1980 Tour de France Winning Bike vs Modern Road Bike

BICYBLE SHOW
111 followers
This is a TI Raleigh, a very pretty and very limited edition of the bike that Joep Settermelk
won the 1980 Tour de France on. And this is a 2025 Trek Madone. It is the epitome of a modern race
bike. It has carbon fibre tubes, it's got carbon fibre wheels, it's got disc brakes and gears that
go beep boop. But how do two bikes that are 45 years apart actually feel to ride? Well, thanks
to Favero's new Asioma Pro RS pedals, we're going to find out. Looking at these two bikes, and they
couldn't be further apart, disc brakes have replaced these fan favourite rim squeezing
contraptions, the tyres have absolutely ballooned, the gears now require electricity to operate,
and modern bikes seem to sometimes have extra holes. Somehow, up until now, I have managed to
evade ever riding a bike with down tube shifters. Today, we're going to change all of that.
To find out the difference between the two bikes, we're going to be subjecting them to a series
of tests. First of all, we're going to do a flat test riding at a set power output.
Then we've got a hill climb test, and then finally, a sprint test to see how both bikes behave.
First of all, though, got to get these Favero power pedals on. I think probably the pedal threads are
the only standard which hasn't actually changed in the last 45 years. To make matters even easier,
all of the technical stuff is inside the pedal axles. The batteries, the strain gauges,
the gyroscopes is all in this stainless steel axle. That's really good because it means there's
not pods to knock or damage. I'm quite clumsy, so it's nice that everything's housed inside there.
There's also the added benefit, because they're pedal-based, you can fit them to one bike on one
day of the week. If you're lucky enough to have a second bike, you can swap them over at the weekend
and get your power data on that as well. Also, because I already use Shimano cleats,
I won't need to change those over. These new pedals are 100% Shimano compatible.
We've just discovered that we've got a hack putting on pedals. Cameraman Ed has apparently
wasted many hours not doing this. If you just do the first few threads and then hold the axle
and just wind the pedals backwards, it's done up. Then you get your pedal spanner,
do the final bit. There you go, hack. It is time for our first test. I have a feeling
that this one is going to be my favorite because it's flat. The aim of the game here is to ride
at a set power output for the lap, and then we'll get back, see which one's fastest,
and if there's any meaningful differences between the two bikes. As with any real-world testing,
you do need to take the results with a little bit of a pinch of salt because it's not a wind tunnel.
I still haven't got one of those. We have done everything in our power to make it a fair test.
We've chosen quite a still day. We've chosen traffic-free roads, so there's nothing to
pull us along or hold us up. We're going to obviously be using the Ferraro power pedals
to measure our power to plus or minus 1% accuracy. Enough procrastinating, let's get going.
The course for our flat test was a 10-kilometer loop, not planned flat, but about as flat as most
real-life rides get. As you can see from the numbers from the Ferraro power pedals,
I managed to get pretty close to my 250-watt target on both efforts. On the rally, I finished
the loop with a time of 17 and a half minutes, and on the track, I was 26 seconds faster.
Now, it should be said that this difference probably wasn't all down to the aerodynamics
of the bikes. I definitely felt more confident when cornering on the modern bike, probably in
part because that's what I'm used to. If we wanted to ride the rally at the same speed, i.e. about a
kilometer per hour faster, then it would require about 15 to 20 watts more. Next up, hill climb
test, the all-important weigh-in. There's three things that are going to make the difference when
riding up a hill. A, the stiffness of the bike and how that translates the power onto the road. B,
the rolling resistance of the tires, and C, the bike weight. I've got to hold the boot up,
so I now can't see where it weighs. 9.8. 9.8. What did I guess? 9.8. 9.8. Although, we do have to
take the weight of the pedals off of this one, but they claim to be the lightest power meter
pedals in the world, 123.5 grams per pedal, which is pretty impressive. We are going to validate
that. We're going to put them on a set of scales. We're going to use Ed's drug scales to give them
away. We'll validate that claim. Time to get the track on it. My drug scales.
