As First Lady during her husband Benjamin Harrison’s presidency, Caroline Harrison quietly transformed the White House—and helped reshape the role of women in public life. A trained musician and accomplished artist, she became the first First Lady to oversee a full renovation of the White House, laying the groundwork for the East and West Wings and founding what would become the White House China Collection. But her influence went far beyond the walls of the Executive Mansion. Caroline was a founding member and first President General of the Daughters of the American Revolution, and she championed women’s education and professional advancement. She helped push Johns Hopkins to admit female medical students, brought cultural education to cabinet wives, and advised her husband on policy. Though often unfavorably compared to her more outgoing predecessor, Caroline Harrison left behind a lasting legacy—one grounded in grace, dedication, and the belief that women’s contributions, past and present, deserved to be honored.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
As the wife of the President, the First Lady has an important job. She must, first and foremost,
serve as the helpmate and confidant, sometimes even political advisor, to the President,
especially when the First Lady is the President's wife. She must also serve as the hostess for
White House events. Another duty which the First Lady must perform is to maintain and often renovate
the White House. Today, we're going to talk about the first First Lady who completed all renovations
on the White House during her husband's single term in office. The 23rd President of the United
States was Benjamin Harrison. He served between the two terms of Grover Cleveland. His wife was
Caroline Lavinia Scott, known to her family as Carrie. She was the daughter of a Presbyterian
minister in Ohio who also was one of the founders of the Farmers College near Cincinnati. Her father
was a teacher at the Miami University in Ohio before being fired from there for his strong
abolitionist views. At this point, he and his family moved and he helped found the Farmers College.
He and his wife believed in the education of women, so his daughters had a very good education,
learning not only the core literary and educational subjects but also foreign languages
such as French and music. Music became quite a passion of Caroline's and she ended up going to
the Oxford Women's College, graduating in 1852 with a degree in music. It was when her father was
teaching at the Farmers College that she met her future husband, Benjamin Harrison. Just a year
older than she, who was studying there. They began a courtship, some of which was rather secretive,
since they would go out in carriage rides and sleigh rides, sometimes without telling her family,
and they'd even go out dancing, which her family thought was quite sinful because they were very
conservative Presbyterian Christians. Although she remained a very devout lifelong Presbyterian,
it seems that she never quite agreed with her parents on the subject of the immorality of
dancing, because years later she would re-institute the practice of having dances at the White House,
something which went back and forth over the years, with some first ladies being very much for it and
others finding it quite scandalous and barring it. They were wed in the year 1853, after a rather long
courtship. They were going to wait a little bit longer, perhaps for Benjamin to finish his law
education, but shortly after she graduated in the year 1852, Caroline had begun teaching. She was
teaching in Kentucky, under another very important music teacher, and it seems that this teacher
worked her very hard, so she began to suffer from poor health. Perhaps to rescue her from this fate,
they made their marriage happen sooner than was originally planned. Her father presided over the
Of course, that wasn't the end of Caroline's music. She continued teaching and studying her own music
as well. Throughout the course of their marriage, she also engaged in other artistic pursuits, such
as painting and pottery. She even made fine china and porcelain works. In the early years of their
marriage, Caroline suffered from loneliness and depression, because her husband was often away.
First with his law studies, then his legal practice, his political career, and serving
in the Civil War. They each were very busy in their individual lives. During the Civil War,
she worked with many charities and helped raise money. She would go to visit him in the front lines
and tend to soldiers and mend uniforms, as well as organizing ladies groups back home. They had
three children during the course of their marriage. A son, a daughter, and another daughter who died
as an infant. But their first two children grew up and had long lives. In addition to keeping
house, pursuing her art and being very involved in social events and charity work was extremely
important to Caroline. She founded women's clubs, she was active in her church, and she was one of
the founding members of the Daughters of the American Revolution, a very active group which
is still in existence today. At the time of their formation, this group, which was a women's club of
sorts, sought to maintain and preserve the history of the role which women had played in the founding
of the nation and its preservation. Having the First Lady as an important member of this group
gave it prominence, and she was its first President General. In fact, she gave a speech at the Daughters
of the American Revolution, which was the first widely publicized speech written and delivered
by a First Lady. Caroline acted as a hostess politically for her husband when he was in the
Senate, and then when he was running for the office of President, she helped him with his
front porch campaign, entertaining people as they would come to visit their hometown and even
visit their personal home. Once he was elected to the White House, however, Caroline wasn't that
interested in performing the hostess duties. She wasn't a recluse like many First Ladies, nor was
she an invalid who wanted to remain only in her quarters. She wanted to be involved in charity work.
