The $6 BILLION Truth About Hawaii’s Short-Term Rentals! Hawaii vacation rentals play a massive role in the state’s economy, but how big is their impact really? In this video, we break down the $6.1 billion economic boost short-term rentals bring, what it means for Hawaii’s future, and how new vacation rental regulations could affect home buyers, investors, and locals.
CHAPTERS: 00:00 Intro - STVR Impact in Hawaii 02:16 Tourism's Role in Hawaii's Economy 02:48 STVR Visitor Spending 05:08 Big Island STVR Economic Impact 06:04 Download Hawaii Relocation Guide 06:41 STVR Tax Contribution 07:17 STVR Supply on the Big Island 08:05 STVR Proposed Regulations 08:22 Impact of Reducing Unlicensed STRs 09:20 STVR Occupancy and Market Resilience 09:51 Key Takeaways
If that's just a 50% reduction in the amount of currently unlicensed short-term rentals,
if those are wiped out and taken away, and then of course, you can basically double those numbers
if you do a 100% reduction where you ban all of those current hosted rentals from operating,
really significant, $10 million in tax revenue, 6,000 jobs lost, so really significant impact
on the island in an economy that's pretty small, right? This is all a very significant amount of
overall spending and contribution to our economy. Hey, what's happening, friends? There is a lot of
talk all across the state of Hawaii about short-term vacation rentals. It's really nothing
new. It's been going on for years, but there's a lot of talk of updated regulations, changes in the
regulations, new regulations, and depending on what island you're interested in or you're looking
at, it's going to be different, and you really want to make sure you understand what's going on,
but there was an interesting study that was commissioned by the county of Hawaii to look
at the economic impact of vacation rentals, specifically for the big island, but all across
the state, and it's got some really good information and numbers around visitor spending
and the amount of economic impact that the vacation rental industry has on our economies,
and so I summarized the whole thing for you. It's a, I think, 12 or 13-page study, but we have all
the information here summarized for you so you can get a high level and get an idea of the economic
impact that vacation rentals have here in the state because it's pretty significant, and these
are numbers that I wasn't aware of either. I knew it always was significant, but when you see
them broken down, you really can tell that if there is significant changes in regulation to
the vacation rental market, there's going to be definitely some significant impacts in our
economy, so Kloginger and Sims Research conducted this study, and so I can send that to you if you
want to look at it. I'm happy to send this entire slide deck to you if you want to get this breakdown
and see all the information in it, but they are based off of 2023 numbers. That was the most
recent number that they could use, but really, it's not that far off from what we could expect
in 24 or 25. It was a pretty stable year post-COVID and the overall market slowing down, so looking at
these numbers, I would expect that they would be similar in the subsequent years, so it's a pretty
good measure of where we're at big picture in the vacation rental market and the overall impact that
has in the state, so big picture, the role that it plays in Hawaii's economy, big, big bucks, right?
There's 20 billion dollars in overall visitor spending. It's about 17 percent of the state's GDP
is based off of income that comes from the vacation rental market, and the total economic
impact is 23 percent, so obviously, the economic impact is bigger because it's not always direct.
There's some indirect impacts that vacation rental spending has on the economy, but very, very big
numbers and significant amounts of money are being contributed to the state. If we look at how much
of a market segment it is, and this is important to understand because we are such a visitor-heavy
industry and economy here, is that nearly one-third of all visitor days in Hawaii were spent in a
vacation rental, so about 30 percent of days that visitors spend here in the islands are done in a
vacation rental, and just on Hawaii Island, it's actually more significant, so 43 percent of the
days that visitors come and spend here are not in a hotel room, they're in a vacation rental, so
almost half of the time that vacationers spend here in a short-term vacation rental is done
in an STBR, so pretty significant overall, and statewide, visitors spend about 6.1 billion dollars,
and it's a critical economic driver in the state of Hawaii. If we look and we want to break down,
if you're wondering, like, what do people spend money on, this is a quick breakdown. It's interesting,
lodging obviously would be the biggest one, 2.9 billion, so almost 3 billion, food is 1.27 billion,
and then transportation is 0.7 billion, so about 700 million, entertainment is 570 million,
and then shopping is another 500 million, so that's the quick breakdown of where the spending goes
in the economy, and so this I thought was very, very interesting, and I hope you can see
islands here on the side, but when you break it out by island, I was surprised that Maui actually
has the most economic impact for a short-term vacation rental, so if you look in Maui,
there was 2.2 billion dollars spent there. The economic impact in Oahu is 1.6 billion,
the economic impact on Hawaii Island is 1.3, and then Kauai is only 1 billion, but what's
interesting is Kauai is about 30 percent the population of Hawaii Island and Maui, and so it's
a much smaller island, but the amount of impact that the short-term rental market has is pretty
significant there, 1 billion versus, it's just 300 million more on the big island where we have
three times as many people here, and if you look, it's over double on Maui, so very, very significant
amount of spending on the neighbor islands, Oahu, 900,000 people there, 1.6 billion,
it's not as big of an issue there, and they have a lot more resorts on Oahu, there's a lot more
hotel rooms on Oahu than we have on the neighbor islands, and so that's why a lot more spending
happens in the short-term vacation rental market, because we just have less inventory of places to
stay on the neighbor islands, because we don't have as many resorts. Okay, moving on to the overall
economic impact for, just specifically, this is the island of Hawaii, so like we said before,
1.3 billion in direct visitor spending, 2.4 in total economic activity on the island, 14,200
jobs are supported by the short-term visitor industry, and then 24.8 million is the amount
of county tax revenue generated directly from visitor spending, that's our general excise tax,
our transient accommodation tax, and then other short-term rental activities, so really, really
significant overall amount of money being spent here on the big island from the short-term vacation
