Keir Starmer on what he knew about Mandelson Epstein emails - full interview
Sep 16, 2025 #Keirstarmer #Politicians
People are baffled why you appointed Peter Mandelson in the first place to this job
when in essence all the facts that we now know we knew when you did the appointment.
It's just that there's been some sort of lurid headline-grabbing language that we've seen since.
Peter Mandelson, before he was appointed, went through a due diligence process.
That's the propriety and ethics team that went through a process and therefore
I knew of his association with Epstein. But had I known then what I know now,
I'd have never appointed him. Because what emerged last week were emails, Bloomberg emails,
which showed that the nature and extent of the relationship that Peter Mandelson had with Epstein
was far different to what I had understood to be the position when I appointed him,
on top of that what the email showed was he was not only questioning but wanting to challenge the
conviction of Epstein at the time. That for me went and cut across the whole approach that I've
taken on violence against women and girls for many years and this government's approach.
On top of that what emerged last week, on Wednesday evening late, were Peter Mandelson's
responses to questions that have been put to him by government officials. I looked at those
responses and I did not find them at all satisfying. You said that details emerged
Wednesday afternoon but from what we can work out, details were furnished to bits of the Whitehall
machinery, the Foreign Office and Downing Street, quite a bit ahead of you defending Peter Mandelson
on Wednesday at Prime Minister's questions and people are scratching their heads saying
why didn't you, the Prime Minister, make more effort to make sure you were briefed on this?
Were people briefing you properly? Were they acting on your behalf? Were they acting slightly
on Peter Mandelson's behalf maybe? It was only on Wednesday early evening that I knew the contents
of the Bloomberg emails. It was only very late on Wednesday when Peter Mandelson replied
to the questions that have been put to him by government officials and it was on that basis
that I took my decision that he should be removed. What I knew before PMQs was that there had been
media inquiries. I didn't know the content of the Bloomberg emails and I knew that questions
have been put to Peter that he had not yet answered. It's baffling to some people that
bits of the Whitehall machinery did seem to know stuff, you didn't. I mean some people are saying
that maybe you weren't well served by your officials but also maybe you were a bit incurious
what the Inland Revenue might call careless, to borrow another recent story. Let me go with that
because this is the American ambassador. It is a week at that stage before a state visit
and my approach is always that if an allegation is made, whether it's Peter Mandelson or anybody
else, it's important that it's put to the individual and their response is then considered
which is what I did. You were drawn a bit towards the status quo not least because of this state
visit just around the corner. You admit that it's slightly and with benefit of hindsight you would
like to have asked for these papers earlier, have them shown to you earlier because you say not
everybody had seen every email but people at the top of the Foreign Office were in possession of
some of the very material which you say was so unacceptable. Well look in retrospect it would
have been better if I had been shown the details of the material before PMQs. The bits that were
in Whitehall already? In retrospect it would have been better if I had seen that. You must have
the team were busy trying to get answers out of Peter Mandelson which they hadn't got answers to.
And you're sure they weren't just working as it were for Peter Mandelson trying to protect his
reputation a bit when they should have been protecting yours? I've seen the questions that
government officials put to Peter Mandelson. I've seen the response he gave to those. You
think he was obfuscating? Well what I'd just say about those questions they were the right questions
in my view and they were waiting for Peter to reply so they didn't know what his reply was
going to be any more than I did. But look if you're asking me now you know days on would it
be better if more of this material had been brought expressly to my attention then yes it would have
been. But I'm satisfied the team were doing what they could to get the answers out of Peter
Mandelson that they needed. There's no bad faith in number 10 at the moment? No the right questions
were asked. I then saw the answers to those questions and I wasn't satisfied with them.
You accept it was a risk a gamble appointing him in the first place? He's got a huge track record
of getting into trouble and you knew that it was a gamble? If I knew then what I know now I would
never have appointed him. Yeah but you knew a lot. Everybody knew a lot. He'd been through due
diligence and therefore I knew of the association and he'd expressed regret in relation to that.
And you knew he'd carried it on way after the conviction? We did know that. That was in the
public realm. The nature and extent of the relationship as I understood it then compared
with what was revealed in the Bloomberg emails which none of us had seen. There's a gulf between
the two situations which is why I can say to you very clearly today had I known that at the time
then there's no way I would have appointed him. Are you angry? I am angry. I don't particularly
think anger helps here but I feel let down. I feel that the process was gone through and now
information has come to light which had I known it at the time I wouldn't have appointed him.
Had I known the nature and extent of the relationship, the fact that he was questioning
and challenging the conviction. I've worked on violence against women and girls for many years.
