Ancient India: sacred stone

Asian Antiquities Museum
23 followers
Hello and thank you all for joining us for this really exciting event which is
part of the nationwide Art History Festival organised by the Association for Art History
and which also relates to the exhibition Ancient India Living Traditions at the British Museum.
I'm Sushma Jansari, Early South Asia Curator at the British Museum and also Curator of that show
and I am so pleased to be joined by Dr Anjana Katwa for this event. Anjana is an award-winning
earth scientist and she specialises in bringing stories about the origins and formation of natural
landscapes to life for a wide range of audiences including all of us today. Her debut non-fiction
book The Whispers of Rock Stories from the Earth came out just the other week on the 4th of
September and it tells a global story of how rock has shaped our world and our lives. I have a copy
right here with me, it is fascinating. For this particular event Anjana is going to give us a
30-minute presentation that explores some themes from her book and many of which connect to the
exhibition too and then after that she and I will have a 20-minute discussion that more closely
focuses I'd say on some sacred images carved in rock of course from the Ancient India Living
Traditions exhibition and I'm really looking forward to your presentation and so without
further ado I'm going to hand over to you. Thank you so much Sushma for that very very generous
introduction. I'm here really to talk about spirituality in nature and how that intersects
with science in the most extraordinary and beautiful ways. I'm, as Sushma introduced me,
I'm an earth scientist so I tell stories about rocks, fossils and landforms and I've done this
through a variety of different ways on television, on radio and more recently in this amazing book
that I've had such a privilege in writing. Let's kick off with this kind of sense about how we feel
about rock and landscape in our own lives because as I've been writing this book and certainly as
I've been working as an earth scientist across much of my career which spans about two decades
I felt that in the western world we've lost a sense of connection with rock but if we look
across the world and particularly at the Ancient India exhibition we get a sense that there are
global communities that still have a sense of connection and particularly a spiritual connection
with rock and landscape and this beautiful photograph of me with some sandstones at the
Petra archaeological site really kind of demonstrates how much I love rock and what
it means to me because when I'm placing my hand on that rock itself it is an actual quite a
spiritual experience for me because I can connect with the rock and its story. This particular
formation dates back to 500 million years ago when rivers were flowing over an ancient desert
which is now Jordan and these beautiful sandstones were deposited by those rivers flowing over a
landscape that was devoid of vegetation so the river could dance wherever it wanted to
and as those sand grains came to rest they eventually became cemented to form these
beautiful bedded structures that you can see in that photo. It really is one of the most
extraordinary places I've ever been. If we travel across the world we can also see how different
indigenous communities and people have revered and looked at the landscape through spiritual lenses.
This is Kororuapeu in Te Ika, Maui, Aotearoa, New Zealand and this mountain which is also a
stratovolcano. The Maori see this as a manifestation of Ruamoko who was the god of earthquakes and
volcanoes and what is really important about this particular landscape is that it's also not only
important for geologists because we look at stratovolcanoes as kind of interesting ways
in how to look at how plate tectonics is manifesting in the landscapes that we live in
and stratovolcanoes are formed in regions of the earth where the oceanic crust is pulled beneath
the continental crust which creates the volcanoes. For Maori, Kororuapeu is a way of understanding
how the earth is expressing itself and so this particular mountain, this particular volcano,
as it expresses itself through volcanic eruptions or lava flows or ash clouds,
Maori believe that this is Ruamoko expressing himself and so the way the site is managed in
terms of communities and people that live in its vicinity, Ruamoko is allowed to express itself
so people are encouraged not to live in areas where there may be lava flows or lahars which are
which are flows of ash and rock from the top of the mountain itself. So essentially,
Maori believe that we as people need to adjust to how the earth and in this case a stratovolcano
expresses itself. If we go to the other side of the world, to California in North America,
this is perhaps one of the most magical stories I encountered as I was researching and writing
the book. This is Teseak. She's a granite intrusion which pretty much makes Yosemite
one of the most iconic landscapes in the world. She's also known in the western language as
Half Dome. Now Teseak is an ancestor of the Awenichi people who are now known today as
Amuak First Nations in California. Now Teseak geologically formed through granitic intrusions
into the crust. So these are essentially plumes of semi-molten magma that rose up,
intruded into the earth's crust and couldn't necessarily break through to form a volcanic
eruption. What happened is that magma got trapped just underneath the earth's crust in layers of
rock or in magma chambers as in this case. And that magma took about two to three million years
to cool down. And as it did, crystals began to grow in that rock. And this is what we see when
we see granites all over the world. You see them sparkling with beautiful crystals. Now the story
of Teseak in the memories and the stories of the Awenichi people goes as follows. Teseak was a
woman traveling with her husband through the Yosemite Valley. And they both became very hungry
and thirsty as they had been walking for a very long time. And as Teseak walked a bit further
than her husband, she came across a lake. And she was so thirsty, she began to drink from the lake
and she drank the lake dry. So when her husband arrived, he was very angry. He asked her,
why did you not leave any water for me? Because I am also hungry and tired. I've been walking as
much as you have. And so a great big argument ensued between the two of them.