rental market, and then this breaks down spending just for the big island specifically, so 590
million on lodging, 276 million on food and beverage, 207 million in transportation, 126 million
in entertainment industry, and then 93 million in shopping, so that further breaks down the total
spending here on the big island. If you're looking to relocate here on the big island, I want to share
with you a resource that we put together, over 80 agents from my team, expert agents here on the big
island, put together a relocation guide that will help you evaluate all of the important factors
that you want to take into account before you move here to the big island, school districts,
health care, employment, all of the things that you got to think about, we put into one homebuyer's
guide that will help you figure out what is best when you start this relocation process here to the
big island, so if you want this guide, just click on the link below, fill out the form, we will send you
the guide for free, and if you want to take the next steps and have a conversation with us, we'd
be happy to help. And so on the big island, when we look at that tax contribution, right, that overall
24 million dollars in taxes that are collected, 17 million of it comes from the county
transit accommodation tax, and then 7.1 million comes from the county general excise tax, so those
are the two main sources of income, and that's one thing that all short-term vacation rentals have to
do, is they have to pay these two additional taxes, these taxes are directly passed on to the visitor,
so visitors are normally, this is part of the bill when you get your airbnb bill, these taxes will be
added on to it, but this is definitely directly coming from visitors that are staying in short-term
rentals. And then overall supply here on the big island, this is interesting because we're going to
do a video next week about the updates to the regulations here on the big island for short-term
vacation rentals, and right now there are 8,300 total estimated short-term rentals in 2023,
the licensed ones are only 4,842, so there's about 3,400 unlicensed short-term rentals on the island,
and these are ones that are hosted, which is the regulation that is currently going to go
into effect, and I want to do a whole entire video on that next week about that new regulation, and
all the additions, and the process of getting a license, and what are the regulations, and all
those things, so we'll break that down further, but pretty significant amounts of current rentals
are currently unlicensed, and will need to be based on the new regulation. And then this is
what's being proposed, what I just talked about, is they want to further restrict vacation rentals,
and require licensing for hosted rentals, so rentals that have the owner living on the
property, or a host living on the property, and again we'll break that down in general
next week, or in specifically next week, so you'll have all the details on that.
And this is the big takeaway from all of this, right, is what is it going to be the impact
if you reduce the number of unlicensed short-term rentals, and that's what the study was all about,
is what kind of impact are we going to have if we reduce the number of short-term rentals,
and if there's a 50% reduction, they're estimating that visitor spending will drop by 271 million,
economic activity will drop by 507 million, tax revenue will drop by 5.2 million, and there will
be 3,000 jobs lost across all the sectors. If that's just a 50% reduction in the amount of
currently unlicensed short-term rentals, if those are wiped out and taken away, and then of course
you can basically double those numbers if you do a 100% reduction, where you ban all of those
current hosted rentals from operating, really significant, 10 million dollars in tax revenue,
6,000 jobs lost, so really significant impact on the island in an economy that's pretty small,
right, this is all a very significant amount of overall spending and contribution to our economy.
And so last thing here is just occupancy and the market resilience, so the occupancy rate for in
2024 was 47%, so about 50% was the occupancy rate, and you know we're seeing that definitely
because the economy is slower, there's less visitors, I mean that's pretty much in most
cases when investors buying a rental, what they can expect in general in terms of occupancy rate,
we have high seasons and low seasons, but in general about 50% occupancy is a good number
to use to estimate what your revenues are going to be based on your nightly rents. And so the
big key takeaways here is obviously vacation rentals play a really critical role overall
in all of the islands, but definitely here on the big island, there's a huge amount of tax revenue,
right, 28 million dollars in tax revenue, it's contributed to the county every year
from vacation rentals, there's always a regulatory risk, so the hardest part about all of these
discussions is how do you enforce it, is there going to be a new vacation rental police department
that is going to go out there and police these things, and I'm actually going to go through
some of the things next week in detail about how they plan to do that, because I think there is
some innovative solutions that are smarter than I've seen in the past be proposed, and of course
you always need a balanced approach with these things, I mean a lot of folks voices on either
side are very black and white, we should allow all vacation rentals or we should ban all vacation
rentals, but at the end of the day there has to be a balanced approach and understand that there is
some economic benefit and balance that with the needs of communities, the needs of neighborhoods
who weren't designed to have vacation rental activity in them, and it's much more complicated
than I think a lot of folks make it out to be, but as always with all difficult problems there
are complicated solutions and this discussion continues to go forward, but understanding what
is at play here is really really important, that's why I wanted to break down all the significant
specific economic impact that vacation rentals have here on the islands, so as always thanks
for watching you guys, if you have any questions about this you can always follow me at Kona Broker
on Instagram, lots of information updates there always in addition to YouTube, and then you can
or I always have a link in the description below to book a meeting with me, we have agents all
across the entire state of Hawaii that are experts in their markets, so if you're looking specifically
on another island not necessarily the big island, we can connect you with somebody who is very very
familiar and understands the regulations in that market and help guide you in the right direction
to make sure you're making a good decision, but as always thank you guys for watching and I'll see
you guys next week, aloha!