Right, the track, it should be lighter. It's not the lightest Madone build, but this Madone
is a lot lighter than the previous generation Madone, which was full on aero. The wheels aren't
the lightest, 105 Di2, also got a bit more weight over Ultegra or Dura-Ace. I'm going to guess,
what did I guess for this one? 8.6. I've got to hold the boot up, but less.
8.45. 8.45. Well done, truck. You've outdone yourself.
To find out if this weight-saving makes a difference, I'm going to need to go and ride
up a hill. Right. Yes, well, it's time for a hill climb test. Ed's chosen me that.
Well, that wasn't very friendly. That tractor can't even get up it. I've got to get up on this.
Let's go. Christ, that's a long hill. How was that? It'll quite fit in the 80s.
You're such an ass. You could have picked so many nicer hills, but we've got time.
I don't know if back in the day, if they have different shaped hands.
His flat test in the drops are absolutely fine. Up here, it's just these bits getting in the way,
which is rather annoying. Yes, so it wasn't the most comfortable experience. Gears,
I was actually really impressed with how well they work. They're indexed beautifully. You can feel
each gear. That is absolutely lovely, but I could have done with a few more up there. I was out the
saddle for most of it. Right, back down. Got to do it all over again, don't I? Let's get these
swapped over. Yes, Trek has most definitely taken on the one bike, one race bike to do it all
concept. They used to have the Madone, which was their aero bike, and then the Emonda,
which was their climbing bike. This latest one is designed to do both. It's got much skinnier
tubes than the old aero one, much more Emonda like, but it supposedly is as aero, although that
was with a set of aero bottle cages fitted. Let me know what you think of this paint job. I don't
know about it. I do rate that Trek has made the logo a lot smaller, but let me know in the
comments below. Whilst you're there, make sure you subscribe to the channel. The hill climb that Ed
chose me was near enough one kilometer long at an average gradient of 10%, but the times were really
rather close. On the rally, I set a time of three minutes and 27 seconds, but despite being lighter,
I was only two seconds faster on the Madone. In fairness, though, that was at a lower wattage,
and I think the downside of all that gear range is that I probably wasn't forced to push myself
as hard. That, and maybe there was some fatigue in the legs by this time in the day. Looking at
the data from the Pro RS pedals, and we can see that my average cadence on the retro bike
was eight RPM slower for the effort than on the modern bike, by no means an insignificant
difference. I don't know about easier, definitely different. This bike is a lot smoother,
which you wouldn't think you'd feel that much at low speeds. You can just apply that power,
just that little bit smoother. Also, I changed gear a lot more on that one,
just because it was easier. There's also more gears. Not only is this 12-speed,
so more quantity of gears, but also more range of those gears. Also, I think because of that
smoothness and the gearing, I did a lot more of that sat down. I think that this one probably
was quicker, and not because it's slightly lighter. Now, I think this test really does
highlight the benefit of using a pedal-based power meter over a crank-based or spider-based
version, because we can fit it to basically any bike. It doesn't matter if it's a bike that's
getting on a bit, like this one. You can use them on a new bike. Because the pedal bodies are
actually removable with an Allen key, you don't even need any proprietary tools. You can swap
them out for the Pro-MX SPD pedal bodies. That means that you could use them on your mountain
bike or gravel bike. For our test, we're using the dual-sided version, which cost this much,
but there is also a single-sided version, which cost this much. You can also upgrade from the
single-sided to the double-sided version for this much. I didn't know you were going to do that.
I didn't know I was going to do that. If that sounds tempting, then we'll pop a link in the
description below. The other really good thing about these pedals is it's not going to change
how either bike rides. That's because it's got a really low stack height. That's the distance
between the pedal axle and your cleat. That's 10.5 mil, which is really rather low for a power
pedal. Also, the Q factor, that's how far away my feet are from the crank arm. It's the same as on a
standard SPD SL pedal, so 53 mil. It's not going to affect how either bike rides because I want to
ride this in all of its glory. For my final, very scientific test, I'm going to be sprinting on both
bikes. Now, this one is less scientific because we're not going to be measuring how much power
gets put through the frames or anything. I literally just wanted to see what it was like
to sprint on a bike from the 80s. I think this might be where we feel the biggest difference
because there's obviously a huge difference in materials. The new bike is composites, everything.