And her husband reached out for his walking stick and reached out to strike Teseak.
But she moved away and instead she threw her basket at him in anger. Now the great spirit
who was looking down upon this man and woman who were arguing so violently, he became very angered.
And so he decided to make a lesson out of them. And he turned the husband into Washington
Sentinel, which is on one side of Yosemite Valley. And he turned the woman, Teseak, into this
beautiful granitic peak. And the Awenichi people who had lived in the Yosemite Valley for about
five or six thousand years, always looked to Teseak to remind themselves of humility and regret.
Because it was a story that told them about kindness and tolerance, and tolerance towards
each other. And what you can see on the face of the granite dome are these black streaks. And
scientists know these black streaks as lichen. And the lichen have been there for thousands and
thousands of years. And the native people, they see them as the tears of the woman who had been
turned into stone. And this is probably one of the most beautiful intersections of science and
spiritualities. It just gives me goosebumps whenever I retell that story. I think it's so beautiful.
We go elsewhere in the North American continent. We go to South Dakota. And this is Six Grandfathers
Mountain in South Dakota. Again, this is a granitic intrusion into that landscape that occurred
a couple of hundred million years ago. Now, this particular mountain is incredibly sacred to the
Lakota, the First Nations people in South Dakota. And this image shows us what this mountain used
to look like. The Lakota believed that this place was incredibly sacred, because what they could see
in the rock formations were six key figures that would be guiding and counseling the members of
their tribe. And quite often, Lakota elders would go up to Six Grandfathers Mountain for something
called vision questing, where they would commune and be with the rocks to find wisdom and guidance
that would help them through the trials and tribulations that their people found themselves in.
Now, today, we know Six Grandfathers Mountain as Mount Rushmore. And as the Lakota were
gradually dispossessed of their lands, and the settlers came in, particularly to prospect for
gold, they turned the mountain, this spiritual space, into an expression of power and supremacy
over the indigenous people. And Lakota today still feel the harm being done to them, because
in the Fort Laramie Treaty, the entire region of the Black Hills area was promised to them as part
of an exchange of lands with the settlers, the European settlers that came. And when gold was
discovered on their indigenous lands, the Lakota were forced off those territories, and the land
was taken back by the US federal government. So there is a little bit of friction in this
landscape. And I just wanted to touch upon that, because landscapes are geologically fascinating,
particularly for people like me that have studied the science. But we also need to recognize that
landscapes also have immense cultural values, particularly for people, the First Nations,
who have lived and been custodians of these landscapes for thousands of years.
There was another sacred object that I wanted to share with you today. And this is Tamanawas,
and he is an ancestor of the Grand Ronde tribe who are in Oregon in the United States.
Tamanawas is actually a four and a half billion year old meteorite that fell to earth about 20,000
years ago. And Tamanawas in their language actually means visitor from the sky people.
And this is a picture of Desiree Hernandez. She's age seven, and she's interacting with Tamanawas
before a ceremony is held by the Grand Ronde delegation at the American Museum of Natural
History in New York. Now Tamanawas was regarded as an ancestor of the Chinook peoples, the Clackamas
and the Chinook peoples, because as the ice sheets melted, this is where Tamanawas landed
20,000 years ago. It was during an ice age when ice sheets covered much of the North American
continent. And Tamanawas was transported to Northern Oregon as part of the late Missoula
floods at the end of the last ice age. When the Clackamas and the Chinook people discovered
Tamanawas, they thought it was an incredible being. They could see and sense a message from
the heavens above. And so Tamanawas became revered within their cultures.
And in this picture, what you can see is somebody from the Grand Ronde tribe worshipping a 3D print
of Tamanawas at the T'Challu Cultural Center and Museum. And it's a really moving story because
it's something that appeals to me as a geologist, but also as a very spiritual scientist.
Because when I went to meet with my contributor, Travis Stewart from the Grand Ronde tribe
in March this year, I was able to hold some of the remains of Tamanawas
in my hands. And the sad story about Tamanawas is that once the Clackamas and the Chinook people
were dispossessed of their lands, Tamanawas was almost melted down by the Portland, Oregon Iron
and Steel Company. And in the end, they sold Tamanawas to a collector who then donated it to
the American Museum of Natural History. When it was under the care of the museum, Tamanawas had
fragments sliced from it for scientific research. And great credit must be given to the Grand Ronde
tribe for acquiring and having remains of their ancestor repatriated back to them.
And so when I visited the Grand Ronde tribe in March, I was allowed to hold the remains of their
ancestor in my hand. And that moment when I could meet the eyes of Travis Stewart, my contributor
to the book, across the room, it was this extraordinary moment where I felt I've touched
rocks like this before in my life. I've touched spiritual beings like this before in my life.