She especially enjoyed the prominence which the position gave her charity work,
and she was very influential in encouraging more education for women and increased women's rights.
She was a strong supporter of women's rights and the suffrage movement. Whether she was actually
in favor of women's right to vote remains unclear. Perhaps she was simply interested in increased
education and job opportunities, but she may have been an actual suffragist. It was with her
encouragement that her husband appointed the first female member of the White House staff, who would
be a secretary there. She and other women whom she organized donated a significant amount to John
Hopkins University with the condition that they would begin admitting female students. This set
quite a precedent and this encouraged many other colleges to begin admitting female medical
students. Now, there already were some female doctors because a few presidencies earlier,
James Garfield's wife had a female physician. She also encouraged the education and cultural
improvement of other women in Washington, such as cabinet wives, organizing classes and lessons at
the White House, such as instruction in French and pottery and other art classes. As head of the
White House household, Caroline had to oversee a huge family. Not just herself and her husband,
but also their two grown children, their families, her own father, her sister, and her sister's
daughter, who was a widow. Because Caroline wasn't too keen on hosting White House events herself,
she heavily relied on her daughter, Mary, and her niece, who was also named Mary. They were only
three weeks apart in age. She encouraged a good reputation for her husband through this
grandmotherly image, which she presented. Whenever someone would write to her saying that
they had named their child after her husband, she would mail them a milk set made out of ceramics,
which she had made herself. She also would send out photographs of her beloved grandson,
which helped popularize the family. One of the most important contributions which Caroline
made, which has continued, was renovating the White House. She asked for a very large sum of
money from Congress to renovate the White House because she was very distressed to realize that
there really wasn't a very private living quarters for the first family. Her husband
also commented on the fact that a door directly leads from the presidential office into the
sleeping chambers. All other politicians get to have a separate house, but the president has to
work basically in his home. She wasn't able to convince Congress to give them enough money
to completely renovate it and give them entirely separate living quarters, but she did get a large
sum of money and successfully renovated the whole White House, making her the first First Lady to do
so. She also put some good ideas into place, which continued after that. For one thing, she began to
preserve the furniture. She brought down a lot of china from past presidencies out of the attic
and started chronicling it, and she commissioned a new set of china for her husband's presidency.
