Gianlorenzo Bernini and Michelangelo Mersi da Caravaggio are two of the biggest names in not only the Baroque era but in all of art history. But, sometimes, historians tend to overlook their personal lives. This video explores their complicated legacies as both artists and men.
TW: Discussions of violence. Please do not watch if you are uncomfortable!
Welcome to Accessible Art History! Here, we provide a space for art lovers, students, and anyone who is curious to explore all periods of art history and human creation.
Accessible Art History: The Podcast: Episode 21: The Calling of St Matthew by Caravaggio: https://youtu.be/4NNXYiHaMzo
Accessible Art History: The Podcast: Episode 23: The Abduction of Persephone by Gianlorenzo Bernini: https://youtu.be/ZLfb-JRzkDQ
Welcome back to the Accessible Art History YouTube channel.
Today's video is a little bit different than my regular content. I'm going to be talking about
a couple of bad boys from the Baroque period and their complicated legacies.
Often we glorify their art as works of genius, but forget that they often had less than stellar
reputations. This video isn't meant to disrespect their memory or their art, but to highlight that
things are a little bit different than we remember, and we shouldn't forget that.
This video will have discussions of violence, so if this is something that you are sensitive to,
please don't watch it. So without further ado, let's get started.
Gian Lorenzo Bernini is arguably the biggest name of the Baroquia. His work was beloved by kings,
popes, and the public. Many of his fountains, sculptures, and architectural elements still
grace the streets and museums of Rome. Bernini's ability to capture passion and drama is remarkable.
However, some of that passion did bleed into his personal life.
Her name was Constanza Bonarelli. She is the wife of Matteo Bonarelli,
one of Bernini's workshop employees. The two had a passionate affair until Bernini discovered that
she was also having an affair with his brother, Luigi. One day, Bernini burst into his brother's
apartments, finding the couple in a state of undress. Enraged, he took an iron bar and attempted
to beat his brother to death. Thankfully for Luigi, he only suffered a couple of broken ribs
before he was able to run into the church of Santa Maria Maggiore and was then under the
protection of sanctuary. But Gian Lorenzo couldn't let the slight stand. He sent a servant to
Constanza's house and instructed him to slash her face with a razor. The aftermath of this
once passionate and loving affair was insane. Luigi was exiled to Bologna, but it was likely
to protect him from his brother versus as a punishment. Constanza, permanently disfigured
from the razor attack, was charged with adultery and fornication and sent to prison for her crimes.
The servant, although he was just following orders from his master, was also sentenced to prison.
Quite unfairly, Bernini was able to get out of his punishment. He was heavily fined,
but Pope Urban VIII, one of his major patrons, agreed to waive it on the condition that
Bernini married. Shortly after the event, he wed Caterina Tizio. The couple seemed happy
and there were no more reports of violence. Together, they had 11 children. This incident shows
us that Bernini was quite powerful in the city. Not only did he escape punishment for these heinous
actions, but he was allowed and encouraged to marry another woman. Like Bernini, Michelangelo
Merced de Caravaggio was a Baroque artist known for his ability to capture drama and realism
using light and shadow. He wasn't afraid to push the buttons of society by violating artistic norms.
One of his most famous examples? Using a well-known sex worker, and likely his mistress,
as the model for the Virgin Mary herself in his 1606 work, The Death of the Virgin.
However, Caravaggio is also famous for something else, his remarkable temper. Records from the era
survive that detail his many court appearances for brawling, possessing illegal weapons,
arguing with city guards, and even throwing a plate of artichokes in a waiter's face.
Caravaggio was exiled multiple times to both Venice and Milan, but he always made his way
back home to Rome. On May 29, 1606, Caravaggio committed his gravest offense. He killed
Renuncio Tomassone. According to records, the two had fought and brawled many times before.
There were even historians that believe that this could have been an accidental killing,
as it wasn't uncommon for them to resort to violence. The motive remains unclear,
the most popular theory is being a gambling den or the love of a woman.
Regardless, Caravaggio was in big trouble. Prior to this incident, Caravaggio's patrons
were able to shield him from the worst of the consequences. Unfortunately, this time around,
Tomassone was from a wealthy and influential family. They pursued the matter, and eventually,
Caravaggio was sentenced to death by beheading. In addition, the court stated that anyone who
In order to escape death, Caravaggio moved south of Rome, but that wasn't far enough.
For the next few years, he moved to Naples, Malta, and Sicily. Despite the death sentence
hanging over his head, Caravaggio continued to work for high-powered patrons, including the
Colonna and Sforza families. He died in 1610 as the result of an infected stab wound received
during a bar fight. These two Baroque artists are remembered for their brilliant works of art
that helped change the way we saw the world. However, it's important to understand that their
legacies are complicated, and they were human. These violent incidents should not be forgotten,
as they tell the story of the whole person, not just the artist.
This video, and all my art history content, is kindly supported by the following individuals.
I can't thank them enough for believing in me and my mission to make art history fun
and interesting for anyone who wants to learn.
Thank you so much, Claudia, Allison, Anna, Susan, and Jessica.