And it reminded me of Mataji from my home temple, my mandir in my family temple. And this is Mataji,
I'm just introducing you to her here. She's an incarnation of Mother Earth. And in Hinduism,
there are almost 21 goddesses that represent Mother Earth itself, Madhati. And in my hands,
you can see how revered she is in my family. She has the sacred mark of Sindur on her body,
and she's draped in a red cloth. And to hold her, to feel the privilege of holding Mother Earth in
my hands is something that I can't quite describe. It's this awareness that I know that she is an
object that has been on Earth for several hundred million years. I know her scientifically as a
granodiorite that my mum picked up from Wales. But I also know her as a manifestation of the
spirit of Mother Earth. And when I held the remains of Tamanawas in my hands, I just felt
that connection that we are unified all over the world, people who believe in the animacy of nature
spirits, that the spirit of nature is all around us, but it's also inside us as well. And here we
come to this question of how we begin to bridge science and spiritualities. This is Rainbow
Bridge National Monument in Utah, and the First Nations people see these bridges as gateways,
portals, if you like, to other worlds. First Nations leaders will never walk under these
bridges or arches. Rather, they will stand by them and commune with the rocks as part of vision
questing to gain knowledge and wisdom about how they can guide their own people in today's society
through the trials and tribulations they experience. But also, science in a way tells us
that as geologists, we also do the same process when we approach rocks. When I go to places like
these bridges in Utah, I know that the sandstones were formed hundreds of millions of years ago,
that they're a record of an ancient breath of wind that once carried sand grains across a landscape.
And it's the textures and the colours and the feel of the rock that gives me this insight.
So scientists, geologists are pretty much following in the footsteps of First Nations people
when they commune with the rock. And this is what I believe is that intersection between
science and spirituality. Geology is a science that's all about the cycles of creation and
destruction. And when I hold sand grains in my hand, there's this incredible moment where I feel
that, yes, I am part of a society that understands that nature is part of an ongoing process that
destroys and creates. Because these sand grains in my hand were once mountains. And of course,
when I scatter them back onto the earth, they will one day be reborn as new rock.
Now, this belief system that I particularly hold goes back to my own faith as a Hindu.
And I just wanted to touch upon this just for a moment. In India, there are these
sacred objects called Narmada pebbles that are held as incarnations of Lord Shiva. And I just
wanted to give you a little bit of the geological background to these Narmada pebbles. They were
formed about 145 million years ago in a rift valley system where the crust was very, very
slowly being pulled apart. Now, as rivers flowed into that valley, they filled it up with sand and
gravel. And over hundreds of millions of years, those river deposits were covered by flood basalts
because this was a tectonically active region where volcanoes and fissure eruptions were covering
the landscape with lava. And those lavas covered these river sediments. And the heat and pressure
of that process transformed these river sediments into quartzite, a really resistant kind of
metamorphic rock. Now, what I find really fascinating about this process is that it
embodies this idealism of destruction and creation. And when we look at the Narmada pebbles that are
these sacred representations of Lord Shiva, they are found in the Narmada river in Madhya Pradesh.
And what I find really fascinating as a geologist is that, yes, we have that geological story of how
the quartzite formed. But for those believers and followers of Lord Shiva, the quartzite pebbles are
actually shot through with quartz veins. And the quartz veins are said to represent the lines of ash
that are spread across Shiva's forehead. And this is why they are so desired and so sought after
by followers of Lord Shiva. They are seen as sacred representations, his incarnation on the
planet Earth. Now, the other really interesting object that you can see in the Ancient India
exhibition is a shaligram. And the origins of shaligrams are actually fossilized ammonites,
fossil ammonites. And they formed, you can find them, or communities have been able to find
ammonites in the Himalayas for thousands of years. And the reason for this is as follows.
As the Indian plate, hundreds of millions of years ago, moved slowly northwards,
it would eventually collide with the Eurasian plate. But in between the two continents,
essentially, was an ocean, was a body of water, where these strange creatures from the Jurassic
period were living at the bottom of the ocean. And as those two plates collided together,
the ocean sediments were uplifted. And eventually, they would create the foothills of the Himalayas.
Of course, with those sediments being uplifted, what went with them, but the fossils, of course.
And so communities for thousands of years have been discovering fossil ammonites. Now, if we look
at this beautiful object that is in the Ancient India exhibition, we can see a carving of Lord
Vishnu into the ammonite itself. And this object is so sacred because the ammonite for these people
represented a nature spirit, a serpent. And so through carving Vishnu on the other side of the
fossil, they were embodying his incarnation on earth. And I simply love this. I spent quite a
long time looking at this object when I visited the exhibition. Another kind of story that I want
to share with you is this story of the limestones. And the limestones in India, which are very much
used throughout the beautiful objects you see in the exhibition, the limestones date back to about
1.8 to 1.4 billion years ago. And I've just put a little video in there to show you what the rock
originally would have looked like before it was carved into those beautiful forms.
