Swords That Stunned Antiques Roadshow Experts!

Historical Heirlooms Hub
9 followers
Step into the world of blades, battles, and billion-dollar surprises! In this thrilling episode, we reveal the most legendary swords ever appraised on Antiques Roadshow — including one believed to have belonged to President George Washington. These iconic weapons aren’t just tools of war; they’re masterpieces of craftsmanship, steeped in history and heroism. Watch expert jaws drop as the values of these antique swords soar far beyond expectations. Don’t miss a second of these unforgettable finds!
#antiquesroadshow #swordcollection #historicswords #georgewashington #militaryweapons
A friend of mine back in the early 80s went back to Maryland to visit his family and while he was
there he went to an estate sale and he bought this and brought it back to Eugene and a couple years
later he found himself in a little bit of financial straits and so he offered to sell it to me and
I bought it from him and I've had it ever since. This sword may have started as a $500 estate sale
purchase but it holds a legacy etched in diamonds and royal history. He had no idea what he was
truly acquiring. Wrapped in silver, studded with rose-cut diamonds, and decorated with rich green
and blue enamel, the sword bore far more than craftsmanship. It carried a hidden imperial
connection. He did some early research on it and along with of course that was before internet.
Once we got internet we did a little more research on it and basically we we know that it's from
Nicholas II, the Tsar, the last Tsar of Russia, and we believe that it was one of his officers'
swords. We're not sure exactly. On the steel blade, the unmistakable monogram of Nicholas II,
the last Tsar of Russia, gleamed beneath a crown. Even more striking was the name Guzunov inscribed
on the reverse, identifying a known arms maker from the Caucasus region during the late 19th
century. Unlike typical military blades from that time, this piece was no simple weapon. It was a
luxurious ceremonial treasure, possibly crafted as a coronation gift or imperial presentation.
Now there's some condition issues as you see. The whole silver and enamel portion at this end
is missing and you've got a little damage to the end. Do you remember what you paid for it back in
the year? Well yes, I paid $500 when I bought it from him. I believe he told me he paid $300
for it when he first picked it up. It's a rare and unusual piece, and even in this condition,
that auction, a conservative price might be $75,000 to $100,000. Whoa, that's a shock to me.
I was thinking, you know, a couple of grand maybe, but whoa, that changes things.
From forgotten drawer to dazzling artifact, this blade turned out to be far more than decoration.
It's a rare survivor from the twilight of the Russian Empire.
I brought in a navy sword, a dress sword, and belonged to Commodore Morris, who was a distant
relative of mine. Morris went to sea at just 15, fighting pirates in the Barbary Wars and taking
command roles during the War of 1812. He served as first lieutenant aboard the USS Constitution
in its legendary battle against the HMS Guerriere, one of the most iconic ship duels in American
history. The sword itself is a rare gem, an 1852 U.S. naval officer's sword crafted by
Ames Manufacturing Company as part of the first production run of just 500. The sword is decorated
with the typical naval motifs. You've got the sea serpent on the quill and the USN and a ribbon on
the face of the guard. You've got the knots on the mounts, and you also have the sea serpent on the
drag. I love him. And on the reverse of the blade, we've got the etched USN and a ribbon, and we've
got the fouled anchor motif that is so associated with naval arms. While valuable on its own,
what elevates this piece far beyond most collectibles is the man who wielded it. At auction,
a similar sword might fetch $2,000 to $3,000, but because it belonged to Commodore Morris,
a man with 57 years of naval service and second highest ranking officer at the time of his death.
If this sword were to be offered in a retail setting, we think the asking price for the
be in the neighborhood of $25,000. Wow, that's amazing. We would probably insure it in the
neighborhood of $50,000 because it is absolutely irreplaceable. You could go find another first
contract 1852 naval officer's sword, but you couldn't find Commodore Morris's sword.
Gosh, that's really wonderful information. Handed down from father to son for generations,
this Confederate officer's sword once belonged to the guest's great-great-great-grandfather
and has hung on family walls since childhood. But this isn't just any sword, it's a rare and
sought-after piece made by William J. McElroy of Macon, Georgia, one of the South's most notable
wartime manufacturers. Known for his craftsmanship and bold branding, McElroy etched his name clearly
into the blade, leaving no doubt about its authenticity. This is his cavalry officer's
version of his sword. This is one of the rarest swords a sword collector could get.
