“The simplest, most powerful way to reinforce work, not jobs, is to ask people to do something different.”
Most careers are built on a widely -held assumption: climb the ladder, earn the title, wait for the promotion. But what if that traditional model no longer leads to reliable growth?
HR researcher and author Josh Bersin explains why the traditional idea of a job is outdated and how breaking free from it unlocks growth for both individuals and organizations.
About Josh Bersin:
Josh Bersin is an analyst, author, educator, and thought leader focusing on the global talent market and the challenges and trends impacting business workforces around the world. He studies the world of work, HR and leadership practices, and the broad talent technology market. He is often cited as one of the leading HR and workplace industry analysts in the world.
Every human being makes the job different.
Even if you're working in a restaurant serving hamburgers
in a very repeatable kind of a fashion,
your style, your way of talking to them,
your way of presenting the food is unique to you,
and you make it what you've learned
is the way to do it the best.
There's a very dated, limited view of management
going back to the industrial age where we have a job,
and you as a human are the replaceable part
and the job is the part that remains.
And we will swap people in and out of that job
the way that job is defined.
And I swear to God, my life was all about
that kind of a career for the first 20 years of my life.
We had hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of books
written in the 1960s and 1970s and 1980s
based on this job-centric model of management.
But I know from the research that I've done
in the companies I've worked with,
the more you get away from this idea
that I have this box around me
and I have to work inside the box,
the higher performing company you're going to have.
My name is Josh Bersin.
I'm a researcher and an industry analyst
and consultant in human resources.
I've been doing this for close to 30 years.
I have written several books,
the most recent book being Irresistible,
The Seven Secrets of the World's Most Enduring
Employee-Focused Organizations.
The idea of a job goes back to very old industrial companies
where we had management and labor.
The managers decided what to do and the labor did the work.
Going back to the early days of Frederick Taylor,
they would take apart the manufacturing of steel
or other things, break them into component parts.
Because the industrial engineers had mathematically proven
we could optimize the whole
by specializing a person in each part.
And the old model of this still exists
in every single company, every HR practice,
every pay practice, in recruiting, where we have a job.
And the job has a title, it has a level, it has a pay band,
it has required capabilities and certifications
and maybe educational credentials,
then it has responsibilities.
This job architecture, job-centric work
creates lots and lots of problems.
The typical behavior in a job-centric company is,
well, that's not my job,
so I'm not sure if I should do it or not
because it's actually somebody else's job.
It gets in the way of paying somebody who's young,
but very, very highly capable
because they're lower in the hierarchy
than someone who has a higher level job.
The director job has a different pay
than the individual job,
even though the individual
may be adding more value than the director,
but there's no way to pay them.
It gets in the way of moving people around.
Oftentimes, companies will try to move people
from this business to this business
when this is shrinking and this is growing.
And people say, well, I'm not going to take that job
unless it's a promotion.
I don't feel qualified to do that job.
I wasn't trained to do that job.
There's lots of fear and uncertainty and reward systems
that create brittle fragility in the company
when we spend too much time thinking about what our job is.
In reality, of course, as you know,
every human being is different.
Every individual, even in the same job, is different.
And so we need to kind of relax that job-centric structure
in every possible way, in HR in particular,
to allow these more agile organizations to flourish.
Now, that's not easy.
Let me just warn you.
All the HR software, all the pay models,
all of the career and progression models,
all the nine-box grids,
based on this job-centric model of management.
I'm not saying we still don't have job titles and levels.
That stuff's probably going to be around forever.
But we have to operate beyond that in the work that we do
and not let that get in the way of solving the problems
and addressing the opportunities
that we have in our companies.
The simplest, most powerful way to reinforce work, not jobs,
is to ask people to do something different.
Ask people to work on a developmental assignment.
Give them a special project.
Give them a rotation.
Ask them what they're interested in doing
outside of the work they're doing now,
and then let them do that
so they are not forced to do the same thing
over and over and over again.
They still might have the responsibility
of their primary job,
but all of a sudden you'll realize
that this new sense of energy and learning
has come into this individual
when they get to do something new.
And the more you do that, the faster it goes around
and there's more agility in the organization.
For example, in our company, we have close to 50 people.
Everybody does everything.
Everybody talks to customers.
Everybody works on research.
People come together and work on our conference
because we need them to do different things.
And so they end up having very rich,
rewarding developmental careers
because we have the ability and sort of the DNA
of asking people to do things
outside of their primary responsibility.
That's a lot easier than it sounds,
but that's really what it comes down to.
Every human being from the day you're born is learning.
And so when you go to work
and you're doing the same thing over and over again
and you're not learning,
you get this sense of stasis
that I'm not going anywhere
and maybe I'll just retire in this job
and maybe that'll be the end of that.
That's not good for the company
and that's not good for the individual.
So we have to find ways in the company to reward growth
without waiting for that promotion.
I remember several times in my career
where I would go to my boss and say,
on this level, what is it gonna take
for me to get to the next level?
And I remember one time my boss said to me,
you just need to wait.
It takes at least two years.
I remember thinking to myself, that's ridiculous.
Why does it take two years?
And he would say,
because that's the way we do it around here.
I was never very good at politics,
but I've had an incredibly enriching, successful,
fulfilling career in many, many ways
and grown in so many ways.
The fact that I'm even here doing this video for you
is because my career was based on personal,
professional growth all the time.
And I was lucky enough to have companies
that allowed me to do that,
or I left the company and went to another one at times
to get the development and growth that I needed.
The one thing I would say that I've learned
over the 25, 30 years that I've been doing this,
spending a lot of time in HR is a massive respect
for the culture and organizational dynamics
of high-performing companies.
And if you as a leader or as an individual
or as an HR person can think systemically
about the people issues that are creating
the business issues that you're dealing with,
you will always be a high performer
because every business problem is at its core
a people problem.
And I've learned that again and again and again.
And so that is the secret that I would like to share
with those of you that are listening.