This was a region, this was a time when life was in its most primitive form. And these single-celled
organisms were called stromatolites. And you can see that in that picture on the right-hand side
in that video. Now, stromatolites were single-celled organisms existing in these very shallow basins of
water that became essentially drains for rivers flowing from the mountains that surrounded them.
And you can just see that basin that I refer to just circled there. And this particular basin,
the stromatolites would flourish, they would grow, they would trap sediments into their algal mats
and bloom in their millions. And over time, they would compress to form a limestone. So you get
to see layers of these stromatolites in the raw rock that we can see in the right-hand side.
Now, if we look at some of the beautiful artwork showcased in the exhibition, what you can see
are the layers of these stromatolites. And as a geologist, I find this absolutely stunning.
It's a stunning representation of geology and art together because what the artist has done,
the artisan has done, is essentially worked with the fabric and the texture of the rock
to really enhance the features of the multiple-headed cobra that you can see carved
into the limestone. You really get a sense of reptilian skin, don't you? And I think the rock,
the features in the rock add to that. It's really very, very beautiful. We can also see this
manifesting in this beautiful carving of the Bodhisattva Manjushri. Sorry about my pronunciation
there. I get really excited about the rocks and then sometimes I forget about my word
pronunciations. But what you can see here, again, this is a limestone from the same area that the
previous piece of artwork was carved from. What you can see is how some of the layers of the
limestone, and I think looking at them, they are stromatolites. What we can see is how the artist
has worked with the fabric of the rock to enhance features of this figure. You can see the muscles,
you can see the shape of the leg, the calf muscles, the face itself. There are so many beautiful
features of the bodily form that are working in harmony with the rock and that's what I find so
thrilling about when we begin to bring science of the geology and how the limestone formed
together with how the artisans were crafting the rock. If we come to one of the pieces that
is actually from a different part of Asia, this is one that I wanted to speak to actually because
it's quite unusual to see some of the pieces in the exhibition formed from volcanic rocks
because a lot of the pieces that I saw were formed from sandstones and limestones.
Now this particular piece is formed from what I call a volcanic tuff and it was a piece that was
discovered in Java. Now Java is located on the Ring of Fire and that particular rock that the
piece is made from is formed from volcanic eruptions of ash and rock. Now the volcanoes
along the Ring of Fire form because the oceanic crust is sinking very slowly, it's being pulled
beneath into the mantle and as it melts the globules of magma, they rise up towards the
earth's crust and intrude and break through and then form volcanoes and this is how these rocks
form. So the rock that you're going to see in the next picture is formed from the eruptions of ash
and pumice and lava. What we see in this beautiful representation of Ganesh
is this exquisite use and understanding of the rock itself. This particular figure is carved
from what I call volcanic tuff and when I went to see Ganesh in Java at the exhibition I noted
just the subtle beauty of how the artisan has created so many of the details here. Now volcanic
tuff can be very, well it lends itself to very intricate carving because it is relatively soft
to carve. I mean when we consider other rocks like limestone which can be a little bit more tricky,
it's a little bit more resistant but the volcanic tuff is slightly easier to carve and this is why
we see these beautiful intricate details. For example Ganesh's fingers are so beautifully
carved, you can see his toes, you can even see some of the details in upon the chair on which
he's sitting and the crown that adorns his head. What I find really fascinating about this piece
is that if you go to other areas of the British Museum and explore some of the other artworks,
particularly Hoa Hakananaia from Rapa Nui, that particular object as well is also carved from
volcanic tuff, ancient volcanoes that erupted on Rapa Nui. So it gives us a sense of global
connection through rock. So volcanic tuff is a rock that many people all over the world in how
they were expressing their love for nature and their understanding of spirituality in nature,
they were using these rocks as a way to manifest those belief systems and I just find that terribly
exciting and terribly unifying in a way because it makes us feel and it makes us sense that just
like how I held the remains of Tamanawas in my hands and I looked in Travis Stewart's eyes,
he's the curator and the guardian of Tamanawas, I could feel this sense of connection that no
matter where we are, no matter who we are, we feel this connection with nature and with nature
spirits and I think when we look at objects like this, it's this beautiful sense that there were
communities all over the world who had a reverence for rock and landscape and were using those
materials as an expression of that joy and that connection that they felt with the earth. So that's
what gives me such a thrill when I walk through the exhibition and I could see the limestones
and the sandstones and this volcanic tuff, I thought I've seen these rocks elsewhere in the
world, I've seen them celebrated in other cultures and I think that's the beauty of this exhibition
is that it just gives us this moment in time to centre ourselves particularly in ancient India
but it also opens our eyes to so many different cultures that understand and revere nature in a
that perhaps we could look towards. And I just want to come on to this final slide because I've
been working with a number of indigenous people from all over the world and this is a statement
that was given to me by Kingi Biddle of the Ngāi Whakao Iwi in Aotearoa New Zealand and I was
working with Kingi to understand Māori belief systems about animacy and nature and this statement