We have a sand cast guard that has the floral patterns, which lets us know it's for an officer,
not an enlisted man. The enlisted man's version of this is just smooth all over.
On the handle, we have a wooden core, and then they put a high-quality leather over the top of
it, and they use a single strand of copper wire and wrap it around to hold everything together.
And then they join it all together with another sand cast pommel cap. The real showstopper is the
blade itself. Deep, dramatic etching with floral motifs and the crossed first national Confederate
flags that practically leap out under the light. And crucially, the original scabbard bears the
same etching, confirming its match and skyrocketing its rarity. This sword, because of condition and
all the aspects that we've talked about, if I were going to insure this sword, I would insure this
for $50,000. Oh, my Lord. I'm speechless. I had no clue that it would be anywhere near that. This
sword, if it didn't have that scabbard, would be around $20,000. The scabbard is the rare part.
I'm just shocked right now. I don't know what else to say.
These are from my great-grandfather, who was a captain for the Confederacy in the Civil War.
This is his sword. This is the sword of a captain from the Union side that he captured in the Battle
of Petersburg in 1864. This is one of the most powerful and humanizing collections ever brought
to the Antiques Roadshow. A pair of Civil War swords, the guest inherited this remarkable
archive from his great-grandfather, a Confederate captain who fought in the Battle of Petersburg
in 1864. During the clash, he was wounded by a musket ball that passed through his
captured Union adversary's sword and into his hand. Despite the brutality of the moment,
something extraordinary followed. The Union officer, the very man he had just disarmed,
helped clean and dress his wound, even asking for a bath before being escorted to a prison camp.
And they started talking, and the Michigan captain helped him clean his hand in that
wound. They went down to the river. The captain said, you know, I haven't taken a bath in a month,
and I know I'm going to go to this internment camp. And, you know, could I take a bath? He
said, sure, go ahead. They walked back to the lines. They had to spend the night before they
were taken to the internment camp, and they never thought they'd see each other again.
They both survived the war. My great-grandfather lived in North Carolina. He worked for the
railroad. He had a boarding house. He was, you know, telling the story one night with boarders
there, and the boarder said, I've heard that story, but from the other side, from the Union side.
So he wrote to the Detroit Free Press, the paper there in Michigan, and basically said,
dear captain, if you are here and you read this, I have your sword. I'd like to give it back to you.
Years later, by sheer chance, their paths crossed again, through a newspaper letter
in the Detroit Free Press. The Union captain replied with a touching note. He remembered the
wound, the kindness, and gave his blessing for the sword to remain with the Confederate captain's
family, as a trophy captured in a fair fight, and a symbol of mutual respect between men who fought
with conviction, yet found common ground after war. The archive includes both swords, a rare
New Orleans-made Confederate belt buckle, and letters beautifully transcribed by a descendant.
Together, they form not just a Civil War relic, but a tangible story of reconciliation,
of enemies who became friends, and a shared American legacy passed down generations.
A retail value for this group, as presented here today, would be between $20,000 and $25,000.
That's surprising, but great. I mean, we aren't looking, obviously, to part with it, but that's
good to know. We're calling our insurance person to make sure we can insure it. But its true worth
lies in the lesson it holds, that even in the darkest times, humanity can still shine through.
This Civil War presentation sword is far more than a finely crafted weapon.
It's a tribute from soldiers to a general they followed into some of the bloodiest battles in
American history, including the pivotal clash at Gettysburg. Brought in by the descendant of
General Stephen McGroarty, this breathtaking sword tells a story of grit, bravery, and devotion.
McGroarty, a native of Cincinnati, began his service in the 10th Ohio,
and was wounded so many times that he was eventually mustered out.
I've got a Civil War sword of my great-great-grandfather's,
and a picture of him in his uniform. Okay.