This was the beginning of the White House china collection. She and her husband cataloged all the
historic furniture that was in the White House for its preservation. Before that, it was common
practice to sell off the furniture at the end of each presidency, many pieces of it, and that's why
basically each First Lady had to redecorate the White House. I often wondered, reading about
how each First Lady needed all this money to redecorate. Did the furniture not exist? Apparently
not, because they sold off most of it. But she saw that it would be worthwhile to preserve this
furniture, so that was something beneficial which she did. She also helped modernize it. She installed
some new bathrooms. She ripped up a lot of the old floorboards that were decaying from rot, replaced
wooden bathtubs with iron ones. She renovated the greenhouse, and she made the plans that would
become the modern East Wing and West Wing, such as are in place today. She also consulted with
Thomas Edison about installing electric lighting in the White House, and apparently this was done,
although they never used it during their time in the White House, because they were afraid of
electrocution, and I think Edison said that it was a little too dangerous to use, but it was a step toward
that modernization of the White House. While she was in the White House, that was the first time
that a Christmas tree was in the White House. She eliminated the practice of a long line of
hand shakers at White House events, which was something which would be continued. However, her
lack of wanting to engage with people and having really active social events led to a lack of
popularity for Caroline, and she began to be rather unfavorably compared with her predecessor,
the much younger and much friendlier Francis Cleveland. During her time in the White House,
she became ill with tuberculosis. She went away to a cabin in the Adirondacks to recover, but it
wasn't long before she realized that her tuberculosis was terminal, so she returned to the White House
to spend her last days. The strain of this condition was exacerbated by the fact that rumors
were circulating around this time that her husband was having an affair with her niece, Mary, who was
also acting as the interim First Lady. There's no real proof whether or not this is true, and it seems
rather unlikely that right there in the White House, where everybody was living there, that
they would have been doing such a thing. Perhaps she became a little too friendly with him. It's not
known whether that's actually true or even whether she actually suspected her husband, but it added
to her mental strain for people to be rumoring such things. Maybe it even contributed to the fact
that he didn't win that election. Sadly, she ended up dying two weeks before the 1892 election, which
her husband did not win. So her daughter, Mary, who was often known as Mamie, served as the official First
Lady for the remainder of her father's presidency. This was very unpopular with the Second Lady, the
wife of the Vice President, and the wife of the Secretary of State, both of whom thought that they
should act as the acting First Lady after Caroline's death. This was quite ridiculous on their part,
because Mary, also known as Mamie, had been serving as the First Lady and the hostess
throughout the presidency, as had her cousin, the niece, also named Mary, and it was very common
practice up to that point for daughters to serve as the First Lady when their mothers were unable
to do so. Several years later, after leaving the White House, Benjamin Harrison ended up marrying
the niece, with whom he had been rumored to have an affair years earlier, which perhaps gives a
little bit of credibility to the earlier rumors. His son and daughter were both appalled at this
fact because she was younger than both of them, and they did not attend the wedding. He died only
four years after their marriage of pneumonia, having had one daughter with her. Caroline's
lack of femininity. She wasn't a feminist like Rose Cleveland, the sister and acting First Lady
under Grover Cleveland, because she was a very old-fashioned woman in many ways, still being a
very devoted mother, grandmother, wife, etc. She was a devoted companion to her husband, a close
political advisor, and a great confidant to him. I think rather than a feminist who would say women
weren't honored in society and was bitter, perhaps, in fighting for really abandoning the more
traditional gender roles, Caroline was seeking more recognition for the roles women had already
played. As I pointed out, women already were doctors and they had served in important positions,
so I think that the goal of societies like Daughters of the American Revolution was not
necessarily to abolish the way things had always been in America, but rather to put a spotlight
on the important role which women have always played in the United States. And I think that
this series of looking closer at the First Ladies really shows that women were not downtrodden or
second citizens throughout the history of America. Women have always been a very important member of
society. Even in the centuries before they'd be granted the right to vote, they had many other
rights and important duties. There is a very memorable quote from that first speech which
Caroline Harrison gave at the Daughters of the American Revolution, and I think it summarizes
not only what she believed, but what the organization believed at the time of its founding.
She said, we have within ourselves the only element of destruction. Our foes are from within,
not without. It has been said that the men to make a country are made by self-denial,
and it is not true that the society, to live and grow and become what we would desire it to be,
must be composed of self-denying women. Our hope is in unity and self-sacrifice.
Since the society has been organized, and so much thought and reading directed to the early
struggle of this country, it has been made plain that much of its success was due to the character
of the women of that era. The unselfish part they acted constantly commends itself to our
admiration and example. If there is no abatement in this element of success in our ranks,
I feel sure their daughters can perpetuate a society worthy the cause and worthy of themselves.
She gave a great example of how a woman can be a good wife, mother, and grandmother, and also
play a very active role in her church, in society, and in social clubs for the increase in social
activities and the preservation of important activities in the United States. Thank you
for spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.