that he gave me that I can share with you today is imbued with mana, it's imbued with tapu,
it's a sacred statement. He says rocks do whisper, we've forgotten to listen to what they are saying
and I found it so profound to hear this from him because I thought that's how I feel and in my
hands what you can see is a piece of vesicular basalt, that essentially means it's a volcanic
rock that was collected when I was 13 years old in Kenya. I hold that rock today as a some 50 year
old woman and it's whispering to me that I did what I set out to do to a become a geologist but
also to carry the stories of rock with me for my life and that's it. Thank you so much for listening
to me. That was so interesting, I've got a whole page of notes I was taking down as you were
talking. Thank you so much, honestly when we first met a few years ago now I remember you talking
about your project and it really made me think about all of these sacred sculptures that I'm
fortunate enough to curate in a completely different way and I think one of the many
things that I've noted down as you were talking is when you talked about how you felt
such a spiritual connection with the rock when you touched it and I thought oh my god
that's really interesting because actually for Hindus in particular, when the
rock is shaped into the form of a deity, it's carved in particular ways,
particular sizes and stuff like that but also there's a particular ceremony that takes
place which imbues the rock with almost like a living quality so people believe that actually
it's the god is alive, it comes to life and actually it's the touching of it because not
only do you look directly at the deity carved from rock in the eyes as part of veneration but
also you would go and touch the feet as well and actually it's this, I never really thought about
how the type of the rock, the fact that you're communicating with nature like the ultimate,
I suppose the building blocks of life literally when you're talking about that this limestone
made from the stromatolites but also part of everything that we walk on, it's really kind of
changing how I think about some kind of creation, gods and enlightened teachers created and shaped
from rock. I think that's extraordinary that I've been able to do that Sushma, thank you for
sharing that and obviously I don't live with my mum anymore, she keeps Mataji in her
own temple but I have Mataji here, my own veneration of Mother Earth and you're absolutely right, what
we do or what I do as a Hindu is that I embrace my faith and I have done more so as I've been
writing in this book and I genuinely believe that even as a scientist or a spiritualist
I am touching this rock and I'm feeling the wisdom of hundreds of millions of years of Earth's
history in my hand but also the wisdom of my ancestors flowing through me to give me a greater
sense of kinship with nature and that's why it's so special. I think also there's a couple of
things, the story you were telling from Aitaroa in New Zealand about staying out of
the way and letting the volcano express itself, there's so much common sense in that as well
because you hear about stories from the Andaman Islanders during the awful tsunami that
unfortunately happened a few years ago and where there's a lot of people they felt the earth
shaking and the sea recede, they weren't sure what was going on, it's actually quite interesting so
more people went towards the beaches whereas actually for them stories had been passed down,
I think this might have been true in Japan as well but that might be a faulty memory there
but it had been handed down over generation after generation that if the earth
shakes and the waters recede, look for the higher ground and go there and so many of them were
thankfully able to, their lives were saved because of that learning so actually there's so much we
can remember and it has an impact on our own lives when we listen as you say to the
the whispers of rock and the voices of our ancestors. I think that's a really beautiful
expression of how science and spiritualities intersect because having studied Shintoism
in Japan and how it manifests itself in nature spirits, I do believe there is a very strong part
of Japanese culture that embodies that sense of resilience like those stories have been told
over thousands of years of how to cope with and become more resilient in the face of I would say
natural disasters and so it's inbuilt into Japanese society, what do we need to do and how do we
prepare ourselves for when nature expresses itself and I think it's something that we can
all really look towards these ancient belief systems and this reverence for nature that we
seem to have just lost touch with slightly. And yet it's not far below the surface because once
you start telling these stories and all of a sudden you think oh so that's what it meant, now I understand
Oh that's fascinating, I think there was when we were talking about unfortunately the
deity that was unfortunately sort of taken into collection and partly destroyed it kind of reminds
me of when sacred images in the subcontinent are damaged in some way you know for whatever reason
you know accidentally damaged whatever it might be, it's interesting that what tends to happen
is you don't completely destroy or just leave it to one side you tend to bury it back in the earth
so it's almost this idea that the rock goes back to where it kind of came from and it's normally
kind of buried under the underground or it might be placed in a riverbed which again actually now
that I'm thinking about it having heard you is another source of a lot of these stones which are
I love that because what governs every single aspect of life on earth is the rock cycle
and essentially rocks are created and destroyed in multiple processes at time scales we can't
imagine and sometimes we can imagine but essentially you know destruction it sounds
like such a negative word it sounds so frightening but actually in order to create new rock new
landscapes new opportunities we do need to destroy something in order to create that opportunity and
and you know here I'll give you an example I live on the Jurassic coast and and there are regular