Was wounded so much he was sort of mustered out of service, and he came back as, eventually,
as the colonel of the 61st. Well, what you have here is a beautiful presentation sword
that was presented to him in honor of his service by his men. It's made by Klauberg
of Solingen, Germany. It was probably purchased from a high-end retailer like Skyler Hartley &
Graham in New York, or maybe even from Tiffany. As you can see, it's engraved with presentation
information on it. The scabbard and the hilt are enhanced with faux rubies. It's really probably
the highest-grade sword that Klauberg ever made. The blade is etched with floral designs,
military panoplies, and, most poignantly, a complete record of General McGroarty's battle
history, including the sacred name Gettysburg engraved right on the scabbard. Despite some
condition wear to the blade's brightness, the appraiser noted this is the kind of artifact
that commands respect among collectors. We know it's a Klauberg sword because we've got
the Klauberg maker's mark here on the ricasso. Okay. And like most presentation-grade swords,
it has an etched blade with floral patterns and a panoply of arms. But probably the nicest
feature of the sword is this beautiful Lady Liberty statue hilt. Absolutely gorgeous.
And I think, realistically, at auction, with all the history and with those magic words,
he was at Gettysburg. Yes. You've got a sword that's going to bring somewhere between $15,000
and $20,000. It's just a wonderful, wonderful piece, and it's fabulous that it stayed in the
family. Yes. This is not just a ceremonial sword. It's a royal-era treasure steeped in honor,
history, and exquisite craftsmanship. Brought in by a guest whose late husband inherited it
from his great-uncle, this English presentation sword from around 1805 is unlike any battlefield
relic. It doesn't look like something that you would... It doesn't look like a battlefield sword.
No. Have you done any research on it, or... I've tried to research it, and I could not
find a thing on it. But what do you know about, I mean... I believe it was made in London.
Just what the inscription says. That's basically all I know about it. Though family lore suggested
it may have come from Verdun, its pristine, elegant appearance made it clear to the appraiser
that this was a ceremonial weapon, not a combat tool. Crafted by Woolley, Dutton, Deakin,
and Johnson, renowned Birmingham-based swordsmiths of the early 19th century,
the sword features a blued and gilt blade, elaborately engraved with gold leaf and bearing
the royal cipher of King George III. But its most striking feature is the detailed
presentation inscription. Presented by the loyal Crayford volunteers to their much-esteemed
commandant, John Henry Taylor, Esquire, in testimony of their high sense of his attention
to the discipline and respectability of the Corps, 1805. From the engraved gilt brass mounts to the
original family coat of arms, every detail speaks to the sword's ceremonial importance
and aristocratic ownership. I think at auction,
conservatively, this would bring somewhere around $20,000 to $30,000.
Is that a good place to start? It's a good place to start, absolutely.
A remarkable sum for a sword that once symbolized honor and prestige
among Britain's loyal volunteer forces. I brought my great-great-grandfather's
Confederate sword. And how do we know it's his sword? Well, it's engraved, has his name on it.
We also know because it's been passed down through the family with the stories associated
with his having the sword. And also his beautiful wife, my great-great-grandmother,
wrote about the time he spent during the war in some of the fighting around the city of Mobile.
This sword isn't just a weapon. It's a Southern legacy, etched in steel by one of the finest
craftsmen of the Confederacy. This Confederate presentation sword comes with powerful family
provenance, complete with wartime stories passed down through generations. But the real surprise
came when the appraiser flipped the blade over and revealed the name Bissonnet, a master engraver
and jeweler from Mobile, Alabama, known for going above and beyond in a time of scarcity.
Where most Confederate blades were modest and rushed, this one is lavish. On the guard,
we have the standard cast brass guard with the floral design on it. But what's cool is if you
turn it just right, we have CS applied. They cast the guard and then hand applied those letters CS.
That's above and beyond in a war where necessity drove basically everything. Despite some condition
issues, including a missing section of the scabbard and light rusting at the blade's end,
the historical and artistic significance of this piece remains untarnished. This is a sword that
would insure for $30,000. Seriously? $30,000? Oh, wow. We need to... I've had it hidden in the attic.