I know exactly how all this affects victims. That was a factor I didn't know anything about
until Wednesday afternoon that he was encouraging the challenging of the conviction. That goes to
a different issue to the nature and extent of the relationship. On top of that that even on
Wednesday evening I wasn't getting through my officials from Peter Mandelson satisfactory
answers. So are you angry? Yes. You're angry with Peter Mandelson? I'm angry to have been put in
that position. So you're angry with Peter Mandelson. You're angry with some elements of the
system? I'm not angry with elements of the system. Are you angry with yourself at all?
Look, in retrospect of course I think it would have been better if the detail allegations that
have been made in relation to Peter had been put in front of me before PMQs. But the team were
trying to get answers out of him in relation to those questions and that was the right thing to
do. I've seen the questions. The questions that were being asked to Peter were the right questions.
This comes as you try to reset the government and as you know that probably contributes to your
anger because you had the reshuffle. You hoped to be talking about delivery the last two weeks.
You've been talking about everything but really. And that reset itself puzzles people because you
say you now have the right people in the right jobs. It doesn't speak very well of the preceding
months. The first year plus in office. If you've had to move them all around something wasn't
working. Whether it was in the Home Office or one of the other departments you've hollowed out
and changed. That would be an argument for never having a reshuffle. It's a giant reshuffle for
a new government. I said a big thank you to all those people who moved on from their post for
what they've done, the hard work that they've done in the first 14 months of this government.
We do go on to a new phase. We were fixing the foundations in the first phase. We're now moving
on to the delivery and showing what a difference a Labour government makes. Obviously the
resignation of Angela Rayner meant that I had to make some changes and I thought
it was therefore right to make the wider changes I did. But I want to be clear in relation to those
that served no longer serving. I have said thank you to them and I say thank you again.
But you know it is important I have the right people as we go forward to this next stage of
government. You've been very clear about the threat of reform. You want to do anything to
the threat of reform in this country. Would that include, if the party felt it was necessary,
stepping aside as leader? No because I'm absolutely clear what the task is in front of me.
We have a crossroads really in terms of the future of this country. We go forward with
Labour for national renewal, a patriotic call about this country and taking this country forward,
true patriotism. Or we have division and decline under reform and a country in which
people feel that they're not part of the country that we are, that is divisive. You saw this on
Saturday. Look what happened on our streets on Saturday. That wasn't just very bad behaviour
in central London, although it was that, assaulting police officers and the like,
that's plastic patriotism. It sent a shiver through so many of our communities who now feel
more scared than they did before. I understand that. I'm absolutely determined to lead in this
fight of our times between renewal, the patriotic cause of the Labour Party and the division and
toxic chaos and decline that would come under reform. You've been announcing just in the next
door room, a new investment on nuclear energy. Do you ever feel there you are doing all these,
as you would see it, long-term projects for growth and there's reform, as you would see it,
doing short-term gimmicky instant gratification announcements and you're kind of sometimes,
do you feel checkmated a bit? Well it's important that we do do the medium and long-term decision
making because my strong belief is over the last 15 years under the last government they didn't do
the medium and long-term decisions and therefore we didn't have a steady country, so we must
operate in that way. But yes, are we up against fake solutions and they are fake solutions from
reform that don't, that won't work, haven't been costed, can't be implemented, the easy answers
that will deliver nothing. Yes, we are up against that and that's why it's very important for me
and for you and everybody else to hold what reforms say up to the light because they are
fake solutions and they're fake, to peddle fake solutions to a worried public is about as
unpatriotic as you can get. You'll be announcing later today, by the time we're on air, it will
have been announced that RAF jets may be active in Polish airspace. People will be worried,
maybe want reassurance that there won't be direct involvement, the RAF shooting down Russian
jets, potentially, or unmanned drones. What can you say to reassure people about this deployment?
Well, you'll have seen the levels of concern last week when Russian drones carried out an attack in
Poland, unprecedented. As a result of that, NATO leaders have discussed what the appropriate
response should be. I spoke to both the President and the Prime Minister of Poland last week to
discuss this and today we've announced that we will deploy further air defence cover in Poland.
That is the right thing to do. The wrong thing to do would be to ignore this increased aggression
from Putin, from Russia, because this wasn't a one-off. You saw only a few weeks ago the
bombing of the British Council in Kiev, the attacking of the EU embassy and the direct
hits on the Council of Ministers in Kiev itself, central government in Kiev. So it's absolutely
clear that the Russians are upping the aggression. It's very important that with our NATO allies,
that we respond appropriately to that and that's what we're doing today.
Prime Minister, thank you for your time.
Thank you.