cliff falls that happen along the coastline when those rocks collapse the waves will wash away that
rockfall but what they'll do is they'll transport the you know the gravels the sands and even the
fossils further down the coastline to form a different beach and so this kind of process of
renewal and rebirth is something we see again and again spoken about through legends and stories
and songs across cultures across the world and I find that that level of understanding and
sophistication of how to work within those processes particularly in indigenous cultures
is quite extraordinary and as scientists we've almost come to the game quite late
because those ideas you know were formulated several hundred years ago but they had been
spoken about for thousands of years previously. I love that I think this idea of the destruction
and the recreation of earth and stuff it reminds me of the stories connected with the the Hindu
god Vishnu and there were 10 incarnations of Vishnu and one of them is Vraha which is the
boar-headed deity and in the hot pink section of the exhibition my favourite colour
and there's a really gorgeous sandstone sculpture actually of Vraha and actually if you look closely
on his shoulder he's kind of looking up with his beautiful boar head and he's rescuing the
personification of the earth which is the goddess Bhool from where she was placed in a cosmic ocean
by an anti-god I mean the stories are incredible they are just so fabulous and he's rescuing her
there are so many different kind of ideas which are coming together all of which
you know come down to nature because you know the sculpture is made from this gorgeous
reddish pink sandstone it's slightly mottled which is from a region around Mathura in northern India
and then you've got the idea of the personification of earth but then you have this idea of an animal
headed deity and you know thinking about the pose sort of you know lifting her on his tusks
and it kind of reminds me of the boars you know the wild boars when they're throwing up
clods of earth as they're searching for tubers to eat and so you have so many different things
coming together for people through these stories and Vishnu is wonderful because you know every
time we all get ourselves into trouble you know humankind and the earth in different ways
this god comes down and rescues us so it's like hooray thank you very much we need it
yeah I could do we could do with a bit of Vishnu action today couldn't we
I just wanted to briefly talk about that stunning Ganesh sculpture that you mentioned from Java
and I think one thing I hadn't I mean I think lighting and the way certain images are displayed
wherever they are has such an impact on how you see them and think about them and it was
fascinating to hear about the creation of that beautiful volcanic stone and I thought what's
really interesting the way he's lit in the show it kind of really reminds me of elephant skin
and you sort of wonder you know those crafts people in the past because that dates from about
11th or 12th century you sort of wonder you know were they looking at these stones and seeing the
quality of elephant skin or something is that one of the reasons they selected it and I think
that's probably true in so many different ways because although a lot of sacred sculptures
were and are painted or adorned in different ways whether they're dressed or you talked about the
Sindoor on your Mataji sculpture for example and yet you still come down to the craftspeople and
an actual piece of stone and the qualities that they're seeing in it from the Narmada stones or
this beautiful sculpture of Ganesh. I absolutely believe you're onto something there and I think
that's a whole PhD project because when we look into well prehistory and archaeology we absolutely
know that these ancient artisans and tool makers had a very deep understanding of geology and in
the book I write about flint tools from Orkney and actually they were those prehistoric tool
makers were incredibly selective about the types of flints they chose and they used to create their
tools and their objects and their artefacts and I would imagine that that beautiful stone that
Ganesh is carved out of you know yes it does remind you of you know this kind of rumpled rough
skin it has that texture it has that quality and I think the beautiful kind of that we know that
obviously the colour of the rock has changed because of weathering and being transported
and being moved but the texture of the rock is you know they must have felt something about
what the rock was giving in terms of its messages in terms of physical like you know here is this
deity that you can come here and you can worship and look in the eye and connect with with you know
the greater divine beings but also this is part of you as well because this rock is all around you
you know if Ganesh was in in his original context we would be able to see those tufts those volcanic
tufts in the landscape all around us and so the deity becomes part of us as well as being this
divine being and I find that quite mind-blowing. That is extraordinary thank you and I'm going to
actually show some sculptures which are in the exhibition that I'd love to get your thoughts on
we talked about that really stunning sandstone and this lovely pinkish sandstone from in the
regions of Mathura and it's really I mean it's so famous this the sandstone I think one of the
things when you're looking at how to share quite unfamiliar art with different people
when we were working on the Hotan gallery which is the gallery of South Asia and China
at the British Museum the permanent one when I was thinking about the displays I was really
thinking about the colours of the rock because actually as you're walking through so even
subcontinent obviously a massive space but we don't probably think very much about how
different so much of the stone is around us in terms of colour and actually when you walk
through you've got these the lovely grey slightly sparkly shifts so it's really interesting to hear
from you about why they've got these lovely shiny inclusions in them so I've made a note of that as
well and then you kind of walk through and you go to the Mathura region and all of a sudden you've
got this lovely pinkish reddish mottled kind of stone then you carry on going up into slightly