It's got carbon fiber handlebars, carbon fiber frame, carbon fiber wheels. This one, I'm pretty
sure, well, it was state-of-the-art in the day, but it's got Reynolds 753 tubing, which is obviously
steel. Back in the day, it was very special because they managed to make the tubes so thin
that they then had to solder it with silver solder so they could do it at a lower temperature as to
not damage the walls. I think the only bit of composite on this bike is the lightweight pedal
bodies of the Favaro paddles. Yes, there's quite a difference there. Let's see how it handles.
I mean, it's a bucket list item ticked off. It was a bit nerve-wracking because I really didn't
want to crash on this lovely bike. I think one thing that's weird is the gears. I think it's
just a case of getting used to them, to be honest, because obviously, well, A, you can't change gear
whilst on the hoods or drops. There's no sprint shifters either. I have them on my bike. None of
that. Yes, it's just like, am I in that gear? Am I half in between it? Then you get out. To sprint,
it actually felt pretty good. I can only imagine what it would have felt like in a mass bunch sprint
with everyone playing with their gears and stuff like that. It would have been cool. Yes, I'll
stick to my bike for sprints for now. Right, sprint number two. It should be a lot more
like what I'm used to. Let's go.
It's amazing how a bike can be both stiffer and more compliant, isn't it? I've never really
got my head around that, but it is a thing. The bottom bracket does feel like it translates that
power a bit better, but then you sit back down, you don't feel all those road vibrations
through both your bum and through your hands. I must admit, I'm getting on with this cockpit
much better. That's the main change that feels different to ride both bikes. The bars on the
Raleigh are just so skinny, whereas these are really quite chunky. I find the hoods much more
comfortable, obviously. That doesn't matter so much while sprinting. It wasn't all in favor of
this one though. The Raleigh is just so much more involving to ride. It feels like a bit of an
event, whether that's a sprint or just riding it. If I could choose one bike to go and ride
to the cafe on a Sunday, I think it would have to be the Raleigh. It feels like an adventure
going out on a ride. It feels like you have to do something, whereas on this, you just sit there.
Does that make sense? How much difference have the last 45 years or so made? Well,
if you look at the results from the power pedals, then potentially less than you might think.
You see, the thing is, even with bikes that are decades apart, there couldn't be more difference
in their frame construction and in their componentry and wheels. Yet, the difference
is still mainly made by the rider. That shouldn't really be any big surprise.
80% of your air resistance comes from your body and not from the bike. I've been dropped by many
people on much worse bikes than me because they've just got stronger legs or bigger lungs. I don't
know what it is, but they're just much stronger. If you want to get faster on the bike, probably
just do some more training rather than buy a new bike. Don't worry, the last 40 years or so
haven't been a complete waste of time. The Trek was so much more comfortable. I think that's true
of if we'd chosen any modern race bike, it would be so much more comfortable than this TI Raleigh.
No doubt, the frame material comes into that, but I think in main, that is down to the tires.
The Trek's got 28 mil tires on it. Our TI Raleigh's got 23 mil tires on it. That was actually
fairly large for the time. The other thing is that you can get on the Trek and thanks to its
geometry and the geometry of a lot of modern race bikes, you can just get on it and you can
ride to your potential. You can get on it and you can do a sprint. You can get on it and
smash it up a hill as hard as you can without having to worry about anything else.
They're very pretty, this gear set, but downtube shifters, they look cool and they're definitely
of their time, but for actually riding a bike, I don't think anyone will argue that they actually
function better. You can argue with me in the comments below, but keeping your hands on the
bars with the STI shifters, just so much nicer. I think that's what it comes down to, the geometry,
the frame materials, that is where the evolution has been. Yes, it is probably a bit faster. It
was a little bit faster in our testing, but the biggest difference was its comfort and its ease
of use. There you go, there's some progress. Let me know which of these two bikes you would
choose to have in your garage down in the comments below. If you want to find out any
more details or get yourself a set of those Fevero pedals, then we'll pop a link in the
description. Make sure you subscribe to the channel, give this video a like, and we'll see
you next time.
