their family here not start their business here
and that impacts us all because i remember in oakland that was bustling i remember in oakland
where things were wonderful where we had you know tons of festivals you know and concerts and
you know things that are still here you know there's still a little bit of that here we still
got a lot of culture i love my city but i want to get it back to its heyday where oakland was
the place to be and um and we had you know good news coming out of oakland
have you ever thought about leaving absolutely i think about it all the time i think about it
when i when i'm tired at the end of the day and i'm just like is it even worth it i think about
when i go into another city and i'm like oh my god there are no potholes here i think about
driving to places and having a meal and it's just so clean and i'm like you know what i don't know
how much longer i'm gonna be on this earth but um darn this neighborhood is nice right
what is going on in this city that that that's not going on in oakland and maybe i just say you
know what i can't win this battle let me just move to the burbs and then deal with the suburban
issues which are uh you know neighbors butting heads about your apple from your fruit tree
dropped in my backyard those issues versus potholes and illegal dumping you know which
problems do you want i do think about it all the time i think about it all the time am i gonna
take action and leave um i don't know maybe we'll need to uh you know check back in five years
but i do feel like oakland is one of the best cities in in the world and that um you know if
we can just if we can just clean it up then more people would come back and invest you spend a lot
of time on this how much time do you spend doing this filming and do you do it on a regular basis
i try to get up every morning and go out and document because school is in session um i try
to get out really early so that i can capture people going to school and going to work and
seeing what they walk past and then you have to edit the video and upload the video i would say
i spend maybe two hours a day so it's kind of like community service right absolutely absolutely
and i don't get paid anything how did you learn to do this like you're doing a service for your
community i worked at a lot of non-profits growing up i did a lot of youth work uh growing up i wanted
to be a high school teacher so you know a lot of my mentors were uh you know pushed for service
oriented or they were service oriented people community service we have to take care of our
community we have to look out for each other that's just my upbringing we can't solely rely
on these people you know downtown to do everything you know we have to help as well we may not have
all the resources but um we can still do our part sometimes it's creating awareness sometimes
it's picking up the trash um you know sometimes it's knocking on doors sometimes it's just having
a conversation um i think that that there's there's different ways that we can contribute
but i would say that my overall upbringing you know being raised in the church and um you know
in oakland public schools i had some really amazing teachers um you know shout out to dennis
geickema my favorite teacher the history of like the black panther party in oakland and
feeding the community and things like that we have a lot of great people doing work the east
collective feeding the community oakland is is a grassroots city where um historically
oaklanders have figured things out on their own without city hall involvement so i just think
that that's part of being from oakland you're gonna have to figure it out they say if you can
survive in certain places you can survive anywhere so uh i don't i don't have any you know formal
training if you will i would just say that just growing up um this is just the way we do things
Ansel Troy east oakland neighborhood council chair it was great to have you on california insider
thank you for having me it was a wonderful conversation and hopefully when we see you
next time the trash is gone i hope so as well i hope so as well i'll continue posting online
let us know what you think is happening in the streets of oakland do you think the city should
do more to punish illegal dumping or do you think the residents need to do more to clean up the
streets you can always comment or email us at siamakacaliforniasider.com we read all of your
emails and comments and when you comment make sure to consider everybody our platform is a
bringing people together i'm siamak karami this is california insider we'll see you next time