more central India and it's a buff coloured sandstone then you go into eastern India and
it's this much darker granite as well and you carry on going and you know you go down south
to the southeast and you've got this lovely almost like a pale whitish creamy limestone as well and
it's so interesting it's almost like a way of directing people towards you to kind of think
oh yes you're in a different region now the colours are different and I just wanted
a slightly random question maybe a daft one but what gives this particular sandstone or any
sandstone these gorgeous rich colours like some of them are mottled some of this is just the most
beautiful warm reddish pink like what is that about? Yeah well it's all to do with the chemical
composition of the rock itself so as it's forming so this fine grain sandstones and this one
is absolutely beautiful and you can see that the texture of the sandstone has aided the artisan to
do so many intricate details and this sandstone was probably formed I would say in a desert
environment in an environment where you had grains of a very similar size cementing together not so
much an environment where you would have had flowing water so flowing water tends to transport
you know if you go to a river nearby you'll see all manner of size of grains on the riverbed
and what we see here is quite a homogenous sandstone and that that pinkish colour comes
from the minerals inside the rock and quite often what we see if we're kind of looking at red and
orange tones it tends to be iron oxides and when I was in Petra a few years ago it's probably one
of the most beautiful places where I've seen multi-coloured sandstones and where you see
blues and oranges and you know it's extraordinary because those are the blues are down to manganese
so when we're looking at the types of rocks that the artisans are choosing firstly they're
choosing rocks within their local regions because obviously it's incredibly expensive and arduous
to transport rocks inside into a region in order to to carve the things that you want to carve so
you're going to use locally what's around you so when you spoke about the exhibition you know
you're travelling through the different artworks and you're seeing a representation of different
types of geologies well essentially what you're looking at is a geological map of India as well
as an expression of the artistic form that the artisans were doing but essentially the colours
of the different sandstones are down to the minerals within the rock as it formed. Amazing,
thank you very much really helpful question answered and I wanted to also ask about you
talked about the softness and the hardness of different stones and rocks and those kind of
materials and this is another limestone piece and it's the same limestone as the two that you
showed in your in your lecture. I just wanted these particular sculptures and carved in this
particular kind of rock they're renowned for the incredible detail and you can see this one
I mean this is about 2,000 years old and you can still see so much incredible detail all the
figures all the expressions the clothes, jewellery, ornaments, the lot. I just wondered is
is there a reason why this particular limestone is so soft like what gives it its particular
texture is it the way different materials are kind of bonded and joined together or what is that?
Yeah well limestone is what we would call a chemical sedimentary rock so it forms when
dissolved calcium carbonate in water the molecules as it usually forms in
well stromatolites live in warm shallow waters. Let's start at the beginning so stromatolites
are single-celled organism organisms they were one of the very first organisms that began to
evolve on earth billions of years ago and they exist in warm tropical waters. Now if the waters
begin to cool down the calcium carbonate that dissolves from from their bodies begins to
molecules begin to kind of become attracted together and they deposit to form these very
fine-grained limestones at the bottom of basins or seas. Now let's fast forward to this
rock itself in its complete form and what you see is these beautiful intricate carvings in a
rock that allows the artisan to express him or herself I would assume it's a hymn but the
homogeneity of the rock itself so here we haven't seen that the artisan has chosen a very finely
layered stromatolite like we've seen in those other artworks they specifically chosen a piece
where the limestone is is what we would call as geologists massively bedded so it's a big
piece of limestone that has homogeneity across its structure so you're not so different I would
say inclusions of different things or different layers in the limestone are not interfering
with the way the artisan has created this sculpture. Now I say limestone is quite a soft rock
it can be depending on its texture but because this is so intricately carved it's either down
to the softness of the rock so limestone has yielded to the hands of this incredible artisan
and I think it's the two it's the artisan working together with the rock and understanding
how it behaves under his hands and this is quite extraordinary because when you talk to stone
masons today and I've met a couple over the research for this book they do talk about this
relationship they have with the rock they can hear it like you say sing to them it speaks to
them and as they're as they're doing these very intricate carvings they can sense perhaps I
shouldn't be pushing too far into this perhaps I need to just relax the pressure that I'm trying
to do to achieve this part of the work so I would imagine that artisan had a very close
and intimate relationship and understanding of what this rock was. Oh that's so interesting
thank you so much just got one or two left don't worry yeah I've got this one and we weren't sure
what the stone was it's potentially sandstone or potentially even granite but I was really
intrigued by the idea of the Narmada stones that you were talking about and then I thought I'd put
in this shiveling so it's shiver in the form of a lingam which actually means symbol and you can
see what's interesting is like a snake which is kind of winding around the shaft then above it
