Carolingian and Ottonian Art | Art History | Otis College of Art and Design

Ancient Art
10 followers
52 Video Views·Sep 15, 2025
From the Caves to Romanticism, take a journey through centuries of art and learn about the role of art in culture and the place of the artist in society. This series of five-minute podcasts from Otis College of Art and Design features sumptuous images and informative texts.
Presented by Dr. Jeanne Willette, faculty at Otis College of Art and Design.
Welcome to a journey through the history of art.
We will travel along a timeline from the caves to the 19th century.
My name is Dr. Jean Ouellette.
Let's begin by making the familiar unfamiliar.
One of the themes of this series has been the extraordinary lengths
people will go to to make art.
How else do we explain the effort expanded on the pyramids,
the amazing precision of the Parthenon,
except to say that culture matters?
From the subsistence society of the people of the caves
to the artists who found themselves having to create
a new language for a new religion, Christianity.
We have already discussed how a new visual culture
based on a dehumanized version of classicism
evolved in the East and the South,
in Constantinople and Ravenna.
The transition of the classical language of pagans
into the spiritual cadences of the Christians
seems fairly straightforward.
But the situation in Northern and Western Europe
was more complicated,
for out here in modern day Britain, France, Germany
was the frontier of the Roman Empire.
The reluctant dissident savages
who shook off the thin veneer of civilization
and devolved into the dark ages
under the barbarians following the fall of Rome.
That said, Christianity had to penetrate and shed light
and spread the word of God to the heathens,
a task for art.
But the tradition of barbaric art
was inarticulate in its zoomorphic abstractions.
The great treasury of such and who was a case in point.
The barbaric style was small scale,
designed for ornament and decoration and portability,
but not for communication of ideas.
While we can see the relationship between barbarian art
and the manuscript illumination in Great Britain,
these magnificent designs are superb articulations
of spiritual intensity and religious belief
inscribed on the carpet pages,
protecting the word of God.
But as can be seen in the manuscripts,
when the human figure appears,
the simple representation of the body
was utterly alien to these Northern artists.
The problem was acute.
The gospels had to be used by missionaries
who needed to communicate Christian ideals
and spiritual doctrines,
only some of which lent themselves to symbolism.
It was under Charlemagne
that the Christians of Northern Europe
created a new figurative and articulate language
that could visualize the new religion
by combining the inherited tradition of barbarian art
with imported classicism.
The strategy conveyed vividly
in Charlemagne's palace chapel at Aachen or Aix-la-Chapelle
was appropriation and assimilation
of Italian or classical elements
to convey the Christian conquest of the pagans
while reviving the nostalgic memory of the Roman Empire.
As the first Holy Roman Emperor,
Charlemagne pulled together a mini empire
and dedicated his efforts
to educating himself and his subjects,
starting schools and monasteries
and importing monks to his palace
to copy ancient manuscripts
and to write and illustrate Bibles and gospels.
Combining a belated version of Roman painting
with abstract ornamentation,
the art of the Carolingian Renaissance
established an art of Christianity
for these new converts.
After the death of Charlemagne,
his empire eventually split
into what would be modern-day France and Germany.
On the German side, another empire arose,
copying not the Roman Empire
but the Holy Roman Revival Empire of Charlemagne.
This smaller empire was called the Ottonian Empire,
called so after a number of rulers named Otto
and a few Henrys.
The monks in the monasteries
and the nuns in the convents
remained the essential artists,
trained in the scriptoriums,
crafting a Christian language for the Christian faith,
a religion that has now created its own stories,
myths, legends, narratives of devotion.
Perhaps anachronistically,
the art of this Germanic empire
has been termed expressionistic,
but perhaps a better word would be expressive.
Abandoning the Carolingian attempt
to assimilate Roman illusionism,
the Ottonians created a flat frontal field
of frozen figures,
suspended in a time and space made of gold.
This linear and stylized art to the north
is not based on monumental art,
as are the mosaics of Ravenna,
but is the product of small-scale,
intricate ornamental barbarian art.
It has taken no less than 1,000 years
to create a Christian art form,
but as we head into the new millennium,
distinct differences between the art of the north
and the art of the south remains.
Southern art would be haunted
by the memory and loss of classical art,
while the visual culture of the north
developed undisturbed.
For hundreds of years,
these very different traditions
would be subsumed under the coming wave
of Romanesque and Gothic
architectural accomplishments.
But 500 years later,
the sleep of classicism
would be disturbed by yet another renaissance.