I think I need to put it somewhere safer than that. I'd say. You brought in quite a collection
of swords, all related to one individual. Who is he to you? This is my great-grandfather,
Captain John Hetherington. He was a Berdan sharpshooter in the Civil War. This sword is
kind of the family legendary sword. He was wounded, and this is a picture of how he was
carrying the sword when he was struck by the bullet. All I was ever told was that this saved
his life. When the bullet hit his hand, a piece of the sword lodged in his hand, and that's why
he had to leave the army. And eventually it crippled his hand right up. The blade itself
took the hit, breaking apart and sending a fragment into his hand, an injury that ended
his military service and left his hand permanently crippled. That battle-worn sword, never drawn again,
became a family legend, a literal lifesaver forged in war. Alongside it are two other
swords from his service, a German-made foot officer's sword, the most affordable option
for a newly appointed officer, and a regulation-defying 1850 staff and field sword,
likely purchased privately despite not being standard issue. But this appraisal wasn't just
about swords. The guest also brought a cabinet card photograph of Hetherington in uniform
and a framed service record, rare documentation that ties the weapons to a specific name,
battle, and story. As we learn here, this sword is a lifesaver. On Jerusalem Plank Road at
Petersburg, he's carrying this sword, and we can see on the back end where the bullet has
actually wrecked the thing, and it probably never left the scabbard after that day. Absolutely
incredible stroke of good fortune. You've got the photograph, which puts it all in context,
and these three swords. If I was cataloging this for an auction, I would put an estimate
of $15,000 to $20,000. This sword came down through my family, from my father's family.
They were German. They lived in Missouri. He was 11 when he came from Germany with his family,
and in 1862, he joined the Union Army, 30th Missouri Infantry. And they were sent to Louisiana
and Mississippi, and so this was presented to him by his Louisiana friends as a token of their
esteem in 1864. The presentation inscription reads, Presented to Lieutenant Louis Beerwith
by his Louisiana friends as a token of their esteem, July of 1864. This sword is no ordinary
blade. It's a Civil War statue hilt presentation sword. Among the most elaborate types ever
commissioned during the war. The hilt is a literal sculpted figure with exceptional detail,
reflecting the highest levels of craftsmanship. The blade bears the name of Schuyler, Hartley,
and Graham, one of the premier military retailers of the 19th century, and likely German made,
just like Beerwith himself. Well, I was quite excited to see it, just to curtail our enthusiasm
over it. The condition issues like the missing sword that stems here, and the wear to the etching,
at auction, I would estimate that this sword would be worth $10,000 to $15,000.
And considerably more if it was in slightly better condition.
Thank you. So you have your research cut out for you to find out what he did for these people.
This is a sword that's been in my family, apparently for many years,
from my great-great-great-grand-uncle, something like that. Apparently was quite a proverbial hero
in several battles in the Civil War. With this Company C, that became the 48th Regiment,
I believe, in the Civil War. I think it was, the number was about 40 battles,
and then ended up sort of the last part of the Civil War with General Sherman in Atlanta.
Here's a story forged in fire, valor, and legacy. Tied to a single sword,
and a young Union officer who wouldn't back down. This ornate Union presentation dress,
sword, belonged to Colonel Greathouse of the 48th Illinois Infantry, a regiment that saw action in
around 40 battles during the Civil War, eventually joining General Sherman's march to Atlanta.
At just 22 years old, Greathouse was killed in combat.
Your ancestor fought for the 48th Illinois, and your ancestor uttered a rather famous quote that's
been preserved right before he was shot. Are you familiar with his quote?
To paraphrase, he was told by the rebels that, look, you're outnumbered, you're beaten,
and he basically said, beat hell, the fight has just begun.
Ah, that's great. This sword is a very high-grade presentation sword. It was a dress sword,
it wasn't a combat sword. The blade was made by Klauberg of Solingen, Germany, a top-tier
sword manufacturer, and features elaborate decorative elements, a silver-plated brass hilt,
garnet inlays, including one set in the eye of the dragon-shaped guard, and design motifs likely
copied from the elite American firms Schuyler, Hartley, and Graham. Though not their exact make,
it's a clear tribute to their elite craftsmanship. Sadly, time has taken its toll. The blade is
heavily rusted and pitted, with much of the original gold plating worn away due to moisture
and poor storage. But the historical weight and emotional resonance remain intact.
What kind of idea of value would you have on this? Oh man, I would have no idea, 500 bucks.
Well, you may be pleased to know that in its current condition, I would estimate a retail
value in the neighborhood of $12,000. Oh, wow. With a little bit of restoration, it can go even higher.