and it's got a mouth open with the fork tongue spreading out over the top and you can there are
different in the top part is quite smooth because that would have been protruding above the surface
whereas the bottom part is quite roughly carved because it's probably based inside the floor
of a shrine and I mean this is quite a hard rock it's very heavy to hold and yet they've managed
to kind of smooth it out and it's almost like they're trying to make it resemble a feature
of the landscape whether it's you know one of the Narmada stones or a kind of this kind of shaft
shape natural rock I just wondered I don't even know if you know this a random question but how
do you go about intricately carving and smoothing down such incredibly hard rock I mean if that's
something you know much about absolutely fine if not don't worry I'm just asking you all the
questions I've always wanted to ask it's okay so I've worked I've kind of spoken to various stone
masons as I've kind of gone through this process and and they are using different tools and
techniques to smooth and shape the rock usually it's it's a very delicate chisel so they are using
like I would say a mallet and using a chisel to begin to take away the bulk of the rock and then
when you get to the finer details it is a process of skill and care and different tools and using
I would say I mean these days they would use you know kind of different type of papers to achieve
that very smooth glossy finish that you see on those carvings but I think back in these days
several hundred years ago they would be using very fine tools to chip away and to get the intricate
detail that you have when I actually saw this at the exhibition I wasn't quite sure I knew it was a
crystalline rock and I wasn't sure whether that black coloring was painted on or stained but it
certainly felt like a like a crystalline granite so that's why we kind of see this almost sense of
holistic you know it just feels like this entire piece has been beautifully carved without any
obstruction or any kind of obstacles presented by the rock itself so that's why I kind of thought
this is a this is a crystalline granite or because it I wasn't sure whether the black was painted on
it could have been a basalt as well no the top bit was definitely painted and you can see the
natural color yeah yeah yeah oh this is one of my favorites I love it and do you know what I
love about the fact that you've got these kind of ancient sea creatures up in the Himalayas
just this one place and actually it's the um you know the beautiful curve the corner
it resembles um Vishnu's chakra weapon the discus weapon and you get them in such different
sizes you get massive ones little ones and as you say this lovely one it's also carved on the other
side what I love about Shaligrams are they for geologists we see the fossil fossil ammonites
up in Himalayas as this evidence for how India collided with the Eurasian plate some you know
15 million years ago and the uplifting of those marine sediments to then you know end up in the
foothills over the Himalayas that in itself is quite mind-blowing and then this kind of
beautiful connection with you know the followers of Vishnu seeing his chakra in these manifestations
you know and I I just find that utterly magical how the two can intersect I think it just goes
to show that you know when you've got people walking through different places wherever they
might be whether they're encountering ammonites or anything else it might be that kind of these
stories that we have already developed um has such an impact on how we then interpret what we're
looking at how we shape it because you know if they were not um worshippers of Vishnu they might
have been other people and they would look at these and a whole range of other stories would
have kind of emerged as well then you've got on the other hand this is part of what you were
talking about in your lecture is the other way around the landscape itself helps shape some of
these stories and you know you venerate the mountain um or the volcano and understand the
lessons that it is sharing with you and that's how you end up living your life so I think this
this twofold um I suppose play that we have with nature it's I think it has such a big influence
on our lives in ways that we often don't think about so much anymore yeah and I think you know
the other thing we haven't touched upon is manifestations of deities uh within the Himalaya
so Mount Kailash which is a very sacred place for Buddhists for Hindus I'm not sure about Jainism
but it is the spiritual home of Lord Shiva so you know the fact that the Himalayas are formed from
the collision and the destruction of an ocean that lay between those two continents you've
got the two continents colliding the mountain you know the mountains forming from crusts being
squeezed and compressed and uplifted to form Mount Kailash I mean that the manifestation of
of a Hindu Buddhist deity plus the science I just love that it excites me beyond words
and it's wonderful because a lot by you know lovely coincidence or not I don't know um the
god Shiva is associated with cycles of creation and destruction because when he dances you know
yes that's that's the endless cycle that takes place so that's the fact that they've kind of
quite perfectly yeah it is perfect brilliant oh well thank you so much I have to say I've
really really enjoyed our discussion today and I've learned so much from you too so thank you
and also thank you everyone else for joining us for this wonderful event today and especially
to Anjana for sharing her fantastic book as well with us um the book is available to buy at all
good bookshops and I'm also glad to say that Ancient India Living Traditions is open until
the 19th of October so please do come and see it if you can um and also it's free on Fridays so
you know book your ticket for free on any Fridays and of course members go free any time um thank
you so much from me and I don't know if Anjana you have any uh words for um the ending as well
well thank you very much for having me along I think just this intersection of art of archaeology
of spirituality and science is something that I think should bring joy to everybody's hearts
certainly has to mine oh fantastic well thank you so much and goodbye everyone bye