Wow, fantastic. The value of this sword goes far beyond money. It embodies sacrifice,
leadership, and an immortal defiance in the face of death. Passed down through six generations,
and still burning bright. Here's a sword that may have once caught the eye of George Washington
himself. A weapon steeped in the fire of the American Revolution, and the legacy of one of
its officers, Colonel Oliver Spencer. This elegant, silver-mounted dress sword, handed
down through generations of the guest's family, is believed to have been presented to Spencer
during his service under General Washington. His daughter, Sarah Bloomfield Spencer Evans,
moved to the Felicianas in the Spanish land grants in the early 1800s, and I've since
owned it down through the family. So who is Colonel Spencer? Colonel Oliver Spencer
was in the Revolutionary Army, serving under General George Washington. I was told that
this was presented to him as his dress sword. And how do we know it was presented by George
Washington? Just by my grandmother's tales. While there's no hard documentation linking
it directly to the general, Colonel Spencer's name is no footnote. He fought in key battles
such as Brandywine and Monmouth, and was a respected officer in the Continental Army.
The sword's styling, particularly the lion's head pommel with a flowing mane,
closely resembles the work of John Bailey, a New York silversmith active during the 1770s.
And here's the kicker. Bailey is the same craftsman known to have made swords for George
Washington himself, unlike mass-produced English blades, which would bear hallmarks.
This piece has no such marks, suggesting it's American made,
a rarity among surviving swords of the Revolution. From the style of the pommel here, it's a lion's
head, and it has a beautiful flowing mane. However, it would probably be very, very difficult
to prove any association between, other than the fact that he served under Washington,
to prove anything in terms of the gift. With no other provenance, I would say that it was
probably worth $5,000 to $7,000. But with the prominence of your ancestor, and the service
that he saw through the Revolutionary War, and that even though we don't have that association
with Washington, he was there, and we know who he was because it's been in your family ever since.
If I had this auction, I would easily put it at around $10,000 to $15,000.
Very nice. That's wonderful.
A Confederate officer's sword made by William J. McElroy of Macon, Georgia. One of the finest and
most artistic swordsmiths of the Confederate South. Known for vivid, crisp etching, and rich detail.
I brought what I believe is a Confederate sword. My grandfather said it's been passed
down from generation to generation, but I honestly think it's a replica. I don't know
if they want it at a state fair. You got one free when you buy a used car. I don't know, but
I'm here to see if it's authentic or not. What makes you think it's a replica?
It's this coloring to it. It doesn't seem to be right.
Well, that coloring is 150 years worth of beauty.
Etched into the blade was a name. J. Knight. John. A soldier of the 7th Mississippi Infantry Battalion,
also known as the Beauregard Defenders. This unit saw intense action, most notably at Vicksburg
and the Battle of Franklin, one of the war's fiercest engagements. Somehow, Knight survived
the entire war, returning home and living until 1893. Don't try to clean it because it's such a
beautiful sword. I love that patina. We have the original grip and wire. The scabbard was made of
leather and brass, and they break very easily, and that's why it's probably missing. Have you ever
thought about what the sword might be worth? No. Like I said, I thought it was fake.
Well, then the new should be very good. Okay. The sword today would retail for about $10,000.
Really? Wow. I'm glad I didn't try to recycle it or something.
Me too. I'd love to do what you said and trace their interactions.
You didn't know you were going to get homework today. No, I didn't. I appreciate it. Well,
this sword belongs to my grandfather's great-uncle, the Union Army officer in charge of the hospital
at Washington, D.C. Here's a story where quiet service and rare craftsmanship come together
in a single elegant artifact from the Civil War, a Model 1840 Union Medical Staff Officer's sword
brought to Antiques Roadshow by a guest whose ancestor once oversaw the Union Hospital in
Washington, D.C. At first glance, the sword doesn't scream, battle. Its design is slim,
ceremonial, and refined. But its meaning runs deep. It was carried by a medical officer,
a figure who stood in the shadows of the battlefield, trying to save lives amid chaos.
This particular example was crafted by Schuyler, Hartley, and Graham, one of the most prestigious
arms retailers of the 19th century. Known for supplying high-quality swords, their pieces
were often prized by officers and collectors alike. Accompanying the sword was its original
green sash, the official color for medical personnel in the Union Army.
Through these blades, we've witnessed the weight of war, the bonds of brotherhood,
and the stories etched not just in steel, but in memory. Each sword was more than a weapon.
It was a legacy, passed down, preserved, and now brought to light on the Antiques Roadshow stage.
From battlefield rescues to presentations of honor, from Confederate craftsmanship to Union
pride, these swords remind us of who we were and what we've carried forward. If these powerful
relics moved you, help share their stories, like, subscribe, and join us as we continue
uncovering the greatest treasures of the past.
